A proposal to redirect at least a tenth of AI development funding to life extension
A proposal to redirect at least a tenth of AI development funding to life extension
On November 20, a writer using the pseudonym don't_wanna_be_stupid_any_more published an essay on LessWrong. He proposes halting the race to superintelligence, AI that would far surpass humans. His hypothesis is that the race is fueled by disillusionment with humanity's ability to build a better society on its own.
The author describes growing up in Libya: a shell exploded beside a neighbor's fence at night, and he had to take cover from stray bullets at school. As a teenager, he dreamed of a catastrophe that would let the country start over. Meeting people who held all of humanity in contempt had the opposite effect on him: he regained his belief that people could build a better future. He became interested in transhumanism, the idea of using science and technology to overcome the limitations of the human body.
He was disappointed by the Culture, Iain M. Banks's science fiction series. The books depict a society of abundance in which immensely powerful artificial intelligences called Minds control ships and habitats. The Culture's inhabitants can choose biological immortality or storage followed by future awakening. The essay's author believes that adventures in the service of the Minds help people feel that their actions matter. In his view, overcoming disease should go hand in hand with people's ability to determine their own future.
He asks readers to imagine an alternative Earth where people have learned to cooperate and fund research on aging. Everyone has access to cryonics, the voluntary preservation of the body at low temperatures after death has been declared, in the hope of possible revival in the future. In his argument, cryonics offers hope of reaching a future with more advanced medicine, while aging research should bring life extension methods closer to reality. He suggests that this hope would ease the fear of death that drives people to rush the development of superintelligence. He proposes directing at least a tenth of the money that would otherwise go toward AI development to cryonics and life extension. He describes his choice in a hypothetical bargain as follows:
“I would still reject even a 1% chance of extinction in exchange for a 99% chance of utopia.”
A commenter, Ninety-Three, considers Dath ilan, the fictional world that inspired the author's alternative Earth, a dystopia. In his reply, the essay's author clarifies that the future should be built around the needs of people on Earth. He proposes leaving the decision to create superintelligence to people who have learned to reach agreements and manage risks more effectively.
Another commenter, datawitch, believes that humans will develop the technologies they need even without AI and supports accelerating AI development. In his view, relying on humans would take too long and leave too much suffering:
“It doesn't matter who does the work, as long as it gets done.”
Datawitch sees current governments and institutions as a major source of danger. He believes that the faster AI develops, the less time they will have to prevent it from doing good.
- https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/jxEvGjPnCiT4LKHmp/if-you-had-faith-in-humanity-would-you-still-pray-to-a
- https://redsails.org/a-few-notes-on-the-culture/
- https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/jxEvGjPnCiT4LKHmp/if-you-had-faith-in-humanity-would-you-still-pray-to-a/comment/gd5WivFAnHRgee48g
- https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/jxEvGjPnCiT4LKHmp/if-you-had-faith-in-humanity-would-you-still-pray-to-a/comment/DeayJJXhDs37iASiB