23 donors approved $45,1 million in grants for 147 projects through the collaborative funding service Lightcone Commons
23 donors approved $45,1 million in grants for 147 projects through the collaborative funding service Lightcone Commons
In their report dated 10 November, the organizers said that 17 evaluators had recommended which projects to fund and how much to give. Applications for the next round are open until 15 November; the organizers plan to hold monthly rounds starting in 2027.
When others fund a shared goal, donors can save their own money for projects they particularly care about. Donors may therefore agree that research is needed yet still wait for someone else to pay for it. According to the service's creator, his team worked with other developers to build software used to allocate more than $100 million in grants through the Survival and Flourishing Fund and Lightspeed Grants charitable programs. Lightcone Commons uses this software for collaborative funding.
Evaluators read applications and draw up lists specifying which projects they would fund, how much they would give, and in what order of priority. Donors can read the applications, available rationales, and evaluators' discussions before choosing whose recommendations to follow. They can also select projects themselves. Donors pay for evaluation and the service on top of their grants: the standard fees are 2% of the funds allocated through an evaluator, paid to that evaluator, and 3% of the grant total, paid to the service. Discounts are available, and evaluators can waive their fees.
In an example in the rules, one donor wants a project to receive a total of $100 thousand, while another wants it to receive $150 thousand. The final grant is $150 thousand: the donors share the first $100 thousand in proportion to their budgets for the entire round, and the second donor alone covers the remaining $50 thousand. If anyone changes their budget or priorities, the service recalculates the contributions, and the other donors can reconsider their decisions. The round closes once every donor has approved their allocation.
In the first round, 79% of grants had multiple donors. Recipients included Palisade Research, which studies the risk of losing control of AI, and AI Futures Project, which forecasts its development. Public lists show who recommended funding a project; donors decide separately whether to disclose their own involvement.
The research space Mox also received a grant in the first round. In the discussion of the report, Austin Chen of Mox brought up a question that charities are asked:
So who gave you all this money?
Chen wants to know whom to thank and who is responsible for the consequences of the funding. The service's creator replied that most donors had chosen to keep their grants private and acknowledged a mistake: the interface had tied consent to disclose a donor's name to the recipient to consent to announce the grant publicly. He hopes to improve transparency in the next round.