A complex organism can still have a single cause of aging, biologist Peter Lidsky counters
A complex organism can still have a single cause of aging, biologist Peter Lidsky counters
On November 8–9, researchers debated the search for a single cause of aging, an approach Richard Miller considers misguided. Aging researcher Kamil Pabis proposed a thought experiment: if every cell were rejuvenated, what would still need repair?
In an essay published on October 27, University of Michigan gerontologist Richard Miller describes numerous interacting changes that impair memory, weaken immune defenses, and reduce muscle function. He concludes that searching for a single cause of aging is pointless. Peter Lidsky, a biologist at City University of Hong Kong, asked what observations rule out a common origin for these changes.
Aging researcher Max Unfried cited complex systems theory: in his view, such systems generally fail for several underlying reasons. He believes organisms follow the same pattern. Lidsky countered that a mutation in a single gene can cause many problems throughout the body.
In Marfan syndrome, for example, a change in a single gene disrupts fibrillin-1, a protein involved in forming the supporting fibers of connective tissue. Because connective tissue is found in different parts of the body, one defect causes a range of problems. In a subsequent reply, Lidsky clarified his question: do the proposed causes of aging arise independently, or do they share a common origin?
On November 9, Pabis proposed imagining that every age-related change within every cell had been reversed. He argued that wear in long-lived structures such as teeth would remain: these structures form during development without an intrinsic repair mechanism. Rejuvenating cells and repairing these structures would require different solutions. In response, Lidsky questioned how much this damage contributes to aging in the organism as a whole.
Discussing possible treatments, Pabis added:
“Even with many causes, it matters whether we target each one separately or large groups of causes at once.”
In his October essay, Miller proposed comparing mice while they are still young that will age at different rates because of different genetic changes, diets, and drugs. Comparing them when young helps separate the effects of these interventions from the consequences of aging that has already occurred. Changes shared across different ways of slowing aging could identify processes that allow many age-related problems to be delayed at once.
Even if age-related changes share a common origin, damage that has already occurred may require separate repair. Several causes may respond to a single intervention if it affects several processes at once.
- https://link.springer.com/article/10.1038/s44318-026-00946-2
- https://x.com/MaxUnfried/status/2119365232019767561
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119386612044030196
- https://medlineplus.gov/genetics/condition/marfan-syndrome/
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119657474555093256
- https://x.com/Aging_Scientist/status/2119650311384248537
- https://x.com/PeterLidsky/status/2119667487088496697
- https://x.com/Aging_Scientist/status/2119661063977484617
- https://t.me/UkhvatNews/4758