University of Hawaii preprint finds that the proximal tubule, which returns 60–70% of water and salt to the blood, remained immature in gene activity across kidney organoid datasets, regardless of culture method or transplantation into mice
University of Hawaii preprint finds that the proximal tubule, which returns 60–70% of water and salt to the blood, remained immature in gene activity across kidney organoid datasets, regardless of culture method or transplantation into mice
The preprint (a paper awaiting peer review) appeared on bioRxiv on November 5. Michael Ortega’s group combined 13 datasets on gene activity in cells from kidneys, organoids, assembloids (organoids assembled from separate components), and organoids transplanted into mice, without conducting new experiments.
A kidney organoid is a cluster of cells that organizes itself into a kidney-like structure containing nephrons, the kidney’s functional units. Each nephron consists of a glomerulus, where blood is filtered, and tubules, where water, salt, and nutrients return to the blood from the initial filtrate. The methods used to grow organoids are called protocols. A 2018 study examined organoids grown using two of the most common protocols and found many immature cells; non-kidney cells accounted for 10–20%.
Researchers have tried to improve organoid maturity by making the models more complex. In the embryo, the nephron and ureteric primordia develop together, exchanging signals. Most protocols grew them separately, whereas assembloids combine nephron progenitors with ureteric or vascular progenitors. Organoids have very few blood vessels, but those transplanted beneath a mouse’s kidney capsule acquire vessels from the host. A study in 2019 found fewer non-kidney cells after this type of transplantation, and its authors suggested that the organoids might also have matured.
Ortega’s group compared organoids with two references: fetal kidney tissue and an atlas of the healthy adult kidney. They assessed nephron segments separately because these mature at different times: podocytes (the filtering cells in the glomerulus) and the proximal tubule mature early, while distal tubular segments mature toward the end of pregnancy and after birth.
Assembloids came closest to adult podocytes and distal tubular segments. Only protocols that included ureteric progenitors produced collecting ducts, which carry urine away, and these remained immature. Genes that identify mature cells in distal tubular segments showed very little activity in transplants. In the transplanted assembloid from Huang’s study, these genes were less active than in the untransplanted assembloid, while two mitochondrial genes involved in cellular respiration were more active.
The proximal tubule retained an immature gene activity profile in every dataset, although it is one of the first segments to form in the embryo. Genes characteristic of its mature regions, such as SLC5A2, which encodes the glucose transporter SGLT2, were active almost exclusively in the adult kidney.
Cell classifications depended on the reference. The fetal reference identified no ureteric cells in Huang’s assembloid, whereas the adult reference identified collecting ducts. The atlas has a limitation of its own: it contains no early nephron cells, so it assigned these cells to the most similar adult cell type. In organoids derived from fetal tissue, it classified 60,4% of cells as proximal tubule cells, while the fetal reference classified only 3,6% as proximal progenitors. Those 60,4% consisted mainly of early nephron cells and early podocytes. Their gene activity resembled that of adult proximal tubule cells that had reverted to an immature state after injury, but they lacked expression of mature tubular genes. The authors therefore recommend using both references to annotate cells whose developmental stage is uncertain.
The authors write:
“Each protocol advanced different segments, and none advanced them all. More complex assembloids and transplanted models did not outperform simple organoids.”
The authors recommend choosing the model to suit the task: assembloids for studying glomeruli and tubules, simple organoids for testing compounds for proximal tubule toxicity, and transplantation for studying maturation within a living organism.