A committee of scientists chaired by physicist David Gross has announced that it will release a machine-checkable version of OpenAI’s claimed proof of the existence of Yang-Mills theory and a validation report on 10 November
A committee of scientists chaired by physicist David Gross has announced that it will release a machine-checkable version of OpenAI’s claimed proof of the existence of Yang-Mills theory and a validation report on 10 November
The five-member committee issued its third statement on 9 November. Quantum Yang-Mills theory underlies the description of the strong interaction, which binds quarks into protons and neutrons; OpenAI has claimed to have proved that the theory exists. On Tuesday, 10 November, the committee will publish two GitHub repositories (collections of files): one containing the complete proof code in Lean, a language in which a computer checks each step, and the other containing a document titled “Validation of OpenAI’s Yang-Mills Construction (Lean Proof).”
On 16 October, OpenAI completed the proof in Lean and asked Gross to oversee its release to the scientific community. On 26 October, the company announced that its models had proved the existence of the theory, and on 28 October it gave the committee the complete Lean code. In its October statement, the committee said it wanted to establish that the proof was correct before releasing it and that the Lean code would help with this.
Lean accepts a proof when every step follows from the definitions and axioms encoded in it; people must establish whether those definitions correspond to the physics. The committee identified two checks as its first task: the definitions and problem formulation in the Lean code must match those accepted in physics and mathematics, and the code itself must agree with OpenAI’s written proof.
According to the committee, the validation document “summarizes the results and our checks of the material provided, namely that it proves the existence of pure Yang-Mills theory according to problem formulations standard in physics and mathematics.”
Pure Yang-Mills theory describes only gluons, the particles that carry the strong interaction. The committee’s October statement referred to a proof of the theory’s existence “including coupling to fermions” (matter particles such as quarks), whereas the third statement refers to the pure theory. OpenAI described the pure theory as a subproblem within its broader work on quantum chromodynamics, the theory of quarks and gluons together.
The Clay Mathematics Institute’s Yang-Mills Millennium Prize Problem requires proof of two properties: the existence of the theory and a mass gap (any excitation of the vacuum, the state with no particles, has an energy at least as large as some positive value). The committee described the mass gap as an open problem. The official problem statement specifies what counts as existence: its authors, Arthur Jaffe (a committee member) and Edward Witten, require properties at least as strong as those set out in the Wightman axioms and the Osterwalder-Schrader axioms, two sets of conditions for a mathematically rigorous quantum field theory.
The release date is consistent with the second statement: on 3 November, the committee said it would release the Lean code after completing its checks, hoped to do so the following week, and would give a full day’s notice before releasing the model-generated material. The complete written proofs, totaling 1147 pages, which the committee had planned to release alongside its assessment, are absent from the list of two announced materials.
In October, after reading that the code would be released once the definitions had been checked, Columbia University mathematician Peter Woit wrote on his blog Not Even Wrong: “Until then, I suppose, what has supposedly been proved will remain a secret.” The Lean code contains the precise statement of the theorem that OpenAI claims to have proved. Once it is published, specialists will be able to compare what that statement means by the existence of the theory with the requirements of the Clay problem.
- https://www.kitp.ucsb.edu/sites/default/files/3rd-Statement-About-Quantum-YangMills-Theory_Nov-9.pdf
- https://openai.com/index/building-scientific-understanding-with-academic-communities/
- https://www.kitp.ucsb.edu/sites/default/files/YM_working_group.pdf
- https://lean-lang.org/doc/reference/latest/ValidatingProofs/
- https://t.me/UkhvatNews/4730
- https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/yangmills.pdf
- https://www.kitp.ucsb.edu/sites/default/files/2nd-Statement-About-Quantum-YangMills-Theory_Nov-3.pdf
- https://t.me/UkhvatNews/4762
- https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=15948