Pabis asks how many causes of aging must be eliminated to live for 200 years; Lidsky sees no way to test whether there are several
Pabis asks how many causes of aging must be eliminated to live for 200 years; Lidsky sees no way to test whether there are several
On November 9–10, the debate on X continued over an article in The EMBO Journal in which gerontologist Richard Miller argues that aging has no “cause.” Aging researcher Kamil Pabis believes it has several causes. Biologist Peter Lidsky calls this hypothesis untested, while gerontologist João Pedro de Magalhães allows that different manifestations of aging may have different causes.
Lidsky asked de Magalhães, who had noted that the article made some good arguments, what experimental evidence supported the claim that aging has no single root cause. Pabis joined the discussion, calling it a trivial fact that aging has several physical causes. The body forms teeth, and possibly many other structures, once during development; these structures undergo no repair, and even perfect rejuvenation of every cell would not save them. There are therefore at least two causes requiring very different solutions: molecular aging, which could itself have anywhere from one to millions of causes, and wear in these structures. In his view, the more interesting question is how many causes would have to be eliminated to achieve a long but finite lifespan, such as 200 years. A single root cause would imply that there are few causes to address, whereas pessimists would argue that “millions of very different types of damage, diseases, and problems” would need to be fixed.
Lidsky replied that the existence of several independent causes was neither self-evident nor typical in biology, and asked for another example of a disease with multiple causes. The symptoms of any disease, he added, could be declared independent “hallmarks” and treated separately, but that would lead nowhere. He called the hypothesis of multiple root causes untested and unfalsifiable, meaning that no experiment could disprove it:
“It has never been demonstrated, and I cannot see a good experiment to test it.”
Evolutionary biologist Alexander Wolf supported Lidsky: the existence of molecular aging and wear in long-lived structures does not establish that aging has multiple causes; parts of the body that are not renewed contribute little to its aging. Pabis offered deep wrinkles as an example of wear without repair and found it strange to dismiss this as something other than aging. Wolf replied that wrinkles do not kill, while Lidsky linked them to the loss of collagen fibers. If that loss mattered, Wolf countered, fibroblasts could easily be stimulated to deposit new collagen, just as osteoblasts build bone throughout life. Lidsky agreed that the question was why this does not happen. Wolf added that wrinkles cause little trouble and that evolution had done little to eliminate them. Lidsky described them as likely side effects of the skin’s declining capacity for repair.
De Magalhães reviewed Miller’s article and, in his September review, agreed that aging has no single cause, adding that the number of mechanisms of aging is “not infinite.” Miller responded that aging has neither a cause nor a small set of causes that could serve as a working explanation: there is only a vast number of factors, including thousands of gene variants and forms of environmental damage. De Magalhães later wrote to Lidsky that whether aging has a single cause depends partly on how aging is defined, but that its different manifestations, such as menopause, cancer, and tooth erosion, “clearly can have different causes.”
On November 10, Lidsky agreed with de Magalhães’s examples but noted that aging research commonly relies on a three-part argument: the body contains many biochemical processes, all are prone to errors, and those errors cause aging. He considers the first two points self-evident and asks about the third:
“Do you agree that this third point is a conjecture?”
- https://t.me/UkhvatNews/4911
- https://link.springer.com/article/10.1038/s44318-026-00946-2
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119613906549412148
- https://x.com/jpsenescence/status/2119579032274579714
- https://x.com/Aging_Scientist/status/2119650311384248537
- https://x.com/Aging_Scientist/status/2119661063977484617
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119657474555093256
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119667487088496697
- https://x.com/AlexanderMWolf7/status/2119743345522356324
- https://x.com/Aging_Scientist/status/2119750390149493107
- https://x.com/AlexanderMWolf7/status/2119758309188137153
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119763358434185443
- https://x.com/AlexanderMWolf7/status/2119771076171571625
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119771673931198651
- https://x.com/AlexanderMWolf7/status/2119772585806221561
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119776886448611492
- https://media.springernature.com/original/springer-static/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs44318-026-00946-2/MediaObjects/44318_2026_946_MOESM1_ESM.pdf
- https://x.com/jpsenescence/status/2119908564223270913
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119964729829650925