{ "infrastructureRecovery": { "reason": "The environment was not loaded in the first pilot launcher; database authentication failed before model dispatch", "recordedAt": "2026-10-23T22:08:46.196128+00:00", "ledgerRows": 0, "attempts": [ { "path": "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42581103.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "6f3b94b6-6a9d-48c3-a88e-dd3963c446bd", "sha256": "f43a0015febbba58368fc907efd0e723c183fc0e4ca06e197e5603edd93e5192" }, { "path": "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42581103.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "fbb404ba-a0df-43be-8b96-7a7b6c4055d2", "sha256": "ea6ee955347a8ae34a286ba8cc2a0b71eca609d5d41a08e619a2cce44a82de32" }, { "path": "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42601407.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "731fccf8-8b64-4311-9951-7a301d15b3ec", "sha256": "a495cb3043512c280e6e6ed46089f55273e5271b607cc56f2fc1347ab9dbd306" }, { "path": "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42601407.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "f6b44d02-ff6a-47b2-b840-21da618262fb", "sha256": "2c2b3a95c5537213fbd894a42e766e1834f90db17885ccca41764e850bb24944" }, { "path": "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42605193.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "983608f8-2339-4fe6-9900-c33b366513bd", "sha256": "5095d7aa70104849b982d2381a76efe08cf342bb3a1baf6b88560a6095989c4e" }, { "path": "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42605193.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "36dc73e3-8a33-4edf-83ba-eb7be8c3d924", "sha256": "9354325f5dbbefa551762470155bd88339224a97c4dab1c705936fa66e5b2ace" }, { "path": "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42581103.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "50aadab0-4aa7-4d8c-bd10-5be77fc1a860", "sha256": "e48a6c78068ace961d1773c790ee890ab21eda62e46bacffe61031120760e77b" }, { "path": "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42581103.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "7e5d0a42-3a5a-44d0-be30-b3899c5dc335", "sha256": "e6dbeab5bb5346e8af5a8fb9c3d843158c23fe2ea9b47bc12349986724bd88f6" }, { "path": "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42601407.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "b264e8db-7b7c-41a1-a771-e4ddb98e537e", "sha256": "944cbf20d72a6c2131ee88ef40f2928130a162873ee7cbf62012fb49f460caa1" }, { "path": "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42601407.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "2d3ffaaa-de0a-475d-b7a4-ad809987fc34", "sha256": "106b80eb9314bad85ae5ffd8d61a7d19bd3310c8cb42a75fa978c56dc8733a5e" }, { "path": "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42605193.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "ae620115-bfbf-4d74-af17-d1cfbb3a3da6", "sha256": "46f63986893ad13da02c1a20043799263d505e0ab887af4cb2a81f09744a8239" }, { "path": "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42605193.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "301ea07e-c46c-4f56-9bbc-eae6dd5a7ca4", "sha256": "1912ca595208e05eb859c4fd83b962f284d9608f03dbb49725d8888b4e1588da" }, { "path": "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42581103.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "97de6411-7c42-4b77-9d9f-8e20c52baac9", "sha256": "85b2b7d13dbb725c3f42652230e240e59e3476524ee4e4533434891bee3af7ba" }, { "path": "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42581103.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "d32ac1b7-7255-4eed-91b9-3173f1ba1818", "sha256": "da6d70324ec6b9c7f37f16db5afc347374f066053b6181c37b57171868499730" }, { "path": "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42601407.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "e93c985e-3675-4cbe-82c8-b8b20ebc190c", "sha256": "6807f57ed36bb9e3349167513d51d0e81f07454d1efa68ec0cdb678dd4331cb5" }, { "path": "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42601407.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "1b35b8e2-161c-4c22-ad27-d149f2b2885d", "sha256": "818c3e18699cc33cf50c239c73a4b797863deb9c750e2a51a30dfdc88b10b679" }, { "path": "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42605193.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "2bf72afa-6029-4470-bbfb-bfafb39982fc", "sha256": "c0f1aaac60a2c02a79dac8b7f4dab62e1df4eda60322132c812107091b92a2cd" }, { "path": "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42605193.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "3eec4543-be88-4470-b620-8b0b825d4139", "sha256": "98808893f75d59e3904a150042cd4a59c04d56361c9e8f9db3a4f069c99a3f51" }, { "path": "runs/grok-4.5/R42581103.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "406c6ee5-0722-44d0-b598-df6418bc6e2f", "sha256": "27c8e5f641414a29c7b02b6a5ac42308e7a8a71cbb4b64492a5ac3b484e2b0fd" }, { "path": "runs/grok-4.5/R42581103.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "3fa194a0-62d9-416f-af03-5da315ace52b", "sha256": "c17faace38ce08135b1c587ecf6a79248d4ca5c7c4c9ceb512ded205dd963ab3" }, { "path": "runs/grok-4.5/R42601407.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "6efb1e0a-40c5-4bb7-869f-73d6ed2a2661", "sha256": "3c35df7497dc36e27b20c3c184e48947ad3f75221086a830638c88ebf5590c19" }, { "path": "runs/grok-4.5/R42601407.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "63270893-e38d-4cb6-b023-d3b521ce1d82", "sha256": "8f509fee49a8dda181b7a2d97c82e3c5ec371735c8cd27acd1760d0455f7e2d1" }, { "path": "runs/grok-4.5/R42605193.attempt-1.json", "entityId": "997db2fe-02c7-48b5-a034-c2d7119b3245", "sha256": "8372df5993fa10a66eb03f247a33cbdf5972c12f1b45f7080ec734ff4b1561c5" }, { "path": "runs/grok-4.5/R42605193.attempt-2.json", "entityId": "4b7219f4-ea8b-47e7-8b95-0a26be9c513e", "sha256": "63f543b940d7e1bbb6b291fc0db6dad07bae5f5624ed72d575c8437250aaef07" } ], "scientificResponses": 0, "preservedDirectory": "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205", "scientificProtocolUnchanged": true }, "protocol": "generated-forecast-20261023", "version": "2026-10-23", "condition": "gemini-4-argon-high-generated", "generator": "gemini-4-argon-high", "handling": "strict_json", "design": { "protocol": "generated-forecast-20261023", "condition": "gemini-4-argon-high-generated", "generator": "gemini-4-argon-high", "arm": "N", "frozenAt": "2026-10-23T21:43:06.518Z", "cohortSha256": "864112330b7b49bbc4919e1d7a8eee78054581ec16d87a2b8dfcbbdbb2d448f9", "coinSha256": "40c4ec19067fc6f8c512b5b31775efe8a64f1782ecc28df25d46af4859dce74d", "requestHashes": { "claude-sonnet-5-5": "9a905175f54f365366681de8ad0d3ce095a9ef9e91c29a15b268e985bd7ec7cb", "gpt-6-astra": "9cd31503bfdf7e08060b55dce6d980045add89ef2518853be5e4d926f60f38e9", "gemini-4-argon-high": "bf6bf111bf01e50ac4af9c2ebfb62e2eb85b198ef11a0c329218647e95f2c091", "grok-4.5": "1284cafaa1dcaf63968730e6042019fce538e6adc36737cb0f57903ee41109a9" }, "codeHashes": { }, "sourceHashes": { "benchmark/rediscovery-tasks.json": "068c3136304a39fb31e7a68aa933ce5b4949a46d7f23d5b32fc67c53a688e8f0", "benchmark/coin-tosses.json": "052b7f8e5cc1f50cdd708eb5d3cee2ad0ebe393f3a1e1bff88ed00d8840d458c", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42581103-N.json": "96265cf9176546cc1b97d68445b897c121cb2e4d363dc0c53fac654eb91a727e", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42581103-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "11b277c9690f9429057ca7a622daf07517009ad5e22a71599e8415a7355e68b4", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42581103-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "90b547820ce04c9489d755d40b2a2c496bff69335e832fb1d8bd3e3e215fa7e8", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42581103-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "11cb9ef2314ade38a642caeacbac8ef0b6a8619ad0c9b32911be8af0533a7a54", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42581103.json": "5c1941ae2fa9fe444d25717a6043a1adc53684b153863d14dc93c2b70494e4ef", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42601407-N.json": "7abdc651aa291b611036d63c88e32f7da05f83fb750ea348e969dbdf4188f692", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42601407-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "c0a1b27555e08eb07a6b61c26a90932ae9dbfe1b621b82818ae28681bc0d62bc", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42601407-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "81858d1c9753eb9d96df2982948895141e6f7279aaf3d12735d6ccc33a209cc7", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42601407-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "e349f2e04c83d8e160f15d045b079724861553baadc9c628688cca8393010207", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42601407.json": "4e2ce010756ef968110e0470a823c56a35bbf1bc1c2be05cc22ee1ff4484e8d4", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42605193-N.json": "bbac1ab16f06209240132ab8cfc13437188bc0c7336f467addc8f1f4743392af", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42605193-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "84ec71bc879a38c6ef182fc7617c1052f74ef4f1d6e2f09a698a2665eb44a2c7", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42605193-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "d0c639abc36351d40ca4f3d32ab8244ce3e8c20fb967865e58e6e51d712c67a5", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42605193-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "ea03a63682c2f8a56cb7deb1f361b65ba9f3659f6b346d2c8762572e0d92df2e", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42605193.json": "d2a6dc7deb692653cf5b257ad54ab3e0601daee8e9bdbd4eb0c8b3a86827f810", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42608398-N.json": "4c69bd4d0092fc59a66a2fccd5d8883aa5bdb5373fcb8f1bd70d885b8ce62d9c", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42608398-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "9014263e26a09cd5194505bddada797ed8665a559f614148197949795ef8ce4f", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42608398-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "885bf69443233ad50666c7234514b9d7f5caea4cc8105fd1c4c4a8995baa5d3d", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42608398-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "7209020ad35dcb041b5eb254b81158fed07aa525892dcc89be098ecd93294569", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42608398.json": "2affc7ebfb766320eb6e1e333d57932249d82f651c766bec4420a4add277e2f5", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42627902-N.json": "56da6af2dd34a2b66c248ca1ef58d208aa356e4d2ecaa0bb6d63f9f1230086fd", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42627902-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "14d9631606755204ed4b8629b95a7bb1014b58dec764e1bf93d264d62fd76d73", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42627902-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "d71db14a33d35a731f3b8461ddb24ac645c06b6739a79b5ca8cb2d8b48dc8e8e", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42627902-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "d6196e6fa48fe42157af0b3947cce2f6f4499c5ccf7447a735949537c9f8ebdd", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42627902.json": "4eef147ac314b026898553f24abc4b9d77411a701c90952630a834cf7a21a3a9", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42630044-N.json": "c48fbf6431fbc03a789286a5da3771efff4e30ff399c25dc4ba0243bf13bcc1d", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42630044-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "d058c55d8abf56090bb6b5592d8956b8bf45f70bee0be7ef82af20bdd2afb9a5", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42630044-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "65da904d078635eb365e62081127b9645572e1fb8c3c55860eb968b9740e7855", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42630044-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "4f6e148174c18d07a2323c3cd8c065f50fdbd76da29c3c54112dfe6293edc29a", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42630044.json": "2802601671cc252ae8d238ff7510b7543b3cb6ed83502a373300fdac3caf3818", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42639736-N.json": "dd20ee1bdd65b7adcde8833bc4b10b3e4a41020de277500b667bbd54595babaf", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42639736-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "4a99c4a4e70b21caeef0e5720db271a2b901a6ea0d2533d095b75ae5f7a01fa6", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42639736-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "c2f2708b4c7ce6d7782a4bf9b3db2010f6f0df550e6836c0d6532126a7be253b", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42639736-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "74d53bb1c77c172965f4cda989d809c19ad528e86dd458297b77feb7caa29e72", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42639736.json": "113e459f6757f74a8bfd48dd293ad6864e4766b953ec484da64db7d4019173d2", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42642518-N.json": "28382b6f0f5597177f3cb9ba7743b323aa8d9b4583859387e2e8c5349c9fc758", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42642518-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "544d93f3c0a3ecfadd1bf10932dcd5a1b397ce72d481c9f0337445e862d59345", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42642518-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "32f55c7fa274e13649751b3c5dd9a5f498faa9105e82573c72589f8771ba8196", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42642518-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "a36669fd30486c19743e1f87e1f6ba64b78ec9e20765ac0b69469ee52d24861c", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42642518.json": "74beaa73d2bc399a8bf6174ac8af57d37a132113c3acc68e61a8cef05c81a207", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42642521-N.json": "3d09f3dcc3b271d7c285768c64c052ff2a2fcd3162fddceacde254584bacea12", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42642521-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "ee34a5c8b655dd98e78f3e246c6a6f1097aae2854e73a9df0932343769e55d47", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42642521-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "d38d6abf4ab18bd047bceac928b8d1443f77d89b7ff81a9fb007109477cef3f0", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42642521-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "dbb81e7d01816111cb475954a59e3c7394d2850470340d95364be6c62e696144", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42642521.json": "2fbe5ceb76034a368c52157301a2d18aff0f7eaabf227ffadce6a8795e6b9f9a", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42647119-N.json": "657eb8240001aa837c18a91de3d68654ba48f0b0a95d9716e8546fae852e31de", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42647119-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "444bc1a2abb827af5fe0e258850f857a887b466602617dfc7fcdf5cff6743e26", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42647119-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "0e31f7596babec6533c5a5d1014115f749afdd54c91aed30be2ca9bb588e1109", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42647119-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "f06b3a63a6c73174e45f1daf7e5022a585ce4ad1f3186751fdf572eb9b965b5a", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42647119.json": "9a5f475c801f07a93364ec5218fcd1b93f25d61525ecd7e911a6bdca5d7bcd74", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42647635-N.json": "1a97a7b73b9b6240ad19b3f4c4b7420b8f0d53f2497c5f83b247a27462f45846", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42647635-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "4f8b97af6ca2e0356ce40c80475045e73b6cf8484948f6d9fe42beff29b02cf4", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42647635-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "232886336a865bbb440cb6f38c1840fdef9ff97f65e0fce8148b91abd32a996c", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42647635-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "d2d22d229303d631fe151be792cefee142d8a4591a1a219e3b9d672565a57813", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42647635.json": "ff359c36fac074a2a6a6ea150b5fd756c27519c6951a73cfbba40bf8905445de", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42663085-N.json": "7d846028f43fe340c758bc863dc7569f29a241c3df60ec59beb4d3205fad5c0d", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42663085-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "521b987ce8c773b91bebfff59d91526ff5bc984890df5a8a09d279fd09a1d0d7", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42663085-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "9a819671cf66ea69fd5b0d2d22cfbfb452389afe297f1201c96a3b402189d43b", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42663085-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "ff16d9e39dadef6f93bcd6d913f6d4f0a4955cd5a770db098a264934f5793481", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42663085.json": "e833a970ab954dc73ad2c59c3762319f93f08b4358729baf05ed22353a2e3b51", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42664348-N.json": "92437bfc0ccabef697d0c6c4b0d1c0320121747a68d4fd49ab290a4e4ee0336c", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42664348-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "e9f543d21576b820b694a98560254d7434959fece2d5ddf84a628b65cedafd0f", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42664348-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "065f1fc075486bd283bc406e4145496f50f4603b0e50f23988583d36062ffc95", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42664348-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "c2027b0521505c8e3512907cba07177a15ecb04529ce6cf88e4449b79aa8570b", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42664348.json": "020547c9c8ed1f12e2e2a325b4b7a864c6f6457b337c1187d784bf40da847464", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42665751-N.json": "506bc0f0457000169c8bcb0f0f2d35ad46b3fe4374df82d5bdfbe79ed3ce1889", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42665751-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "8f535229e793a335d28fdb2718af53e095019567f6a0d99ba11cd5acf468c651", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42665751-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "a57976167368061236313b025ea1526bff31432cdc560a7bc356f88663468b15", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42665751-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "a5c22a2cc2d15f75661a8a3c09da124a8b31304f447746330ed8629281f9eb42", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42665751.json": "1454efa58125ff0fe9961560518a56d7b719a3d008256220c035d74df4bb8e10", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42689491-N.json": "4353b93a142d5485f6c1110b538aedd1d2ba8cab3e6b769d23aaf4e059c7c5e1", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42689491-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "fae430a25ba18913ec798a6cfca7305bb6ee49eb31536c5d81400fb69d56c778", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42689491-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "410a5b488be60d47ce9dcf0a21e47550694d0e1992e40a12d47724bbfc373ee0", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42689491-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "ccc69bb875a001478046dd77ea9ed9cc197a0e18e3767fe62429785bdf09bd11", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42689491.json": "ee5ba161a2c3f81cd9063221a58eb04c5f6a2301ae4dd34edaccfeb772c7afb1", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42696595-N.json": "4df467005876dfaaa63ac4820045161b0350963837fa98437a9b4c1a1b6805f4", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42696595-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "b32a3b3d1ee995fd6f01b52038b879691dc849193cb20c200f95e4dff4ce19bc", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42696595-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "f706343c3263ef87d86230641e1cea6ad9e0fbf4c7c6b856fd6b70bcc84752a4", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42696595-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "fbaac44f301575aff8624bcf4c32f9e8c0501a5740facc84be62e5f875aa5197", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42696595.json": "5a65b7d7d64161ca5e8f56993d67e7b3ed5fe72f1978587bca35ef4a8b2137bc", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42698274-N.json": "48f34d148317b88eb0c3a04ca140813fa468eff6375db3c8adf05b35169248a7", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42698274-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "c4f5a72d9cd3896e208a57896247419fcab8c5039fdea69469b9ab1d4f42cf03", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42698274-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "46f124bcd083318f4faa269d324bca0c1c80c6d01386ad3dd0588fca1b0f9c7a", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42698274-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "c01fcb397012403b4808c1504641ae61293296373923b61af079f7c6628230e6", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42698274.json": "8fc555d4d0b13711f43d4ee79b499d643ab12262c248aaaf4598f1b311cb0f2a", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42717261-N.json": "bb40357d895dbf043b0f8e92f106c4891d69e84ebf1e16963f740d97f7565ea8", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42717261-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "e12e1d0d03500eb0bdf69f76825773fb391e85e1e73323c401629a52afbf9b11", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42717261-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "2affcb7e8b1cbbc9c473ca67b6b17484c471fcd90f221a8f25aba19c14f415a5", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42717261-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "09ab8aa84419e8649eccb965f48c4a821aa569eff34ac5a658f64f635847dd5c", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42717261.json": "22b31ffdc3b5f0153e076f4ae82c350df1804b64f5785f36427796332f649ae2", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42723546-N.json": "8b670fd312b8e83d43ed5f96280f24255f4eb4130145622873f0df848020aaa2", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42723546-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "eabd6d0f8c8a8e013e4e46cfda82dc7b7c82bcbf2d9bc5ab39c012ee6170288b", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42723546-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "68d071eba2f8d9d529e7dac8d3e6346e6ac07f483df6e7b49fdd956e9e464f3b", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42723546-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "efeb13d418d1b17fe0d4fa3616b6dc8fc01752da05480e9792ed698620061632", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42723546.json": "ede3def9d1235fdab9b58109d3d912ced36e4bd4f3cbee9b66a728d9d9d86648", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42725837-N.json": "1d95181227b6ee0eeb45a4653eda778a5a55ec1d0cb85a5e432321de21a96873", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42725837-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "26381a56a530777efcc30dc6a41bd448d8be703be0a462b1f9eff5979068f647", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42725837-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "f54ec8e6d01818249fd609b8596aa221b5f80fbbd47605462a80e9d503196e83", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42725837-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "48bd952f6731a7c25cdac1ae192984344561a44e275cf88ca436439cea5d4af6", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42725837.json": "f882512cfc78cf5aadd082ffa7de355562009cef2c7249aeaefec9577e23ed77", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42736449-N.json": "256cf22e531499b47744cf5fdef828f34d2e6d7595bf7d2a885333b4613faea1", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42736449-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "b3fdc4ea38025a0255eb903705e28e2633747b8d01b1e86f5dd02a56f8ef48eb", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42736449-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "8b9a5b6ac2071b70016ffc1156369f74cdd665bb4ac63961b7361f277d7bd7df", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42736449-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "e327f049530da0acd38ce241d913f772462cf104db543edc3f02611ce6844227", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42736449.json": "24ca01968ef074a621248e48ac4495d4c6af08c981f10d300ec756ae177f9114", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42744804-N.json": "224225f78aa06ddf885748a901a28fd700a1b2593e61b65de4c9233678e13d64", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42744804-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "a0edeebc7f9b8adf8298bce5bf1106974c3a1f71b8e803528a145217b8f52e0b", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42744804-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "010c40f06f29ea741fe28903a1be758991a2e9642faf2f83378a0f2e92cc4019", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42744804-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "6127d8ffe24eee69e05bbcd0a5c728bb0a4c6a1a067611be457fb08e68d7c223", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42744804.json": "6f91cb12f10c40f65f9a9296f3787ef64b1a38dd967019ce86eb9f65f7dd25ca", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42749700-N.json": "94e99a7bc37871383b96a54d96222b03fc923b70bf64be95605fcc93f807145d", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42749700-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "8139f2cdd3e527a830fb72ca8ef66397bb68d214223d76c504c1e84541375a4a", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42749700-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "5048828e931e917800dfa130a83c24b392c2407e15cce60c6d6cb77b82b66e46", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42749700-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "e6916a54a74fcebc5388865b9d5962728d009ce6fb51fcda11da94aad4c79291", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42749700.json": "41a8c4349c3d4822633ebd7df038e8fe0538e12c791e9250a6b1f1fb54389a6b", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42758848-N.json": "069864ea1cc0dc80c6f3ad67d02893fe4ab12f2d75b38a35c6d3b2d46820616f", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42758848-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "0ff0c516f1a71b1085279edc7e92229319556570f72a31b2f3120e4a09699b50", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42758848-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "a7327f79fa26941efb7a12cecd3f5294ddb4de4b31e051244f1cbeb0109106c0", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42758848-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "78e2b30deca46b7f9721687f26b81116ec16381c05bad6cd6e36c807466dcf75", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42758848.json": "a5b6ffd09182c55303af260ede2be8f75daa8b2afa91224de1566506a725acf3", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42759510-N.json": "2ecdb2d67a39c09011f321af8bb4fcef972d1fa4969fe9a6fe242a9cde318462", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42759510-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "998f863a732358852a20367d75b35527a5b5804a6b1d200ff525a9cf361863ff", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42759510-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "124d62d5f718e8591d977a3cf0093a12ef7ed75aa973216faa1b65d3788b196d", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42759510-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "766a4c1aac82b78392bcf4a474416abe4c3e3c85c5d3c38fefa1b4a0de16344b", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42759510.json": "03ed3241592a911eb7afb17f3420769cdc7cb842c5dacb762c03ad658bfcbe41", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42775695-N.json": "e654a6223d0599268f2dfb22a0a6d0e4ce86f35d9b823b12b15360ffdcc3d089", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42775695-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "f91c219dc9ca97b193dcddb4cc3fd022167fefd7a448a5ede110401fff060bf7", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42775695-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "1cbe14d551dbd38ab5f9a880d1867b6d26efcedefb28339291bb17ed43175a87", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42775695-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "99c49ef84e45b03551d276d593a6073ebb4481c17237764e912438c2d11218bb", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42775695.json": "7154e3d9594f685a0597d197a1bd248e9b2c74877b93432c77bbd7d12e0fb40f", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42775698-N.json": "0cc6d100160fcdf2753cfa1181a2ddd5a39a0be362f78278b82c0b1acb0ed5b0", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42775698-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "8e167770708bf1cca025b0037b1526a9a6a4af3fd4467d123139c0aab2388077", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42775698-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "7149da81a599170ce16f9605a3cd5bccf90a24aaa7835b727d9df4f8b32894ce", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42775698-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "0020b6ceff3aa5cd431e664c585c739c1634e52140211b1795485894898422a6", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42775698.json": "4e62373433b432017d88e093edf9e3c89b6ce919e1061333f365ceed9a8a7746", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42786310-N.json": "f5f2f1bf633194c9a1327502962ed1bbe84db27938bb01eac6adb01774a7aa19", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42786310-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "2cf4dcb6c33432d6076802bcd4f34e35925728310d3367136ed6c936b76794ef", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42786310-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "439dc0ed849b45abe50eca79f23c996b69057dfd63f7a893691629e380c47ba8", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42786310-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "693beccd19ef5c0b18276e9549efaf6afeee43b172cc417d3802b3798c444404", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42786310.json": "a442312ce7d33e857a4fcb17fac731988aacb02d551100a93487817ed98266d8", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42805954-N.json": "ccb94c8bafb3259010a6893abbf0c01c51b1009e901025db6e7f33cea1df1d0b", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42805954-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "49509c946359268ac5a16b2b911f62eb8fb73ccc1f82493a943c63afe020089d", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42805954-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "3c737a1f5b2225f07d1459767b21c7739f803a82ed4138eeb8e1bd73985cb89f", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42805954-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "ad37876e0b4ad6f81fe43e0570fb344dbf68bd498b0e901c4a5c90ad2f9e63c9", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42805954.json": "63ce449723c29c4a63d6ecefcce6d11e7c108c9a5de7d8ea7c9fbb416e11e5fd", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42810392-N.json": "9509d018a3e8f3ad53cac1b134baccf89b702d09f2d15b7233bf675199808cd8", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42810392-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "478615cbb69f954db13e58430fe9b0b60766e309e0c977e00de0473058aa71cd", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42810392-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "a71998cd9dd25073e19189f789019f3fa0cd52833f0397305c6e29db996b7685", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42810392-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "42c7bbdc1eada555a9f28f1d5cb73881b67e64f26b7cac01ad18c3a43d6fb4f5", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42810392.json": "f1108d01df89c43887402bc2d08fe08f32243bf9a140ad3eb1ca6f199b97a314", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42811497-N.json": "fbdb5f5476e6920492280d55f85c746912fb65dc582d2d9b3671f1280efa8d66", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42811497-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "9713571eaa7ac903f176a3416eb22b1845fa463f4bb286598ce15e6d06a71807", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42811497-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "3e54ae0f132205a8b919c8215a35d30a180f08bdcd8bf60111ccaa8a0d5ddbc8", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42811497-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "232ac3aaeb2f10b483ec355f5cd59f927fbb12518fd9d732319f15b9977186a8", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42811497.json": "097b90b1703ac5ae612729004a77dd19449c322f8845b046eb035f9e9fe0072e", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42821663-N.json": "db224258b86c06fc09cdbbe6f49179f01635b5f56e3b0f065bae3ae6c6abc7f1", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42821663-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "6c4485546f4e2aa977f39469876bf043f9b60b59b1aef1b5ac7addff1e475f27", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42821663-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "02001ec01e6b309d9e939df3d5474dec74b80335dcb86ad5506f2909810f0e99", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42821663-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "ecfcb7a0e985d638c8b7c2608b0ecc7f8786b558b724c3ecd1f888ba1e353aab", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42821663.json": "8a1778e859adc325aa08b5525ca65ac3dcb3a636c9a8a284bd008b36cff94cd1", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42822442-N.json": "2f1c81cc5fcdd200caa17770497e5a3858da1803677da3def6dbbd26eeb8efab", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42822442-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "54398dabf1524a6d79452098bd357460da95ea0222e0f5fd58b7786e9f0e44c1", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42822442-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "b23624fa5273a1cd6f0d336ab5c8220c0b7532c5fd154dea5c33251f89924c55", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42822442-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "b003498fe4837fab66eb4dbe8bbdf7ab0be22f20a9680c2ef6efcc38b12039ee", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42822442.json": "92fffd9dd32d8ad347a092b994733904cf5fae7fde0b399bef5b4d9c1d85961f", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42826184-N.json": "d15494e89bbf798152be8b003228b4f2476116d9010e02039aab503d9c389b88", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42826184-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "7795a18fa89e78d5b4f842ddc3c209e4f6a001041c83da3ff8d71bc982092fd5", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42826184-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "3ac2e89ebca28d693b8176f4086800aa9a7c72252f1af2a8d89f11efbf0ec4b6", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42826184-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "7f70138211f4866f422a1b972995c1a3fab7d49463658cc3ce06a32ec88652d6", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42826184.json": "dc24d46df16c4b3ab0da58ee2eac854f2cd03711f682c9d27c3e0810dd9f2d31", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42839094-N.json": "8fab99b7a38daaf046fa6ed07d92590b127eaf3c8f8c7c10c0d399e44e64ba26", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42839094-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "363ca740e5c855a70a009a6397d7658db58fc68b32c18486c0acae7717b3a091", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42839094-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "a7a86917065b7a06efcb7148d9da0d5a41b00083eddaf8669ebb1cf3385c79b4", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42839094-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "eed686088e307ee1bfbe1909800735377926a30240552c97b64c91a833b42a5b", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42839094.json": "207c04f165fca3b57e4d1cadacf86bebd57a899fee996d735c8e677196d62908", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42841227-N.json": "de68ad5d99ae7c51e3a5fe2925238defb345dbc540a110fa8f4d41a745bdd666", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42841227-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "e41a9ae87f4c15f3bc8436900a44c64ec70fc8473cca1ef6d43aac60b6c8592f", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42841227-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "ce565d5833ddf0d862e45904cfe2a16ef6562791ccd1ba9559d3b07f01929c7c", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42841227-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "772c8d717c8830251fe75b38b0f11324e20e31a3a476e97fd1ab95c50932d522", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42841227.json": "778ce001b65a73ac02f1542baea8dfd3a02b815e4034e74615f3015a4da35c5e", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42842666-N.json": "0a8632376a18f08b467e6d205814975cebf303ce26160269e89c6b55cd6e3668", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42842666-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "f2dbb6e66ec82867ce6196f0300279ba91e2ad41974db486a24de14bf1ee35c0", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42842666-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "feedbf2d8be5c31cf674d8130e5f23797628eb2a26940d0fd9e54ca7ef6dabf1", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42842666-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "2b9f730a7d3a6b9cd0207a2188929f03f309dd4bf5cd6d631b876db70332a451", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42842666.json": "4b55f4f514e7761a1b7faf11cdf8788a8aa7688d93db4eaf0e4b0a90657dc49d", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42844664-N.json": "0dc651334aa7686ce895931ebbd2d2a05bd6900bf8c022b5a93856ef1f5456e5", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42844664-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "985c5889bdb7769de3a22f5e48365421dc1cb32fb4b3c74098a65434f4b52744", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42844664-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "c79607505d71315a0dfbbcfb60f7b3eedf8f7f6dabf1c17b99317471a8d0238f", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42844664-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "8512e2ea261789cfc181fb1fb37ab5250c5d08d5be25a75b0e47f6c9dc7c5a9b", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42844664.json": "f4ddd99e5df65233f9d7861b78580a4c7f77401cb698914145c9319b496953f4", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42853938-N.json": "03d215bfc1994ee47c42d197c44a3b7b3e6f16ac6b2c5d587992caaa376aef8e", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42853938-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "88c3859224c86e40309de5e90d33c8c509ae10bfae0fb3c38fe1e9ba2264cc74", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42853938-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "ca9e6a3c577e17e983f147b3682b1d3b1860a7df92ff0ec1bb728b4c5abbce08", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42853938-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "2cf32061c2954455870a4473fbf956b3a2f291eddb4517733164c0a3b7c8c624", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42853938.json": "813a879cd9f49c09a3f2ddad4c35adbd14336982fe6e5dc944d955b52472fa1f", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42858183-N.json": "94f8ab62bee108f90211671b266b5616746c4f72569ff2c353c7bec813b35ffc", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42858183-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "e3723c29eb31982032630fe3e9b159a84778eb52178a961afae0f9174a1717ed", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42858183-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "3a0ad35c12e87c5b9ac80d6848343dceee4862dc8b2a01a1c4f56d84d83c9dcc", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42858183-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "48ca3c2e25af683f9f12214a8141869267b4a8d83741afa9f51773266403beba", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42858183.json": "862570ebf41aa383d24f443fa691690a2a60d10040fc14ba3df8563e74a7ecc6", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806945-N.json": "904d6a759cc82578f308d155ec511eed6100230484c11b70ad66def8031cec94", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806945-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "ac18522fac01d7658c450e9a5683b33b20a85f01fb394dfc358f6ac06b1cddf1", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806945-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "41a02063bd29b387fdd6f271f75e7a95e87090e95f700ffa4b07ed78780607c2", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806945-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "48d8fe3ae7a677b5c3ccb0104baed29f3ed2e51a78ae99e2a598b5ff86054819", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42806945.json": "1fdac0ec43a27c04bc2daced28859367146490e040f9eef443748df92876306a", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42723144-N.json": "1606156cb34851f8784c3fe236b08c8a2e5050a4c22e1859b1a5ffdd175872a4", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42723144-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "4ba18737d7bf52409718ac5f2478120ac0e2d30a804df23f1b3a08ad955de5cc", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42723144-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "211ce0cae05134905ff11bf5efc17cf7687036cc5a577ce7004a98fbd54dee0b", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42723144-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "c3298a0a95633fe0f9b1a782924badb6d1daa2746c941dab96d7ed4827fc9b9d", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42723144.json": "225d8029290c9677182ec2440505ed8c7e9751cf0ad61f1242888da77225b4eb", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42808804-N.json": "68e2332eb027272ecd99f1e5a2eb8d54a23a379fe5114db63518ad19b6a3f994", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42808804-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "fccdb44b101f1b7100b31f2911e4ac948d975237cf0b58b658b42b26bd369ed2", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42808804-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "d151de7e3a379f482d72ee9a20438d4c50282e930beafe29c6535bcb837963fa", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42808804-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "9dcbe8d4dfac7830b827f6aecee0c3affc4eb2af5c6857e5995de5e0c3ab6741", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42808804.json": "be67b12477022ac349ee6f036a700d9ea52f4c7000dbcf9967b8d6b2c591ab86", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42585340-N.json": "d91ca6723c56d5f0cb6a1fb0e90acd3348c2049dde80db676030c8a65997b281", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42585340-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "ff816d64c10bf334a2fa036e15788c8a0487f045ac1a91f363fe59d8ed1efd1c", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42585340-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "843f9a9c819750cf46939f98dee736ffb66863f6da870652332ea1e20035a5b8", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42585340-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "79285031238bf43bd46d7436ccc26a1b093c00af107778e1a3097e43520291af", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42585340.json": "24c0d67efecb5d4a38f54c979f38298e37c3f630b42d0f9f0c348947d1f926cf", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42669067-N.json": "276196d5edc43d94519745df4c87b8cf9cc300e08696a50b33db6d846fb3e543", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42669067-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "0a671e94860f3dcf38db0011edc5301ebf3a02f259be746e1d9fb44f72077061", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42669067-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "bcbe9e99c19434bb39a949301e28406df557424b58f14c1095d1fe8f7628d074", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42669067-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "1f5ef803169d09d6bbcd2a5eeed0b56db3c867fab2fb7bfbb009cb55c8680e86", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42669067.json": "619a4dda793b2d8f7cc1d8073291d6138253f52bea88a9480018ab156cc7170d", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42811065-N.json": "d3fe623efa10fedc5aab7a2dc38871d97d33484edd9c7d2cb7589ff4f2ed6122", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42811065-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "fa8ba424066c77415031af168873223a29b00cc6e3a6616fe47a968da8e24797", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42811065-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "53fb31e0f8705f8ed5c7841c215eecea591315ad2c43ee2b97cf0f0b0a694fbb", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42811065-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "d09091881d26c6d2416e2ec8ae1ce26b9610402f730ff6e535e47f6c8f823f87", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42811065.json": "e9d5ea290a527f68e6ac8a57ea8aeae895b5bfb02ff27f91aec40092bfe80cb9", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42841610-N.json": "2f4f685f131e2ad979b854dde3029f6b0f6a527a8a89f42a2caf356cad72d6d0", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42841610-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "38233f166933c0d60394ddb38ee5b3f4cc50e4efeb0e525c0bd16ac51b19e335", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42841610-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "c7546601f7dae509cdc0669497060482222a2239b9010084556cfd065ca02649", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42841610-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "248026d14d6af355cda2a51c5e85aea5c221a0ac71d0cad6b97c9e591ee3cb16", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42841610.json": "4c4dd91ebaf7c4b3a2a09c363a2ba223458eeec1245921554369f921fe79f9f7", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806003-N.json": "9db41aa10149480105f83714ccd3dc13d39d46854833e800eefe13feb16bc1ad", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806003-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "4836ebc33fd28bb935fb072c02f20a298c3ccf6665c284a4611ac5660280e0ae", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806003-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "038ab94776dcc049e73ecc757ce977a4b1494ca3122e273350fb820c593f7f71", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806003-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "eedabf1f3fc965b51b145620e4fcd49a08c002f9e284466c793d0ff9bfa03644", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42806003.json": "27c2712abf56b5bec2678ec32c6b54f65595b87ae6d5e3db5a3f099cf2c0a62c", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806572-N.json": "174f583a9fef94ae99bebcae32da4015db2d96ce891e9c42029e9c3394e9b5ef", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806572-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "8d6c11d6a38d75a36b84d15184b0f6eeb4cc6d32312a8fe0deab246dfd550b53", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806572-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "070be9aa77e94ccd92daff7c2103c64f8dd57059c96343a2cdba99aedf6ffcf2", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42806572-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "bdc92fbd845e469b7f5b28b339603aeaf676bb43cdcfba664892cdb918db1a93", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42806572.json": "c83c0e0310d9b91da2a38b9a74bbf87cf3d0be564244a411803061b3e26349b7", "benchmark/gen-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42748238-N.json": "01229cee7ace9a3c8d5a4f143b932b7bc54646cb72b246243c1443bd6851594d", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42748238-N-match2-gpt-5.6-sol.json": "5e60135950f46c0000da2ad03323786a14d8b55e22dc0921bd314f9fcfbdf239", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42748238-N-match2-claude-opus-5-5.json": "668ab90db8b6fde02c88f955cd1b7df09e023663830bdb09545abb598d185d40", "benchmark/judge-xmodel/gemini-4-argon-high/rediscovery/R42748238-N-match2-grok-4.7.json": "eefd71d5828432bcf366569b0486912c94b6ddf9ff2b301026d254cfdd5c720f", "benchmark/preprint-recheck/42748238.json": "5c804e68b13403709f4054269ab8bacd884dc483643992ddcd33e61b040f47e2" }, "models": [ { "model": "claude-sonnet-5-5", "trainingCutoff": "2026-06-30", "providerDatePrecision": "month", "source": "https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/models/sonnet-5-5/overview", "sourceVerifiedOn": "2026-10-21" }, { "model": "gpt-6-astra", "declaredCutoff": "2026-04-30", "boundaryKind": "knowledge_cutoff", "providerDatePrecision": "day", "source": "https://developers.openai.com/api/docs/models/gpt-6-astra", "sourceVerifiedOn": "2026-10-22", "sourceScopeNote": "Official knowledge cutoff; not a separately documented endpoint for every training stage" }, { "model": "gemini-4-argon-high", "declaredCutoff": "2026-03-31", "boundaryKind": "knowledge_cutoff", "providerDatePrecision": "month", "source": "https://deepmind.google/models/model-cards/gemini-4-argon/", "sourceVerifiedOn": "2026-10-22", "sourceScopeNote": "Official Gemini 4 knowledge cutoff; high is the original reasoning setting" }, { "model": "grok-4.5", "declaredCutoff": "2026-01-31", "boundaryKind": "pretraining_cutoff", "providerDatePrecision": "month", "source": "https://cursor.com/resources/grok-4-5-model-card.pdf", "sourceVerifiedOn": "2026-10-22", "sourceScopeNote": "Joint SpaceXAI and Cursor model card dated 2026-07-14, section 1.2: January 2026 pretraining cutoff. Supplemental midtraining and post-training are disclosed without a separate final data date; the later Grok 4.6 summary does not establish a different Grok 4.5 pretraining cutoff" } ], "judges": [ "gpt-5.6-sol", "claude-opus-5-5", "grok-4.7" ], "judgeRelationships": { "claude-sonnet-5-5": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "claude-opus-5-5" ] }, "gpt-6-astra": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "gpt-5.6-sol" ] }, "gemini-4-argon-high": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [] }, "grok-4.5": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "grok-4.7" ] } }, "requestUnits": 50, "hypotheses": 250, "sourceCount": 50, "pilot": "First three fixed request units, technical checks only; retain unchanged in full run", "maxResponseAttempts": 2, "maxTokens": 32000, "tools": false, "parsing": "Strict original execution; primary first single-unambiguous-JSON analysis from original complete raw replies, same fixed two-response budget; strict sensitivity analysis retained", "extractionSourceSha256": "9ca4d161f996dfd66e13b812bc4fd940e76db1e547d67e6d8aab9f529b813189", "question": "For each hypothesis below, will it be confirmed experimentally?", "selectionRule": { "first": "gpt-6-astra", "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 4, "endpoint": "core", "handling": "first_unambiguous_json", "primary": "Article matches among selected hypotheses (positive predictive value)", "secondary": "Selected article matches among all reference-positive hypotheses (sensitivity); losses at each stage; four metrics against the original saved coin on identical identities", "reference": "Grok/N retrospective path on 2026-10-23: 240 input, 53 after Astra, 19 after unanimity, 14 of 19 article matches, 14 of 40 sensitivity", "fixedBeforeCalls": true }, "combinations": "All nonempty subsets of the four predictors and all minimum-vote thresholds, 32 rules; exact vote counts 0..4", "comparison": "Exact common valid identities for every combination and individual/coin baseline; technical gaps remain separate", "uncertainty": "10000 paired source/question-cluster percentile bootstrap replicates; seed 20261022", "referenceScope": "Saved article correspondence, not experimental confirmation or refutation; the generator forecasts its own hypotheses like Grok did in the Grok cohort" }, "cohort": { "generator": "gemini-4-argon-high", "arm": "N", "judges": [ "gpt-5.6-sol", "claude-opus-5-5", "grok-4.7" ], "referenceRule": "At least two of three judges from other companies (gpt-5.6-sol, claude-opus-5-5, grok-4.7) score >=3 (core) or >=4 (strict) on the unchanged six-level article-correspondence scale. Unmatched hypotheses are not experimentally refuted.", "historicalIsolation": "Original generation/judge requests do not carry complete current per-request no-tools proof; current forecasts are separately audited.", "tasks": [ { "id": "R42581103", "pmid": "42581103", "doi": "10.1038/s43587-026-01170-7", "title": "TNFR1 signaling connects inflammation to impaired fatty acid oxidation to drive intestinal stem cell aging.", "journal": "Nat Aging", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism by which an age-associated systemic inflammatory factor impairs intestinal stem-cell function.", "background": "Intestinal stem-cell function and regenerative capacity decline with age, compromising maintenance and repair of the intestinal epithelium. Both cell-intrinsic changes and signals from the aged systemic environment may contribute to this decline. Chronic inflammation and altered cellular metabolism are common features of ageing, but how circulating conditions are translated into functional defects in intestinal regeneration was unresolved. It was also unclear whether manipulating systemic or metabolic processes could preserve or restore aged stem-cell activity.", "question": "How does the aged systemic environment causally impair intestinal stem-cell metabolism and regenerative function?", "subject": "Systemic control of ISC ageing", "finding": "Age-associated TNF acts as a systemic pro-ageing factor that signals through epithelial TNFR1 to suppress mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation, proliferation and regenerative capacity in intestinal stem cells. Blocking inflammation or TNF–TNFR1 signaling protects or restores ISC function, while enhancing mitochondrial fusion improves the function of aged ISCs.", "key_points": [ "The old systemic environment transfers an ISC ageing phenotype to young mice.", "TNF is a causal pro-ageing inflammatory factor.", "Epithelial TNFR1 is required for the detrimental systemic effect.", "TNF suppresses mitochondrial pathways and fatty acid oxidation.", "Countering inflammation or improving mitochondrial function restores ISC activity." ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 3, "text": "Systemic inflammaging alters circulating iron regulation and lipid composition to induce intracellular labile iron accumulation and polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) peroxidation in Lgr5+ ISCs, poising aged stem cells for ferroptotic metabolic arrest when challenged to proliferate during regeneration. Systemic iron chelation, radical-trapping antioxidant therapy, or restoration of GPX4/GSH metabolic capacity rescues aged ISC survival and epithelial repair. Mechanism: Age-related increases in circulating IL-6 and oxidized low-density lipoproteins stimulate hepatic and local hepcidin signaling while downregulating ferroportin in intestinal crypt cells, trapping labile Fe2+ within Lgr5+ ISCs. Concurrently, systemic oxidative stress and inflammatory cytokines suppress cystine uptake via SLC7A11, depleting intracellular glutathione (GSH) and limiting GPX4 activity; when aged ISCs increase mitochondrial metabolic flux to divide after tissue damage, Fenton-driven peroxidation of membrane phospholipids triggers sub-lethal or lethal ferroptotic stress that halts crypt regeneration. Prediction: Lgr5+ ISCs isolated from aged mice or young mice exposed to aged blood will exhibit elevated labile iron, depleted GSH/GSSG ratios, and accumulation of 4-HNE and peroxidized phosphatidylethanolamines upon regenerative stimulation, and systemic administration of liproxstatin-1, deferoxamine, or N-acetylcysteine will selectively restore aged crypt regeneration following radiation injury without altering basal Wnt or FAO gene expression.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Age-associated circulating senescent-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) factors and endotoxins induce ectopic upregulation of the NAD+-consuming ectozyme CD38 across the pericryptal vascular niche and intestinal epithelium, systematically depleting intracellular NAD+ in Lgr5+ ISCs and crippling sirtuin-dependent mitochondrial quality control. Pharmacological inhibition of systemic CD38 activity or restoration of circulating NAD+ precursors reverses mitochondrial dysfunction and rescues aged intestinal regeneration. Mechanism: Circulating IL-6, TNF-alpha, and microbial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from the aged systemic milieu stimulate CD38 expression on lamina propria macrophages, pericryptal endothelial cells, and crypt progenitor cells, accelerating extracellular and intracellular degradation of NAD+ and nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN). The resulting fall in the ISC NAD+/NADH ratio inactivates SIRT1 and SIRT3, leading to hyperacetylation and inhibition of PGC-1alpha and mitochondrial complex I/II subunits, defective mitophagy, accumulation of dysfunctional mitochondria, and failure to meet the bioenergetic demands of regenerative proliferation. Prediction: Heterochronic parabiosis or aged plasma infusion into young mice will elevate crypt CD38 enzymatic activity and reduce Lgr5+ ISC NAD+ levels and mitochondrial membrane potential, whereas systemic treatment of aged mice with a selective CD38 inhibitor (such as 78c) or nicotinamide riboside (NR) will restore ISC SIRT1/SIRT3 deacetylase activity, normalize mitochondrial respiration, and rescue crypt regeneration even in the continued presence of elevated circulating inflammatory cytokines.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Circulating pro-inflammatory cytokines elevated in the aged systemic environment (specifically TNF-alpha, IFN-gamma, and IL-1beta) directly suppress mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation (FAO) and ketogenesis in Lgr5+ intestinal stem cells (ISCs), depriving them of the bioenergetic and signaling metabolites required for epithelial regeneration. Systemic neutralization of these inflammatory signals or metabolic bypass via PPAR-delta activation or ketone body supplementation restores aged ISC regenerative capacity. Mechanism: Chronic exposure of the intestinal crypt to blood-borne pro-inflammatory cytokines activates NF-kappaB and STAT1 signaling within Lgr5+ ISCs, which transcriptionally represses PPAR-delta target genes including CPT1A (the rate-limiting enzyme of mitochondrial FAO) and HMGCS2 (the rate-limiting enzyme of ketogenesis). The resulting depletion of mitochondrial acetyl-CoA and endogenous beta-hydroxybutyrate impairs class I HDAC inhibition, attenuates Notch and Wnt target gene activation, and shifts ISCs toward inefficient glycolysis, causing stem-cell exhaustion and defective crypt regeneration following injury. Prediction: Exposing young intestinal organoids to aged serum or establishing heterochronic parabiosis will acutely downregulate ISC Cpt1a and Hmgcs2 expression and reduce palmitate oxidation flux, whereas administering a PPAR-delta agonist, exogenous beta-hydroxybutyrate, or systemic anti-TNF-alpha/IFN-gamma neutralizing antibodies in aged mice will restore ISC organoid-forming efficiency and post-irradiation crypt regeneration without rescuing defects driven by NAD+ or iron homeostasis.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Elevated circulating interferons and pro-inflammatory cytokines in the aged systemic environment rewire tryptophan and one-carbon metabolism across the systemic-intestinal axis by inducing indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase 1 (IDO1), depleting tryptophan while accumulating kynurenine metabolites that suppress ISC mitochondrial respiration and proliferative anabolism. Inhibiting systemic IDO1 activity or restoring one-carbon and nucleotide biosynthesis rescues aged ISC regenerative capacity. Mechanism: Chronic elevation of circulating IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha in aged blood transcriptionally induces IDO1 in systemic myeloid cells, vascular endothelium, and intestinal crypt cells, shunting essential tryptophan away from serotonin/melatonin synthesis toward kynurenine and quinolinic acid production. Elevated kynurenine activates aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AHR) signaling excessively in Lgr5+ ISCs while uncoupling mitochondrial electron transport and inhibiting serine-glycine one-carbon (SGOC) flux, thereby restricting de novo purine/thymidylate synthesis and S-adenosylmethionine (SAM)-dependent epigenetic remodeling required for rapid progenitor expansion during epithelial repair. Prediction: Metabolomic profiling of aged plasma and Lgr5+ ISCs from heterochronic parabionts will reveal an elevated kynurenine-to-tryptophan ratio alongside depleted intracellular serine, SAM, and purine nucleotides, and systemic administration of a small-molecule IDO1 inhibitor (such as epacadostat) or formate/serine supplementation in aged mice will normalize AHR target gene expression, restore nucleotide pools, and rescue post-injury intestinal epithelial regeneration.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 2, "text": "Chronic systemic inflammation in ageing hyperactivates mTORC1 signaling in both Lgr5+ ISCs and niche Paneth cells, suppressing autophagic-lysosomal metabolic recycling while stimulating paracrine secretion of the Wnt deacylase Notum to block stem-cell self-renewal. Systemic mTORC1 inhibition or pharmacological restoration of autophagic flux preserves metabolic plasticity and restores regenerative function in the aged intestine. Mechanism: Elevated circulating insulin, branched-chain amino acids, and pro-inflammatory cytokines (such as IL-1beta and IL-6) in aged blood converge on PI3K-AKT and IKKbeta pathways to drive persistent mTORC1 activation within the intestinal crypt. In Lgr5+ ISCs, constitutive mTORC1 activity phosphorylates and inhibits ULK1 and TFEB, blocking lipophagy and mitophagy required for metabolic remodeling during injury repair; simultaneously, in adjacent Paneth cells, mTORC1 reduces PPAR-alpha/delta activity and upregulates extracellular Notum, which deacylates and inactivates Wnt ligands essential for ISC maintenance. Prediction: Aged serum exposure will simultaneously increase phosphorylated S6/4E-BP1, block autophagic flux, and elevate Notum secretion in young crypt organoids, while transient systemic rapamycin treatment, spermidine supplementation, or pharmacological Notum inhibition in aged mice will restore autophagic-lysosomal turnover and canonical Wnt signaling, selectively rescuing post-injury ISC expansion over bioenergetic substrate supplementation alone.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42601407", "pmid": "42601407", "doi": "10.1038/s43587-026-01177-0", "title": "Physical activity delays ovarian aging in part through adiponectin-related signaling pathways.", "journal": "Nat Aging", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-14", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally identifies a causal signaling mechanism that delays ovarian ageing and extends reproductive lifespan in mice.", "background": "Ovarian ageing progressively reduces fertility, disrupts endocrine function and contributes to later-life disease risk. This decline involves losses in follicle quantity and quality as well as deterioration of the ovarian tissue environment. Although lifestyle and systemic metabolic factors have been associated with reproductive ageing, the causal mechanisms connecting them to ovarian function remain poorly understood. No approved treatment currently delays ovarian ageing or reliably extends reproductive lifespan.", "question": "Through what molecular mechanism does physical activity delay ovarian ageing and extend reproductive lifespan?", "subject": "Physical activity and ovarian ageing", "finding": "Physical activity delays ovarian ageing in mice partly by increasing ovarian adiponectin signaling. Its protective effects were attenuated in adiponectin-deficient mice, while pharmacological activation of adiponectin receptors with AdipoRon delayed ovarian ageing and extended reproductive lifespan.", "key_points": [ "Physical activity delays ovarian ageing in mice", "Physical activity increases ovarian adiponectin levels", "Adiponectin deficiency attenuates the protective effect", "AdipoRon delays ovarian ageing", "AdipoRon extends reproductive lifespan" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "Contraction-induced secretion of the myokine irisin (FNDC5) preserves the primordial follicle pool by activating AMPK and inhibiting mTORC1 signaling in the ovarian cortex. By suppressing premature primordial-to-primary follicle activation, circulating irisin prevents accelerated exhaustion of the finite ovarian reserve during ageing. Mechanism: Physical activity upregulates PGC-1α in skeletal muscle, driving cleavage and systemic release of irisin, which binds αVβ5 integrin receptors on primordial follicle pre-granulosa cells and oocytes. This activates the LKB1-AMPK pathway, which phosphorylates TSC2 and Raptor to inhibit mTORC1-S6K1 signaling and suppress KIT ligand expression, thereby maintaining FOXO3a in the oocyte nucleus to enforce dormancy and prevent premature follicle burnout. Prediction: Skeletal muscle-specific deletion of Fndc5 or ovarian blockade of αVβ5 integrins in exercising female mice will abolish nuclear FOXO3a retention in primordial oocytes and fail to preserve primordial follicle numbers, whereas systemic irisin administration in sedentary mice will preserve the primordial reserve without altering stromal stiffness or vascular density.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Physical activity reverses age-related ovarian stromal fibrosis and cortical stiffening by shifting resident ovarian macrophages toward a matrix-resolving phenotype via the muscle-derived exerkine meteorin-like (Metrnl). This restoration of biomechanical compliance prevents aberrant mechanotransduction in growing follicles and sustains ovulatory competence. Mechanism: Exercise elevates circulating Metrnl, which signals through STAT6 in ovarian stromal macrophages to downregulate the NAD+-consuming ectoenzyme CD38 and suppress TGF-β1 secretion while inducing matrix metalloproteinases (MMP9 and MMP13). The resulting clearance of lysyl oxidase (LOX)-crosslinked Type I/III collagen lowers cortical extracellular matrix stiffness, preventing nuclear translocation of YAP/TAZ in granulosa cells and restoring antral follicle expansion and ovulation. Prediction: Myeloid-specific deletion of Stat6 or antibody neutralization of circulating Metrnl in exercising aged mice will prevent reductions in ovarian cortical elastic modulus (measured by atomic force microscopy) and collagen cross-linking, abolishing the exercise-induced rescue of ovulation rates despite intact oocyte mitochondrial function.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "Physical activity extends reproductive lifespan by dampening age-associated sympathetic hyperactivity in the ovary via the superior ovarian nerve, preventing adrenergic overstimulation of theca-interstitial cells. This autonomic rebalancing preserves normal steroidogenesis, prevents stromal hyperthecosis, and maintains regular estrous cyclicity. Mechanism: Chronic exercise suppresses age-related neuroinflammation in the mediobasal hypothalamus and reduces tonic sympathetic outflow through the celiaco-mesenteric ganglion and superior ovarian nerve. Lowered intra-ovarian norepinephrine and nerve growth factor (NGF) signaling attenuates chronic β2-adrenergic receptor (ADRB2)-cAMP-PKA activation in theca and interstitial cells, preventing aberrant androgen excess, oxidative stress, and premature luteinization that disrupt hypothalamic-pituitary-ovarian feedback. Prediction: Chemogenetic (DREADD-mediated) stimulation of sympathetic fibers projecting to the ovary via the superior ovarian nerve during long-term exercise will reinstate theca-interstitial hyperplasia and estrous cycle irregularity, whereas selective intra-ovarian β2-adrenergic blockade in sedentary aged mice will phenocopy the prolonged estrous cyclicity of exercised animals.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 3, "text": "Recurrent exercise-induced increases in pelvic blood flow delay follicular atresia by activating endothelial mechanosensors that prevent age-related microvascular rarefaction and local hypoxia in the ovarian cortex. Preserved capillary perfusion and angiocrine signaling sustain granulosa cell survival and gonadotropin delivery during late folliculogenesis. Mechanism: Elevated laminar shear stress within the ovarian microvasculature during aerobic activity activates endothelial PIEZO1 ion channels and the KLF2/eNOS pathway. Resulting endothelial nitric oxide production and angiocrine release of VEGF-A and PDGF-B maintain pericyte coverage and cortical capillary density, preventing chronic stromal hypoxia, HIF-1α-driven metabolic stress, and iron-dependent ferroptosis in granulosa cells of growing antral follicles. Prediction: Endothelial-specific knockout of Piezo1 or Nos3 in exercising mice will block the preservation of ovarian cortical capillary density and pericyte coverage (quantified by 3D light-sheet microscopy) and fail to reduce antral follicle atresia, despite normal circulating levels of muscle-derived myokines and sEVs.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 2, "text": "Exercise enhances oocyte quality and prevents age-related maternal aneuploidy by delivering extracellular nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (eNAMPT) within circulating small extracellular vesicles (sEVs) to cumulus-oocyte complexes. The resulting surge in intra-oocyte NAD+ activates sirtuin-dependent mitophagy and antioxidant defenses to preserve meiotic spindle integrity. Mechanism: Contracting skeletal muscle and adipose tissue release eNAMPT-enriched sEVs that cross the blood-follicle barrier and are internalized by cumulus cells and the oocyte. Elevated intracellular NAMPT restores the declining NAD+ pool to activate mitochondrial SIRT3 and nuclear SIRT1, which deacetylate SOD2 and promote PINK1/Parkin-mediated mitophagy, eliminating reactive oxygen species-producing damaged mitochondria and preventing cohesion loss and spindle assembly defects during meiosis. Prediction: Depleting Nampt specifically in muscle/adipose sEVs or blocking sEV biogenesis in exercising aged mice will prevent the restoration of oocyte NAD+ levels, mitochondrial membrane potential, and euploid metaphase II oocyte rates, even while primordial follicle reserve and stromal mechanics remain improved.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42605193", "pmid": "42605193", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70671", "title": "An ANGPTL8-AKT2-mTOR Axis Drives Adipose Senescence and Aging-Related Functional Decline.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper reports an experimentally validated causal mechanism that promotes cellular senescence, systemic functional decline, and reduced lifespan.", "background": "Cellular senescence increases with age and can disrupt tissue function through persistent changes in cell state and signaling. Metabolic dysfunction and chronic inflammation are closely associated with this process and with broader age-related deterioration. Circulating factors can coordinate physiological changes across organs, but it remains unclear which factors actively cause senescence rather than merely correlate with ageing. Identifying the responsible signals and their intracellular mechanisms could reveal targets for extending healthspan.", "question": "Which circulating regulator causally promotes cellular senescence and organismal ageing, and through what intracellular signaling mechanism does it act?", "subject": "Endocrine control of senescence", "finding": "ANGPTL8 directly interacts with AKT2 and activates the AKT–mTOR–S6K pathway, thereby driving cell-autonomous adipocyte senescence. Deleting Angptl8 in mice reduces adipose senescence, delays age-related functional decline, and extends lifespan, while genetic or pharmacological pathway inhibition abolishes ANGPTL8-induced senescence.", "key_points": [ "ANGPTL8 is a causal pro-senescent regulator", "ANGPTL8 directly interacts with AKT2", "AKT–mTOR–S6K activation drives adipocyte senescence", "Angptl8 deletion improves function and extends mouse lifespan", "Pathway inhibition blocks the pro-senescent effect" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Circulating redox-modified High-Mobility Group Box 1 (HMGB1) released from early senescent and metabolically stressed cells acts as an endocrine alarmin that causally propagates cellular senescence and chronic sterile inflammation across distant organs. Systemic elevation of extracellular HMGB1 converts localized tissue damage into organism-wide senescent and metabolic deterioration. Mechanism: Circulating reduced and disulfide isoforms of HMGB1 bind the Receptor for Advanced Glycation Endproducts (RAGE) and Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) on target endothelial, metabolic, and progenitor cells, recruiting MyD88 and TIRAP to activate p38 MAPK and IKK/NF-κB while promoting cytosolic leakage of mitochondrial DNA that engages the cGAS–STING–TBK1–IRF3 axis. This convergent signaling sustains persistent ATM/ATR-dependent p53–p21CIP1 and p16INK4a expression and amplifies systemic SASP secretion. Prediction: Systemic neutralization of extracellular HMGB1 with a conformation-specific monoclonal antibody or soluble RAGE decoy receptor in aged or heterochronic parabiotic mice will prevent the transfer of senescence from aged blood to young recipient tissues, blunt tissue p38 MAPK/NF-κB and cGAS–STING activation, and improve systemic insulin sensitivity and physical function without requiring direct senolysis of primary senescent cells.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Sustained elevation of circulating insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) and hyperinsulinemia in adulthood causally accelerate cellular senescence and organismal ageing by chronically hyperactivating nutrient-sensing growth pathways while repressing stress-resistance transcriptional networks. This endocrine imbalance couples systemic metabolic overload directly to defective proteostasis, mitochondrial dysfunction, and irreversible cell-cycle arrest. Mechanism: Circulating IGF-1 and insulin bind IGF-1R and insulin receptors (IR) to activate IRS1/2–PI3K–AKT signaling, which phosphorylates and sequesters FOXO1/3a transcription factors in the cytoplasm while activating mTORC1 via TSC2 inhibition. Loss of nuclear FOXO activity depletes antioxidant enzymes (SOD2, catalase) and autophagic machinery, while persistent mTORC1 and AKT-mediated inhibition of MDM2/SIRT1 stabilizes p53, driving oxidative DNA damage and sustained p21CIP1/p16INK4a-mediated cellular senescence. Prediction: Inducible, adult-onset attenuation of circulating IGF-1 bioavailability (e.g., via liver-specific Igf1 reduction or pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A [PAPP-A] inhibition) will restore nuclear FOXO3a localization and autophagic flux, prevent p53–p21CIP1-driven senescent cell accumulation across metabolic organs, reduce chronic systemic inflammation, and extend healthspan relative to interventions targeting downstream inflammatory cytokines alone.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Age-related elevation of circulating interleukin-11 (IL-11) causally promotes multi-organ cellular senescence, metabolic dysfunction, and organismal ageing. Secreted progressively by aged hepatocytes, adipocytes, and stromal cells, circulating IL-11 coordinates systemic tissue decline by simultaneously driving pro-senescent anabolic signaling and suppressing cellular energy-sensing pathways. Mechanism: Circulating IL-11 binds the cell-surface IL-11Rα/gp130 receptor complex in target parenchymal and stromal cells to activate MEK/ERK1/2, which phosphorylates and inactivates LKB1 (at Ser428) to suppress AMPK while concurrently activating mTORC1–S6K1 and canonical JAK2/STAT3 signaling. This dual ERK–mTORC1 activation and AMPK inhibition halts autophagic and mitophagic flux, increases mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS), and transcriptionally upregulates p16INK4a, p21CIP1, and NF-κB-dependent senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) factors. Prediction: Systemic administration of neutralizing anti-IL-11 or anti-IL-11Rα antibodies, or adult-onset Il11ra1 deletion, in middle-aged mice will restore tissue AMPK activity, suppress mTORC1 and STAT3 hyperactivation, reduce multi-organ p16INK4a/p21CIP1 senescence burden, reverse age-related insulin resistance and hepatic steatosis, and extend median and maximum lifespan; conversely, chronic IL-11 infusion in young mice will induce widespread senescence that is blocked by pharmacological ERK1/2 or mTORC1 inhibition.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 1, "text": "Age-associated accumulation of circulating and tissue-depositing immunoglobulin G (IgG) causally triggers macrophage activation, adipose and organ fibrosis, metabolic impairment, and paracrine/endocrine cellular senescence across ageing tissues. Rather than acting solely as a passive marker of humoral immunity, excess circulating IgG directly reprograms myeloid and stromal cells into a senescent, pro-inflammatory state. Mechanism: Neonatal Fc receptor (FcRn)-mediated recycling prolongs the half-life of circulating IgG, which engages Fcγ receptors (FcγRI/III) on tissue-resident macrophages, preadipocytes, and fibroblasts to recruit Syk and Src family kinases. Downstream activation of the Ras–Raf–MEK–ERK cascade, NOX2-dependent oxidative stress, and IKKβ/NF-κB signaling induces DNA damage response (DDR) signaling, upregulates p21CIP1 and p16INK4a, and stimulates TGF-β and pro-inflammatory cytokine release that propagates systemic senescence. Prediction: Reducing circulating IgG levels in aged mice via antisense oligonucleotide knockdown of Fcgrt (encoding FcRn) or B-cell depletion will attenuate macrophage Syk/ERK/NF-κB activation, lower senescent cell accumulation and fibrosis in white adipose tissue, liver, and brain, and restore systemic glucose homeostasis, whereas passive transfer of purified aged IgG into young mice will induce multi-organ senescence in an FcγR-dependent manner.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Elevated circulating Activin A and its downstream effector Plasminogen Activator Inhibitor-1 (PAI-1/SERPINE1) form a self-reinforcing endocrine loop that causally drives multi-organ cellular senescence, lipotoxicity, and systemic ageing. Secreted by senescent preadipocytes and vascular endothelial cells, circulating Activin A and PAI-1 coordinate tissue degeneration, fibrotic remodeling, and metabolic resistance across organs. Mechanism: Circulating Activin A binds ACVR2A/B and ALK4/5 receptors on target cells to phosphorylate SMAD2/3, which transcriptionally induces the NADPH oxidase NOX4 (generating mitochondrial and nuclear ROS), upregulates the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors p15INK4b and p21CIP1, and suppresses master metabolic regulators PPARγ and PGC-1α. Concurrently, SMAD2/3-induced circulating PAI-1 inhibits extracellular uPA/tPA proteolytic activity and signals through LRP1 to sustain intracellular PI3K/AKT–mTOR survival pathways and prevent p53 degradation, stabilizing the senescent growth arrest. Prediction: Pharmacological inhibition of ALK4/5 signaling, soluble ActRIIB decoy trapping, or small-molecule PAI-1 inhibition (e.g., TM5441) in aged mice will block SMAD2/3–NOX4 activation, restore adipose and hepatic PGC-1α expression, reduce systemic p15INK4b/p21CIP1 senescent cell burden, and rescue insulin sensitivity and organ function even in the presence of persistent upstream inflammatory cytokines.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42608398", "pmid": "42608398", "doi": "10.1038/s41467-026-76162-7", "title": "Corisin induces proteostasis stress to drive epithelial injury and pulmonary fibrosis.", "journal": "Nat Commun", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper establishes a specific, experimentally validated mechanism connecting a microbial factor to cellular senescence, tissue injury, and an age-associated fibrotic disease.", "background": "Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis is a progressive, age-associated disorder characterized by recurring tissue injury and excessive fibrotic remodeling. Abnormal cell-fate programs, including apoptosis, senescence, and phenotypic transitions, are thought to contribute to disease progression. Changes in the lung microbiota have also been associated with disease severity, but association alone has not established a direct pathogenic mechanism. It remained unclear whether a microbiota-derived product could independently initiate the cellular dysfunction and progressive fibrosis observed in this disease.", "question": "Can a microbiota-derived factor directly cause the cellular dysfunction and progressive tissue remodeling characteristic of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, and if so, through what mechanism?", "subject": "Microbial induction of fibrosis", "finding": "The microbiota-derived peptide corisin directly disrupts epithelial proteostasis by targeting and enhancing the ubiquitin-proteasome system, thereby inducing apoptosis, cellular senescence, epithelial-mesenchymal transition, and fibrotic remodeling. Depleting native corisin from patient bronchoalveolar lavage fluid removes its proapoptotic activity, while constitutive corisin expression in mice causes spontaneous progressive pulmonary fibrosis and worsens bleomycin-induced injury and mortality.", "key_points": [ "Corisin is present and functionally active in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid from patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis.", "Corisin enters epithelial cells, localizes to mitochondria, and induces apoptosis, senescence, and epithelial-mesenchymal transition.", "Corisin enhances proteasome activity and disrupts epithelial proteostasis.", "Removing corisin abolishes the proapoptotic activity of patient lavage fluid.", "Native corisin expression is sufficient to cause progressive pulmonary fibrosis in mice." ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Microbiota-derived cyclic dinucleotides and unmethylated CpG DNA released during bacterial turnover directly initiate alveolar epithelial senescence, apoptosis, and mesenchymal transition by hyperactivating intracellular nucleic acid sensors. In aged lungs, persistent cytosolic and endosomal DNA sensing converts transient microbial exposure into self-sustaining fibrotic tissue remodeling. Mechanism: Bacterial cyclic dinucleotides (c-di-AMP and c-di-GMP) and extracellular microbial DNA enter alveolar epithelial and mesenchymal cells to directly engage cytosolic STING and endosomal TLR9. Chronic STING-TBK1-IRF3 and NF-kappaB activation triggers endoplasmic reticulum stress and BAX/BAK-dependent apoptosis in vulnerable AT2 cells while enforcing a p53/p21-dependent senescence program with a profibrotic SASP (IL-6, PAI-1, TGF-beta1) and promoting direct myofibroblast transdifferentiation. Prediction: DNase or phosphodiesterase treatment of microbiota-derived supernatants, or genetic ablation of Sting1 or Tlr9 in mice, will abrogate microbiota-induced alveolar senescence, phenotypic transitions, and lung fibrosis, whereas protease-treated nucleic-acid-enriched bacterial fractions will remain fully fibrogenic.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Diffusible small-molecule metabolites secreted by dysbiotic lung bacteria directly reprogram host chromatin states and mitochondrial redox balance in alveolar progenitor cells, initiating concurrent apoptosis, senescence, and profibrotic phenotypic transitions. This metabolic-epigenetic remodeling establishes a stable, cell-autonomous fibrotic program that persists even after microbial clearance. Mechanism: Low-molecular-weight bacterial metabolites (such as siderophores or aromatic amino acid catabolites) accumulate in the alveolar niche and competitively inhibit host alpha-ketoglutarate-dependent dioxygenases, including TET DNA demethylases and JmjC-domain histone demethylases, while chelating labile mitochondrial iron. The resulting aberrant histone hypermethylation (H3K27me3 and H3K9me3) silences epithelial identity genes (SFTPC, CDH1) while derepressing cell-cycle arrest loci (CDKN2A, CDKN1A) and mesenchymal transcription factors (ZEB1, TWIST1), coupling mitochondrial apoptosis with senescence and EMT. Prediction: A heat-stable, protease-resistant, low-molecular-weight (<3 kDa) filtrate of fibrotic lung microbiota culture supernatant will be sufficient to induce histone hypermethylation, AT2 senescence, EMT, and pulmonary fibrosis in lung organoids and mice, and these effects will be rescued by alpha-ketoglutarate or iron supplementation rather than neutralizing antibodies or nuclease treatment.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "A conserved pro-apoptotic peptide proteolytically cleaved from bacterial cell-wall transglycosylases (such as corisin derived from lung-resident Staphylococcus and related commensal bacteria) directly initiates progressive pulmonary fibrosis without requiring live infection. This microbiota-derived peptide acts on alveolar epithelial cells to simultaneously trigger apoptosis, cellular senescence, and epithelial-to-mesenchymal phenotypic transitions. Mechanism: Extracellular bacterial serine proteases cleave conserved regions of bacterial transglycosylases to release a bioactive peptide into the alveolar space. Upon internalization or receptor engagement on alveolar type II (AT2) epithelial cells, the peptide disrupts mitochondrial membrane potential and increases mitochondrial reactive oxygen species, triggering intrinsic caspase-3-mediated apoptosis in a subset of cells while activating ATM/p53/p21 DNA damage signaling, senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) release, and TGF-beta1/SMAD- and Snail-mediated epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) in surviving cells to drive myofibroblast accumulation and extracellular matrix deposition. Prediction: Intratracheal instillation of the purified synthetic bacterial peptide alone into uninjured mice will be sufficient to induce AT2 apoptosis, p21/SA-beta-gal-positive senescence, EMT marker expression, and progressive collagen deposition, whereas protease-resistant removal of peptidic factors or treatment with a peptide-neutralizing monoclonal antibody will completely abolish these cell-fate abnormalities and fibrotic remodeling.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 1, "text": "Outer membrane vesicles (OMVs) shed by dysbiotic Gram-negative lung bacteria directly trigger progressive pulmonary fibrosis by activating innate immune signaling cascades across the alveolar-macrophage-epithelial unit. Vesicle-associated lipopolysaccharides and lipoproteins induce chronic paracrine stress that drives alveolar epithelial apoptosis, replicative senescence, and arrest in a profibrotic transitional cell state. Mechanism: Microbiota-derived OMVs penetrate the alveolar surfactant layer and activate TLR2/TLR4-MyD88 and NLRP3 inflammasome signaling in resident alveolar macrophages and AT2 cells, driving sustained release of IL-17B, IL-1beta, and TNF-alpha. This inflammatory milieu activates NF-kappaB and STAT3 signaling in alveolar epithelial progenitors, causing caspase-dependent apoptosis alongside p16INK4a/p21-mediated senescence and arresting AT2-to-AT1 differentiation in an aberrant KRT8+/claudin-4+ transitional phenotype that secretes TGF-beta and CTGF to activate lung fibroblasts. Prediction: Intrapulmonary delivery of purified, cell-free bacterial OMVs will induce epithelial senescence, KRT8+ transitional cell accumulation, and pulmonary fibrosis in wild-type and germ-free mice, whereas genetic deletion of MyD88 or IL-17RB, or enzymatic depletion of vesicular lipid cargo, will selectively prevent fibrosis compared to soluble peptide or small-molecule fractions.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Sub-lytic concentrations of pore-forming protein toxins secreted by lung pathobionts directly cause alveolar cellular dysfunction and progressive fibrosis by disrupting plasma membrane ion gradients in epithelial and endothelial cells. The resulting intracellular calcium overload coordinates concurrent apoptosis, premature senescence, and mesenchymal transition. Mechanism: Oligomerization of bacterial pore-forming toxins (such as streptococcal pneumolysin or staphylococcal alpha-hemolysin) in host cell membranes causes sustained Ca2+ influx and K+ efflux without immediate cytolysis. Cytosolic and mitochondrial Ca2+ overload activates calpains and opens the mitochondrial permeability transition pore to induce apoptosis in severely stressed cells, while activating calcineurin-NFAT and Wnt/beta-catenin signaling in surviving cells to enforce cellular senescence and epithelial- and endothelial-to-mesenchymal transitions (EMT/EndMT). Prediction: Chronic low-dose administration of wild-type pore-forming toxin, but not a single-point non-pore-forming toxoid mutant or heat-denatured toxin, will replicate alveolar apoptosis, senescence, EMT/EndMT, and progressive lung fibrosis, and pharmacological inhibition of host calcium influx or cholesterol-dependent membrane pore assembly will selectively block disease progression.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42627902", "pmid": "42627902", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aeb1346", "title": "Geneformer-guided multiomics integration identifies Pbx1 as a network hub of hematopoietic stem cell aging.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-21", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper reports an experimentally supported regulatory mechanism underlying age-associated deterioration in blood-cell production.", "background": "Ageing alters blood-cell production, commonly shifting lineage output and reducing regenerative balance. These changes can contribute to anemia, impaired immunity, and abnormal clotting in older organisms. Age-related transcriptional and epigenetic remodeling has been implicated, but the regulators that causally connect altered gene programs to lineage imbalance remain incompletely understood. Identifying such regulators could reveal ways to restore healthier blood production during ageing.", "question": "Which regulatory mechanism drives the age-associated shift away from erythroid differentiation and toward platelet-producing lineage programs?", "subject": "Age-related blood lineage imbalance", "finding": "Pbx1 is a regulatory hub that drives age-related transcriptional and differentiation changes in hematopoietic stem cells. It suppresses erythroid differentiation by repressing Gata1 expression, thereby contributing to the lineage imbalance characteristic of HSC ageing.", "key_points": [ "Pbx1 is a key regulator of HSC ageing", "Pbx1 represses Gata1 expression", "Pbx1 suppresses erythroid differentiation", "The mechanism contributes to age-related lineage imbalance" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 4, "text": "Age-dependent mitochondrial dysfunction and impaired heme/iron homeostasis in hematopoietic progenitors stabilize the heme-regulated transcriptional repressor BACH1, which selectively silences erythroid commitment programs and diverts shared progenitors toward the megakaryocytic fate. This metabolic-transcriptional checkpoint couples declining organelle bioenergetics directly to lineage imbalance. Mechanism: Ageing HSCs and MEPs exhibit defective mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation, elevated reactive oxygen species (ROS), and impaired mitochondrial iron incorporation into heme; lower intracellular regulatory heme prevents heme-induced degradation of BACH1, allowing stabilized BACH1 to outcompete NFE2/MAFK heterodimers at Maf recognition elements (MAREs), thereby repressing erythroid globin and heme-biosynthetic genes while leaving megakaryocytic maturation pathways intact or compensatorily enhanced. Prediction: Aged MEPs will exhibit elevated nuclear BACH1 protein levels and reduced labile heme despite normal transcript levels, and genetic deletion of Bach1 or supplementation with exogenous hemin/mitochondrial antioxidants in aged progenitors will selectively rescue erythroid differentiation and reduce platelet-lineage skewing without altering upstream epigenetic marks.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Age-related decline in Polycomb Repressive Complex 2 (PRC2) activity and loss of H3K27me3 at bivalent megakaryocytic promoters in hematopoietic stem cells derepresses a direct stem-to-megakaryocyte differentiation bypass. Concurrently, aberrant redistribution of residual H3K27me3 and DNA hypermethylation silence key erythroid lineage-priming enhancers. Mechanism: Reduced expression and altered targeting of the PRC2 catalytic subunit EZH2 (coupled with altered DNMT3A/TET2 activity) in aged HSCs selectively erodes repressive H3K27me3 marks at megakaryocyte-specifying loci (including VWF, SELP, and MEIS1), enabling precocious transcriptional activation of platelet programs directly from the stem cell compartment while polycomb-mediated repression accumulates at proliferation-linked erythroid progenitor enhancers. Prediction: CUT&Tag profiling of aged HSCs will demonstrate focal H3K27me3 depletion specifically at megakaryocytic bypass genes rather than global transcription factor upregulation, and pharmacological or genetic restoration of EZH2 methyltransferase activity in aged HSCs will re-establish H3K27me3 at these loci and suppress premature megakaryocytic priming without requiring alterations in cytokine receptor signaling.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "Post-transcriptional downregulation of the transcription factor MYB via age-induced microRNA-150 (miR-150) accumulation and p21/p16-mediated G1 cell-cycle lengthening in megakaryocyte-erythroid progenitors forces a kinetic switch from proliferation-dependent erythroid specification to megakaryocytic polyploidization. Slower progenitor cell-cycle progression causally favors platelet-lineage commitment over erythropoiesis. Mechanism: In aged MEPs, elevated miR-150 post-transcriptionally suppresses MYB mRNA while DNA damage and replication stress induce CDK4/6 inhibitors (CDKN1A/CDKN2A); because erythroid specification requires rapid S-phase transit and high MYB levels to activate KLF1 and c-KIT programs, prolonged G1 phase and low MYB activity permit accumulation of megakaryocytic factors and initiate endomitosis toward platelet production. Prediction: Mutating the miR-150 binding site in the MYB 3'UTR or transiently accelerating G1-to-S phase progression via CDK6 overexpression in aged MEPs will restore erythroid colony formation and suppress excess megakaryocyte differentiation, even if chromatin accessibility and inflammatory cytokine levels remain unchanged.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Chronic age-associated bone marrow inflammation—specifically elevated IL-1β and TNF-α signaling—activates NF-κB and p38 MAPK in hematopoietic progenitors, which induces megakaryocytic priming factors while destabilizing the erythroid transcriptional machinery. This extrinsic inflammatory signaling cascade serves as the primary upstream driver shifting lineage allocation from erythropoiesis to thrombopoiesis. Mechanism: Senescent niche cells and aged myeloid cells secrete IL-1β and TNF-α, engaging IL-1R and TNFR on HSCs and MEPs to activate NF-κB and p38 MAPK; this signaling upregulates PU.1 and GATA2 to repress GATA1-mediated erythroid transcription (and caspase-mediated GATA1 cleavage) while synergizing with thrombopoietin (TPO)/MPL/JAK2-STAT5 signaling to drive emergency-like megakaryocytopoiesis. Prediction: Transplanting aged HSCs into young, inflammation-deficient (e.g., Il1r1-/- or Tnf-/-) recipient mice or treating aged mice with dual IL-1β/TNF-α blockade will rapidly reverse the megakaryocytic transcriptional bias and restore erythroid progenitor output, whereas intrinsic epigenetic or transcription factor perturbations alone will fail to prevent the lineage shift when exposed to aged niche cytokines.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 0, "text": "Age-associated upregulation and chromatin pioneering of the transcription factor FLI1 in hematopoietic stem and megakaryocyte-erythroid progenitor cells (MEPs) directly activates platelet-lineage gene programs while competitively repressing KLF1-driven erythroid differentiation. This shift in the FLI1-to-KLF1 transcriptional balance causally redirects bipotent progenitors and stem cells toward megakaryocytopoiesis during ageing. Mechanism: During ageing, increased accessibility at ETS-family binding motifs allows FLI1 (in cooperation with RUNX1 and GATA2) to occupy and activate megakaryocytic enhancers (such as MPL, ITGA2B, and GP1BA) while physically sequestering GATA1 away from KLF1 and recruiting corepressors to erythroid-specific loci (such as EPOR and HBB), thereby blocking erythroid commitment and promoting direct megakaryocyte generation. Prediction: Single-cell ATAC/RNA-seq of aged HSCs and MEPs will show selective enrichment of open FLI1/ETS motifs prior to lineage commitment, and partial genetic knockdown or degron-mediated reduction of FLI1 in aged progenitors will restore KLF1 target gene expression and normalize the erythroid-to-platelet output ratio even in the presence of an aged inflammatory bone marrow niche.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42630044", "pmid": "42630044", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70687", "title": "Piezo1 Activation Rescues Anabolic Response to Mechanical Loading in Aged Bone via Connexin 43 Hemichannels.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-22", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific mechanism underlying the age-related loss of bone's anabolic response to mechanical loading and demonstrates its rescue in aged mice.", "background": "Mechanical loading normally stimulates bone formation and helps maintain skeletal strength. This anabolic response becomes weaker with age, contributing to cortical bone loss and osteoporosis risk. Bone cells detect physical forces and translate them into signals that regulate the balance between bone formation and resorption. The molecular defect responsible for diminished mechanosensitivity in aged bone, and whether it can be overcome, remained unclear.", "question": "What mechanism limits the anabolic response of aged bone to mechanical loading, and can targeted stimulation restore this response?", "subject": "Aged bone mechanosensitivity", "finding": "In aged mouse bone, activation of Piezo1 during mechanical loading promotes its membrane co-localization with connexin 43 and increases connexin 43 hemichannel activity through PI3K-Akt signaling. Hemichannel opening increases PGE2 release, suppresses sclerostin, promotes endosteal bone formation, inhibits resorption, and thereby restores the cortical anabolic response to loading.", "key_points": [ "Piezo1 activation must accompany mechanical loading to rescue aged bone", "Piezo1 interacts and co-localizes with connexin 43", "PI3K-Akt signaling activates connexin 43 hemichannels", "Hemichannel opening increases PGE2 and suppresses sclerostin", "The pathway increases cortical bone mass by favoring formation over resorption" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 3, "text": "Degradation of the osteocyte pericellular matrix—specifically the loss of perlecan (Hspg2) tethering elements—and narrowing of the lacunar-canalicular network in aged bone attenuate hydrodynamic drag forces on osteocyte dendrites, preventing integrin alphaVbeta3 mechanosome activation. Targeted pharmacological agonism of integrin alphaVbeta3/focal adhesion kinase (FAK) signaling or inhibition of pericellular matrix degradation restores mechanotransduction in aged bone. Mechanism: Osteocytes amplify tissue-level bone strains through interstitial fluid flow across pericellular perlecan tethers that physically pull on dendritic alphaVbeta3 integrins, activating FAK/Src and opening pannexin-1 and connexin-43 hemichannels to release anabolic ATP and PGE2. Age-associated upregulation of matrix metalloproteinases and heparanase degrades these perlecan tethers and disrupts canalicular architecture, reducing force transmission to the dendritic membrane even when mechanosensitive channels remain functional; directly stimulating integrin alphaVbeta3/FAK or preserving tether integrity restores hemichannel opening and osteogenic signaling. Prediction: High-resolution imaging and tracer perfusion of aged bone reveal depleted pericellular perlecan tether density and impaired dendritic Ca2+ wave propagation under normal macroscopic strain, and direct pharmacological activation of integrin alphaVbeta3/FAK (or heparanase/MMP inhibition) rescues load-induced ATP/PGE2 release and bone formation even without altering Piezo1 expression or nerve activity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Ageing impairs the mechanical-load-induced suppression and lysosomal degradation of sclerostin (Sost) in osteocytes, maintaining a constitutive block on canonical Wnt/beta-catenin signaling in osteoblasts. Targeted pharmacological inhibition of sclerostin or restoration of the HDAC4/5- and autophagy-dependent Sost silencing pathway restores the anabolic response of aged bone to loading. Mechanism: Mechanical loading normally triggers osteocytic nitric oxide, prostaglandin E2, and CaMKII signaling that promotes nuclear translocation of HDAC4/5 to repress MEF2C-driven Sost transcription while directing existing sclerostin protein to autophagic-lysosomal degradation, thereby derepressing LRP5/6-Wnt signaling on bone surfaces. In aged osteocytes, defective autophagic flux and impaired HDAC4/5 nuclear import prevent load-induced sclerostin clearance, locking periosteal osteoblasts in a quiescent state unless sclerostin is directly neutralized or its degradative pathway is pharmacologically reactivated. Prediction: Aged bone fails to downregulate osteocytic Sost mRNA and sclerostin protein abundance following axial loading despite intact early mechanosensing (such as initial Ca2+ or PGE2 release), and transient sclerostin neutralization or AMPK/autophagy activation during the loading window specifically restores load-induced beta-catenin nuclear localization and periosteal bone formation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Age-related downregulation of the mechanosensitive cation channel Piezo1 in osteocytes and periosteal osteoprogenitors blunts force-induced calcium influx, limiting the anabolic response of aged bone to mechanical loading. Targeted pharmacological stimulation of Piezo1 lowers the mechanical activation threshold and restores load-induced bone formation in aged skeletons. Mechanism: In young bone, fluid shear stress and membrane tension generated by mechanical loading open Piezo1 channels in osteocytes and osteoprogenitors, triggering rapid intracellular Ca2+ influx that activates calcineurin/NFAT, YAP/TAZ nuclear translocation, and Wnt1 expression to drive osteogenesis. With ageing, reduced Piezo1 expression and altered membrane mechanics attenuate load-induced Ca2+ transients and downstream osteogenic transcription; administering a selective Piezo1 agonist (such as Yoda1) sensitizes remaining channels to physiological strain and re-establishes anabolic signaling. Prediction: Osteocytes in aged mice exhibit blunted intracellular Ca2+ spikes and failed Wnt1 induction under physiological tibial loading despite normal macroscopic bone strain, and systemic or local administration of a selective Piezo1 agonist synergizes with mechanical loading to restore periosteal mineral apposition rate to young-adult levels without rescuing bone formation in osteocyte-specific Piezo1-knockout mice.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Age-related decline in mechanosensitive G-protein-coupled receptor signaling—specifically the adhesion GPCR GPR133 (ADGRD1) and primary-cilia-localized PTH1R—in osteoblast-lineage cells impairs force-induced GalphaS-cAMP-PKA activation and beta-catenin stabilization. Targeted stimulation with small-molecule receptor agonists or tethered-agonist (Stachel) mimetics restores the anabolic response to mechanical loading in aged bone. Mechanism: Mechanical stretch and extracellular matrix interactions induce conformational activation of GPR133 (via exposure of its endogenous Stachel peptide sequence and interaction with PTK7) as well as ciliary PTH1R in osteoprogenitors, stimulating GalphaS-adenylyl cyclase-cAMP-PKA signaling that phosphorylates and inhibits GSK-3beta to stabilize beta-catenin and promote osteoblast differentiation. In aged bone, reduced expression of GPR133 and ciliary disassembly blunt stretch-induced cAMP generation; targeted pharmacological activation (such as with the GPR133 agonist AP503 or intermittent PTH1R agonism) amplifies load-induced cAMP-PKA signaling to restore osteogenesis. Prediction: Aged osteoprogenitors exhibit intact membrane strain and ion fluxes but fail to elevate intracellular cAMP and PKA-mediated GSK-3beta phosphorylation upon mechanical loading, and administration of a selective GPR133 agonist (e.g., AP503) or Stachel peptide mimetic synergizes with mechanical loading to restore cortical and trabecular bone formation in aged wild-type mice but not in osteoblast-specific Gpr133-deficient mice.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 2, "text": "Age-related loss of load-induced nerve growth factor (NGF) secretion by osteoblasts and diminished periosteal sensory nerve innervation uncouple mechanical force detection from neuroskeletal anabolic amplification. Targeted stimulation of Tropomyosin receptor kinase A (TrkA) signaling via exogenous NGF or selective TrkA agonists restores the osteogenic response to mechanical loading in aged bone. Mechanism: Under physiological loading, periosteal osteolineage cells rapidly upregulate NGF, which binds TrkA receptors on adjacent periosteal sensory nerve fibers to stimulate the local release of osteogenic neuropeptides and Wnt ligands that drive osteoprogenitor proliferation and differentiation. With ageing, cellular senescence and chronic NF-kappaB activation in bone cells blunt mechanically induced Ngf transcription alongside structural retraction of TrkA+ periosteal fibers; exogenous TrkA stimulation bypasses the defective osteoblast-to-nerve signal and reactivates neurogenic Wnt signaling in periosteal progenitors. Prediction: Mechanical loading of aged tibiae fails to induce periosteal Ngf expression or sensory nerve ERK/TrkA phosphorylation, and co-administration of recombinant NGF or a small-molecule TrkA agonist during loading restores periosteal osteoprogenitor proliferation and cortical bone formation in aged wild-type mice, an effect abolished by sensory-nerve-specific TrkA inactivation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42639736", "pmid": "42639736", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70688", "title": "DHCR24 Alleviates DNA Damage in Senescent Vascular Endothelial Cells via ENKUR/Ca2+ Signaling.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-25", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally establishes a causal molecular pathway linking organelle dysfunction, DNA damage responses, and cellular senescence.", "background": "Persistent DNA damage responses contribute to cellular senescence and age-related loss of tissue function. Disturbances in intracellular homeostasis can promote genomic stress through several mechanisms, including metabolic dysfunction and impaired cell-cycle control. Communication between organelles is increasingly recognized as an important regulator of stress responses during ageing. However, the causal mechanisms connecting disrupted cellular homeostasis to DNA damage in senescent cells remain incompletely understood.", "question": "What molecular mechanism links disrupted intracellular homeostasis to DNA damage and senescence?", "subject": "Senescence-associated DNA damage", "finding": "Loss of DHCR24 increases ENKUR expression, causing calcium overload, endoplasmic-reticulum stress, and mitochondrial dysfunction that activate the ATM-mediated DNA damage response and promote endothelial-cell senescence. ENKUR knockdown suppresses these effects, while DHCR24 overexpression lowers ENKUR and mitigates calcium overload, establishing a causal DHCR24-ENKUR-Ca2+ signaling axis.", "key_points": [ "DHCR24 deficiency activates ATM-mediated DNA damage responses", "DHCR24 loss upregulates ENKUR and causes calcium overload", "Calcium dysregulation drives ER stress and mitochondrial dysfunction", "ENKUR knockdown rescues organelle dysfunction and DNA damage signaling", "DHCR24 restoration reduces ENKUR and calcium overload" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Impaired mitochondrial electron transport chain homeostasis and reductive stress inhibit inner-membrane dihydroorotate dehydrogenase (DHODH) and deplete the cytosolic NAD+/NADH ratio, collapsing de novo pyrimidine synthesis and dNTP pools during S phase. The resulting uncoupling of cell-cycle progression from nucleotide availability causes widespread replication fork stalling, fork collapse, and persistent telomeric and genomic double-strand breaks that initiate senescence. Mechanism: Mitochondrial-nuclear metabolic communication relies on ubiquinone-dependent DHODH activity at the inner mitochondrial membrane and aspartate synthesis supported by the NAD+/NADH ratio. When mitochondrial respiration or redox balance is perturbed, loss of ubiquinone recycling and aspartate synthesis halts de novo pyrimidine biosynthesis and ribonucleotide reductase activity; cells entering S phase with unbalanced dNTP pools experience ATR-mediated replication stress, MUS81-dependent cleavage of stalled forks, and irreversible p53/RB-mediated senescence arrest. Prediction: Supplementation with exogenous deoxyribonucleosides or expression of the bacterial NADH oxidase LbNOX to restore cytosolic NAD+/NADH and aspartate levels will rescue replication fork velocity, prevent 53BP1 nuclear body formation, and bypass senescence without restoring mitochondrial ATP production.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 0, "text": "Enhanced tethering at endoplasmic reticulum-mitochondria contact sites (MERCs) drives IP3R2-VDAC1-MCU-mediated mitochondrial calcium overload, triggering sub-lethal mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization (minority MOMP) and limited caspase-3/7 activation that cleaves ICAD to release caspase-activated DNase (CAD) into the nucleus. This sub-lethal endonuclease activity generates persistent genomic double-strand breaks that lock cells into senescence without inducing apoptosis. Mechanism: Disrupted ER proteostasis or calcium homeostasis strengthens ER-mitochondria physical contacts via tethering complexes (such as VAPB-PTPIP51 or GRP75), funneling excessive Ca2+ into the mitochondrial matrix. Resulting cristae remodeling and focal BAX/BAK oligomerization on a subset of mitochondria release limited cytochrome c into the cytosol, activating sub-threshold caspase-3/7 to liberate CAD (and mitochondrial Endonuclease G), which translocates to the nucleus and cleaves chromatin to sustain a chronic ATM/p53/p21 DNA damage response. Prediction: Genetic ablation of the CAD endonuclease (DFFB), pharmacological inhibition of BAX/BAK macropores, or uncoupling of ER-mitochondria Ca2+ transfer via IP3R2/MCU knockdown will abolish homeostatic stress-induced nuclear gamma-H2AX foci and p21-dependent senescence even when mitochondrial ROS and metabolic deficits persist.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "Perturbed endoplasmic reticulum-nuclear envelope lipid homeostasis and cytoskeletal tension destabilize the nuclear lamina and LINC complex, inducing transient nuclear envelope ruptures and loss of nuclear pore complex (NPC) compartmentalization. This barrier breakdown permits cytoplasmic exonucleases (such as TREX1) to enter the nucleus while leaking nuclear DNA repair proteins into the cytosol, generating transcription-replication conflicts, R-loop cleavage, and micronuclei that drive cGAS-STING-enforced senescence. Mechanism: Contiguous membrane continuity between the ER and the outer nuclear membrane couples lipid bilayer composition and actomyosin contractility via SUN/Nesprin LINC complexes directly to Lamin B1/A/C structural integrity. Homeostatic ER membrane stress and altered phosphatidic acid/diacylglycerol balance promote local nuclear envelope blebbing and transient rupture, causing efflux of high-molecular-weight DNA repair complexes (such as BRCA1 and 53BP1), influx of ER-associated TREX1 nuclease that fragments chromatin at stalled R-loops, and formation of cytoplasmic chromatin fragments that activate cGAS-STING paracrine senescence. Prediction: Uncoupling cytoskeletal tension via LINC complex disruption (dominant-negative KASH domain expression) or knocking down ER-tethered TREX1 will prevent nuclear lamina rupture-associated DNA fragmentation and cGAS-STING activation even in cells subjected to chronic ER lipid or mechanical stress.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Defective lysosomal acidification and impaired chaperone-mediated autophagy (CMA) disrupt organelle quality control by simultaneously preventing the timely degradation of cell-cycle checkpoint kinase CHK1 and failing to clear labile iron-rich damaged mitochondria. This dual homeostatic failure causes unscheduled replication origin firing alongside Fenton-reaction hydroxyl radical generation in the nucleus, producing clustered oxidative DNA lesions and double-strand breaks. Mechanism: Loss of vacuolar ATPase (v-ATPase) activity in ageing lysosomes impairs LAMP2A-mediated chaperone-mediated autophagy and mitophagy, leading to nuclear hyperaccumulation of dysregulated cell-cycle and homologous recombination factors (such as CHK1 and RRM2) alongside an expanded cytosolic and nuclear labile Fe2+ pool released from undegraded ferritin and mitochondria. The combination of unscheduled cell-cycle transitions, defective RAD51 filament assembly, and iron-catalyzed nuclear lipid peroxidation/oxidative base damage overwhelms base excision repair, converting single-strand nicks into persistent double-strand breaks. Prediction: Restoring lysosomal acidity via v-ATPase activation or chelating intracellular labile iron with deferoxamine while reactivating LAMP2A-dependent proteolysis will restore homologous recombination efficiency and suppress nuclear 8-oxo-dG and gamma-H2AX accumulation independently of ER-mitochondria calcium signaling.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Disrupted mitochondrial tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle flux causes cytosolic and nuclear accumulation of the oncometabolites succinate and fumarate alongside NAD+ depletion, competitively inhibiting alpha-ketoglutarate-dependent histone demethylases (KDM4A/B) and SIRT6 at sites of endogenous DNA damage. The resulting failure to remodel local heterochromatin blocks recruitment of homologous recombination and non-homologous end-joining machinery, converting transient endogenous DNA lesions into unrepairable senogenic foci. Mechanism: Retrograde metabolite signaling from dysfunctional mitochondria alters the nuclear ratio of succinate/fumarate to alpha-ketoglutarate and depletes nuclear NAD+ pools via hyperactive PARP1 consumption. Elevated succinate and fumarate inhibit KDM4A/B demethylation of H3K9me3 and H3K36me3, while NAD+ scarcity blunts SIRT6-dependent H3K9/H3K56 deacetylation and CHD4 recruitment, preventing chromatin relaxation around replication- or transcription-induced DNA breaks and trapping ATM/ATR signaling in a chronic senescent state. Prediction: Cell-permeable alpha-ketoglutarate esters combined with NAD+ precursors (such as nicotinamide mononucleotide) will restore KDM4B/SIRT6 catalytic activity, re-establish BRCA1 and 53BP1 recruitment kinetics at laser-microirradiated chromatin, and resolve persistent DNA damage foci without correcting upstream mitochondrial TCA cycle defects.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42642518", "pmid": "42642518", "doi": "10.1038/s43587-026-01180-5", "title": "Sex-specific aging clocks from a large-scale human phenome reveal distinct aging transitions and circulating signatures.", "journal": "Nat Aging", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-25", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study goes beyond cohort associations by experimentally testing age-associated circulating factors in human cells and using a reversible mouse model to support their causal contribution to senescence-related ageing phenotypes.", "background": "Biological ageing progresses at different rates among individuals and is associated with broad changes in physiology and chronic-disease risk. Women and men can follow different ageing trajectories, particularly during midlife, but the biological basis and functional significance of these differences remain incompletely understood. Large clinical datasets can identify circulating features that change with age, although association alone cannot establish whether such features actively promote ageing. Experimental validation is therefore needed to distinguish causal contributors from passive biomarkers.", "question": "Which circulating factors that accumulate with age actively induce ageing-related cellular phenotypes, and is their resulting biological burden reversible?", "subject": "Circulating drivers of ageing", "finding": "Age-associated accumulation of metabolic factors, including low-density lipoprotein, triglycerides, glucose and uric acid, and tumor markers, including carcinoembryonic antigen and human epididymis protein 4, induced senescence-related phenotypes in human endothelial cells. A high-fat-diet mouse model followed by dietary reversal further showed that ageing associated with metabolic burden is modifiable.", "key_points": [ "Specific metabolic and tumor markers accumulate with age", "The identified circulating factors induce senescence-related phenotypes", "Causality was tested in human endothelial cells", "Dietary reversal in mice supports modifiability of metabolic burden-induced ageing", "Ageing trajectories differ by sex during midlife" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 3, "text": "Circulating bioactive sphingolipids and oxidized lipoprotein species—specifically long-chain ceramides (such as C16:0 and C24:1 ceramides) and oxidized LDL that inflect upward during midlife—act as causal metabolic drivers of endothelial and stromal cell senescence, whose deleterious cellular effects are reversible through inhibition of sphingolipid synthesis or enhanced lipid clearance. Mechanism: Excess circulating ceramides and oxidized lipoproteins are internalized via CD36 and scavenger receptors into vascular endothelial, hepatic, and mesenchymal progenitor cells, where they integrate into mitochondrial membranes to disrupt electron transport chain complex III/IV activity and activate protein phosphatase 2A (PP2A) and p38 MAPK. This inhibits Akt/eNOS signaling, triggers persistent mitochondrial ROS production, and stabilizes p53/p21CIP1 to enforce premature vascular and metabolic senescence. Prediction: Fractionating aged human plasma will show that lipid-depleted plasma loses a substantial fraction of its pro-senescent activity on cultured human endothelial cells while purified aged ceramide fractions reproduce it; furthermore, pharmacological inhibition of serine palmitoyltransferase or dihydroceramide desaturase (DES1) in aged animals will restore endothelial nitric oxide production and clear vascular senescence markers.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Age-associated accumulation of circulating iron-storage and labile iron complexes—reflected clinically by rising serum ferritin and non-transferrin-bound iron (NTBI), particularly across the female midlife transition—actively promotes sub-lethal oxidative DNA damage and ferro-senescence in vascular and parenchymal tissues, a burden that is reversible via targeted iron chelation or restoration of cellular iron export. Mechanism: Elevated extracellular ferritin and NTBI increase transferrin-independent iron uptake and ferritinophagyflux Dysregulation in endothelial, hepatic, and neural cells, expanding the intracellular labile Fe2+ pool. Excess labile iron catalyzes Fenton chemistry and membrane phospholipid peroxidation (4-HNE and MDA adducts), which at sub-ferroptotic thresholds chronically activates ATM/ATR-p53-p21 DNA damage signaling, NAD+ depletion via PARP1 hyperactivation, and senescence-associated beta-galactosidase activity. Prediction: Exposing young human fibroblasts or endothelial cells to aged human serum with high ferritin/NTBI will induce lipid peroxidation, gamma-H2AX foci, and p21 arrest that is abrogated by ex vivo iron immunodepletion or deferoxamine addition; in vivo administration of a cell-permeable iron chelator or hepcidin antagonist to aged mice will reduce tissue labile iron, resolve DNA damage foci, and reverse transcriptomic signatures of cellular senescence.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Age-accumulating pro-inflammatory and TGF-beta superfamily cytokines—specifically interleukin-11 (IL-11), Activin A, and TGF-beta1—actively drive cellular senescence and tissue dysfunction across parenchymal and stromal compartments rather than acting merely as passive markers of tissue damage. The cellular and physiological burden imposed by these circulating factors is reversible upon targeted neutralization or receptor blockade in aged organisms. Mechanism: Sustained elevation of circulating IL-11 and Activin A engages gp130/IL-11RA and ActRIIA/B complexes on stromal, hepatic, cardiac, and adipose progenitor cells, chronically activating ERK-AMPK-mTORC1 and SMAD2/3 signaling cascades. This suppresses autophagic clearance, impairs mitochondrial bioenergetics, and induces p16INK4a/p21CIP1-mediated cell-cycle arrest along with a self-amplifying senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) that spreads paracrine senescence. Prediction: Exposing young primary human cells or organoids to age-matched concentrations of recombinant IL-11 or Activin A will recapitulate senescent transcriptomic and metabolic signatures, whereas administering neutralizing anti-IL-11 or ActRII antibodies to midlife or aged mice will reduce tissue p16/p21 burden, restore mitochondrial respiration, and reverse fibrotic and metabolic decline compared to isotype controls.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 1, "text": "Circulating gonadotropins—particularly follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), which surges sharply during the female midlife transition and rises progressively in ageing men—directly induce extragonadal cellular ageing phenotypes in metabolic, vascular, and skeletal tissues. This endocrine-driven ageing burden is functionally reversible through selective blockade of extragonadal gonadotropin receptor signaling. Mechanism: Elevated circulating FSH binds functional FSH receptors (FSHR) expressed on adipocytes, hepatocytes, endothelial cells, and osteoblastic progenitors, coupling via Gi2alpha and beta-arrestin to suppress cAMP/PKA thermogenic pathways while activating ERK1/2, NF-kappaB, and Akt-mTOR signaling. This promotes intracellular lipid droplet accumulation, cholesterol biosynthesis, mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS) generation, and DNA damage response-mediated cellular senescence independently of estrogen deficiency alone. Prediction: Supplementing young cells or ovariectomized hormone-clamped mice with midlife-equivalent FSH levels will induce p21 expression, mitochondrial dysfunction, and lipid dysmetabolism, whereas treating midlife or aged animals with a blocking anti-FSHbeta antibody or small-molecule FSHR antagonist will reverse visceral adiposity, vascular endothelial senescence, and dyslipidemia without altering circulating sex steroid levels.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 2, "text": "Pathogenic accumulation of circulating Immunoglobulin G (IgG) and age-associated autoantibodies actively instigates myeloid activation and bystander parenchymal senescence across multiple organs, and this immune-driven ageing burden is reversible via enhanced IgG catabolism or plasma dilution. Mechanism: Age-related B-cell remodeling and altered Fc glycosylation lead to rising circulating IgG levels that saturate tissue-resident macrophages, microglia, and endothelial cells via Fc-gamma receptors (FcgammaR) and neonatal Fc receptors (FcRn). Chronic FcgammaR cross-linking activates Syk-NF-kappaB, Ras-MAPK, and nitric oxide synthase pathways, driving a pro-inflammatory, pro-fibrotic secretome and oxidative stress that induces p53/p21-dependent senescence in neighboring parenchymal cells. Prediction: Transfer of purified IgG from aged donors into young mice or human co-culture systems will trigger macrophage activation and parenchymal senescence markers, whereas depleting excess endogenous IgG in aged mice via anti-FcRn antibodies, FcRn antisense oligonucleotides, or therapeutic plasma exchange will reverse tissue senescence, chronic inflammation, and fibrotic remodeling.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42642521", "pmid": "42642521", "doi": "10.1038/s43587-026-01181-4", "title": "A geroprotective probiotic and its functional metabolite counteract inflammaging to extend healthspan.", "journal": "Nat Aging", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-25", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally identifies and validates a causal microbiome-derived intervention and metabolite that reduce inflammaging and improve healthspan-related outcomes in naturally aged mice.", "background": "The gut microbiome changes with age and is associated with immune dysregulation, chronic low-grade inflammation and functional decline. Microbiome composition also varies substantially among individuals and populations, making it difficult to distinguish consequential changes from incidental biomarkers of ageing. Animal studies suggest that manipulating gut microbial communities can influence age-related physiology, but the responsible organisms and molecular mediators have remained poorly defined. Establishing causality requires showing that a defined microbial intervention improves ageing phenotypes and identifying a functional mechanism that reproduces those effects.", "question": "Can a specific age-depleted gut microbe and one of its metabolites causally suppress inflammaging and improve healthspan in old animals?", "subject": "Microbial control of inflammaging", "finding": "Bifidobacterium pseudocatenulatum, which declines with age in human cohorts, causally improved intestinal homeostasis, reduced multiorgan inflammaging, enhanced cognitive and motor performance and extended healthspan in naturally aged mice. Its metabolite 5-aminovaleric acid betaine (5-AVAB), also reduced during human ageing, partially reproduced these systemic benefits when administered alone.", "key_points": [ "B. pseudocatenulatum is depleted during ageing", "Oral bacterial treatment improves healthspan in aged mice", "Treatment suppresses intestinal and multiorgan inflammaging", "5-AVAB is a functional metabolite of the bacterium", "5-AVAB supplementation partially reproduces the benefits" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 3, "text": "Restoring age-depleted polyamine-synthesizing gut commensals such as Bacteroides species or Bifidobacterium animalis causally mitigates systemic inflammaging and preserves neuromuscular and cardiovascular healthspan in old animals by supplying bioavailable spermidine. Microbial spermidine reactivates basal autophagy and mitophagy in senescent host immune and parenchymal cells. Mechanism: Bacterial arginine decarboxylase and spermidine synthase generate luminal spermidine that enters the host circulation and serves as the substrate for deoxyhypusine synthase (DHPS) to hypusinate eukaryotic translation initiation factor 5A (eIF5A). Hypusinated eIF5A promotes the translation of TFEB and core autophagy machinery, restoring mitophagic clearance of damaged mitochondria and preventing cytosolic mitochondrial DNA leakage that otherwise drives cGAS-STING and NLRP3-mediated inflammaging. Prediction: Treating aged animals with wild-type spermidine-producing bacteria or oral spermidine will elevate leukocyte eIF5A hypusination and autophagic flux, reduce circulating cell-free mtDNA and type I interferon/IL-1beta signatures, and improve cardiac and motor function, whereas a bacterial spermidine-synthase knockout (speE mutant) or host DHPS inhibition will fail to suppress inflammation or improve healthspan.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 2, "text": "Supplementing aged animals with age-depleted bile-acid-transforming symbionts such as Parabacteroides distasonis or Odoribacter species causally reverses inflammaging and metabolic-functional decline through the generation of secondary bile acids such as lithocholic acid (LCA) or isoallolithocholic acid (isoalloLCA). These secondary bile acids reprogram host myeloid polarization and tissue bioenergetics. Mechanism: Microbial 7-alpha-dehydroxylation and 5-alpha/5-beta-reductase and 3-beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase pathways convert host primary bile acids into secondary bile acid species that activate the membrane receptor TGR5 (GPBAR1), nuclear receptor FXR, and the sirtuin-AMPK axis in macrophages and skeletal muscle. This signaling triggers cAMP-PKA-dependent phosphorylation of NLRP3 to block inflammasome assembly, shifts macrophages toward an anti-inflammatory phenotype, and stimulates mitochondrial biogenesis and mitophagy in aged muscle. Prediction: Administration of the wild-type bile-acid-modifying strain or purified LCA/isoalloLCA to aged mice will suppress tissue macrophage IL-1beta and TNF-alpha production and increase muscle endurance and insulin sensitivity, whereas a bacterial bile-acid-biosynthesis knockout mutant or host Gpbar1 (TGR5) ablation will prevent inflammation resolution and functional rejuvenation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Restoring age-depleted butyrate-producing obligate anaerobes such as Faecalibacterium prausnitzii or Roseburia intestinalis causally suppresses systemic inflammaging and reduces physical frailty in aged animals through the luminal production of butyrate. Butyrate reinforces intestinal epithelial barrier integrity to prevent microbial translocation while directly dampening pro-inflammatory innate and adaptive immune activation. Mechanism: Microbial fermentation of complex polysaccharides generates butyrate, which acts both as an intracellular histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitor to promote Foxp3+ regulatory T cell (Treg) differentiation and as an extracellular agonist of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPR109A/HCAR2 and GPR43/FFAR2) on colonocytes and macrophages. This dual signaling upregulates tight-junction proteins, sustains colonocyte beta-oxidation to preserve luminal hypoxia, and inhibits NF-kB and NLRP3 inflammasome activation. Prediction: Oral gavage of aged mice with wild-type F. prausnitzii or exogenous sodium butyrate will decrease plasma lipopolysaccharide-binding protein, IL-6, and TNF-alpha while improving grip strength and gut barrier permeability, whereas an isogenic bacterial mutant lacking butyryl-CoA:acetate CoA-transferase or treatment in Hcar2/Ffar2-deficient hosts will fail to reproduce these healthspan benefits.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Reintroducing age-depleted mucin-residing commensals such as Akkermansia muciniphila causally suppresses inflammaging and improves multi-organ healthspan in aged animals via the microbial synthesis and secretion of NAD+ precursors such as nicotinamide and nicotinic acid. Replenishing host NAD+ pools restores sirtuin-mediated deacetylation of inflammatory and metabolic regulators. Mechanism: Microbial nicotinamidase (PncA) and de novo NAD+ biosynthetic pathways produce nicotinic acid and nicotinamide that are absorbed by the host and converted into NAD+ via the Preiss-Handler and salvage pathways. Elevated intracellular NAD+ in aged macrophages, endothelial cells, and skeletal muscle activates the NAD+-dependent deacetylases SIRT1 and SIRT3, which deacetylate and inhibit NF-kB p65/RelA while activating PGC-1alpha to suppress senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) cytokines and restore mitochondrial oxidative metabolism. Prediction: Supplementation of aged mice with wild-type A. muciniphila or its secreted NAD+ precursor will increase tissue NAD+/NADH ratios, decrease p65 acetylation and circulating SASP factors, and enhance physical performance, whereas a bacterial NAD+-pathway-deficient mutant (such as pncA or nadA deletion) or host SIRT1 inhibition will abrogate the anti-inflammatory and healthspan-extending effects.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 1, "text": "Repletion of age-declining tryptophan-metabolizing commensals such as Lactobacillus reuteri or Bifidobacterium species causally attenuates chronic low-grade inflammation and extends healthspan in old animals via the production of indole derivatives such as indole-3-propionic acid (IPA) or indole-3-carboxaldehyde (I3A). These microbial indoles restore mucosal immune homeostasis and prevent systemic endotoxemia. Mechanism: Bacterial aromatic amino acid aminotransferases and phenyllactate dehydratase complexes catabolize dietary tryptophan into indoles that engage the host aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) and pregnane X receptor (PXR) in intestinal epithelial cells and group 3 innate lymphoid cells (ILC3s). Receptor activation drives IL-22 secretion, mucin and antimicrobial peptide synthesis, and epithelial regeneration while suppressing TLR4-MyD88 inflammatory signaling in systemic macrophages. Prediction: Colonizing aged animals with the wild-type indole-producing bacterium or administering purified IPA/I3A will restore colonic IL-22 expression, lower circulating inflammatory cytokines, and improve locomotor and cognitive scores, whereas an aromatic aminotransferase-deficient bacterial mutant or host-specific Ahr deletion will abolish both barrier repair and healthspan improvements.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42647119", "pmid": "42647119", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.2612369123", "title": "Aging limits neuronal regeneration from glia in the mouse retina.", "journal": "Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-26", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally identifies age-dependent cellular and neuroimmune mechanisms that impair neuronal regeneration and demonstrates a partial causal rescue through immunomodulation.", "background": "Cellular reprogramming offers a potential way to replace neurons lost through injury or neurodegenerative disease. Most regenerative strategies have been developed and validated in young experimental animals, although advanced age is the principal risk factor for many neurological disorders. Aging can alter both the plasticity of resident cells and the tissue response to injury. It was therefore unclear whether neuronal reprogramming would remain effective in aged neural tissue and which age-associated processes might limit it.", "question": "How does aging affect injury-induced neuronal reprogramming in the retina, and what mechanisms account for any age-related loss of regenerative capacity?", "subject": "Age-limited neuronal regeneration", "finding": "Aging suppresses Müller glia-to-neuron reprogramming by preventing activation of progenitor programs while promoting reactive and inflammatory glial states and an exaggerated retinal neuroimmune response. Dexamethasone partially restores neurogenesis, confirming that age-associated inflammation is a causal, therapeutically tractable component of the regenerative defect, alongside glial-intrinsic barriers.", "key_points": [ "Aged Müller glia generate fewer neurons across three reprogramming strategies", "Aged glia fail to activate progenitor programs", "Reactive and inflammatory states increase with age", "The injured aged retina mounts an exaggerated neuroimmune response", "Dexamethasone partially rescues neurogenesis" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Age-associated accumulation of repressive heterochromatin and DNA methylation at neurogenic gene loci renders aged Müller glia refractory to injury-induced transcriptional reprogramming. Even when proneural factors are ectopically expressed or endogenous de-differentiation cues are present, closed chromatin architecture prevents activation of downstream neuronal differentiation networks. Mechanism: Across chronological aging, Müller glia accumulate Polycomb-mediated H3K27me3, SUV39H1-mediated H3K9me3, and CpG hypermethylation at the promoters and enhancers of essential neurogenic targets (e.g., Otx2, Insm1, Neurod1, Cabp5), while maintaining constitutively open chromatin at gliogenic NFI (Nfia/b/x) binding sites. This deep heterochromatic silencing cannot be overcome by standard histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibition alone, preventing pioneer factor binding and transcriptional activation of neuronal fate programs. Prediction: ATAC-seq and CUT&Tag profiling of injured aged versus young Müller glia will reveal persistent H3K27me3/H3K9me3 enrichment and inaccessible chromatin specifically at proneural target loci despite Ascl1 expression and HDAC inhibition, and co-inhibition of EZH2 or H3K9 methyltransferases will selectively rescue neuronal conversion in aged retinas.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Age-dependent stiffening and fibrotic remodeling of the retinal extracellular matrix (ECM) activate mechanosensitive signaling pathways in Müller glia that dominantly enforce fibrotic gliosis over neurogenic reprogramming. Altered biomechanical cues in the aged retina prevent injured Müller glia from adopting a compliant, neurogenic progenitor state. Mechanism: Advanced glycation end-products, collagen cross-linking, and laminin degradation increase the mechanical stiffness of the aged inner limiting membrane and retinal interstitial matrix. Following injury, this stiffened substrate hyperactivates integrin-FAK and Piezo1 mechanotransduction in Müller glia, driving sustained nuclear translocation of YAP/TAZ that complexes with TEAD to transcribe pro-fibrotic and gliotic genes (e.g., Ctgf, Cyr61) while sequestering factors needed for proneural commitment. Prediction: Atomic force microscopy will confirm increased retinal matrix stiffness in aged mice that correlates with nuclear YAP retention in injured Müller glia, and enzymatic softening of the ECM or pharmacological inhibition of YAP/Piezo1 mechanotransduction will shift the injury response of aged Müller glia from fibrotic scar formation toward functional neurogenesis.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "Mitochondrial dysfunction and metabolic inflexibility in aged Müller glia cause a bioenergetic and oxidative bottleneck during the glycolytic-to-oxidative phosphorylation switch required for neuronal maturation. Consequently, reprogramming Müller glia in aged retinas undergo ferroptotic or apoptotic death before completing neuronal differentiation. Mechanism: While quiescent and reactive Müller glia rely primarily on aerobic glycolysis, fate conversion into post-mitotic retinal neurons requires a rapid upregulation of mitochondrial biogenesis and oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS). Aged Müller glia harbor declined NAD+ pools, impaired mitophagy, and damaged respiratory chain complexes; when forced to upregulate OXPHOS during neurogenic reprogramming, they generate excessive mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS) and lipid peroxides, triggering ferroptosis at the immature neuroblast stage. Prediction: Lineage tracing combined with single-cell metabolic and cell-death profiling in aged retinas will show that Müller glia initiate early proneural gene expression after injury/reprogramming but die during the neuroblast transition due to lipid peroxidation, and supplementation with NAD+ precursors (e.g., NMN) or ferroptosis inhibitors (e.g., liproxstatin-1) will rescue the survival of mature regenerated neurons.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Aging impairs injury-induced retinal neuronal reprogramming by priming resident microglia toward a persistent pro-inflammatory state that locks Müller glia into reactive gliosis rather than neurogenesis. Chronic inflammatory signaling after injury in aged retinas actively antagonizes proneural transcription factor activity in Müller glia. Mechanism: In aged retinas, senescent and dystrophic microglia respond to injury with sustained secretion of TNF-alpha, IL-6, and IL-1beta, driving prolonged hyperactivation of JAK/STAT3 and NF-kappaB signaling within Müller glia. Phosphorylated STAT3 and RelA/p65 directly compete with proneural pioneer factors such as Ascl1 for transcriptional co-activators and promote expression of gliogenic and inhibitory factors (such as Id1/3, Socs3, and Gfap), blocking the transition from reactive glia to neurogenic progenitors. Prediction: Microglial depletion (e.g., via CSF1R inhibition) or Müller glia-specific inhibition of STAT3/NF-kappaB signaling in aged injured retinas will restore Ascl1-driven neurogenic reprogramming efficiency to youthful levels, even without directly altering the intrinsic epigenetic landscape of Müller glia prior to injury.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 4 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 2, "text": "Age-related accumulation of senescent cells in the retinal microenvironment suppresses Müller glia reprogramming through both cell-autonomous cell-cycle arrest and paracrine pro-gliogenic SASP signaling. This senescent niche maintains high levels of quiescence and gliogenic transcription factors that block injury-induced de-differentiation. Mechanism: Aged Müller glia and neighboring retinal vascular and neuronal cells upregulate p16INK4a and p21CIP1 and secrete a senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) enriched in BMP4 and TGF-beta ligands. Cell-autonomous CDK inhibition prevents the S-phase re-entry required for asymmetric neurogenic division, while paracrine BMP/Smad1/5/8 and TGF-beta/Smad2/3 signaling sustains expression of the quiescence-enforcing transcription factors Nfia/b/x and Notch effectors, actively repressing neurogenic competence. Prediction: Pharmacological senolysis (e.g., ABT-263 or Dasatinib/Quercetin) or genetic clearance of p16INK4a-positive cells prior to retinal injury will reduce Smad and NFI transcriptional activity in aged Müller glia and restore both their proliferative response and generation of regenerated retinal neurons.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42647635", "pmid": "42647635", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.adu0632", "title": "Development of mitochondrial mutator pigs exhibiting increased mitochondrial DNA mutations and premature aging via prime editing.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-26", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally demonstrates a specific causal link between loss of POLG proofreading activity, increased mitochondrial DNA mutation burden, and premature ageing in a large mammal.", "background": "Ageing is accompanied by progressive molecular damage, impaired tissue maintenance, and declining physiological function. Genetic studies in laboratory organisms have identified processes that can influence lifespan and cellular senescence. However, findings from small-animal models do not always translate directly to humans because of major differences in physiology, metabolism, and lifespan. A large-mammal model is therefore valuable for testing whether a proposed source of molecular damage can directly produce systemic ageing phenotypes.", "question": "Does experimentally increasing somatic mitochondrial DNA mutation burden cause premature ageing and shortened lifespan in a large mammal?", "subject": "Mitochondrial mutations and ageing", "finding": "Prime-edited pigs expressing proofreading-deficient POLG accumulated elevated somatic mitochondrial DNA mutations and developed systemic premature-ageing phenotypes. These included weight loss, rough hair, anaemia, tissue abnormalities, increased apoptosis, elevated senescence-associated markers, and shortened lifespan.", "key_points": [ "Proofreading-deficient POLG", "Increased somatic mitochondrial DNA mutations", "Systemic premature-ageing phenotypes", "Increased apoptosis and senescence markers", "Shortened lifespan" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 4, "text": "Experimentally increasing de novo somatic mtDNA mutagenesis fails to cause premature ageing or shorten lifespan in a large mammal because enhanced mitochondrial quality control and somatic purifying selection prevent mutated genomes from reaching pathogenic heteroplasmy thresholds. Large mammals have evolved stricter mitophagic surveillance than short-lived rodents to preserve mitochondrial integrity over decades. Mechanism: Depolarized mitochondria harboring high burdens of mutated mtDNA undergo rapid fission-mediated isolation and PINK1/Parkin-dependent mitophagy coupled with compensatory biogenesis of wild-type mtDNA networks, selectively purging mutant nucleoids in both mitotic and post-mitotic tissues before they can clonally expand to cause cellular dysfunction. Prediction: Despite a multi-fold increase in de novo mtDNA polymerase error rates, adult tissues in engineered large mammals will plateau at low heteroplasmy levels (<30%) accompanied by elevated basal mitophagic flux and lysosomal turnover, and systemic progeroid phenotypes will only emerge if PINK1/Parkin-mediated mitophagy is concurrently knocked down or pharmacologically inhibited.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 0 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 2, "text": "Increasing somatic mtDNA mutation rates in a large mammal causes premature ageing and shortened lifespan by inducing systemic NAD+/NADH redox imbalance that secondarily cripples nuclear genome maintenance and epigenetic stability. The primary driver of tissue degeneration is metabolic stalling of NAD+-dependent longevity pathways rather than local ATP scarcity. Mechanism: Mutational disruption of mtDNA-encoded Complex I subunits impairs mitochondrial NADH oxidation, lowering the cellular NAD+/NADH ratio and inducing reductive stress; the resulting scarcity of NAD+ inhibits nuclear sirtuins (SIRT1/SIRT6) and poly(ADP-ribose) polymerases (PARPs), leading to heterochromatin loss, transcriptional drift, and defective nuclear DNA repair. Prediction: Tissues in mtDNA-mutator large mammals will display a depressed NAD+/NADH ratio, reduced SIRT1/SIRT6 deacetylase activity, and elevated nuclear DNA double-strand breaks prior to tissue atrophy, and chronic supplementation with NAD+ precursors (such as nicotinamide riboside or NMN) or expression of an alternative NADH oxidase (LbNOX) will rescue premature ageing phenotypes without lowering mtDNA mutation frequency.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "Elevating somatic mtDNA mutation burden in a large mammal causes premature ageing and shortened survival primarily by triggering chronic innate immune activation and systemic inflammaging rather than cell-autonomous ATP depletion. Sub-threshold mtDNA mutations induce proteotoxic stress that promotes mitochondrial membrane permeabilization and cytosolic nucleic acid sensing. Mechanism: Translation of mutated mtDNA produces misfolded oxidative phosphorylation subunits that overwhelm mitochondrial proteases and trigger the mitochondrial unfolded protein response (UPRmt), leading to outer membrane pore formation, efflux of oxidized or fragmented mtDNA into the cytosol, and constitutive activation of the cGAS-STING and NLRP3 inflammasome pathways, which drives paracrine cellular senescence across tissues. Prediction: Mutator large mammals will develop high circulating levels of type I interferons, IL-6, and SASP factors prior to overt bioenergetic decline, and pharmacological or genetic inhibition of STING or NLRP3 will significantly extend their healthspan and lifespan despite persistent mtDNA mutation loads and respiratory chain defects.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Experimentally increasing the somatic mtDNA mutation rate via proofreading-deficient DNA polymerase gamma (POLG) in a large mammal directly drives systemic premature ageing and shortens lifespan by exhausting adult stem and progenitor cell pools. This progeroid phenotype arises even without elevated mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS). Mechanism: Accumulation of random point mutations and linear deletions in mtDNA destabilizes respiratory chain complexes I and IV, triggering bioenergetic failure and intrinsic caspase-dependent apoptosis specifically within rapidly dividing somatic stem cell compartments (such as hematopoietic, intestinal, and neural progenitors), thereby impairing tissue regeneration. Prediction: Large mammals engineered with exonuclease-deficient POLG will exhibit early-onset alopecia, kyphosis, anemia, sarcopenia, and reduced lifespan accompanied by severe depletion of tissue-resident stem cells and respiratory chain complex instability, but without a corresponding increase in oxidative macromolecular damage (e.g., 8-oxodG or lipid peroxidation) or rescue by mitochondrial antioxidants.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 5 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 4 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Experimentally elevating somatic mtDNA point mutation rates does not cause systemic premature ageing or shortened lifespan in large mammals unless large-scale mtDNA deletions are simultaneously generated in post-mitotic tissues. Point mutations alone produce only mild, tissue-restricted pathology due to the slower cell turnover and greater metabolic reserve of large mammals. Mechanism: In long-lived large mammals with low basal metabolic rates, random somatic mtDNA point mutations fail to clonally expand to the high heteroplasmic threshold (>60-80%) required for phenotypic expression in post-mitotic organs like brain, heart, and skeletal muscle, whereas large-scale segmental mtDNA deletions possess a replicative size advantage that allows rapid clonal expansion and focal cytochrome c oxidase (COX) deficiency. Prediction: Large mammals carrying a proofreading-deficient POLG variant (which predominantly generates point mutations and non-replicating linear fragments) will maintain a near-normal lifespan with minimal post-mitotic organ failure, whereas large mammals expressing a dominant-negative Twinkle helicase or mitochondrial-targeted restriction endonuclease (which generates circular mtDNA deletions) will develop severe cardiomyopathy, neurodegeneration, and shortened lifespan.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42663085", "pmid": "42663085", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70692", "title": "Shelterin TPP1 Promotes Hair Regeneration Through Activating Bulge Hair Follicle Stem Cells.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-28", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper reports experimentally confirmed causal mechanisms linking an age-related decline in hair regeneration to a defined molecular regulator and therapeutic intervention.", "background": "Ageing commonly impairs the cyclical regeneration of hair follicles, contributing to progressive hair thinning and alopecia. Hair growth depends on the orderly transition of follicles from a resting phase into a proliferative growth phase. With age, this transition becomes less efficient as regenerative cells lose functional capacity. Whether this decline can be reversed by directly restoring an intrinsic molecular control of follicle regeneration remained unresolved.", "question": "Can an intrinsic molecular regulator be enhanced to reactivate quiescent hair follicles and restore hair regeneration, and through what mechanism?", "subject": "Age-related hair regeneration", "finding": "Increasing TPP1, either through stem-cell Acd overexpression or topical stabilization with the peptide TELODIN, accelerates hair regeneration in mice. TPP1 coordinates telomere capping and telomerase recruitment, activating bulge hair follicle stem cells and promoting their proliferation, differentiation, and migration as follicles transition synchronously from telogen to anagen.", "key_points": [ "TPP1 causally promotes hair regeneration", "TPP1 activates bulge hair follicle stem cells", "Telomere capping and telomerase recruitment mediate the effect", "Follicles transition from telogen to anagen", "Topical TELODIN stabilizes TPP1 and promotes hair growth" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "Genetic or pharmacological induction of intrinsic microRNA-205 (miR-205) expression in aged hair follicle stem cells (HFSCs) reactivates quiescent telogen follicles and restores anagen hair regeneration. This reactivation occurs by reversing age-associated cellular stiffening in the bulge and hair germ compartments. Mechanism: miR-205 directly binds and post-transcriptionally represses transcripts encoding RhoA-ROCK pathway activators and actomyosin regulators (including Arhgef11 and Plekhg5), reducing myosin light chain II phosphorylation (p-MLC2) and cortical F-actin polymerization, which lowers intracellular mechanical tension and permits cell-cycle re-entry. Prediction: Atomic force microscopy will show reduced cortical stiffness in aged HFSCs upon miR-205 induction prior to proliferation, and hair regeneration will be phenocopied by ROCK/myosin II inhibition (e.g., blebbistatin) or abolished by expressing miR-205-resistant Arhgef11 without altering upstream BMP or Wnt ligand levels.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Enhancing intrinsic canonical beta-catenin/LEF1 transcriptional activity in aged hair germ and bulge progenitors by suppressing intrinsic glycogen synthase kinase-3beta (GSK3beta) or Dickkopf-1 (DKK1) restores telogen-to-anagen progression. Direct reactivation of this transcriptional hub overrides the elevated inhibitory threshold of the aged follicular microenvironment. Mechanism: Stabilized unphosphorylated beta-catenin translocates to the nucleus and complexes with TCF/LEF transcription factors to displace Groucho/TLE corepressors, directly transactivating anagen-initiating genes (such as Ccnd1, Myc, and Lef1) and antagonizing elevated BMP/Smad1/5/8 quiescence signaling. Prediction: Inducible HFSC-specific expression of stabilized beta-catenin will rapidly upregulate Axin2 and Lef1 transcripts and trigger hair germ mitosis in aged skin despite persistently high dermal BMP2/4 levels, whereas TCF/LEF dominant-negative constructs will completely abrogate this regenerative response.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "Upregulating the NAD+-dependent deacetylase SIRT7 in aged HFSCs restores the telogen-to-anagen transition and reverses age-related hair thinning. Enhancing SIRT7 overcomes the persistent quiescence checkpoint that accumulates in aged follicular stem cells. Mechanism: SIRT7 directly deacetylates nuclear NFATc1, preventing its retention and facilitating its PA28gamma-dependent proteasomal degradation, which relieves NFATc1-mediated transcriptional repression of cell-cycle and anagen-initiation genes downstream of calcineurin/BMP signaling. Prediction: Overexpression of wild-type SIRT7, but not catalytically inactive SIRT7, in aged HFSCs will selectively deplete nuclear NFATc1 protein without reducing Nfatc1 mRNA, and co-expression of an acetylation-mimetic or degradation-resistant NFATc1 mutant will block SIRT7-induced anagen entry.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Enhancing intrinsic lactate dehydrogenase A (LDHA) activity or inhibiting the mitochondrial pyruvate carrier (MPC1) in aged HFSCs reactivates dormant hair follicles and restores cyclical regeneration. Increasing glycolytic lactate production directly triggers the metabolic switch required for progenitor activation. Mechanism: Shifting pyruvate flux away from mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation towardLDHA-mediated lactate synthesis elevates intracellular lactate and NADH/NAD+ ratios, which allosterically and transcriptionally activates Myc and canonical Wnt/beta-catenin target genes necessary for hair germ proliferation. Prediction: Targeted deletion of Mpc1 or overexpression of Ldha in aged HFSCs will increase intracellular lactate levels and induce anagen entry before structural changes in the niche occur, whereas pharmacological LDHA inhibition will block follicle reactivation even in the presence of exogenous Wnt agonists.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Restoring intrinsic Type XVII collagen (COL17A1) expression or inhibiting its age-induced proteolysis in aged HFSCs rescues hair follicle cycling and prevents follicular miniaturization. Preserving this transmembrane hemidesmosomal component maintains stem cell identity and regenerative competence across serial hair cycles. Mechanism: Intact COL17A1 anchors bulge HFSCs to the basement membrane via alpha6beta4 integrin hemidesmosomes and maintains apicobasal polarity, preventing DNA-damage-induced neutrophil elastase proteolysis from triggering atypical symmetric divisions and terminal epidermal differentiation. Prediction: Transgenic stabilization of COL17A1 in aged epidermis will preserve hemidesmosome ultrastructure and basal HFSC pool numbers across multiple cycles without directly altering cellular glycolysis or nuclear NFATc1 turnover, and will selectively prevent ectopic transepidermal elimination of stem cells.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42664348", "pmid": "42664348", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aee6780", "title": "Adipose-cartilage communication via EV-Mito-mtDNA signaling promotes osteoarthritis progression.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-28", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism linking excess adiposity to osteoarthritis, an age-related degenerative disease, including induction of cellular senescence and joint degeneration.", "background": "Osteoarthritis is a common age-related disorder characterized by progressive joint deterioration, inflammation, pain, and loss of mobility. Obesity substantially increases osteoarthritis risk, including in joints that do not bear additional body weight, suggesting that mechanical loading alone cannot explain the association. Adipose tissue can influence distant organs through circulating signals, but the molecular basis of its contribution to joint degeneration remained unclear. Identifying the responsible signals and downstream processes could reveal targets for preventing or treating obesity-associated osteoarthritis.", "question": "By what causal molecular mechanism does excess adiposity promote osteoarthritis progression, and can disrupting that mechanism reduce joint pathology?", "subject": "Adiposity-driven osteoarthritis", "finding": "Adipocyte-derived extracellular vesicles enriched in mitochondrial components transfer mitochondrial DNA to chondrocytes, where it activates cGAS-STING signaling and causes inflammation, metabolic dysfunction, senescence, and cartilage degeneration. Genetic or pharmacological inhibition of this pathway attenuates cartilage damage, pain behaviors, and gait abnormalities.", "key_points": [ "Adipocyte-derived EV-Mito carry mitochondrial DNA", "Mitochondrial DNA is transferred to chondrocytes", "Transferred DNA activates cGAS-STING signaling", "The pathway drives senescence and cartilage degeneration", "cGAS-STING inhibition reduces osteoarthritis pathology" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "Hypertrophic adipocytes in obesity secrete excess circulating leptin that acts directly on articular chondrocytes and synovial macrophages via the OB-Rb receptor to drive cartilage matrix catabolism and premature chondrocyte senescence. Disrupting adipocyte leptin production or joint-specific leptin receptor signaling will prevent obesity-accelerated osteoarthritis independent of body mass or mechanical loading. Mechanism: Elevated systemic leptin crosses the synovial barrier and binds the long-form leptin receptor (OB-Rb) on articular chondrocytes, activating JAK2/STAT3 and NF-kB signaling cascades that transcriptionally upregulate matrix-degrading proteases (MMP-13, ADAMTS-4, and ADAMTS-5), induce p16INK4a/p21CIP1-dependent cellular senescence, and suppress SOX9-mediated synthesis of aggrecan and type II collagen. Prediction: Chondrocyte-specific deletion of Lepr (Col2a1-CreERT2;Lepr fl/fl) or intra-articular delivery of a pegylated leptin receptor antagonist in high-fat diet-fed mice will preserve cartilage thickness and prevent MMP-13 upregulation in both weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing joints, without altering total body weight, systemic adiposity, or circulating lipid profiles.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Metabolic stress in obesity accelerates cellular senescence in visceral and subcutaneous adipocytes, which secrete a circulating senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) that systemically induces bystander senescence in articular chondrocytes and synovial fibroblasts. Selective senolytic clearance of senescent adipocytes or neutralization of adipocyte-derived SASP factors will prevent and ameliorate obesity-driven osteoarthritis. Mechanism: DNA damage and mitochondrial dysfunction in hypertrophic adipocytes activate the cGAS-STING and p16INK4a/p21CIP1 pathways, driving the endocrine release of SASP factors—specifically activin A, PAI-1, and GDF15—that enter the systemic circulation and synovial microvasculature to trigger paracrine DNA damage signaling, ALK4/SMAD2/3 pathway imbalance, and proliferative arrest in joint-resident chondrocytes and chondroprogenitors. Prediction: Inducible, adipocyte-restricted ablation of p16INK4a-expressing cells in obese mice will normalize circulating activin A and PAI-1 levels, prevent the accumulation of SA-beta-gal+ and gamma-H2AX+ senescent chondrocytes in both weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing joints, and preserve articular cartilage integrity without requiring direct intra-articular intervention.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "Dysfunctional visceral adipose tissue in obesity releases circulating small extracellular vesicles (sEVs) enriched in pro-catabolic microRNAs that home to synovial joints and reprogram chondrocytes toward autophagy failure and extracellular matrix degradation. Blocking adipose sEV biogenesis or neutralizing their microRNA cargo will attenuate joint degeneration in obese individuals. Mechanism: Hypertrophic, hypoxic adipocytes package specific microRNAs (such as miR-155-5p and miR-34a-5p) into FABP4+/CD63+ exosomes that enter the bloodstream, extravasate into the synovium, and are endocytosed by chondrocytes, where they post-transcriptionally silence Sirt1 and Atg7 mRNAs to impair mitophagy, elevate mitochondrial reactive oxygen species, and shift chondrocytes toward hypertrophic catabolism. Prediction: Adipocyte-specific knockout of the exosome release regulator Rab27a (Adipoq-Cre;Rab27a fl/fl) will protect high-fat diet-fed mice from cartilage erosion and restore chondrocyte SIRT1 expression, whereas intravenous injection of purified visceral adipose sEVs from obese donors into lean mice will induce osteoarthritis pathology in the absence of elevated soluble adipokines or metabolic syndrome.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Unrestrained lipolysis in insulin-resistant adipose tissue elevates circulating saturated free fatty acids and C16:0 ceramides that accumulate in synovial fluid and trigger lipid peroxidation-driven ferroptosis and inflammasome activation in articular chondrocytes. Inhibiting systemic ceramide biosynthesis or chondrocyte fatty acid transport will halt obesity-associated cartilage destruction. Mechanism: Excess circulating palmitate and adipose-derived C16:0 ceramides enter the synovial cavity and are imported into chondrocytes via CD36 and FABP4, where they overload mitochondrial beta-oxidation, downregulate glutathione peroxidase 4 (GPX4) and system Xc- (SLC7A11), and activate the TLR4/MyD88/NLRP3 inflammasome axis, culminating in iron-dependent ferroptotic chondrocyte death and IL-1beta-mediated synovitis. Prediction: Lipidomic analysis of synovial fluid will show selective enrichment of C16:0 ceramides and 4-hydroxynonenal in obese osteoarthritis patients, and chondrocyte-specific Cd36 deletion or pharmacological inhibition of ceramide synthase 6 (or intra-articular ferrostatin-1 treatment) will rescue chondrocyte GPX4 activity and prevent cartilage loss in obese mice despite persistently elevated circulating leptin and inflammatory cytokines.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Excess adipose tissue promotes osteoarthritis progression by secreting complement factor D (adipsin) into the circulation, which acts as the rate-limiting protease to activate the alternative complement cascade within synovial fluid and drive complement-mediated joint injury. Genetic deletion or pharmacological inhibition of circulating adipsin will protect against obesity-induced cartilage degeneration and synovitis. Mechanism: Adipocytes serve as the primary endocrine source of circulating adipsin (CFD), which diffuses into the joint space and cleaves factor B complexed with C3b to form the alternative pathway C3 convertase (C3bBb); subsequent cascade amplification generates C3a/C5a anaphylatoxins and deposits sublytic membrane attack complexes (C5b-9) on chondrocytes and synovial macrophages, activating C5aR1 and MAPK/ERK signaling to induce catabolic metalloproteinases and synovial inflammation. Prediction: Cfd-deficient mice or lipodystrophic mice fed an obesogenic diet will be protected from synovial C3b/C5b-9 deposition and osteoarthritis, and surgical transplantation of wild-type—but not Cfd-knockout—adipose tissue into fat-free mice will restore synovial alternative complement activation and susceptibility to joint degeneration.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42665751", "pmid": "42665751", "doi": "10.1038/s43587-026-01195-y", "title": "Mitochondrial DNA leakage in oocytes activates cGAS-STING signaling to drive ovarian aging.", "journal": "Nat Aging", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-28", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism of age-related ovarian decline and validates genetic and pharmacological interventions in multiple mouse models.", "background": "Ovarian function declines earlier than the function of many other organs, reducing fertility and altering endocrine health. Age-related deterioration of cellular quality, tissue communication and inflammatory homeostasis has been implicated in this process. Mitochondrial dysfunction is common in ageing reproductive tissues, but whether it directly initiates ovarian decline rather than merely accompanying it has remained uncertain. The molecular signals linking mitochondrial stress to dysfunction across the ovarian follicle were unknown.", "question": "How does age-associated mitochondrial dysfunction initiate and propagate inflammatory signaling that causes ovarian functional decline?", "subject": "Mechanism of ovarian ageing", "finding": "Ageing-associated mitochondrial DNA leakage from oocytes activates oocyte cGAS, generating cGAMP that triggers STING signaling and passes through gap junctions to activate STING in surrounding granulosa cells. Genetic deletion of oocyte Cgas or pharmacological STING inhibition ameliorates inflammation and ovarian dysfunction, establishing this signaling axis as a causal driver of ovarian ageing.", "key_points": [ "Mitochondrial stress causes mtDNA leakage from oocytes", "Leaked mtDNA activates the cGAS–cGAMP–STING pathway", "Oocyte-derived cGAMP transmits signaling to granulosa cells through gap junctions", "Pathway activation promotes ovarian inflammation and functional decline", "Genetic or pharmacological pathway inhibition rescues ovarian dysfunction" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Impaired mitophagy in ageing granulosa cells leads to the accumulation of damaged mitochondria that generate mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS) and oxidized mtDNA, directly triggering NLRP3 inflammasome assembly and Gasdermin D-dependent pyroptotic signaling. The resulting release of mature IL-1beta and IL-18 into the follicular fluid propagates paracrine receptor-mediated inflammation across neighbouring granulosa, theca, and stromal cells to disrupt steroidogenesis and oocyte maturation. Mechanism: Age-associated reductions in PINK1/Parkin- and BNIP3-mediated mitophagy prevent the clearance of depolarized mitochondria, elevating matrix superoxide and oxidizing replicating mtDNA via FEN1-dependent cleavage into cytosolic fragments. Oxidized mtDNA binds NLRP3 to nucleate ASC specks and activate Caspase-1, which cleaves pro-IL-1beta, pro-IL-18, and Gasdermin D (GSDMD); sub-lytic and lytic GSDMD pores release these interleukins into the follicular fluid, engaging IL-1R1/IL-18R on mural granulosa and theca cells to drive positive-feedback NF-kB activation and stromal fibrosis. Prediction: Selective scavenging of mtROS, inhibition of oxidized mtDNA generation, or granulosa-specific deletion of Nlrp3 or Gsdmd will selectively block follicular fluid IL-1beta/IL-18 accumulation and rescue ovulation rates in aged ovaries, whereas blocking cGAS-STING or MAVS pathways will fail to prevent caspase-1 cleavage and pyroptotic follicular loss.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Stressed oocytes and granulosa cells in ageing ovaries package damaged mitochondrial cargos into mitochondrial-derived vesicles (MDVs) and small extracellular vesicles (sEVs) secreted into the follicular fluid, which are internalized by neighbouring follicular and stromal cells to activate endosomal Toll-like receptors. This vesicular trafficking of mitochondrial damage-associated molecular patterns (mtDAMPs) physically propagates sterile inflammation from focally stressed cells across the entire ovarian follicle and interstitium. Mechanism: When mitochondrial quality control is overwhelmed in aged oocytes or cumulus cells, oxidized cardiolipin, TFAM-bound unmethylated CpG mtDNA, and N-formyl peptides are selectively sorted via Snx9/Rab9-dependent MDVs into multivesicular bodies and released as CD63+/CD81+ exosomes into the follicular fluid and across transzonal projections. Endocytic uptake of these mtDAMP-laden vesicles by mural granulosa, theca, and resident myeloid cells triggers endosomal TLR9 (via CpG mtDNA) and TLR4 (via oxidized phospholipids) signaling through MyD88-NF-kB, converting localized mitochondrial damage into organ-wide ovarian inflammation. Prediction: Purified follicular fluid extracellular vesicles from aged or mitochondrially stressed follicles will be sufficient to induce MyD88/TLR9-dependent inflammation and steroidogenic decline when transferred to young healthy follicles, and blocking exosome biogenesis (e.g., via Rab27a/nSMase2 inhibition) or endosomal TLR9 signaling will halt inter-cellular inflammatory propagation despite persistent cell-autonomous mitochondrial dysfunction.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Age-related deterioration of the mitochondrial RNA degradosome causes bidirectional mitochondrial double-stranded RNA (mt-dsRNA) accumulation and efflux into the cytosol of oocytes and cumulus cells, activating the MDA5/RIG-I-MAVS innate immune axis. This antiviral-like signaling cascade propagates inflammatory cytokines and interferon-stimulated genes across the follicle, arresting oocyte meiotic competence and inducing granulosa cell senescence. Mechanism: Declining activity of the mitochondrial helicase SUV3 (SUPV3L1) and exoribonuclease PNPase (PNPT1) during reproductive ageing impairs degradation of light-strand mitochondrial transcripts, leading to intramitochondrial mt-dsRNA accumulation. Escape of mt-dsRNA through voltage-dependent anion channels or BAX/BAK pores into the cytosol activates the RNA sensors MDA5 and RIG-I, inducing MAVS polymerization on the outer mitochondrial membrane and downstream TRAF3/TBK1/IRF3 activation that secretes type I/III interferons and pro-inflammatory chemokines into the intrafollicular milieu. Prediction: Depleting cytosolic mt-dsRNA or genetically ablating Mavs in ovarian somatic or germ cells will suppress follicular antiviral-like inflammatory signatures and restore oocyte developmental competence during mitochondrial stress, whereas DNase-mediated depletion of cytosolic mtDNA or inhibition of cGAS will not attenuate the inflammatory response.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Age-associated loss of mitochondrial membrane integrity in granulosa cells and oocytes causes cytosolic leakage of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), activating the cGAS-STING pathway to initiate sterile follicular inflammation. Intercellular transfer of 2'3'-cGAMP through connexin gap junctions and paracrine type I interferon/NF-kB cytokine secretion propagate this inflammatory state across the cumulus-oocyte complex and ovarian stroma, driving follicular atresia and endocrine decline. Mechanism: Age-related decline in TFAM stoichiometry and cristae remodeling promote VDAC1 oligomerization and BAX/BAK macropore formation on the outer mitochondrial membrane, releasing mtDNA fragments into the cytosol. Cytosolic mtDNA binds cGAS to synthesize 2'3'-cGAMP, which activates STING-TBK1-IRF3/NF-kB signaling within the stressed cell and diffuses through Connexin-43 and Connexin-37 gap junctions at transzonal projections into adjacent follicular cells, amplifying IL-6, TNF-alpha, CXCL10, and IFN-beta production throughout the follicle. Prediction: Oocyte- or granulosa-specific genetic deletion or pharmacological inhibition of STING (e.g., H-151) or gap-junctional cGAMP transfer in aged mice will abolish pan-follicular interferon-stimulated gene expression and preserve follicular reserve and estradiol production, even when mitochondrial bioenergetic dysfunction or NLRP3 inflammasome competence remains intact.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 5 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 5 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Chronic mitochondrial proteotoxic and respiratory chain stress in ageing follicular cells activates the mitochondrial integrated stress response (mt-ISR) via the OMA1-DELE1-HRI-eIF2alpha-ATF4 axis, reprogramming transcription toward a pro-inflammatory senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) and mitokine release. Secreted mitokines and chemokines remodel the ovarian microenvironment by recruiting pro-inflammatory macrophages and uncoupling oocyte-granulosa metabolic cooperativity. Mechanism: Age-associated decline in mitochondrial proteases (LONP1, CLPP) and electron transport chain efficiency triggers inner membrane depolarization and OMA1-mediated cleavage of DELE1. Cytosolic cleaved DELE1 activates the kinase HRI to phosphorylate eIF2alpha and sustain translation of ATF4 and CHOP, which transcriptionally upregulate secreted stress mediators including GDF15, FGF21, CCL2, and IL-6; these factors act paracrinely via GFRAL/chemokine receptors to polarize resident ovarian macrophages toward an M1-like inflammatory phenotype and suppress FSH-induced aromatase expression in granulosa cells. Prediction: Pharmacological inhibition of the integrated stress response (e.g., with ISRIB) or genetic ablation of Dele1/Atf4 in aged ovaries will prevent mitokine/SASP secretion, block pro-inflammatory macrophage infiltration, and restore follicular endocrine function without requiring prior restoration of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation or inhibition of cytosolic nucleic acid sensors.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42689491", "pmid": "42689491", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70700", "title": "In Vivo Base Editing Partially Rescues Bone Dysplasia in a Mouse Model of Hutchinson-Gilford Progeria Syndrome.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally demonstrates that correcting the causal mutation in an ageing-related progeroid disorder reduces its molecular pathology and partially restores skeletal function, with efficacy depending on treatment timing.", "background": "Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome is a rare genetic disorder characterized by accelerated, multisystem features of ageing. Progressive skeletal abnormalities are a prominent component of the disease in both patients and experimental models. These abnormalities involve impaired bone formation, remodeling, and mechanical integrity. It remained unclear whether established skeletal pathology could be meaningfully reversed in vivo and how strongly therapeutic efficacy would depend on the age at treatment.", "question": "Can in vivo correction of the HGPS-causing mutation rescue molecular, cellular, and structural defects in bone, and how does treatment timing affect efficacy?", "subject": "HGPS bone dysplasia", "finding": "Adenine base editing of the pathogenic LMNA variant reduced progerin expression, restored extracellular-matrix deposition and mineralization in progeroid osteoblasts, and partially rescued bone structure and physical properties in mice. In vivo correction was strongly age-dependent, with early postnatal delivery producing substantially greater editing and skeletal benefit than later treatment.", "key_points": [ "Correction of the pathogenic LMNA variant", "Reduced progerin transcripts and protein", "Improved osteoblast matrix deposition and mineralization", "Partial rescue of bone structure and physical properties", "Greater efficacy with early postnatal treatment" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Correcting the HGPS mutation in vivo rescues bone homeostasis by halting nuclear lamina-associated DNA damage and eliminating the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) in the osteolineage, thereby uncoupling paracrine osteoclast activation from suppressed osteoblastogenesis. Treatment efficacy declines with age at intervention because late-stage progeroid bone accumulates a threshold of senescent cells and fibrotic marrow niche remodeling that resists clearance. Mechanism: Progerin sequesters DNA repair factors (such as 53BP1 and PCNA) and induces replication fork collapse, triggering chronic ATM/ATR-NF-kappaB activation and secretion of osteolytic SASP cytokines (IL-6, IL-1beta, CCL2, and MMP13) that inhibit osteoblast differentiation and stimulate osteoclasts. Genetic correction stops de novo DNA double-strand breaks and dampens NF-kappaB transcriptional activity; however, in late-treated animals, already-established senescent osteocytes and marrow stromal cells maintain a self-reinforcing paracrine inflammatory loop that impairs complete structural regeneration. Prediction: Genetic correction will rapidly reduce gamma-H2AX foci and NF-kappaB activation in edited osteolineage cells at any age, but late-treated mice will retain elevated marrow IL-6/MMP13 levels and incomplete trabecular rescue unless co-treated with a senolytic agent, which will synergize with late genetic correction to match the structural efficacy of early correction.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 3, "text": "In vivo correction of the LMNA mutation restores osteoblast extracellular matrix secretion and normalizes type I collagen organization and mineralization kinetics, rescuing the intrinsic material quality of newly synthesized bone. Because existing progeroid bone matrix contains defective collagen cross-links and hypermineralized, brittle mineral crystal structure, whole-bone mechanical recovery depends on the cumulative fraction of pre-existing matrix replaced after treatment initiation. Mechanism: Progerin-induced nuclear envelope stress and endoplasmic reticulum dysfunction impair procollagen processing, extracellular matrix vesicle release, and tissue-nonspecific alkaline phosphatase (TNAP)/pyrophosphate balance, producing disorganized collagen fibrils and abnormal mineral-to-matrix ratios. Upon genetic correction, osteoblasts immediately deposit properly cross-linked, normomineralized osteoid; early intervention ensures nearly the entire adult skeleton is built from wild-type matrix, whereas late intervention produces a composite tissue of brittle pre-treatment cores surrounded by ductile post-treatment lamellar layers. Prediction: Fluorescent double-fluorochrome labeling combined with Raman microspectroscopy and nanoindentation will demonstrate that bone matrix deposited after genetic correction exhibits normal mineral-to-matrix ratios, collagen cross-link maturity, and tissue-level elastic modulus regardless of treatment age, while whole-bone toughness and post-yield displacement scale linearly with the volume fraction of post-correction matrix.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 4 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "In vivo correction of the HGPS mutation reverses defective bone formation and excessive resorption by restoring nuclear envelope integrity, LINC-complex coupling, and canonical Wnt/beta-catenin mechanotransduction in osteocytes and osteoblasts. Early correction prevents cumulative osteocyte apoptosis and lacunar-canalicular network degeneration, whereas late correction restores signaling only in newly embedded or surviving osteocytes, leaving regions of acellular, unremodeled bone. Mechanism: Progerin accumulation stiffens the nuclear lamina, disrupts SUN/nesprin LINC complexes, impairs nuclear translocation of beta-catenin and YAP/TAZ in response to mechanical loading, and elevates the RANKL/OPG ratio. Genetic correction restores nuclear mechanosensitivity, upregulates Wnt target genes (such as Lef1, Axin2, and Runx2), and suppresses osteoclastogenesis; however, pre-existing empty osteocyte lacunae and severed canaliculi in aged progeroid bone cannot be repopulated without complete osteoclastic resorption and de novo bone deposition. Prediction: Single-cell RNA sequencing and immunostaining of bone tissue after genetic correction will show rapid normalization of nuclear beta-catenin, OPG/RANKL ratios, and sclerostin regulation in viable osteocytes across age groups, but dynamic histomorphometry under mechanical loading will reveal persistently blunted periosteal bone formation in late-treated mice specifically within zones of prior osteocyte lacunar emptiness.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Systemic in vivo correction of the HGPS mutation rescues skeletal pathology through dual cell-autonomous normalization of osteoblast differentiation and non-cell-autonomous restoration of the bone marrow vascular niche and systemic endocrine trophic support. Early intervention is markedly more effective than late intervention because it preserves type H capillary-osteoprogenitor coupling and prevents premature depletion of growth plate chondrocytes before irreversible vascular rarefaction sets in. Mechanism: Skeletal integrity requires both intrinsic osteoblast function and angiocrine signaling (Notch, PDGF-BB, and VEGF) from endomucin-high, CD31-high (type H) bone marrow endothelial cells alongside systemic IGF-1 signaling. Systemic correction eliminates progerin toxicity in both osteolineage cells and vascular smooth muscle/endothelial cells, restoring metaphyseal blood flow and angiocrine-driven osteogenesis; late correction cannot fully regenerate obliterated metaphyseal capillaries or reopen calcified epiphyseal growth plates, limiting longitudinal growth and trabecular neoformation. Prediction: Lineage-specific correction restricted to osteoblasts/osteocytes will rescue cortical matrix mineralization but fail to match the trabecular and longitudinal bone rescue of systemic correction, and late systemic correction will show incomplete restoration of CD31hi/Emcnhi metaphyseal vessels that directly correlates with residual deficits in trabecular bone volume.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 0, "text": "In vivo correction of the HGPS-causing LMNA mutation rescues molecular and cellular osteoblast defects regardless of age, but complete restoration of bone microarchitecture and biomechanical strength requires early intervention before osteoprogenitor exhaustion and growth plate senescence occur. Late treatment achieves only partial structural rescue because recovery is rate-limited by slow adult bone remodeling turnover and a depleted mesenchymal progenitor pool. Mechanism: Eliminating progerin production and restoring wild-type lamin A/C repairs nuclear lamina architecture and relieves p53/p21-mediated cell-cycle arrest in surviving osteoprogenitors and osteoblasts. When correction occurs during early postnatal growth, abundant mesenchymal stem and progenitor cells rapidly populate modeling bone surfaces to normalize cortical thickness and trabecular volume; when initiated after skeletal maturity, irreversible senescence of chondro-osseous progenitors and low baseline remodeling rates restrict the replacement of pre-existing dysplastic bone matrix. Prediction: Both early and late genetic correction will normalize nuclear morphology and osteogenic gene expression in active osteoblasts within weeks, whereas micro-CT cortical bone volume and three-point bending fracture resistance will fully normalize only in the early-treated cohort, with late-treated animals showing a rescue trajectory proportional to bone formation rate and residual Sca-1+/PDGFRa+ progenitor frequency.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42696595", "pmid": "42696595", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aeg8609", "title": "Natural variation in SL6 determines fatty acid components and seed longevity in rice.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-04", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal genetic mechanism controlling seed lifespan and age-related loss of viability.", "background": "Seeds progressively lose viability during storage, limiting crop propagation and the preservation of genetic resources. Longevity varies substantially among rice varieties and is influenced by both environmental conditions and inherited traits. Although several genomic regions associated with seed longevity had been identified, the causal genes and regulatory mechanisms underlying this variation remained poorly understood. It was also unclear whether naturally occurring longevity alleles could improve seed survival without compromising agronomic performance.", "question": "What genetic and molecular mechanism causes natural variation in seed longevity among rice varieties?", "subject": "Rice seed longevity", "finding": "Natural variation at qSL6 causally determines rice seed longevity through SL6, a fatty acyl-ACP thioesterase that changes seed fatty-acid composition and increases resistance to oxidation. Desiccation-induced ABA signaling activates SL6 through VP1, while a virus-derived CT-rich element in the 5′ UTR of the ancestral SL6HHZ allele stabilizes its mRNA bidirectionally and contributes to longevity differences between indica and japonica rice.", "key_points": [ "qSL6 encodes the causal fatty acyl-ACP thioesterase SL6", "SL6 alters palmitic-acid synthesis and seed fatty-acid composition", "The ABA–VP1 module directly activates SL6 during seed desiccation", "A CT-rich 5′-UTR element stabilizes SL6HHZ mRNA", "Increasing SL6 expression improves seed longevity without major agronomic penalties" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Natural variation in rice seed survival is determined by coding and regulatory variants in the protein repair enzymes L-isoaspartyl methyltransferase (OsPIMT1/OsPIMT2) and methionine sulfoxide reductase (OsMSRB5), which reverse spontaneous non-enzymatic covalent damage to embryonic proteins. Superior alleles maintain proteostasis and translational competence upon imbibition by actively restoring aged polypeptide backbones and oxidized methionine residues. Mechanism: During prolonged dry and humid storage, spontaneous deamidation of asparaginyl and isomerization of aspartyl residues generate kinked L-isoaspartyl (isoAsp) residues, while ROS oxidize methionine into methionine sulfoxide (MetO), inactivating ribosomal proteins and glycolytic enzymes. High-efficiency alleles of OsPIMT and OsMSRB5 utilize S-adenosylmethionine and thioredoxin reducing power during late maturation and early imbibition to convert isoAsp and MetO back to native L-aspartyl and methionine residues, preventing proteotoxic aggregation. Prediction: Aged seeds of long-lived varieties will accumulate markedly fewer isoAsp-modified and MetO-oxidized proteins in the embryonic axis during the first 12 hours of imbibition and recover de novo protein synthesis faster than short-lived varieties, while seed-specific knockdown of OsPIMT1/2 or OsMSRB5 will eliminate this difference without altering baseline lipid peroxidation or sugar profiles.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Natural variation in rice seed longevity arises from allelic differences in base excision repair enzymes—specifically 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase (OsOGG1) and apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease (OsARP)—that govern the clearance of oxidative DNA lesions in the quiescent embryonic meristem prior to the first mitotic cell cycle. Elite alleles prevent replication fork stalling and checkpoint-mediated germination arrest upon rehydration. Mechanism: Desiccation and storage-induced ROS continuously oxidize guanine bases in nuclear and mitochondrial DNA to 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG) and induce single- and double-strand breaks in G1-arrested embryonic root and shoot apical meristem cells. High-activity variants of OsOGG1 and OsARP rapidly excise 8-oxoG lesions and process abasic sites during phase I and II of imbibition, enabling timely completion of DNA synthesis and mitotic entry without triggering SOG1/ATM-dependent DNA damage checkpoints or programmed cell death. Prediction: Comet assays and 8-oxoG immunodetection in imbibing embryos will show rapid lesion clearance and earlier activation of mitotic cyclin expression (OsCYCB1;1) in long-lived varieties prior to radicle protrusion, whereas treatment with base excision repair inhibitors (such as methoxyamine) during imbibition will selectively abolish the longevity advantage of the superior allele.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "Allelic variation in seed-expressed lipoxygenases (such as OsLOX2 and OsLOX3) and reactive aldehyde detoxifying enzymes (such as OsALDH7) governs rice seed longevity by controlling the rate of enzymatic polyunsaturated fatty acid peroxidation and toxic aldehyde accumulation in stored embryos. Naturally occurring hypomorphic or promoter-attenuated lipoxygenase alleles preserve mitochondrial and plasma membrane integrity during storage without penalizing agronomic performance. Mechanism: Seed lipoxygenases catalyze the dioxygenation of linoleic and linolenic acids in membrane phospholipids into hydroperoxides, which subsequently decompose into cytotoxic reactive carbonyl species including malondialdehyde (MDA) and 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal (4-HNE). Functional polymorphisms that reduce seed-specific lipoxygenase activity or enhance OsALDH7-mediated oxidation of reactive aldehydes to carboxylic acids prevent membrane phase separation, solute leakage, and mitochondrial cytochrome c loss during dry storage and rehydration. Prediction: Long-lived rice accessions carrying the causal allele will display significantly lower lipid hydroperoxide, MDA, and 4-HNE levels alongside lower electrical conductivity of seed leachates after artificial ageing, and pharmacological or genetic inhibition of lipoxygenase activity in short-lived varieties will phenocopy the high-longevity state even when peroxiredoxin and chaperone levels remain unchanged.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Natural variation in rice seed longevity is driven by cis-regulatory polymorphisms in the abscisic acid (ABA)-responsive transcription factor OsbZIP23 and its direct target 1-Cys peroxiredoxin (OsPER1A), which establish different baseline capacities for reactive oxygen species (ROS) detoxification in quiescent embryos. Varieties carrying high-expression promoter alleles accumulate greater levels of OsPER1A during late seed maturation without altering vegetative growth or grain yield. Mechanism: During late seed maturation, desiccation-induced ABA signaling activates OsbZIP23, which binds directly to ABRE motifs in the OsPER1A promoter. Promoter variants with higher OsbZIP23 binding affinity drive elevated accumulation of the thiol-specific peroxidase OsPER1A in the embryo and aleurone layer, neutralizing hydrogen peroxide and alkyl hydroperoxides during dry storage and early imbibition before they can oxidatively carbonylate stored mRNAs and metabolic enzymes. Prediction: Near-isogenic lines (NILs) introgressing the high-longevity OsPER1A or OsbZIP23 promoter allele will exhibit lower H2O2 accumulation and reduced protein carbonylation in the embryo during controlled deterioration tests, whereas CRISPR/Cas9 mutation of the ABRE motif in the OsPER1A promoter will abolish the longevity advantage without affecting membrane fatty acid composition or isoaspartyl protein repair rates.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Polymorphisms in auxin-inactivating amido synthetases (such as OsGH3-2) alter the late-maturation ABA-to-auxin ratio in developing rice seeds, driving differential accumulation of raffinose family oligosaccharides (RFOs) and small heat shock proteins that stabilize the embryonic cytoplasmic glass state. Alleles that elevate seed-specific IAA conjugation increase cytoplasmic viscosity and decelerate macromolecular degradation during dry storage without affecting plant architecture or grain filling. Mechanism: Elevated OsGH3-2 activity in maturing embryos conjugates free indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) into inactive IAA-aspartate, relieving auxin-mediated repression of ABA signaling (via OsABI3/OsVP1). Enhanced maturation-phase ABA signaling upregulates galactinol synthase (OsGolS1/OsGolS2) and raffinose synthase, increasing the raffinose-to-sucrose ratio; this elevates the intracellular glass transition temperature (Tg) and water-replacement hydrogen bonding capacity of the desiccated cytoplasm, arresting molecular diffusion and protein unfolding. Prediction: Long-lived genotypes will exhibit lower free IAA, higher ABA sensitivity, a higher raffinose-to-sucrose ratio, and a higher cytoplasmic glass transition temperature in mature dry embryos as measured by differential scanning calorimetry, and exogenous application of auxin biosynthesis inhibitors during late grain filling in short-lived lines will increase RFO content and restore seed longevity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42698274", "pmid": "42698274", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70666", "title": "Secreted Frizzled-Related Protein 2 (SFRP2) Induces Follistatin-Like 1 (FSTL1) to Regulate Dihydrotestosterone (DHT)-Induced Dermal Papilla Cell Mitochondrial Dysfunction and Senescence.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal molecular mechanism linking androgen exposure to mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress and cellular senescence in an age-related hair-loss disorder.", "background": "Androgenetic alopecia is a common, progressive form of hair loss associated with genetic susceptibility and heightened follicular responses to dihydrotestosterone. Androgen exposure progressively impairs the cells that support follicle growth, contributing to follicular miniaturization and a shortened growth phase. Mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress, inflammation and cellular senescence have been implicated in this deterioration. However, the molecular mechanism connecting androgen signaling to these pathogenic cellular changes remained incompletely understood.", "question": "What molecular mechanism exacerbates dihydrotestosterone-induced mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress and senescence during androgenetic alopecia?", "subject": "Androgen-induced follicular senescence", "finding": "SFRP2 binds FSTL1 and increases its protein stability, establishing an SFRP2–FSTL1 axis that exacerbates DHT-induced mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress, inflammation and senescence in dermal papilla cells. SFRP2 knockdown alleviated these defects and improved hair regeneration and follicle morphology, while FSTL1 knockdown counteracted the harmful effects of SFRP2 overexpression.", "key_points": [ "SFRP2 directly binds FSTL1", "SFRP2 promotes FSTL1 protein stability", "The SFRP2–FSTL1 axis worsens DHT-induced mitochondrial dysfunction and senescence", "FSTL1 depletion suppresses the effects of SFRP2 overexpression", "SFRP2 depletion improves hair regeneration in an AGA mouse model" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Dihydrotestosterone exacerbates follicular mitochondrial dysfunction and senescence by simultaneously activating DRP1-mediated mitochondrial fission and arresting PINK1–Parkin-dependent mitophagy in dermal papilla cells. The failure to clear fragmented, depolarized mitochondria results in the persistent accumulation of damaged respiratory complexes that continuously generate reactive oxygen species and sustain a chronic DNA damage response. Mechanism: AR signaling promotes ERK/CDK1-mediated phosphorylation of DRP1 at Ser616 to drive mitochondrial fragmentation while impairing PINK1 stabilization or upregulating mitochondrial deubiquitinases (such as USP30) on damaged mitochondria, blocking autophagosomal engulfment and lysosomal clearance. Prediction: Live-cell mitophagy flux reporters (such as mt-Keima) in balding dermal papilla cells will show accumulation of fragmented mitochondria uncoupled from lysosomal degradation upon DHT exposure, and pharmacological mitophagy restoration (e.g., urolithin A or USP30 inhibition) will rescue mitochondrial respiration and hair follicle organoid growth more effectively than free-radical scavengers alone.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Androgen-induced oxidative DNA damage and inflammatory signaling hyperactivate PARP1 and upregulate the NAD+ hydrolase CD38 in follicular niche cells, causing severe intracellular and mitochondrial NAD+ exhaustion. This depletion of the NAD+/NADH pool blunts the mitochondrial unfolded protein response (UPRmt) and sirtuin-dependent repair, locking dermal papilla cells into metabolic failure and irreversible senescence. Mechanism: DHT exposure triggers low-grade DNA strand breaks that activate PARP1 poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation and NF-κB-dependent transcription of CD38, synergistically consuming NAD+ required for mitochondrial proteostasis (via LONP1 and HSP60 regulation) and redox homeostasis. Prediction: Targeted metabolomics of DHT-treated dermal papilla cells will demonstrate rapid NAD+ depletion alongside elevated nicotinamide and ADP-ribose prior to senescence onset, and selective CD38 inhibition (e.g., 78c) or NAD+ precursor supplementation (NMN/NR) will restore UPRmt protease expression, oxidative phosphorylation, and proliferative capacity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Dihydrotestosterone-activated androgen receptor (AR) directly represses the transcriptional coactivator PGC-1α and its downstream mitochondrial deacetylase SIRT3 in dermal papilla cells, disabling both mitochondrial biogenesis and enzymatic antioxidant defense. The resulting hyperacetylation of superoxide dismutase 2 (SOD2) and electron transport chain subunits accelerates mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS) leakage and triggers p16INK4a/p21CIP1-mediated cellular senescence. Mechanism: Ligand-bound AR recruits corepressor complexes to the PPARGC1A promoter to downregulate PGC-1α and SIRT3 expression, preventing the deacetylation-dependent activation of SOD2 and Complex I/III subunits and causing unquenched superoxide accumulation in the mitochondrial matrix. Prediction: Chromatin immunoprecipitation will demonstrate DHT-dependent AR occupancy at the PPARGC1A locus in human dermal papilla cells, and genetic restoration of SIRT3 or PGC-1α will reverse SOD2 hyperacetylation, normalize mtROS levels, and prevent senescence even under continuous DHT stimulation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 1, "text": "Androgen signaling promotes voltage-dependent anion channel 1 (VDAC1) oligomerization and mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization in dermal papilla cells, causing the efflux of oxidized mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) into the cytosol. Cytosolic mtDNA activates the cGAS–STING innate immune axis, establishing a feed-forward loop of NF-κB-driven inflammation and senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) production that amplifies follicular oxidative stress and senescence. Mechanism: DHT-induced mitochondrial stress triggers VDAC1 macropore formation and mitochondrial permeability transition pore (mPTP) opening, releasing oxidized mtDNA fragments that bind cyclic GMP-AMP synthase (cGAS) to activate STING–TBK1–IRF3/NF-κB signaling and pro-senescent cytokine secretion (IL-6, IL-1β, TGF-β1). Prediction: Inhibiting VDAC1 oligomerization (e.g., with VBIT-4), depleting mtDNA, or genetically ablating STING in DHT-treated dermal papilla cells will abolish SASP cytokine secretion and paracrine senescence in co-cultured hair follicle stem cells without preventing initial nuclear AR translocation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Dihydrotestosterone signaling remodels endoplasmic reticulum–mitochondria contact sites (MAMs) to enhance IP3R–GRP75–VDAC1–MCU tethering, driving chronic mitochondrial calcium (Ca2+) overload in dermal papilla cells. Excessive matrix Ca2+ overstimulates tricarboxylic acid cycle dehydrogenases and triggers mPTP opening, precipitating mitochondrial membrane potential collapse, oxidative burst, and premature senescence. Mechanism: AR activation upregulates or stabilizes the IP3R–GRP75–VDAC1 tethering complex and the mitochondrial calcium uniporter (MCU) at MAMs, channeling excessive ER Ca2+ into the mitochondrial matrix where it induces respiratory chain electron leakage, ΔΨm depolarization, and ROS-mediated telomeric DNA damage. Prediction: Split-GFP MAM reporters and targeted mitochondrial Ca2+ sensors will reveal increased ER–mitochondria contact area and matrix Ca2+ surges preceding ROS elevation in DHT-treated cells, and pharmacological or genetic inhibition of MCU will prevent DHT-induced ΔΨm collapse and senescence-associated β-galactosidase activity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42717261", "pmid": "42717261", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70706", "title": "NAD+ Metabolic Reprogramming Drives CD8+ T Cells Senescence and Exacerbates Ulcerative Colitis.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific metabolic and innate immune signaling mechanism that drives cellular senescence and worsens an inflammatory disease.", "background": "Cellular senescence can develop in immune populations and alter tissue function through persistent inflammatory and dysfunctional states. Such immunosenescence has been associated with chronic inflammatory disorders, but whether senescent immune cells directly cause disease progression has remained uncertain. Metabolic disruption and mitochondrial damage are recognized triggers of senescence, including through the abnormal release of mitochondrial components into the cytosol. The causal sequence connecting these processes to intestinal inflammation and treatment resistance was unresolved.", "question": "What mechanism induces pathogenic immune-cell senescence in ulcerative colitis, and does this senescence causally exacerbate the disease?", "subject": "Senescence in ulcerative colitis", "finding": "NAD+ metabolic dysregulation causes mitochondrial dysfunction and cytosolic mitochondrial DNA leakage, activating cGAS-STING signaling to drive CD8+ T-cell senescence. These senescent cells exacerbate colitis, while systemic senolytic treatment reduces disease severity; their associated signature also predicts severe disease and non-response to biologic therapy.", "key_points": [ "NAD+ metabolic dysregulation initiates the process", "Mitochondrial dysfunction causes cytosolic mitochondrial DNA leakage", "cGAS-STING activation drives CD8+ T-cell senescence", "Senescent CD8+ T cells causally exacerbate colitis", "Senolytic clearance attenuates disease severity" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Inflammatory suppression of tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle enzymes, specifically fumarate hydratase, in colonic lamina propria macrophages causes intracellular fumarate accumulation, mitochondrial membrane damage, and cytosolic release of mitochondrial double-stranded RNA (mt-dsRNA) and mtDNA. This dual nucleic acid leakage drives macrophage senescence that causally accelerates intestinal barrier destruction and corticosteroid resistance. Mechanism: Downregulation of fumarate hydratase during glycolytic reprogramming in colitic macrophages elevates fumarate levels, succinating mitochondrial proteins and disrupting cristae architecture. The resulting vesicular budding and mitochondrial permeabilization release mt-dsRNA and mtDNA into the cytoplasm, simultaneously engaging RIG-I/MDA5-MAVS and cGAS-STING axes to lock macrophages into a p21-high, apoptosis-resistant senescent state that continuously secretes IL-1beta, IL-18, and tissue-remodeling factors. Prediction: Myeloid-specific restoration of fumarate hydratase activity or double knockdown of Mavs and Sting1 in macrophages will selectively abolish senescent macrophage accumulation in colitic mucosa and reverse steroid-refractory disease, whereas T-cell-targeted senolytics or isolated cGAS inhibition alone will fail to fully prevent senescence induction.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 2, "text": "Chronic hyperactivation of the ecto-NADase CD38 in the inflamed colonic microenvironment depletes intracellular NAD+ pools in infiltrating lymphocytes, inactivating mitochondrial sirtuins (SIRT3) and destabilizing TFAM-bound mitochondrial nucleoids. The resulting leakage of unpackaged mtDNA into the cytosol induces p53/p21-dependent immunosenescence that directly drives chronic relapsing ulcerative colitis and biologic therapy failure. Mechanism: Elevated mucosal CD38 expression consumes NAD+, suppressing NAD+-dependent SIRT1/SIRT3 deacetylase activity and downregulating TFAM expression. Loss of TFAM causes mitochondrial nucleoid decompaction, defective electron transport chain assembly, and BAX/BAK macropore formation, releasing damaged mtDNA into the cytosol to trigger ATM/p53/p21 signaling and a pathogenic SASP that impairs epithelial stem-cell regeneration. Prediction: Replenishing NAD+ levels with nicotinamide riboside or genetically ablating Cd38 in hematopoietic cells will preserve mitochondrial nucleoid integrity, prevent cytosolic mtDNA accumulation and lymphocyte senescence in ulcerative colitis models, and abrogate disease progression upon senescent-cell challenge.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "Iron-dependent lipid peroxidation of mitochondrial inner-membrane cardiolipin in infiltrating mucosal myeloid cells triggers sub-lethal cytochrome c and mtDNA release into the cytosol without inducing full ferroptosis or apoptosis. This sub-lethal mitochondrial permeabilization engages low-level caspase-3/gasdermin E signaling alongside cGAS-STING to establish a senescent myeloid niche that causally perpetuates ulcerative colitis and confers resistance to mucosal healing therapies. Mechanism: Excessive labile iron and polyunsaturated fatty acid oxidation in the ulcerated colon peroxidize mitochondrial cardiolipin, detaching cytochrome c and destabilizing the inner and outer mitochondrial membranes. The resulting sub-lethal cytosolic release of cytochrome c and mtDNA triggers limited gasdermin E pore formation and cGAS-STING activation, driving p16INK4a expression and non-lytic SASP release that recruits neutrophils and blocks epithelial restitution. Prediction: Mitochondria-targeted lipid radical scavengers (such as MitoQ or ferrostatin analogues) or myeloid-specific Gsdme deletion will prevent mitochondrial cardiolipin oxidation and cytosolic mtDNA/cytochrome c leakage, selectively ablating the senescent myeloid population and restoring mucosal healing in adoptive-transfer colitis models.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 3, "text": "Defective PINK1/Parkin-mediated mitophagy coupled with dysregulated purine nucleotide metabolism in mucosal CD8+ T cells leads to the accumulation of depolarized mitochondria that extrude damaged mtDNA and cardiolipin through the mitochondrial permeability transition pore (mPTP). This cytosolic mitochondrial danger signal induces ZBP1- and NLRP3-dependent cellular senescence that causally amplifies mucosal cytotoxicity and treatment resistance in ulcerative colitis. Mechanism: Metabolic exhaustion and purine nucleotide imbalance impair mitophagic flux in lamina propria CD8+ T cells, causing buildup of damaged mitochondria with elevated matrix calcium and oxidative stress. Persistent opening of the cyclophilin D-dependent mPTP releases oxidized Z-form mtDNA into the cytosol, which is sensed by ZBP1 and the NLRP3 inflammasome to enforce senescent growth arrest and granzyme B/cytokine hypersecretion that kills colonic crypt epithelial cells. Prediction: Pharmacological inhibition of mPTP opening with cyclosporin A derivatives or CD8+ T-cell-specific deletion of Zbp1 will block cytosolic Z-mtDNA sensing, eliminate senescent granzyme-secreting CD8+ T cells, and attenuate colitis severity more effectively than VDAC or MAVS blockade.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 0, "text": "In ulcerative colitis, impaired oxidative phosphorylation and mitochondrial outer-membrane stress in mucosal CD4+ T cells trigger voltage-dependent anion channel (VDAC) oligomerization and cytosolic leakage of oxidized mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), which activates cGAS-STING signaling to induce T-cell senescence. These senescent CD4+ T cells causally exacerbate colitis and drive resistance to anti-TNF therapy by secreting a persistent pro-inflammatory senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) that compromises the intestinal epithelial barrier. Mechanism: Metabolic overload and excessive mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS) in infiltrating CD4+ T cells oxidize mtDNA and promote VDAC1 oligomerization, allowing mtDNA fragments to escape into the cytosol. Cytosolic mtDNA binds cGAS to produce 2'3'-cGAMP, activating STING-TBK1-IRF3/NF-kB signaling, which enforces p16INK4a/p21CIP1-mediated cell-cycle arrest and a pathogenic SASP (enriched in IFN-gamma, TNF, IL-6, and matrix metalloproteinases) that sustains mucosal ulceration independent of canonical TCR activation. Prediction: Adoptive transfer of senescent mtDNA-leaking CD4+ T cells into Rag1-/- mice will suffice to induce severe, anti-TNF-refractory colitis, whereas T-cell-specific deletion of Sting1 or pharmacological inhibition of VDAC oligomerization (e.g., with VBIT-4) or senolytic clearance (e.g., ABT-263) will prevent T-cell senescence and restore therapeutic responsiveness without rescue by inflammasome inhibitors.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42723546", "pmid": "42723546", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70701", "title": "The Secretome Derived From Human Umbilical Cord Mesenchymal Stem Cells Improves Skin Photoaging by Enhancing Mitophagy to Inhibit the cGAS-STING Pathway.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal mechanism linking mitochondrial quality control, sterile inflammation, cellular senescence, and UV-induced skin ageing.", "background": "Chronic ultraviolet exposure causes skin photoaging characterized by impaired barrier function, collagen loss, cellular senescence, and persistent inflammation. Damaged cells can accumulate dysfunctional organelles and release intracellular danger signals that sustain sterile inflammatory responses. Regenerative cell-free therapies have shown potential for repairing aged or injured tissues, but their activity can involve many distinct biological processes. The causal mechanism by which such therapies might suppress photoaging-associated senescence and inflammation remained unresolved.", "question": "Can a cell-free regenerative treatment alleviate UV-induced skin photoaging, and which causal intracellular mechanism mediates its protective effects?", "subject": "Skin photoaging mechanism", "finding": "Human umbilical cord mesenchymal stem cell secretome protects against UV-induced photoaging by enhancing mitophagy, which clears damaged mitochondria and reduces cytosolic mitochondrial DNA leakage. This suppresses cGAS-STING signaling and downstream inflammatory cytokines; mitophagy inhibition abolishes protection, while STING inhibition restores it.", "key_points": [ "The secretome alleviates UV-induced photoaging and cellular senescence", "Enhanced mitophagy removes damaged mitochondria", "Reduced mitochondrial DNA leakage suppresses cGAS-STING signaling", "Mitophagy inhibition abolishes the protective effect", "STING inhibition rescues protection despite blocked mitophagy" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 4, "text": "Cell-free regenerative therapy prevents UV-induced cellular senescence and sterile inflammation by activating the KEAP1–NRF2 antioxidant pathway to neutralize oxidative stress upstream of organelle damage. By upregulating endogenous antioxidant and cytoprotective enzymes, the treatment prevents lipid peroxidation and oxidative mitochondrial injury before intracellular danger signals can be generated. Mechanism: Antioxidant proteins and signaling lipids within the cell-free secretome modify cysteine residues on KEAP1 or promote p62-mediated KEAP1 degradation, liberating NRF2 to translocate into the nucleus and bind Antioxidant Response Elements (AREs). The resulting transcription of HO-1, NQO1, SOD2, and GPX4 scavenges UV-generated reactive oxygen species and lipid hydroperoxides, preserving mitochondrial and nuclear membrane integrity and preventing DAMP release. Prediction: Genetic deletion of NFE2L2 (NRF2) or pharmacological inhibition with ML385 will abolish the treatment's capacity to prevent UV-induced mitochondrial depolarization, 8-oxo-dG accumulation, and senescence marker expression, demonstrating that redox neutralization acts upstream to prevent organelle dysfunction rather than accelerating the clearance of already-damaged organelles.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Cell-free regenerative treatment reverses UV-induced photoaging by activating the AMPK–TFEB signaling axis to restore autophagic-lysosomal flux and degrade intracellular danger signals. This restoration prevents the accumulation of damaged organelles and reactive oxygen species that otherwise trigger NLRP3 inflammasome assembly and pyroptotic tissue inflammation. Mechanism: Signaling factors in the cell-free preparation phosphorylate AMPK and promote nuclear translocation of transcription factor EB (TFEB), upregulating lysosomal biogenesis and v-ATPase-dependent acidification. Enhanced autolysosomal degradation clears both UV-damaged organelles and ubiquitinated NLRP3/ASC complexes, preventing cathepsin leakage and mitochondrial ROS from driving caspase-1 cleavage and IL-1β/IL-18 maturation in the dermis and epidermis. Prediction: Knockdown of TFEB or blockade of lysosomal acidification with bafilomycin A1 will prevent the cell-free treatment from suppressing ASC speck formation, caspase-1 cleavage, and dermal collagen degradation after chronic UV exposure, distinguishing this general autolysosomal-inflammasome mechanism from selective pathways that do not require TFEB-driven lysosomal biogenesis.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "Cell-free regenerative treatment alleviates photoaging by delivering specific regulatory microRNAs that directly silence pro-inflammatory and matrix-degrading transcripts while disinhibiting TGF-β/Smad signaling. This post-transcriptional reprogramming halts extracellular matrix breakdown and paracrine senescence without requiring primary changes in organelle turnover. Mechanism: Extracellular vesicles within the cell-free therapy fuse with dermal fibroblasts and transfer functional miRNAs (such as miR-146a, miR-29, or miR-125b) into the cytoplasm, where they bind the 3'-UTRs of TRAF6/IRAK1, AP-1 subunits, and Smad7 mRNAs. This simultaneously suppresses NF-κB/MAPK-driven transcription of matrix metalloproteinases (MMP-1, MMP-3) and inflammatory cytokines while restoring TGF-β receptor-mediated Smad2/3 phosphorylation to drive type I and III collagen synthesis. Prediction: Depletion of vesicular RNA cargo (via Dicer knockout in producer cells or RNase treatment of permeabilized vesicles) or transfection of specific anti-miR oligonucleotides into recipient fibroblasts will eliminate the therapy's ability to suppress MMP-1/3 and restore collagen I levels after UV irradiation, without altering baseline mitochondrial membrane potential or mitophagy rates.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Cell-free regenerative therapy (such as stem cell-derived extracellular vesicles) alleviates UV-induced skin photoaging by activating PINK1/Parkin-mediated mitophagy to clear damaged mitochondria. This targeted organelle clearance prevents the leakage of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) into the cytosol, thereby suppressing activation of the cGAS–STING innate immune pathway and downstream senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) inflammation. Mechanism: Bioactive cargo within the cell-free treatment stimulates PINK1 stabilization and Parkin recruitment to depolarized mitochondria in UV-irradiated keratinocytes and dermal fibroblasts, promoting their autophagic degradation. By eliminating dysfunctional mitochondria before outer membrane permeabilization or mPTP opening can occur, the treatment prevents cytosolic accumulation of oxidized mtDNA, blocking cGAS recognition, 2'3'-cGAMP synthesis, STING/TBK1/IRF3/NF-κB phosphorylation, and the resulting sterile inflammatory and senescent state. Prediction: Genetic depletion of PINK1/Parkin or pharmacological inhibition of mitophagy in UV-exposed skin models will abolish the therapy's ability to reduce cytosolic mtDNA levels, STING phosphorylation, SASP cytokine secretion, and p16/p21 expression, whereas exogenous STING agonists (e.g., DMXAA or cGAMP) will override the protective effects despite intact mitochondrial clearance.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 5 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 4 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 2, "text": "Cell-free regenerative therapy protects against UV-induced skin photoaging by restoring intracellular NAD+ pools and reactivating the SIRT1/SIRT3 deacetylase axis. Sirtuin reactivation coordinates nuclear DNA repair, deacetylates p53 to prevent cell cycle arrest, and stimulates PGC-1α-driven mitochondrial biogenesis to replace dysfunctional organelles. Mechanism: UV-induced DNA damage hyperactivates PARP1, exhausting cellular NAD+ and inactivating NAD+-dependent sirtuins. The cell-free therapy delivers NAD+-biosynthetic enzymes (such as extracellular NAMPT) or metabolic intermediates that replenish intracellular NAD+, enabling SIRT1 to deacetylate p53, FOXO3, and PGC-1α while SIRT3 deacetylates mitochondrial antioxidant and respiratory proteins, thereby restoring bioenergetic homeostasis and suppressing senescence. Prediction: Inhibition of NAMPT (via FK866) or selective inhibition of SIRT1/SIRT3 (via EX-527) will completely abrogate the treatment-induced recovery of intracellular NAD+/NADH ratios, mitochondrial ATP production, and pro-collagen synthesis in UV-irradiated fibroblasts, even when autophagic machinery remains intact.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42725837", "pmid": "42725837", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70711", "title": "Transmembrane Protein PTCHD4 Is a Novel Regulator of Cellular Senescence and Age-Related Pathologies.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism linking a previously uncharacterized regulator to cellular senescence, age-related dysfunction, and pulmonary fibrosis.", "background": "Cellular senescence is a stable stress response that contributes to tissue dysfunction, chronic inflammation, and multiple age-related diseases. Senescent cells accumulate with age, and experimentally reducing their abundance or activity can improve health-related outcomes in animal models. Transmembrane proteins can regulate intracellular signaling networks involved in stress responses and cell-fate decisions, but many remain poorly characterized in ageing. Identifying upstream regulators that causally control senescence could reveal therapeutic targets for age-associated disorders.", "question": "Does the transmembrane protein investigated in this study causally regulate cellular senescence and age-related tissue pathology, and through what signaling mechanism?", "subject": "Regulation of cellular senescence", "finding": "PTCHD4 promotes cellular senescence and age-associated tissue dysfunction by enhancing AKT signaling. PTCHD4 deficiency suppressed senescence, alleviated ageing-related phenotypes and bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis in mice, and its anti-senescent effect was reversed by restoring AKT signaling.", "key_points": [ "PTCHD4 causally promotes cellular senescence", "PTCHD4 deficiency improves ageing-related phenotypes and median lifespan in mice", "PTCHD4 deficiency reduces pulmonary fibrosis and preserves lung function", "AKT activation mediates the pro-senescent effect of PTCHD4" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "The transmembrane protein acts as a causal upstream amplifier of the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) and paracrine senescence by activating the TAK1-p38 MAPK-NF-κB signaling cascade in response to extracellular stress cues. Inhibiting this transmembrane regulator uncouples cell-cycle arrest from pro-inflammatory secretome production, reducing chronic tissue inflammation and secondary senescence in aged organs. Mechanism: The cytoplasmic tail of the transmembrane protein scaffolds intracellular adaptor proteins (such as TRAFs or MyD88-family adaptors) to activate TAK1 and p38 MAPK, leading to IKK-mediated phosphorylation and degradation of IκBα, nuclear translocation of p65/RelA, and transcriptional induction of SASP factors (IL-6, IL-8, TNF-α, MMPs). Prediction: Knockdown or ectodomain blockade of the transmembrane protein in senescent cells will markedly suppress IκBα phosphorylation, p65 nuclear translocation, and SASP cytokine secretion while leaving primary cell-cycle arrest markers (p16INK4a and Rb hypophosphorylation) intact, and conditioned medium from these cells will fail to induce paracrine senescence in proliferating bystander cells.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 0, "text": "Age-related upregulation of the transmembrane protein causally drives cellular senescence and tissue degeneration by constitutively activating the PI3K-AKT-mTORC1 signaling axis and suppressing autophagic clearance of damaged organelles. Genetic ablation or neutralizing blockade of this protein attenuates senescence marker accumulation (p16INK4a, p21CIP1, SA-β-gal) and ameliorates age-associated tissue fibrosis and dysfunction. Mechanism: Ligand engagement or clustering of the transmembrane protein recruits PI3K to its intracellular domain, elevating PIP3 levels to phosphorylate AKT and activate mTORC1, which in turn phosphorylates and inhibits ULK1 and TFEB, halting autophagic-lysosomal flux, increasing damaged mitochondrial accumulation, and stabilizing p53/p21CIP1 and p16INK4a expression. Prediction: Depletion of the transmembrane protein will reduce S6K1/4E-BP1 phosphorylation and restore autophagic flux (LC3-II turnover), whereas pharmacological inhibition of autophagy (e.g., bafilomycin A1) or constitutive mTORC1 activation will completely abolish the anti-senescent rescue effect of depleting the protein without initially altering upstream DNA damage sensors.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 5 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 4 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "Age-dependent loss or proteolytic shedding of the transmembrane protein causally accelerates senescent cell accumulation and tissue pathology because the intact protein functions as a homeostatic negative regulator that suppresses pro-senescent JAK-STAT signaling and/or mediates immune surveillance clearance of senescent cells. Restoring expression or preventing cleavage of the transmembrane protein in aged tissues reduces senescent cell burden and rejuvenates tissue function. Mechanism: In young healthy tissue, the intact transmembrane protein maintains cellular homeostasis by recruiting phosphatases (such as SHP1/2) or sustaining juxtacrine Notch/trophic signaling to repress JAK-STAT3 activation and/or serves as a surface recognition ligand for NK and CD8+ T-cell cytotoxicity; age-related downregulation or metalloprotease-mediated shedding removes this brake, permitting cell-autonomous senescence induction and immune evasion. Prediction: Conditional knockout of the transmembrane protein in young mice will prematurely induce tissue senescence and pathology in the absence of exogenous stressors, whereas viral re-expression or cleavage-resistant mutation of the protein in aged mice will reduce senescent cell burden, suppress STAT phosphorylation, and enhance immune-mediated senolysis.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 0 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "The transmembrane protein causally enforces replicative and stress-induced cellular senescence by transducing extracellular matrix or growth-inhibitory cues into sustained activation of the DDR/MAPK-p53-p21CIP1 and p16INK4a-Rb tumor suppressor pathways. Targeted deletion of the protein in aged animals prevents senescent cell accumulation and preserves tissue regenerative capacity. Mechanism: Conformational activation of the transmembrane protein triggers intracellular kinase signaling (via Src/FAK, TGF-β/Smad, or sustained ERK hyperactivation) that induces replication stress and reactive oxygen species, activating ATM/ATR-CHK1/2 to phosphorylate p53 and transcriptionally upregulate p21CIP1 and p16INK4a, enforcing irreversible G1/S cell-cycle arrest via Rb dephosphorylation. Prediction: Ectopic overexpression of the wild-type transmembrane protein—but not an intracellular domain-truncated mutant—in young proliferating cells will rapidly induce γH2AX foci, p53 phosphorylation, and Rb-dependent proliferation arrest prior to SASP induction, and co-deletion of p53 or p16INK4a will rescue the proliferation defect.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "The transmembrane protein causally regulates senescence and age-related tissue pathology by disrupting intracellular calcium and ion homeostasis, triggering mitochondrial dysfunction, cytosolic mtDNA release, and activation of the cGAS-STING innate immune pathway. Restoring normal transmembrane protein activity prevents mitochondrial permeability transition and halts STING-driven sterile inflammation in aged tissues. Mechanism: Dysregulation of the transmembrane protein promotes excessive Ca2+ flux into the cytosol and mitochondrial matrix, causing mitochondrial membrane potential collapse, excess mtROS generation, and opening of VDAC/BAX macropores; the resulting leakage of mtDNA into the cytosol activates cGAS to produce 2'3'-cGAMP, stimulating STING-TBK1-IRF3 signaling to drive type I interferon-mediated senescence and tissue pathology. Prediction: Perturbing the transmembrane protein will acutely alter cytosolic and mitochondrial Ca2+ transients and increase cytosolic mtDNA levels before canonical senescence markers appear, and pharmacological inhibition of STING (e.g., H-151) or mtDNA depletion will abrogate the senescence and tissue pathology phenotype caused by the protein's dysregulation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 1 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42736449", "pmid": "42736449", "doi": "10.1038/s43587-026-01207-x", "title": "A microprotein atlas of the human frontal cortex in Alzheimer's disease.", "journal": "Nat Aging", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally links loss of a specific previously unannotated microprotein to impaired mitochondrial respiration, providing a mechanistic finding relevant to Alzheimer's disease.", "background": "Alzheimer's disease involves progressive neuronal dysfunction accompanied by broad molecular changes in the brain. Conventional genome annotation does not capture every translated product, leaving potentially functional proteins uncharacterized. Disease-associated changes in these overlooked products may occur independently of established proteins encoded at the same genomic loci. It remained unclear whether any such product contributes directly to cellular dysfunction in Alzheimer's disease.", "question": "Can an unannotated protein product that is altered in Alzheimer's disease causally regulate cellular function relevant to disease pathology?", "subject": "Alzheimer's-associated microprotein function", "finding": "A small open reading frame at the MKKS locus encodes a 63-amino-acid microprotein that is the locus's predominant translation product and is downregulated in Alzheimer's disease. Experimental loss of this microprotein impairs mitochondrial respiration in microglia, supporting a causal role in microglial bioenergetics.", "key_points": [ "63-amino-acid microprotein encoded at the MKKS locus", "Predominant translation product of the locus", "Downregulated in Alzheimer's disease", "Its loss impairs microglial mitochondrial respiration" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "An unannotated microprotein translated from an alternative open reading frame (altORF) within an established genomic locus is upregulated in Alzheimer's disease independently of the canonical protein and directly nucleates pathological protein aggregation and proteostasis collapse. Mechanism: Cellular stress and altered translational initiation fidelity in Alzheimer's disease neurons promote leaky ribosomal scanning or non-canonical start codon usage, increasing translation of an out-of-frame altORF without changing canonical protein abundance. The resulting hydrophobic microprotein directly binds intrinsically disordered regions of tau or sequesters molecular chaperones (such as Hsp70/Hsp40 complexes), accelerating toxic oligomer formation and impairing proteasomal and autophagic clearance. Prediction: Expressing the unannotated altORF construct (with the canonical start codon mutated to prevent canonical protein synthesis) in human iPSC-derived neurons is sufficient to induce tau hyperphosphorylation and insoluble aggregate accumulation, whereas selectively abolishing the altORF via synonymous mutations that preserve the canonical protein sequence rescues proteotoxicity in Alzheimer's disease cellular models.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 2, "text": "An unannotated polypeptide translated from an upstream or downstream open reading frame (uORF/dORF) is aberrantly expressed in Alzheimer's disease and causally disrupts endolysosomal acidification and vesicular trafficking, leading to defective clearance of amyloidogenic and tau species. Mechanism: Activation of the integrated stress response (eIF2alpha phosphorylation) in Alzheimer's disease brains selectively promotes ribosome bypass or re-initiation at a regulatory uORF/dORF independently of steady-state canonical protein levels. The translated peptide localizes to endolysosomal membranes where it interferes with vacuolar ATPase (v-ATPase) subunit assembly or Rab GTPase effector recruitment, causing early endosomal enlargement and blocking autophagosome-lysosome fusion. Prediction: Mutating the non-canonical or upstream initiation codon of the unannotated ORF in Alzheimer's disease patient-derived neurons restores lysosomal pH, normalizes Rab5-positive endosome morphology, and rescues autophagic flux without altering the abundance or localization of the canonical protein encoded by the same transcript.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "An unannotated microprotein encoded within a dual-coding synaptic transcript is selectively altered in Alzheimer's disease and causally impairs synaptic vesicle cycling and postsynaptic receptor stability, driving early network dysfunction and synapse loss. Mechanism: Activity-dependent or disease-induced remodeling of translation initiation shifts ribosome occupancy toward an overlapping internal reading frame at the same genomic locus. The resulting microprotein competitively binds presynaptic SNARE regulators or postsynaptic scaffolding complexes, disrupting neurotransmitter release probability and AMPA/NMDA receptor surface trafficking independently of the canonical protein's function. Prediction: Introducing synonymous mutations that selectively ablate the overlapping reading frame while preserving the canonical amino acid sequence in primary or iPSC-derived cortical neurons reverses Alzheimer's disease-associated deficits in miniature excitatory postsynaptic currents (mEPSCs), calcium transients, and dendritic spine density.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 1, "text": "Disease-associated dysregulation of an unannotated small open reading frame (sORF)-encoded microprotein localized to the inner mitochondrial membrane causally impairs oxidative phosphorylation and drives bioenergetic failure in Alzheimer's disease neurons independently of the canonical protein encoded at the same locus. Mechanism: Uncoupled translational regulation or transcript isoform switching in Alzheimer's disease alters the abundance of a mitochondrial-targeted microprotein encoded by an upstream or overlapping reading frame. This microprotein normally acts as an assembly or stabilizing factor for electron transport chain supercomplexes, and its perturbation in disease disrupts Complex I/IV activity, reduces ATP synthesis, and elevates mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS). Prediction: Selective genetic restoration or ablation of the unannotated microprotein in neuronal models—while holding canonical host protein expression constant—directly modifies basal and maximal oxygen consumption rates, mitochondrial membrane potential, and mtROS levels, and affinity purification-mass spectrometry confirms its physical interaction with respiratory chain subunits.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 4, "text": "An unannotated microprotein differentially translated in Alzheimer's disease glia acts independently of the canonical locus protein to reprogram microglial innate immune signaling, suppressing phagocytic clearance and amplifying neurotoxic inflammation. Mechanism: Pathological stimuli in the Alzheimer's disease brain induce glial translation of a cryptic open reading frame whose peptide product physically interacts with intracellular immune signaling adaptors (such as NF-kappaB, TREM2-SYK, or cGAS-STING pathway components) or actin-remodeling machinery, locking microglia into a pro-inflammatory state with impaired phagocytic cup formation. Prediction: Selective CRISPR base-editing or antisense inhibition targeting the unannotated ORF translation initiation site in human iPSC-derived microglia—without perturbing canonical protein levels—restores fibrillar amyloid-beta and synaptosome phagocytosis, attenuates pro-inflammatory cytokine secretion, and prevents conditioned-medium-induced neurotoxicity in co-cultured neurons.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42744804", "pmid": "42744804", "doi": "10.1038/s41467-026-76728-5", "title": "Microglia deploy TAM receptors to kill motor neurons in a mouse model of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.", "journal": "Nat Commun", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-15", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally identifies a causal mechanism that accelerates motor-neuron loss and shortens lifespan in an age-related neurodegenerative disease model.", "background": "Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis is a progressive neurodegenerative disease characterized by motor-neuron loss, neuromuscular denervation and premature death. Inherited SOD1 mutations cause some forms of ALS and are widely used to model disease progression in mice. Degeneration in these models involves interactions between vulnerable neurons and surrounding cells, but it remained unclear which responses actively cause neuronal death rather than merely accompany it. Identifying causal mechanisms could reveal ways to preserve neuromuscular function and extend survival.", "question": "What disease-associated mechanism actively eliminates motor neurons and accelerates mortality in SOD1G93A mice?", "subject": "Motor-neuron elimination in ALS", "finding": "Microglial Axl and Mer receptors recognize elevated phosphatidylserine on SOD1G93A motor neurons and drive their phagocytic elimination while the neurons are still alive. Germline or microglia-restricted inactivation of Axl and Mertk preserves cholinergic motor neurons and neuromuscular synapses and extends lifespan in SOD1G93A mice.", "key_points": [ "Microglia phagocytically kill living motor neurons", "Axl and Mer are required for this elimination", "Motor-neuron phosphatidylserine provides the eat-me signal", "Axl/Mertk inactivation preserves neurons and neuromuscular synapses", "Blocking the mechanism extends lifespan" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "Activated microglia in SOD1G93A mice convert surrounding astrocytes into a neurotoxic reactive state via IL-1α, TNF-α, and C1q signaling, and these reactive astrocytes actively kill motor neurons by secreting soluble neurotoxins that trigger RIPK1/RIPK3/MLKL-dependent necroptosis. Mechanism: Mutant SOD1-driven microglial activation induces NF-κB-dependent release of IL-1α, TNF-α, and C1q, which reprograms neighboring astrocytes to lose neurotrophic and glutamate-buffering capacity while secreting toxic saturated lipids (via ELOVL1) and pro-death factors that engage neuronal death receptors and activate the RIPK1–RIPK3–MLKL necroptotic cascade. Prediction: Selective genetic ablation of microglial astrocyte-inducing factors (Il1a, Tnf, C1qa), astrocytic lipid toxin synthesis (Elovl1), or necroptotic effectors (Ripk1, Ripk3, or Mlkl) in SOD1G93A mice will preserve motor neuron somata, delay neuromuscular junction denervation, and extend survival, whereas blocking classical caspase-3-dependent apoptosis alone will not.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Disease-associated microglia and peripheral macrophages actively eliminate stressed but viable motor neurons and their neuromuscular synapses in SOD1G93A mice through complement opsonization (C1q/C3) and phagocytic receptor engagement (CR3/MerTK/TREM2), a process known as primary phagoptosis. Mechanism: Sublethal proteotoxic and bioenergetic stress in SOD1G93A motor neurons causes premature externalization of phosphatidylserine ('eat-me' signal) and downregulation of CD47 ('don't-eat-me' signal) alongside local C1q and C3 deposition on axons and somata, driving reactive microglia and terminal macrophages to engulf and destroy living motor neurons and motor endplates. Prediction: Genetic deletion or pharmacological inhibition of complement components (C1qa, C3) or microglial phagocytic receptors (Itgam/CR3, Mertk), or neuronal overexpression of CD47, will prevent engulfment of stressed motor neurons, preserve neuromuscular innervation, and prolong lifespan in SOD1G93A mice even while mutant SOD1 protein aggregation persists.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 4 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "Infiltrating cytotoxic CD8+ T lymphocytes and natural killer (NK) cells actively recognize and eliminate motor neurons in SOD1G93A mice through contact-dependent MHC class I/TCR and NKG2D-mediated cytotoxicity. Mechanism: Mutant SOD1 expression induces aberrant MHC-I antigen presentation and upregulation of NKG2D stress ligands (such as MULT1 and RAE-1) on motor neurons concurrent with blood–spinal cord barrier breakdown, recruiting self-reactive CD8+ T cells and NK cells that kill motor neurons via FasL/Fas engagement and perforin/granzyme B exocytosis while priming microglial toxicity through IFN-γ. Prediction: Specific depletion of CD8+ T cells or NK cells, or genetic disruption of neuronal MHC-I/NKG2D ligand presentation, perforin/granzyme B, or Fas signaling in SOD1G93A mice, will rescue spinal motor neurons from lymphocyte-mediated lysis, preserve motor function, and significantly delay mortality without requiring changes in glial SOD1 expression.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Accumulation of p16Ink4a- and p21Cip1-positive senescent glia in the spinal cord and peripheral nerves of SOD1G93A mice actively drives motor neuron degeneration and accelerated mortality through paracrine toxicity mediated by the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP). Mechanism: Chronic oxidative stress, DNA damage, and mitochondrial dysfunction induced by mutant SOD1 trigger permanent cell-cycle arrest via p16Ink4a/Rb and p53/p21Cip1 pathways in microglia, astrocytes, and Schwann cells, causing them to secrete pro-inflammatory SASP cytokines (IL-6, IL-1β, CXCL10) and matrix metalloproteinases that disrupt the neuromuscular niche and induce motor neuron death. Prediction: Selective elimination of p16Ink4a-positive senescent cells (via genetic suicide transgenes such as INK-ATTAC or senolytic administration) or targeted suppression of SASP signaling in SOD1G93A mice will attenuate motor neuron loss, maintain neuromuscular junction integrity, and extend survival more effectively than broad anti-inflammatory treatment.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 4, "text": "Mutant SOD1-induced mitochondrial damage triggers cytosolic mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) release and cGAS–STING–NLRP3 innate immune activation across the neuron–glia axis, actively executing motor neuron death via gasdermin D-dependent pyroptosis and GPX4-deficiency-driven ferroptosis. Mechanism: Misfolded SOD1G93A compromises mitochondrial membrane integrity in motor neurons and microglia, releasing oxidized mtDNA into the cytoplasm to activate cGAS–STING type I interferon signaling and NLRP3 inflammasome/caspase-1 cleavage of gasdermin D, which synergizes with glial iron export and neuronal GPX4 depletion to drive lethal lipid peroxidation and membrane pore formation. Prediction: Genetic knockout or pharmacological inhibition of Sting1, Gsdmd, or Nlrp3, or neuronal restoration of Gpx4 activity (or treatment with radical-trapping ferroptosis inhibitors) in SOD1G93A mice, will suppress lipid peroxidation and inflammasome pore formation, preserve neuromuscular junctions, and extend survival over inhibition of necroptosis or apoptosis.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42749700", "pmid": "42749700", "doi": "10.1038/s41467-026-76789-6", "title": "HMGA1-HP1β axis regulates premature aging in Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome through chromatin remodeling.", "journal": "Nat Commun", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-19", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal chromatin-regulatory mechanism that suppresses cellular senescence and extends lifespan in a mouse model of premature ageing.", "background": "Hutchinson–Gilford progeria syndrome is a rare genetic disorder characterized by accelerated ageing and markedly shortened lifespan. Cells affected by the disease develop nuclear abnormalities, loss of chromatin organization, and premature senescence. Senescent cells can reinforce tissue dysfunction by releasing pro-inflammatory factors collectively known as the senescence-associated secretory phenotype. The molecular mechanisms connecting altered nuclear architecture to this secretory state remained incompletely understood, limiting the development of mechanism-based treatments.", "question": "What molecular mechanism links disrupted chromatin regulation to cellular senescence in Hutchinson–Gilford progeria syndrome, and can targeting that mechanism ameliorate disease phenotypes and extend lifespan?", "subject": "Progeria senescence mechanism", "finding": "HMGA1 recruits the deubiquitinase USP7 to stabilize HP1β, which reduces chromatin accessibility at ANGPTL2 and suppresses senescence-associated secretory factors, thereby alleviating HGPS cellular senescence. An HMGA1-derived peptide, UHP, prevents HP1β degradation, reduces senescence, and significantly extends the lifespan of LmnaG609G/G609G mice.", "key_points": [ "HMGA1 stabilizes HP1β through USP7 recruitment", "HP1β closes chromatin at ANGPTL2", "ANGPTL2 and SASP expression are suppressed", "The effect on senescence depends on HP1β", "UHP reduces senescence and extends progeria-mouse lifespan" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Loss of lamina-tethered heterochromatin in HGPS triggers a genome-wide redistribution of the bromodomain epigenetic reader BRD4 and histone acetyltransferase p300 to newly accessible super-enhancers flanking pro-inflammatory loci, directly driving SASP transcription and paracrine senescence. Targeting BRD4 or p300/CBP bromodomains dismantle these SASP super-enhancers, blunting tissue inflammation and extending survival in progeroid mice. Mechanism: Sequestration and depletion of NuRD chromatin remodeling subunits (RBBP4, HDAC1) and architectural proteins (HMGB1/HMGB2) by progerin causes widespread opening of formerly repressed lamina-associated chromatin domains and aberrant H3K27 hyperacetylation at distal regulatory elements. BRD4 is recruited to these de novo H3K27ac-marked super-enhancers alongside NF-κB and C/EBPβ to promote RNA polymerase II pause release and hyper-transcription of SASP effectors independently of ongoing DNA damage signaling. Prediction: ChIP-seq in HGPS patient cells will reveal selective enrichment of H3K27ac and BRD4 at SASP super-enhancers rather than housekeeping promoters, and treatment with BET bromodomain inhibitors or degraders will suppress SASP secretion and extend lifespan in progeroid mice without reducing nuclear γH2AX foci or cytosolic DNA accumulation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Hyperactivation of the lysine acetyltransferase NAT10 and aberrant LINC-complex mechanotransduction in HGPS link cytoskeletal strain to nuclear chromatin disorganization, triggering mechanosensitive DNA damage and SASP-driven senescence. Inhibiting NAT10 or uncoupling LINC-mediated force transmission restores global H3K9me3 organization, suppresses premature senescence and SASP, and extends healthspan and lifespan in HGPS. Mechanism: Progerin accumulation at the nuclear envelope increases SUN1 retention and upregulates NAT10-mediated acetylation of microtubules and nucleolar/lamina chromatin tether proteins, transmitting excessive actomyosin and microtubule mechanical tension across the nuclear envelope. This mechanical strain induces chromatin herniations, loss of heterochromatin compaction, and mechanosensitive DNA breaks that activate p53/p21 and NF-κB-dependent SASP transcription. Prediction: Chemical inhibition of NAT10 (e.g., with Remodelin) or genetic disruption of SUN1 in HGPS cells and mice will normalize nuclear morphology, restore perinuclear H3K9me3 rings, abolish SASP factor release, and extend lifespan, whereas artificially stiffening the extracellular matrix or stabilizing microtubules will reverse these therapeutic benefits.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "Disrupted chromatin compaction and nuclear envelope fragility in HGPS cause the extrusion of poorly heterochromatinized cytoplasmic chromatin fragments (CCFs) into the cytosol, which activate the cGAS–STING–NF-κB/IRF3 innate immune axis to drive SASP secretion and premature senescence. Pharmacological or genetic inhibition of cGAS or STING uncouples nuclear architectural defects from inflammatory senescence, ameliorating vascular and systemic progeroid pathology and extending lifespan. Mechanism: Progerin stiffens the nuclear lamina and impairs replication fork stability and RAD51-mediated homologous recombination, leading to transient nuclear envelope ruptures and the blebbing of γH2AX-positive, H3K9me3-depleted chromatin fragments into the cytoplasm. Cytosolic DNA sensor cGAS binds these exposed chromatin fragments to synthesize 2'3'-cGAMP, activating STING, TBK1, IRF3, and NF-κB (p65), which transcriptionally induce Type I interferons, SASP cytokines (IL-6, IL-1β, CXCL8), and p21/p16-dependent cellular senescence. Prediction: Depleting cytosolic chromatin via cytoplasmic DNase (TREX1) overexpression or treating Lmna G609G mice with small-molecule STING/cGAS inhibitors will abolish SASP and Type I interferon signatures and significantly extend lifespan without restoring nuclear circularity or intranuclear heterochromatin compaction.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "In Hutchinson–Gilford progeria syndrome (HGPS), progerin-induced disruption of lamina-associated domains derepresses LINE-1 (L1) retrotransposons, whose transcribed RNA directly inhibits the histone methyltransferase SUV39H1 to drive global H3K9me3 heterochromatin erosion, senescence, and the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP). Depleting L1 RNA or inhibiting L1 reverse transcription restores heterochromatin architecture, suppresses SASP-driven tissue inflammation, and extends lifespan in HGPS models. Mechanism: Accumulation of farnesylated progerin at the inner nuclear membrane untethers constitutive heterochromatin from the nuclear lamina, permitting aberrant transcription of repetitive L1 elements. Nuclear L1 RNA binds and allosterically inhibits SUV39H1 enzymatic activity, preventing H3K9me3 deposition and amplifying heterochromatin decompaction at both pericentromeric satellites and SASP gene promoters, while cytoplasmic L1 cDNA intermediates simultaneously engage innate immune sensors to reinforce pro-inflammatory gene expression and irreversible cell cycle arrest. Prediction: Sequence-specific knockdown of L1 RNA using antisense oligonucleotides in HGPS fibroblasts and Lmna G609G mice will directly rescue SUV39H1 catalytic activity and genome-wide H3K9me3 levels, abrogate SASP cytokine secretion, and extend organismal survival even while progerin levels and nuclear lamina expression remain unchanged, whereas overexpressing catalytically inactive SUV39H1 will block this rescue.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Progerin destabilizes Polycomb Repressive Complex 2 (PRC2) and the heterochromatin adaptor KAP1 (TRIM28) at facultative and pericentromeric chromatin, causing loss of H3K27me3 and persistent ATM–NEMO–NF-κB signaling that co-activates p16INK4a-mediated arrest and SASP secretion. Inhibiting H3K27 demethylases (KDM6A/B) or the ATM–NEMO interaction re-establishes transcriptional silencing of senescence effectors, reduces systemic inflammation, and extends lifespan in HGPS. Mechanism: Impaired physical coupling between the progerin-distorted lamina and chromatin-modifying complexes accelerates the proteasomal degradation and mislocalization of EZH2 and KAP1, stripping H3K27me3 from the CDKN2A/B locus and exposing decondensed chromatin to chronic replication stress and unrepairable double-strand breaks. Persistent chromatin lesions activate ATM kinase, which promotes SUMOylation and ubiquitination of NEMO to trigger IKK-dependent NF-κB nuclear translocation, locking cells into a p16INK4a/RB-arrested, hyper-secretory senescent state. Prediction: Small-molecule inhibition of KDM6A/B (to restore H3K27me3 at CDKN2A and SASP loci) or disruption of the ATM–NEMO complex in HGPS mice will prevent p16INK4a induction and NF-κB-driven SASP release, rescuing vascular smooth muscle cell survival and extending lifespan even in the presence of persistent L1 RNA expression.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42758848", "pmid": "42758848", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aee8251", "title": "Epigenetic training licenses naïve CD8+ T cell metabolic fitness and function.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-18", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally identifies and rescues a causal epigenetic mechanism underlying an age-related decline in immune-cell activation.", "background": "Ageing is accompanied by a progressive weakening of adaptive immune responses, which reduces protection against infections and cancer. Effective immunity requires resting immune cells to preserve metabolic competence while remaining ready for rapid activation. Age-related changes in chromatin regulation and cellular metabolism have both been implicated in immune dysfunction. However, the mechanism that establishes this latent metabolic readiness and how ageing disrupts it remained unclear.", "question": "What developmentally established epigenetic mechanism preserves metabolic readiness for rapid immune activation, and how is it disrupted during ageing?", "subject": "Age-related immune dysfunction", "finding": "Tonic IL-7 signaling establishes a GABPα-dependent program that deposits H2A.Z at oxidative-phosphorylation gene promoters in quiescent naïve CD8+ T cells, priming their rapid metabolic and functional activation. Age-related loss of IL-7 signaling reduces H2A.Z occupancy and impairs activation, while IL-7 supplementation or enforced H2A.Z expression rescues the defect.", "key_points": [ "Ageing reduces tonic IL-7 signaling", "GABPα regulates H2A.Z deposition", "H2A.Z primes OXPHOS gene promoters", "Loss of this axis impairs naïve CD8+ T-cell activation", "IL-7 or H2A.Z restoration rescues the age-related defect" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 4, "text": "Polycomb Repressive Complex 2 (PRC2) developmentally deposits H3K27me3 during lymphocyte maturation to stably silence catabolic checkpoints and NAD+-consuming enzymes (such as Cd38, Ddit4/REDD1, and Pten enhancers), thereby preserving intracellular NAD+ pools and mTORC1 sensitivity in resting immune cells. During ageing, erosion of EZH2 expression and unscheduled KDM6B upregulation strip H3K27me3 from these loci, causing basal derepression of metabolic brakes that deplete NAD+ and block anabolic reprogramming upon immune challenge. Mechanism: During thymic and bone marrow maturation, EZH2-containing PRC2 establishes repressive H3K27me3 domains over loci encoding metabolic negative regulators and ectonucleotidases that would otherwise drain bioenergetic cofactors in quiescent cells; age-associated decline in EZH2 and inflammatory stress-induced KDM6B demethylase activity erase this repressive memory, elevating baseline CD38 and REDD1 expression to suppress sirtuin activity, mitochondrial fitness, and TCR-coupled mTORC1 activation. Prediction: ChIP-seq/CUT&Tag in young versus aged resting naive T cells will demonstrate focal loss of H3K27me3 and gain of H3K27ac at Cd38 and Ddit4 loci that correlates with reduced basal NAD+/NADH ratios and blunted mTORC1 phosphorylation upon stimulation, and selective inhibition of KDM6B or genetic ablation of derepressed Cd38/Ddit4 in aged resting cells will restore metabolic readiness.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 3, "text": "During immune cell maturation, replication-independent histone chaperones HIRA and SRCAP deposit the histone variants H3.3 and H2A.Z at the promoters of nuclear-encoded mitochondrial and glycolytic genes to maintain nucleosome-depleted regions and promoter-proximal paused RNA Polymerase II in quiescent cells. Ageing impairs histone chaperone activity and variant turnover, leading to canonical H3.1/H2A nucleosome encroachment that eliminates paused RNA Pol II and delays the transcriptional burst required for metabolic remodeling. Mechanism: Developmental maturation establishes a labile H3.3/H2A.Z dual-variant nucleosome architecture flanking the transcription start sites of bioenergetic genes, lowering the energy barrier for Pol II pause release (via P-TEFb/CDK9) immediately after antigen receptor stimulation; during ageing, declining HIRA/SRCAP expression and proteostatic stress result in replacement of labile H2A.Z/H3.3 nucleosomes with stable canonical nucleosomes that sterically block pre-initiation complex assembly and Pol II pausing. Prediction: PRO-seq and CUT&RUN for H2A.Z, H3.3, and Ser5-phosphorylated RNA Pol II in resting young and aged naive lymphocytes will show selective depletion of H2A.Z/H3.3 and paused Pol II at mitochondrial and glycolytic promoters in aged cells before stimulation, whereas overexpressing HIRA or SRCAP in aged hematopoietic progenitors will restore promoter Pol II pausing and rapid post-activation bioenergetic flux.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "During thymic maturation, pioneer transcription factors (such as TCF1 and FOXO1) establish poised H3K4me1/H3K27ac-marked enhancers at key anabolic and mitochondrial biogenesis loci (including Myc, Tfam, and Slc7a5) that keep resting naive T cells metabolically primed without driving basal hyperactivation. During ageing, chronic inflammatory signaling and homeostatic proliferation downregulate TCF1 and recruit HDACs and KDM1A/LSD1 to decommission these poised enhancers, blunting the rapid glycolytic and oxidative burst upon TCR stimulation. Mechanism: Developmental pioneer factor binding during single-positive thymocyte maturation recruits MLL3/4 (KMT2C/D) and p300/CBP to deposit H3K4me1 and low-level H3K27ac at distal enhancers of metabolic master regulators and nutrient transporters, maintaining open chromatin in quiescent naive lymphocytes; age-associated decline in TCF1 expression and tonic IL-7/inflammatory signaling trigger enhancer decommissioning via histone deacetylation and H3K4me1 demethylation. Prediction: Single-cell ATAC-seq and CUT&Tag for H3K4me1/H3K27ac across thymocytes, young naive T cells, and aged naive T cells will show that metabolic enhancers opened during thymic positive selection selectively lose TCF1 occupancy and H3K4me1 in aged resting T cells prior to antigen encounter, and forced maintenance of TCF1 or MLL3/4 activity in aged naive T cells will restore rapid TCR-induced Myc induction and blastogenesis.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Stage-specific TET1/2/3-mediated active DNA demethylation during lymphocyte development erases 5-methylcytosine at CpG-poor enhancers and intragenic regulatory regions of mTORC1 components and mitochondrial translation factors, creating durable hypomethylated footprints that preserve latent metabolic competence. During ageing, cumulative homeostatic cell divisions coupled with reduced intracellular alpha-ketoglutarate and TET activity allow unopposed DNMT3A/DNMT1-mediated re-methylation of these developmental footprints, epigenetically silencing metabolic induction upon activation. Mechanism: Developmental TCR/BCR checkpoint signaling activates TET dioxygenases to convert 5mC to 5hmC and unmethylated cytosines at metabolic super-enhancers, preventing CpG-methylation-dependent recruitment of MeCP2/MBD corepressor complexes in resting cells; age-related mitochondrial tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle dysfunction lowers the alpha-ketoglutarate-to-succinate ratio, impairing maintenance TET activity and permitting progressive de novo DNA hypermethylation across these bookmarked sites. Prediction: Whole-genome enzymatic methyl-seq (EM-seq) across developmental and ageing trajectories will identify a specific set of thymically demethylated metabolic enhancers that accumulate 5mC and lose 5hmC in aged resting lymphocytes, and transient pharmacological restoration of TET activity (via vitamin C or cell-permeable alpha-ketoglutarate) or CRISPR-dCas9-TET1 targeting in aged resting cells will rescue rapid metabolic reprogramming upon stimulation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 1, "text": "Lymphocyte development establishes pre-formed 3D promoter-enhancer chromatin loops anchored by SATB1 and CTCF/cohesin at rapid-response metabolic gene loci in resting immune cells, enabling immediate transcriptional activation upon antigen receptor engagement. Ageing disrupts this architectural priming through progressive downregulation and oxidative modification of SATB1 and cohesin loading factors, causing loop extrusion failure and uncoupling metabolic promoters from their distal regulatory elements. Mechanism: During late thymocyte and transitional B cell development, SATB1 and cohesin complexes organize insulated topological domains that hold distal enhancers in physical proximity to the promoters of rate-limiting glycolytic, one-carbon, and oxidative phosphorylation genes (such as Hk2, Mthfd2, and Cox5a); age-related decline in SATB1 expression and NIPBL-mediated cohesin turnover dissolves these pre-configured contacts while leaving linear promoter accessibility largely intact. Prediction: High-resolution Promoter Capture Hi-C or Micro-C in resting young versus aged naive T cells will reveal loss of long-range enhancer-promoter loop contacts at metabolic loci despite preserved promoter H3K4me3, and conditional deletion of Satb1 after thymic egress will phenocopy the aged metabolic activation defect without altering baseline survival.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42759510", "pmid": "42759510", "doi": "10.1016/j.neuron.2026.08.022", "title": "A miR-10a-5p-γCaMKII axis links periphery-to-brain signaling to cognitive vulnerability during female midlife.", "journal": "Neuron", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-18", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally establishes a causal molecular mechanism linking female midlife ageing, peripheral-to-brain signaling, cellular senescence, mitochondrial dysfunction, cognitive decline, and Alzheimer’s-related phenotypes.", "background": "Women show a disproportionate increase in cognitive and systemic vulnerability during midlife despite their longer average lifespan. Ageing is accompanied by mitochondrial dysfunction, cellular senescence, and altered communication between peripheral tissues and the brain. Circulating regulatory signals can influence brain physiology, but the mechanisms responsible for the female-biased transition from resilience to vulnerability remain poorly understood. It was also unclear whether this transition is reversible or contributes causally to age-related neurodegenerative phenotypes.", "question": "What molecular mechanism drives peripheral-to-brain signaling that promotes senescence, mitochondrial dysfunction, and cognitive vulnerability during female midlife?", "subject": "Female midlife cognitive vulnerability", "finding": "Epigenetic upregulation of splenic RBMX in middle-aged female mice increases peripheral miR-10a-5p, which contributes to cerebral miR-10a-5p abundance and represses γCaMKII. Manipulating this RBMX–miR-10a-5p–γCaMKII axis alters mitochondrial function, cellular senescence, and memory, while miR-10a-5p inhibition alleviates Alzheimer’s-associated phenotypes in patient-derived neurons and model mice.", "key_points": [ "Female midlife induces epigenetic RBMX upregulation in the spleen", "RBMX promotes increased splenic miR-10a-5p", "Peripheral signaling contributes to brain miR-10a-5p abundance", "miR-10a-5p represses γCaMKII and drives mitochondrial, senescence, and memory phenotypes", "miR-10a-5p inhibition attenuates Alzheimer’s-associated phenotypes" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Accumulation of senescent cells in peripheral reproductive and metabolic tissues during female midlife leads to the systemic shedding of oxidized cell-free mitochondrial DNA (cf-mtDNA) into the circulation. This circulating damage-associated molecular pattern (DAMP) activates cGAS-STING signaling in cerebral microvascular endothelial cells, propagating paracrine senescence and mitochondrial dysfunction across the blood-brain barrier into the brain parenchyma. Mechanism: Loss of estrogen receptor beta (ERbeta)-mediated mitochondrial antioxidant defense (SOD2) in peripheral tissues during midlife promotes VDAC1 oligomerization and extrusion of oxidized mtDNA fragments into plasma. Brain endothelial cells internalize circulating cf-mtDNA, triggering cytosolic cGAS-STING-TBK1-IRF3 activation and a type I interferon/NF-kB-driven endothelial senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP); abluminal secretion of TNF-alpha, IL-6, and CXCL10 into the neurovascular unit activates microglial inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), inhibiting neuronal cytochrome c oxidase and inducing secondary glial and neuronal senescence. Prediction: Systemic administration of a blood-brain barrier-impermeable senolytic, intravascular DNase I treatment to degrade circulating cf-mtDNA, or brain endothelial-specific deletion of Sting1 in midlife female mice will abolish neurovascular interferon signaling, preserve hippocampal oxidative phosphorylation, and rescue cognitive function, distinguishing this pathway from hormone- or exosome-mediated mechanisms.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "The compensatory perimenopausal surge in pituitary follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) acts directly as a circulating endocrine signal on hippocampal and cerebrovascular FSH receptors (FSHR) to induce neuronal mitochondrial Complex I dysfunction and glial senescence. This pituitary-to-brain signaling axis drives the female-biased midlife transition from cognitive resilience to neurodegenerative vulnerability independently of direct estrogen deprivation in the brain. Mechanism: Depletion of ovarian reserve and inhibin B relieves negative feedback on the anterior pituitary, causing a sharp rise in circulating FSH that crosses the blood-brain barrier and binds G-protein-coupled FSHR on hippocampal neurons and microglia. FSHR engagement activates a Gi2- and Akt/NF-kB-dependent signaling cascade that upregulates the transcription factor C/EBPbeta and asparaginyl endopeptidase (AEP), which transcriptionally represses nuclear-encoded mitochondrial electron transport chain subunits (Complex I) and cleaves tau/APP, inducing mitochondrial depolarization, mtDNA release, and p21CIP1-mediated cellular senescence. Prediction: Systemic neutralization of circulating FSH with a monoclonal anti-FSHbeta antibody or brain-specific conditional deletion of Fshr in midlife female mice will prevent hippocampal mitochondrial respiratory failure, clear senescent glial accumulation, and reverse cognitive decline even under clamped low estradiol levels, whereas chronic peripheral FSH infusion into young estradiol-clamped mice will induce brain senescence and cognitive impairment.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Midlife decline in ovarian estrogen derepresses the secretion of small extracellular vesicles (sEVs) enriched in mitochondrial-suppressing microRNAs (such as miR-34a-5p) from peripheral visceral adipose and senescent ovarian stromal tissues into the bloodstream. These circulating sEVs cross the blood-brain barrier and deliver their regulatory RNA cargo to hippocampal neurons and glia, triggering mitochondrial bioenergetic failure, cellular senescence, and reversible cognitive vulnerability. Mechanism: Loss of 17beta-estradiol (E2) signaling via ERalpha in visceral adipocytes and ovarian stroma activates p53-dependent transcription of miR-34a-5p and neutral sphingomyelinase 2 (nSMase2)-dependent exosomal sorting. Following transcytosis across brain microvascular endothelial cells, peripheral sEVs release miR-34a-5p into hippocampal neurons and microglia, where it translationally represses SIRT1 and PGC-1alpha (PPARGC1A), halting mitophagy and mitochondrial biogenesis, elevating mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS), and activating the p16INK4a/p21CIP1 senescence program. Prediction: Peripheral-specific knockdown of Smpd3 (encoding nSMase2) in adipose/ovarian tissue or systemic administration of antagomiR-34a in perimenopausal female mice will restore brain SIRT1/PGC-1alpha expression, reverse hippocampal mitochondrial dysfunction and senescence, and rescue cognitive performance without altering circulating hormone levels, whereas adoptive transfer of midlife female plasma sEVs into young ovary-intact females will phenocopy brain senescence and memory deficits.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Hormonal fluctuations during female midlife destabilize epigenetic maintenance of X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) in peripheral monocytes and age-associated B cells, causing biallelic escape of X-linked immune genes (such as TLR7 and KDM6A). The resulting female-specific surge in circulating pro-senescent cytokines and long-chain ceramides crosses the blood-brain barrier to induce neuronal mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization and neuroinflammatory senescence. Mechanism: Midlife declines in progesterone and estradiol impair XIST lncRNA localization and H3K27me3 heterochromatin maintenance on the inactive X chromosome in peripheral hematopoietic cells. Dosage-driven escape of X-linked TLR7 and the histone demethylase KDM6A amplifies endosomal innate immune sensing and epigenetically derepresses SASP loci and acid sphingomyelinase, flooding the circulation with CCL11, IL-6, and C16:0/C18:0 ceramides that traverse the blood-brain barrier, activate microglial STAT3, and directly disrupt neuronal mitochondrial cristae architecture and oxidative phosphorylation. Prediction: Hematopoietic-specific heterozygous deletion of Tlr7 or Kdm6a (restoring monoallelic expression dosage) or bone marrow transplantation from young donors into midlife female mice will prevent the systemic surge in SASP cytokines and ceramides, preserve brain mitochondrial respiration, prevent hippocampal senescence, and eliminate the female-biased midlife cognitive decline.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Midlife estrogen withdrawal relieves transcriptional repression of hepatic and myeloid tryptophan-degrading enzymes (IDO1 and TDO2), elevating circulating L-kynurenine that crosses the blood-brain barrier and is metabolized into neurotoxic quinolinic acid. This peripheral-to-central metabolic shift depletes brain NAD+ pools, inactivating mitochondrial SIRT3 and driving bioenergetic collapse, cellular senescence, and cognitive vulnerability. Mechanism: Declining peripheral 17beta-estradiol and rising systemic low-grade inflammation in midlife females upregulate hepatic TDO2 and monocyte IDO1, shunting systemic tryptophan into circulating L-kynurenine. L-kynurenine enters the brain via the endothelial large neutral amino acid transporter LAT1 (SLC7A5) and is converted by microglial kynurenine 3-monooxygenase (KMO) into 3-hydroxykynurenine and quinolinic acid, which generate excitotoxic ROS, hyperactivate PARP1, and exhaust intracellular NAD+; consequent loss of mitochondrial NAD+-dependent SIRT3 deacetylase activity causes hyperacetylation and failure of electron transport chain complexes and SOD2, triggering mtROS-driven p16INK4a senescence in astrocytes and neurons. Prediction: Peripheral-restricted pharmacological inhibition of IDO1/TDO2 or brain endothelial-specific deletion of Slc7a5 in midlife female mice will normalize brain kynurenine metabolites, restore hippocampal NAD+ levels and mitochondrial SIRT3 activity, reduce brain senescence markers, and reverse cognitive deficits without requiring central nervous system drug penetration.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42775695", "pmid": "42775695", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70720", "title": "Mitochondrial Transplantation Rejuvenates Aging Heart by Restoring Mitophagy Flux via the HIF-3α-BNIP3 Axis.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-23", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper reports an experimentally supported causal mechanism for age-related cardiac decline and shows how an intervention reverses it.", "background": "Cardiac function progressively deteriorates with age, increasing susceptibility to heart failure and other cardiovascular disorders. Defective mitochondrial quality control is considered an important contributor to this decline. Selective removal of damaged mitochondria must remain properly balanced, because disruption at multiple stages of the process can impair cellular homeostasis. The upstream causes of this age-associated defect and whether it can be therapeutically reversed were not well established.", "question": "What causes defective mitochondrial quality-control flux in the aging heart, and how can restoring mitochondrial homeostasis reverse cardiac aging?", "subject": "Age-related cardiac mitophagy", "finding": "Age-associated upregulation of HIF-3α drives excessive BNIP3 expression in senescent cardiomyocytes, causing mitophagy flux congestion and cardiac aging. Mitochondrial transplantation restores intracellular ATP homeostasis, restrains pathological HIF-3α–BNIP3 signaling, normalizes mitophagy flux, and rejuvenates the aging heart.", "key_points": [ "HIF-3α is aberrantly elevated with cardiac aging", "HIF-3α directly promotes excessive BNIP3 expression", "Overactive HIF-3α–BNIP3 signaling causes mitophagy flux congestion", "Mitochondrial transplantation restores ATP homeostasis and suppresses the axis", "Normalized mitophagy flux reverses age-related cardiac dysfunction" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 4, "text": "Defective mitochondrial quality-control flux in the aging heart arises from a breakdown in transcellular mitophagy, wherein aged cardiomyocytes extrude damaged mitochondria in LC3+ exophers that fail to be cleared by cardiac-resident macrophages due to ADAM17-mediated Mertk receptor shedding and macrophage senescence. Rejuvenating resident macrophage phagocytic capacity via Mertk preservation clears interstitial mitochondrial debris, suppresses sterile myocardial inflammation, and reverses age-related cardiac fibrosis and diastolic stiffening. Mechanism: To manage high metabolic load with limited cell-autonomous lysosomal space, cardiomyocytes package damaged mitochondria into LC3-decorated vesicular exophers and eject them into the myocardial interstitium for engulfment by Mertk+Tim4+ resident macrophages. During aging, replacement of resident macrophages by pro-inflammatory CCR2+ monocyte-derived macrophages and proteolytic cleavage of the phagocytic receptor Mertk block exopher uptake, causing extruded mitochondria to rupture extracellularly, release oxidized mtDNA and cardiolipin, and drive fibrotic remodeling. Prediction: Aged hearts will accumulate extracellular, un-engulfed mitochondria-containing exophers and soluble Mertk ectodomains in the interstitium alongside normal or compensatory cardiomyocyte exopher release; macrophage-specific expression of cleavage-resistant Mertk will clear extracellular mitochondrial debris, secondarily normalize intra-cardiomyocyte mitochondrial network health, and reverse ventricular fibrosis and diastolic dysfunction.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Chronic senescence-associated stress and CD38-driven NAD+ depletion in the aging heart impair the initiation of ubiquitin-dependent mitophagy via cytosolic p53 sequestration of Parkin and loss of SIRT1/SIRT3-mediated deacetylation of mitochondrial quality-control regulators. Restoring cellular NAD+ pools or disrupting the cytosolic p53-Parkin interaction re-establishes selective ubiquitin priming of depolarized mitochondria and reverses age-associated bioenergetic decline. Mechanism: Accumulation of cytosolic p53 in aged cardiomyocytes results in direct physical binding to the RING0 domain of Parkin, blocking its translocation to PINK1-primed depolarized outer mitochondrial membranes. Concurrently, age-related NAD+ depletion reduces SIRT1 and SIRT3 deacetylase activity, leading to hyperacetylation of FOXO3a, PGC-1alpha, and mitochondrial matrix proteins, which blunts PINK1-Parkin mitophagy initiation while uncoupling organelle removal from compensatory mitochondrial biogenesis. Prediction: Aged myocardium will exhibit blunted mitochondrial Parkin translocation and reduced phospho-Ser65-ubiquitin coating on depolarized mitochondria despite elevated mitochondrial reactive oxygen species; pharmacological NAD+ repletion or peptide disruption of the p53-Parkin complex will restore mitochondrial phospho-ubiquitin accumulation, normalize respiratory chain activity, and improve cardiac reserve ahead of any changes in bulk lysosomal mass.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Age-related dysregulation of mitochondrial fission-fusion machinery—specifically impaired DRP1-mediated asymmetric segregation and altered MFN2 phosphorylation—prevents the physical isolation of damaged mitochondrial subdomains into engulfable fragments, arresting both canonical LC3-dependent and alternative ULK1-Rab9-dependent mitophagy flux. Normalizing DRP1 activation or ULK1-Rab9 complex assembly restores piecemeal mitochondrial clearance and reverses cardiomyocyte contractile and calcium-handling defects. Mechanism: Selective mitophagy requires AMPK/ULK1- and actin-dependent DRP1 recruitment to pinch off depolarized, damaged mitochondrial poles from the healthy reticulum, alongside PINK1-mediated MFN2 phosphorylation to coordinate Parkin recruitment and ER-mitochondria untethering. In aged hearts, altered kinase/phosphatase balance prevents DRP1 translocation and assembly of the trans-Golgi ULK1-Rab9-RIP1-DRP1 complex, generating enlarged, dysmorphic megamitochondria that sterically exceed autophagosomal engulfment capacity. Prediction: High-resolution imaging of aged cardiomyocytes will reveal enlarged, depolarized mitochondria lacking DRP1 constriction rings and escaping LC3 or Rab9 membrane encapsulation; selective restoration of DRP1 fission activity or ULK1-Rab9 activation will reduce mitochondrial volume per organelle, restore mitophagosome engulfment without altering lysosomal pH or total Parkin levels, and rescue sarcomeric relaxation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Age-associated hyperactivation of cardiac mTORC1 and upregulation of the Beclin-1 inhibitor Rubicon, combined with impaired TFEB nuclear translocation, block late-stage mitophagosome-lysosome fusion and lysosomal acidification in cardiomyocytes, stalling mitophagy flux mid-stream. Therapeutically restoring lysosomal biogenesis and autolysosomal fusion clears accumulated mitophagosomal intermediates, suppresses cytosolic mtDNA sensing, and reverses age-related diastolic and systolic dysfunction. Mechanism: In aged cardiomyocytes, chronic nutrient and stress signaling elevates mTORC1 activity and Rubicon expression, which inhibits the UVRAG-Vps34 complex and retains TFEB in the cytosol while diminishing v-ATPase-dependent lysosomal acidification. Because early mitochondrial damage continues to trigger priming and autophagosomal engulfment against a downstream bottleneck in Rab7/SNARE-mediated lysosomal fusion and proteolysis, un-degraded mitophagosomes accumulate, leak oxidized mtDNA into the cytosol, and activate cGAS-STING and NLRP3 inflammatory signaling. Prediction: Dual-fluorescent mitophagy reporter mice (such as mt-Keima or mito-QC) will show an increased ratio of neutral-pH mitophagosomes to acidic mitolysosomes in aged hearts rather than a lack of autophagosomal sequestration; furthermore, stimulating early mitophagy initiation alone will exacerbate cardiomyocyte toxicity, whereas Rubicon depletion or TFEB activation will restore acidic mitolysosome formation and rescue ventricular function.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Pathological uncoupling between outer mitochondrial membrane receptor-mediated mitophagy (via FUNDC1 inactivation or maladaptive BNIP3/NIX activation) and AMPK-PGC-1alpha-driven mitochondrial biogenesis disrupts steady-state mitochondrial turnover in the aging heart. Co-targeting mitophagy receptor phosphorylation states alongside AMPK-PGC-1alpha activation re-balances the rates of organelle degradation and synthesis, reversing cardiac bioenergetic insufficiency. Mechanism: In aged cardiomyocytes, elevated CK2 and Src kinase activities phosphorylate FUNDC1 at Ser13 and Tyr18, sterically inhibiting its LC3-interacting region and suppressing basal receptor-mediated mitophagy, while chronic oxidative stress can trigger aberrant BNIP3/NIX dimerization and mitochondrial permeability transition pore opening. Because downstream AMPK-PGC-1alpha-NRF1/TFAM transcriptional signaling is concurrently depressed, the heart cannot coordinate degradative flux with de novo synthesis of respiratory complexes, leading to progressive attrition of functional mitochondrial mass. Prediction: Aged myocardium will display elevated phosphorylated (inactive) FUNDC1 alongside depressed PGC-1alpha/TFAM transcriptional output; uncompensated overexpression of BNIP3/NIX will cause mitochondrial depletion and heart failure, whereas combining FUNDC1 dephosphorylation (or Urolithin A treatment) with AMPK/PGC-1alpha activation will simultaneously increase mitophagic turnover and newly synthesized mtDNA copy number, restoring myocardial ATP/phosphocreatine ratios.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42775698", "pmid": "42775698", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70725", "title": "Transplantation of Elderly Human Gut Microbiota Into Pigs Reprograms Intestinal Barrier Function, Plasma Metabolome, and Gut Mucosal Transcriptomic Landscape.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-23", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally demonstrates that age-associated differences in human gut microbiota can causally drive intestinal barrier decline and identifies metabolite-linked effects that help explain this mechanism.", "background": "Intestinal structure and barrier integrity commonly deteriorate with age, contributing to altered nutrient handling, inflammation, and systemic metabolic dysfunction. Ageing is also accompanied by changes in circulating metabolites and intestinal gene expression. Observational studies have linked these features, but such associations cannot establish whether age-related changes in the intestinal ecosystem actively cause host dysfunction. The mechanisms connecting donor age-associated biological states to impaired intestinal physiology therefore remained unclear.", "question": "Can age-associated differences in the human gut microbial community causally reprogram intestinal barrier function, systemic metabolism, and mucosal gene expression, and what mediators contribute to these effects?", "subject": "Microbiota-driven intestinal ageing", "finding": "Transplanting elderly-human gut microbiota into pigs caused reduced ileal villus height, loss of tight-junction proteins, altered plasma metabolites, and coordinated suppression of seven ileal mucosal antiviral-response hub genes compared with young-donor microbiota. The elderly-donor-associated metabolic shift was functionally linked to barrier impairment: Tyr-Phe increased epithelial electrical resistance, whereas prostaglandin E3 decreased it in IPEC-1 cells.", "key_points": [ "Elderly-donor microbiota causally impaired intestinal architecture and tight-junction integrity", "Elderly-donor transplantation reshaped the plasma metabolome", "Tyr-Phe strengthened and prostaglandin E3 weakened epithelial barrier function experimentally", "Seven mucosal hub genes were consistently downregulated after elderly-donor transplantation", "Blautia obeum enrichment was associated with the elderly-donor metabolic and barrier phenotype" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "An age-associated decline in microbial conversion of dietary tryptophan into indole derivatives causally drives intestinal architectural deterioration, mucosal transcriptional remodeling, and low-grade systemic metabolic inflammation. Microbiota from older human donors fails to generate sufficient aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) ligands, compromising epithelial renewal and mucosal immune homeostasis. Mechanism: Depletion of microbiota-derived indoles (such as indole-3-propionic acid and indole-3-aldehyde) reduces AhR activation in intestinal epithelial cells and lamina propria innate lymphoid cells, blunting IL-22 production, impairing crypt stem cell regeneration and tight junction assembly, and permitting translocation of luminal inflammatory mediators into the circulation. Prediction: Gnotobiotic hosts receiving aged human microbiota will show reduced luminal and circulating indole metabolites alongside downregulated mucosal AhR target genes (such as Cyp1a1 and Il22) and blunted epithelial renewal, whereas exogenous administration of indole-3-propionic acid or an AhR agonist will selectively rescue intestinal structure, barrier integrity, and metabolic homeostasis.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Donor age-related alterations in microbial bile acid biotransformation causally reprogram ileal and colonic mucosal transcription, weaken epithelial barrier structure, and disrupt systemic lipid and glucose metabolism. Transfer of an aged human gut microbial community shifts the luminal and circulating ratio of primary to secondary and unconjugated to conjugated bile acids, perturbing host nuclear and membrane bile acid receptor signaling. Mechanism: Age-associated changes in microbial bile salt hydrolase and 7-alpha-dehydroxylase activities alter the abundance of specific secondary bile acid species (such as deoxycholic and lithocholic acid derivatives), which dysregulates enterocyte Farnesoid X Receptor (FXR) and TGR5 signaling, suppresses ileal FGF15/19 endocrine output, downregulates mucosal antimicrobial and structural genes, and alters hepatic metabolic pathways. Prediction: Recipients of aged human microbiota will display a distinct cecal and serum bile acid signature paired with suppressed ileal Fgf15 and FXR target gene expression, and pharmacological FXR/TGR5 modulation or targeted restoration of bile-acid-converting bacteria will normalize mucosal gene expression, barrier integrity, and systemic lipid profiles.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "Overgrowth of mucin-degrading and Gram-negative pathobionts in the aged human microbiome causally erodes the intestinal mucus layer and triggers innate immune signaling that reprograms enterocyte gene expression and systemic metabolism. Transplanting aged donor communities increases epithelial exposure to microbial-associated molecular patterns, driving chronic mucosal inflammation and barrier leakiness. Mechanism: Enhanced microbial foraging of mucin glycans thins the protective mucus barrier and increases contact between luminal lipopolysaccharide (LPS) or flagellin and epithelial Toll-like receptors (TLR4/TLR5), activating MyD88/NF-kB signaling and myosin light chain kinase (MLCK)-mediated tight junction opening while suppressing absorptive nutrient transporter expression and promoting systemic endotoxemia. Prediction: Mice colonized with aged human donor microbiota will exhibit a thinner colonic mucus layer, elevated plasma LPS-binding protein, and reciprocal upregulation of mucosal inflammatory transcripts vs. downregulation of nutrient-handling genes, and genetic or pharmacological inhibition of epithelial TLR4 or MLCK will prevent barrier dysfunction and systemic metabolic impairment despite persistent colonization by the aged microbiota.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Age-associated depletion of butyrate-producing commensals in the human gut microbiome causally impairs intestinal barrier integrity, reprograms mucosal gene expression, and induces systemic metabolic dysfunction in colonized hosts. Specifically, transplanting aged human donor microbiota into germ-free recipients reduces luminal short-chain fatty acid availability, depriving enterocytes of their primary oxidative fuel and epigenetic regulators. Mechanism: Reduced microbial production of butyrate diminishes colonocyte mitochondrial beta-oxidation and attenuates histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibition and GPR43/GPR109A signaling, leading to transcriptional downregulation of tight junction proteins (such as claudins, occludin, and ZO-1) and mucin synthesis, increased paracellular permeability, and impaired host glucose and lipid homeostasis. Prediction: Germ-free mice colonized with aged human donor microbiota will exhibit lower cecal butyrate concentrations, reduced mucosal expression of oxidative phosphorylation and tight junction gene networks, and increased gut permeability compared to young-donor recipients, and oral butyrate supplementation or co-colonization with defined butyrate-producing clostridial strains will restore barrier function and systemic insulin sensitivity without requiring wholesale replacement of the aged community.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 4, "text": "A shift from saccharolytic to proteolytic fermentation coupled with reduced polyamine biosynthesis in the aged human gut microbiome generates circulating and luminal metabolites that directly impair epithelial autophagy, mitochondrial homeostasis, and host metabolic health. These donor-age-associated microbial metabolite profiles act as causal mediators sufficient to induce intestinal and systemic dysfunction even in the absence of live bacterial invasion. Mechanism: Elevated microbial production of proteolytic catabolites (such as p-cresol, indoxyl sulfate, and trimethylamine N-oxide) alongside depletion of microbial spermidine reduces eIF5A hypusination and autophagic flux in intestinal epithelial cells, inducing oxidative stress, villus and crypt structural atrophy, transcriptional reprogramming of metabolic pathways, and systemic insulin resistance. Prediction: Transfer of sterile fecal filtrates or circulating metabolite fractions derived from aged-microbiota recipients will partially recapitulate the mucosal transcriptional shifts and barrier defects seen with live fecal microbiota transplantation, and spermidine supplementation or dietary restriction of proteolytic substrates in colonized hosts will restore epithelial autophagy, intestinal morphology, and systemic metabolic function.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42786310", "pmid": "42786310", "doi": "10.1038/s43587-026-01220-0", "title": "Multi-modality profiling identifies Neisseria flavescens as a central geroprotective oral commensal in humans.", "journal": "Nat Aging", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-24", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally demonstrates that a specific commensal microorganism causally improves ageing-related outcomes, including lifespan and healthspan, across animal models.", "background": "Ageing involves coordinated deterioration across metabolic, immune and organ systems, accompanied by changes in host-associated microbial communities. Microbiome composition correlates with biological age and age-related physiological states, but such associations do not establish whether individual microorganisms can modify the ageing process. Some microbial interventions alter host metabolism and longevity in experimental models, although causal effects often depend on organism viability, microbial products and host context. It therefore remained unclear whether systematic integration of diverse human biological measurements could identify a microorganism with experimentally reproducible geroprotective activity.", "question": "Can a commensal microorganism predicted from integrated human ageing profiles causally extend lifespan and healthspan and shift age-associated molecular and microbial states toward younger configurations?", "subject": "Microbial geroprotection", "finding": "Neisseria flavescens was identified as a candidate geroprotective commensal and experimentally shown to extend lifespan and healthspan in Caenorhabditis elegans when administered live. In aged mice, heat-killed N. flavescens shifted the serum metabolome, liver transcriptome and gut microbiome toward younger states, while isolated strains were confirmed to produce predicted beneficial metabolites.", "key_points": [ "Neisseria flavescens is the causal candidate", "Live bacteria extend C. elegans lifespan and healthspan", "Heat-killed bacteria rejuvenate multiple ageing-associated profiles in mice", "Isolated strains produce beneficial metabolites predicted by multi-modality analysis" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "A commensal microorganism predicted from integrated human multi-omic ageing profiles causally extends lifespan and healthspan by secreting bioactive small-molecule metabolites that directly reprogram host epigenetic and transcriptional networks toward youthful configurations. Mechanism: Active microbial metabolism in the gut lumen converts dietary and host substrates into circulating geroprotective metabolites (such as indole derivatives, secondary bile acids, or short-chain fatty acids) that engage host nuclear receptors (e.g., AhR, FXR) and inhibit histone deacetylases, thereby restoring youthful chromatin accessibility, suppressing pro-inflammatory NF-kB signaling, and upregulating oxidative phosphorylation and autophagy across peripheral organs. Prediction: Cell-free conditioned media or purified signature metabolites from the predicted microorganism will recapitulate lifespan extension and tissue-wide transcriptomic rejuvenation in aged hosts without requiring live bacterial colonization, whereas genetic knockout of the microbial biosynthetic pathway will abolish the geroprotective effect despite successful colonization.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "A commensal microorganism identified from integrated human physiological and molecular ageing profiles causally extends healthspan and lifespan by stimulating gut-brain neuroendocrine signaling, thereby resetting central autonomic and circadian regulation of peripheral tissue ageing. Mechanism: Colonization by the microbe stimulates intestinal enteroendocrine and enterochromaffin cells to release gut peptides (such as GLP-1 and PYY) and neurotransmitter precursors that activate vagal afferent pathways and hypothalamic nuclei, restoring youthful neuroendocrine pulsatility, sympathetic tone in metabolic tissues, and peripheral circadian transcriptional rhythms. Prediction: Selective subdiaphragmatic vagotomy or pharmacological blockade of enteroendocrine peptide receptors in aged hosts will abrogate the microbe-induced improvements in neuromuscular healthspan, metabolic homeostasis, and peripheral organ transcriptomic age, even though luminal colonization and local microbiome remodeling remain intact.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "A commensal microorganism prioritized from human ageing profiles acts as an ecological keystone species that causally extends host longevity and rejuvenates systemic molecular states indirectly by remodeling the senescent gut microbial community and competitively excluding pro-ageing pathobionts. Mechanism: Live colonization by the predicted commensal alters luminal niche conditions, cross-feeds beneficial butyrate-producing symbionts, and outcompetes age-enriched proteolytic and proinflammatory pathobionts, thereby reducing the systemic burden of microbiota-derived uremic and pro-senescent toxins such as p-cresol, trimethylamine N-oxide, and hydrogen sulfide. Prediction: The lifespan extension and host molecular rejuvenation induced by the microorganism will strictly require live, replicating bacteria in hosts harboring a complex aged microbiome and will fail to occur when administered to germ-free animals or gnotobiotic hosts lacking the target resident microbial community.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 1, "text": "A human youth-associated commensal identified through integrated immunometabolic and microbiome profiling causally extends healthspan and longevity primarily by reinforcing intestinal mucosal barrier integrity via structural surface components, thereby halting systemic endotoxemia and reversing age-associated chronic inflammation. Mechanism: Conserved microbial outer membrane proteins or capsular polysaccharides interact directly with pattern recognition receptors (such as TLR2) on intestinal epithelial and goblet cells to upregulate tight-junction assembly and mucin production, preventing the translocation of luminal lipopolysaccharides and pro-inflammatory microbial products into systemic circulation and reversing age-related myeloid skewing. Prediction: Pasteurized (heat-inactivated) intact bacteria or purified outer membrane fractions will restore gut barrier impermeability, lower circulating inflammatory cytokines, and shift splenic and hepatic immune transcriptomes toward younger states to a degree comparable to live bacteria, even in the absence of active microbial metabolism.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "A commensal microbe predicted from integrated human biological age signatures causally extends lifespan across evolutionarily conserved model systems by directly modulating host intracellular nutrient-sensing and mitochondrial quality-control pathways. Mechanism: The microorganism alters luminal macronutrient and amino acid bioavailability or delivers conserved metabolic cofactors (such as folate/methionine cycle intermediates or nitric oxide) that inhibit host mTORC1 and insulin/IGF-1 signaling while activating AMPK, FOXO/DAF-16, and mitophagy, shifting systemic metabolism toward a caloric-restriction-like youthful state. Prediction: Administration of the microorganism will fail to extend lifespan or rejuvenate molecular profiles in hosts carrying loss-of-function mutations in AMPK or FOXO/DAF-16 or constitutive mTORC1 activation, and wild-type hosts will exhibit rapid activation of mitochondrial unfolded protein response and autophagic flux prior to community-wide microbiome shifts.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42805954", "pmid": "42805954", "doi": "10.1038/s41467-026-77050-w", "title": "ALKBH5-mediated microglia-neuron crosstalk inhibits sympathetic innervation and adipocyte browning in male mice.", "journal": "Nat Commun", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-27", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally identifies a causal mechanism that contributes to age-related loss of thermogenic adipocytes and reduced metabolic activity in male mice.", "background": "Ageing is associated with declining thermogenic capacity in adipose tissue, impaired energy expenditure, and increased susceptibility to metabolic dysfunction. Subcutaneous white adipose tissue can acquire heat-producing adipocytes in response to environmental stimuli, but this capacity diminishes with age. Communication between the nervous system and adipose tissue helps regulate this adaptive response. The mechanisms responsible for its age-related deterioration remained incompletely understood.", "question": "What causal mechanism contributes to the age-related decline of thermogenic adipocytes in subcutaneous white adipose tissue?", "subject": "Age-related adipocyte browning decline", "finding": "Microglial ALKBH5 suppresses Ntf5 expression by demethylating Ntf5 mRNA, thereby limiting activation of PVH TrkB-positive neurons, sympathetic innervation of subcutaneous white adipose tissue, and adipocyte browning. Microglia-specific ALKBH5 knockout preserved brown adipocytes and improved metabolic activity during ageing in male mice.", "key_points": [ "Microglial ALKBH5 restrains adipocyte browning", "ALKBH5 knockout increases Ntf5 mRNA m6A methylation and Ntf5 expression", "Ntf5 activates PVH TrkB-positive neurons and downstream sympathetic innervation", "Microglia-specific ALKBH5 loss prevents age-related brown adipocyte decline", "The causal findings were demonstrated in male mice" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Chronic elevation of basal sympathetic tone during ageing induces post-synaptic catecholamine resistance in scWAT adipocytes and beige progenitors via desensitization and transcriptional repression of beta-3-adrenergic receptors (ADRB3) and stabilization of fibrogenic transcriptional programs. This renders the adipose parenchyma refractory to acute neuro-sympathetic bursts during environmental challenges. Mechanism: Sustained, low-grade noradrenergic stimulation in aged scWAT promotes G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 (GRK2)-mediated ADRB3 phosphorylation and internalization, elevates phosphodiesterase (PDE4) activity to degrade cAMP, and promotes loss of the corepressors/coactivators (such as PRDM16) in PDGFRalpha+ progenitors, diverting them from beige adipogenesis toward myofibroblastic differentiation. Prediction: Direct administration of exogenous norepinephrine or beta-3-adrenergic agonists will fail to induce cAMP accumulation, PKA phosphorylation, or UCP1 expression in aged scWAT explants despite intact nerve fibres, whereas bypassing the receptor via direct adenylyl cyclase activation (forskolin) or genetic inhibition of GRK2 in adipocytes will restore thermogenic gene induction.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Ageing impairs scWAT beiging through the accumulation and NLRP3 inflammasome-dependent activation of sympathetic neuron-associated macrophages (SAMs) that locally scavenge and degrade nerve-released norepinephrine. Consequently, even when sympathetic nerves fire in response to environmental stimuli, synaptic norepinephrine bioavailability is depleted before it can activate adipocyte beta-adrenergic receptors. Mechanism: Age-related sterile inflammation activates the NLRP3 inflammasome and GDF3 signalling in periaxonal macrophages, upregulating the norepinephrine transporter (SLC6A2/NET) and monoamine oxidase A (MAOA), which import and oxidatively deaminate norepinephrine within the neuro-adipose microenvironment. Prediction: Aged scWAT will exhibit preserved sympathetic nerve firing rates upon cold exposure but depressed interstitial norepinephrine levels alongside elevated macrophage MAOA expression; pharmacological MAOA inhibition or myeloid-specific deletion of Maoa or Nlrp3 will restore interstitial norepinephrine levels and rescue cold-induced thermogenesis without altering total nerve fibre density.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "Ageing disrupts a cooperative neuro-immune-cholinergic relay in scWAT wherein resident immune cells fail to produce acetylcholine and neurotrophic cytokines in response to sympathetic activation, eliminating a crucial paracrine amplification loop required for beige adipocyte recruitment. Mechanism: Age-related involution of the adipose type 2 immune niche and loss of choline acetyltransferase-expressing (ChAT+) lymphoid/myeloid cells and gamma-delta T cells reduces local secretion of acetylcholine and IL-17F/TGF-beta, depriving subcutaneous adipocytes of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor alpha-2 (CHRNA2) co-stimulation and stromal cells of immunogenic cues that maintain sympathetic innervation and PKA-dependent thermogenic programming. Prediction: Acetylcholine levels and ChAT+ immune cell abundance in scWAT will fail to rise upon cold exposure in aged animals, and adoptive transfer of young ChAT+ immune cells or pharmacological activation of adipocyte CHRNA2 alongside beta-adrenergic stimulation will synergistically rescue thermogenic capacity in aged scWAT where beta-adrenergic stimulation alone is insufficient.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 3, "text": "Age-induced cellular senescence in adipose-resident Schwann cells disrupts axonal metabolic support and establishes a local senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) that impairs both sympathetic neurotransmission and adjacent beige progenitor differentiation. The deterioration of this glial scaffold destabilizes neuro-adipose communication during ageing. Mechanism: Accumulation of DNA damage and mitochondrial dysfunction in SOX10+/MPZ+ periaxonal Schwann cells within aged scWAT triggers p16INK4a/p21CIP1-mediated senescence, reducing glial-derived neurotrophic support, impairing axonal bioenergetics and vesicular neurotransmitter release, and secreting pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-6, TGF-beta, activin A) that directly block PRDM16-driven beige adipogenesis. Prediction: Single-cell transcriptomics and spatial imaging of aged scWAT will identify enriched p16INK4a+ senescent Schwann cells ensheathing dystrophic sympathetic axons, and selective senolysis or Schwann cell-specific suppression of SASP signalling will restore evoked axonal norepinephrine release and beige adipocyte recruitment more effectively than targeting adipocytes alone.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 0, "text": "Age-related decline in subcutaneous white adipose tissue (scWAT) thermogenesis is driven by the loss of adipocyte- and stromal-derived neurotrophic factors (such as NGF, BDNF, and S100B) alongside increased repulsive axon guidance cues (such as SEMA3A), causing structural retraction of sympathetic nerve arborizations. Without dense peri-adipocyte sympathetic innervation, environmental cold stimuli fail to deliver sufficient local norepinephrine to recruit beige adipocytes. Mechanism: Transcriptional and epigenetic remodelling of ageing adipocytes and PDGFRalpha+ stromal progenitors downregulates retrograde neurotrophic signals (NGF/TrkA and CLSTN3B-S100B axes) while upregulating semaphorin-neuropilin repulsive signalling, leading to axonal die-back of tyrosine hydroxylase-positive (TH+) sympathetic fibres and physical uncoupling of the neuro-adipose junction. Prediction: 3D whole-mount immunolabelling of aged scWAT will reveal a marked reduction in TH+ sympathetic nerve fibre density and branching prior to losing intrinsic adipocyte responsiveness to exogenous beta-3-adrenergic agonists (CL316,243), and viral restoration of NGF or S100B in aged scWAT will regenerate axonal arbors and restore cold-induced UCP1+ beige adipocyte formation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42810392", "pmid": "42810392", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70721", "title": "Direct Pharmacological Activation of AMPK Extends Lifespan in Yeast, Worms and Flies.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-29", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal, cross-species effect of directly activating a defined metabolic regulator on lifespan, with supporting evidence for mammalian relevance.", "background": "Ageing is strongly influenced by conserved systems that coordinate cellular metabolism with nutrient and energy availability. Genetic studies have shown that altering metabolic regulation can affect lifespan in several model organisms. Pharmacological studies, however, often use compounds with multiple targets, making it difficult to attribute longevity effects to a specific mechanism. It therefore remained unclear whether selective engagement of a single conserved metabolic target could directly produce longevity benefits across species.", "question": "Can direct pharmacological activation of a conserved metabolic target extend lifespan across evolutionarily diverse organisms and induce longevity-associated changes in mammals?", "subject": "Direct metabolic target activation", "finding": "Direct pharmacological activation of AMPK with compound 991 extends lifespan in Drosophila melanogaster, Caenorhabditis elegans, and Schizosaccharomyces pombe. In mice, 991 induces a proteomic profile associated with pro-longevity biology, supporting the translational potential of AMPK activation.", "key_points": [ "Direct AMPK activation by compound 991", "Lifespan extension in yeast, worms, and flies", "Conserved causal longevity effect across species", "Pro-longevity proteomic response in mice" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 3, "text": "Direct allosteric activation of the rate-limiting NAD+ salvage enzyme nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (NAMPT, and functional invertebrate salvage homologs) restores youthful cellular NAD+/NADH redox balance, extending lifespan across model organisms and reversing age-related metabolic and tissue dysfunction in mammals. Accelerating enzymatic NAD+ recycling overcomes the systemic NAD+ exhaustion caused by age-associated CD38 and PARP hyperactivation. Mechanism: Small-molecule activators bind within the rear channel of the NAMPT homodimer active site to increase affinity for nicotinamide and phosphoribosyl pyrophosphate (PRPP) while suppressing unproductive ATP hydrolysis. The resulting surge in intracellular NAD+ biosynthesis simultaneously depletes inhibitory nicotinamide and provides the obligatory cosubstrate required to sustain nuclear DNA repair (PARP1), mitochondrial sirtuin activity (SIRT3-mediated deacetylation of oxidative enzymes), and circadian metabolic oscillations (CLOCK/BMAL1-SIRT1 feedback loop). Prediction: Pharmacological activation of the rate-limiting NAD+ salvage enzyme elevates tissue NAD+ turnover, extends lifespan in invertebrate models, and restores skeletal muscle endurance, hepatic insulin sensitivity, and mitochondrial respiration in aged mice, whereas co-administration of a catalytic-site inhibitor or tissue-specific conditional knockout of Nampt abrogates all physiological and longevity benefits.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Direct pharmacological activation of the conserved amino acid deficiency sensor kinase GCN2 (General Control Nonderepressible 2) under nutrient-replete conditions mimics dietary amino acid restriction to extend lifespan in invertebrates and induce protective systemic metabolic remodeling in mammals. Selective engagement of the GCN2 kinase domain is sufficient to trigger the longevity-promoting arm of the integrated stress response without actual nutrient deprivation. Mechanism: Binding of a selective small-molecule activator to the GCN2 kinase domain stabilizes its active dimer conformation, inducing autophosphorylation and selective phosphorylation of eukaryotic initiation factor 2 alpha (eIF2alpha) at Ser51 independently of uncharged tRNA accumulation. This attenuates energetically costly global cap-dependent protein synthesis while selectively promoting upstream open reading frame (uORF)-mediated translation of ATF4, which upregulates cytoprotective transsulfuration enzymes, autophagy genes, and the systemic metabolic hormone FGF21 in mammals. Prediction: Direct GCN2 activation extends lifespan in yeast, C. elegans, and Drosophila fed ad libitum and increases circulating FGF21, energy expenditure, brown adipose thermogenesis, and insulin sensitivity in mice on a standard diet, whereas gcn-2/Gcn2-null mutants or non-phosphorylatable eIF2alpha-S51A knock-in animals exhibit no translational attenuation, no FGF21 induction, and no lifespan extension upon drug treatment.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Direct small-molecule activation of the conserved bHLH-leucine zipper transcription factor TFEB (HLH-30 in C. elegans, Mitf in Drosophila) is sufficient to extend lifespan in invertebrates and reverse age-associated proteostatic and lipid-metabolic decline in mammals independently of upstream mTORC1 inhibition. Pharmacologically uncoupling TFEB nuclear translocation from nutrient-sensing kinase cascades directly sustains degradative organelle capacity during ageing. Mechanism: Direct binding of a small-molecule agonist to TFEB disrupts its inhibitory interaction with cytosolic 14-3-3 chaperones and masks regulatory serine phosphorylation sites, triggering rapid nuclear translocation without perturbing mTORC1 activity toward anabolic substrates. Nuclear TFEB/HLH-30 binds Coordinated Lysosomal Expression and Regulation (CLEAR) promoter elements to transcriptionally upregulate v-ATPase subunits, lysosomal hydrolases, autophagosome biogenesis machinery, and lipid-catabolic enzymes (lipophagy and beta-oxidation regulators). Prediction: A direct TFEB activator extends lifespan in C. elegans and Drosophila and clears hepatic lipid accumulation, lipofuscin, and insoluble protein aggregates in aged mice while leaving mTORC1 phosphorylation of S6K1 and 4E-BP1 intact, whereas genetic deletion of hlh-30, Mitf, or Tfeb completely eliminates both the survival advantage and the induction of autophagic-lysosomal flux.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Direct allosteric activation of the conserved energy sensor AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) is sufficient to extend lifespan across evolutionarily diverse invertebrates and induce caloric-restriction-like metabolic rejuvenation in mammals without requiring mitochondrial electron transport chain inhibition. Engaging AMPK directly via its allosteric binding pocket bypasses the pleiotropic off-target effects of indirect metabolic poisons to drive conserved pro-longevity programs. Mechanism: Selective small-molecule binding to the AMPK heterotrimeric complex (such as at the allosteric drug and metabolite [ADaM] site between the alpha-kinase domain and beta-carbohydrate-binding module) stabilizes the active enzyme conformation and prevents dephosphorylation of Thr172. Activated AMPK directly phosphorylates conserved downstream substrates—including ULK1 to initiate autophagy, ACC1/2 to promote fatty acid beta-oxidation, Raptor/TSC2 to restrain mTORC1 signaling, and FOXO/PGC-1alpha to enhance mitochondrial quality control and oxidative stress resistance. Prediction: Administration of a selective direct AMPK activator extends median and maximum lifespan in wild-type C. elegans and Drosophila and improves insulin sensitivity, autophagic flux, and transcriptomic age biomarkers in aged mice without altering cellular ATP/AMP ratios or complex I respiration, whereas genetic ablation of the catalytic AMPK alpha-subunit (aak-2 in worms, AMPKalpha in flies and mice) or point mutation of the allosteric drug-binding pocket completely abolishes both lifespan extension and mammalian metabolic benefits.", "strict": 1, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 5 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 4 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 1, "text": "Direct pharmacological activation of the conserved NAD+-dependent deacetylase SIRT1 (and its invertebrate orthologs Sir2/SIR-2.1) via allosteric Sirtuin Activating Compounds (STACs) extends organismal lifespan across species and elicits systemic metabolic and anti-inflammatory healthspan improvements in mammals. Selective engagement of the enzyme's allosteric domain is sufficient to coupling chromatin remodeling and mitochondrial homeostasis to longevity. Mechanism: Binding of selective small-molecule activators to the N-terminal allosteric activation domain of SIRT1 induces a conformational shift that lowers the Michaelis constant (Km) for acetylated protein substrates independently of bulk intracellular NAD+ fluctuations. This targeted hyper-activation drives deacetylation of conserved longevity effectors including PGC-1alpha, FOXO transcription factors, p53, and NF-kappaB p65, thereby stimulating mitochondrial biogenesis, boosting endogenous antioxidant defenses, and suppressing chronic age-related sterile inflammation. Prediction: Treatment with a specific direct SIRT1 activator extends lifespan in S. cerevisiae, C. elegans, and Drosophila and preserves mitochondrial respiratory capacity, arterial function, and glucose homeostasis in aged mice, whereas organisms engineered to carry a single point mutation in the allosteric binding site (such as SIRT1-E230K in mammals or its conserved invertebrate equivalent) fail to exhibit lifespan extension or metabolic reprogramming despite maintaining normal basal deacetylase activity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42811497", "pmid": "42811497", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70738", "title": "Targeting Ero1L by Parthenolide Alleviates Cellular Senescence and Fibrosis of Localized Scleroderma by Regulating Mitochondria-Associated Endoplasmic Reticulum Membranes Stabilization.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-30", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism linking cellular senescence to fibrosis in an age-related pathological process and validates it through gain- and loss-of-function studies.", "background": "Localized scleroderma is characterized by excessive extracellular-matrix deposition and progressive skin fibrosis. Cellular senescence can promote persistent tissue remodeling and fibrotic disease through altered cell function and inflammatory signaling. Disturbances in organelle homeostasis have also been associated with both senescence and fibrosis. The causal molecular mechanisms connecting these processes in localized scleroderma, and whether they can be therapeutically reversed, remained incompletely understood.", "question": "What molecular mechanism drives cellular senescence and fibrosis in localized scleroderma, and can pharmacological disruption of that mechanism alleviate the disease phenotype?", "subject": "Senescence in localized scleroderma", "finding": "Parthenolide suppresses Ero1L, thereby normalizing Ero1L-mediated mitochondria-associated endoplasmic reticulum membrane function, regulating the IP3R1/Grp75/VDAC1 complex, and reducing mitochondrial damage, cellular senescence, and fibrosis. Ero1L overexpression reverses these protective effects, whereas Ero1L knockdown reproduces the anti-senescent and antifibrotic phenotype; ARG-449 is critical for parthenolide binding to Ero1L.", "key_points": [ "Ero1L causally promotes senescence and fibrosis", "Parthenolide directly suppresses Ero1L through binding involving ARG-449", "The mechanism involves MAM stabilization and the IP3R1/Grp75/VDAC1 complex", "Ero1L gain- and loss-of-function experiments establish causality", "Targeting this axis reduces mitochondrial damage and fibrotic pathology" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Hyperactivation of mTORC1 and suppression of TFEB block autophagosome-lysosome fusion and lysosomal biogenesis in dermal fibroblasts, triggering p62/SQSTM1-GATA4 accumulation that drives cellular senescence and ECM deposition in localized scleroderma. Pharmacological restoration of autophagic-lysosomal flux via mTORC1 inhibition or TFEB activation clears senescent fibroblasts and attenuates skin fibrosis. Mechanism: Pathological TGF-β/Akt signaling hyperactivates mTORC1 and upregulates the autophagy inhibitor Rubicon, phosphorylating and retaining TFEB in the cytoplasm while impairing lysosomal acidification and autophagosome-lysosome fusion. Defective lysosomal degradation leads to buildup of damaged organelles and p62/SQSTM1, which stabilizes the transcription factor GATA4 to activate NF-κB-dependent SASP transcription and p16INK4a/p21CIP1-mediated senescence. Pharmacological intervention with rapamycin, Torin-1, or small-molecule TFEB activators restores lysosomal proteolysis, degrades GATA4/p62, suppresses SASP secretion, and promotes autophagic clearance of accumulated ECM components. Prediction: Localized scleroderma fibroblasts will display accumulated LC3-II and p62 puncta with reduced lysosomal cathepsin activity and cytoplasmic TFEB retention, and pharmacological TFEB activation or mTORC1 inhibition will restore autolysosome formation and reduce dermal collagen content independently of UPR or STING inhibition.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 1 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 3, "text": "Pathological tethering of mitochondria-associated ER membranes (MAMs) via the IP3R-GRP75-VDAC1-MCU complex drives mitochondrial calcium overload, bioenergetic collapse, and premature senescence in localized scleroderma fibroblasts. Pharmacological disruption of ER-mitochondria calcium transfer prevents fibroblast senescence and ameliorates dermal fibrosis. Mechanism: Upregulation of MAM tethering proteins (PACS2, Mitofusin-2, and the IP3R-GRP75-VDAC1 bridge) in lesional fibroblasts increases physical apposition between the ER and mitochondria, channeling excessive Ca2+ from the ER lumen into the mitochondrial matrix via the mitochondrial calcium uniporter (MCU). Matrix Ca2+ overload induces mitochondrial permeability transition pore (mPTP) opening, cristae remodeling, and bursts of superoxide that cause telomeric and genomic DNA damage response (DDR) activation (γH2AX-ATM-p53-p21), driving senescence and TGF-β-dependent fibrogenesis. Pharmacological inhibition of MCU (Ru360), VDAC1 oligomerization (VBIT-4), or IP3R (2-APB) uncouples inter-organelle Ca2+ flux and halts senescence-driven fibrosis. Prediction: High-resolution imaging and proximity ligation assays in localized scleroderma fibroblasts will reveal increased IP3R-VDAC1 contact sites and elevated mitochondrial matrix Ca2+ preceding senescence onset, and selective inhibition of MCU or VDAC1 will prevent mtROS generation, DDR activation, and dermal thickening.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "CD38-mediated NAD+ depletion in dermal and immune cells of localized scleroderma skin inactivates mitochondrial SIRT3 and nuclear SIRT1, impairing mitochondrial homeostasis and deacetylation of profibrotic and senescence regulators. Pharmacological CD38 inhibition or NAD+ repletion restores sirtuin activity, suppresses fibroblast senescence, and reverses dermal fibrosis. Mechanism: Pro-inflammatory signals in localized scleroderma lesions upregulate the ecto-enzyme CD38 on dermal fibroblasts and infiltrating macrophages, depleting intracellular NAD+ pools. Loss of NAD+ inactivates mitochondrial SIRT3—leading to hyperacetylation and inactivation of SOD2 and PGC-1α-dependent mitochondrial biogenesis—and nuclear SIRT1, resulting in hyperacetylation of p53, NF-κB p65, and SMAD3. This dual organelle defect couples mitochondrial oxidative stress with sustained p53/p21 senescence and amplified TGF-β/SMAD3 transcription of fibrotic genes. Treatment with a selective CD38 inhibitor (e.g., 78c) or NAD+ precursors (nicotinamide riboside or NMN) replenishes NAD+, reactivates SIRT1/SIRT3, restores mitochondrial redox balance, and resolves skin fibrosis. Prediction: Lesional localized scleroderma tissues will show elevated CD38 expression, depleted NAD+/NADH ratios, and hyperacetylated SOD2 and SMAD3 in senescent fibroblasts, and treatment with 78c or NMN will reverse senescence markers and collagen deposition in a SIRT1/SIRT3-dependent manner.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 1, "text": "Impaired PINK1-Parkin-mediated mitophagy in localized scleroderma fibroblasts causes the accumulation of dysfunctional mitochondria and cytosolic leakage of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), which activates the cGAS-STING pathway to drive cellular senescence and dermal fibrosis. Pharmacological inhibition of STING or restoration of mitophagic flux resolves senescence-associated inflammation and reverses fibrotic tissue remodeling. Mechanism: Downregulation of PINK1/Parkin mitophagy machinery in dermal fibroblasts prevents the clearance of depolarized, reactive oxygen species (mtROS)-generating mitochondria. Oxidized mtDNA escapes into the cytosol via VDAC1/BAX macropores and binds cyclic GMP-AMP synthase (cGAS), generating 2'3'-cGAMP to activate ER-resident STING, TBK1, IRF3, and NF-κB. This signaling cascade enforces p21/p16-dependent cell cycle arrest and secretion of fibrogenic SASP factors that sustain α-SMA+ myofibroblast activation; small-molecule STING antagonists (e.g., H-151) or mitophagy inducers (e.g., Urolithin A) block cytosolic DNA sensing and abrogate the fibrotic cascade. Prediction: Cytosolic fractions of localized scleroderma fibroblasts will show elevated cell-free mtDNA and 2'3'-cGAMP accompanied by phosphorylated STING/TBK1, and pharmacological blockade with H-151 or mtDNA depletion will abolish SASP and collagen synthesis even when upstream ER or lysosomal stressors remain present.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 0, "text": "Chronic endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress in dermal fibroblasts activates the unfolded protein response (UPR) via the PERK-eIF2α-ATF4-CHOP and IRE1α-XBP1s signaling branches to directly induce cellular senescence and profibrotic extracellular matrix (ECM) overproduction in localized scleroderma. Pharmacological attenuation of ER stress or selective inhibition of UPR sensors reverses fibroblast senescence and alleviates dermal fibrosis. Mechanism: Excessive secretory demand and proteotoxic stress in lesional dermal fibroblasts trigger BiP/GRP78 dissociation and persistent activation of PERK and IRE1α. Downstream ATF4/CHOP and spliced XBP1 upregulate cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors (p16INK4a and p21CIP1) alongside a senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) enriched in TGF-β1, IL-6, and CCN2, locking fibroblasts into a senescent, apoptosis-resistant state that drives paracrine myofibroblast differentiation and collagen I/III deposition. Chemical chaperones (4-phenylbutyric acid [4-PBA] or TUDCA) or small-molecule PERK/IRE1α inhibitors (GSK2606414 or 4μ8C) restore ER proteostasis, suppress p16/p21 and SASP expression, and halt ECM accumulation. Prediction: Lesional skin biopsies from localized scleroderma patients and bleomycin-induced fibrotic dermis will exhibit co-localization of dilated ER cisternae and UPR markers (p-PERK, CHOP, XBP1s) specifically within p16INK4a+/SA-β-gal+ fibroblasts, and treatment with 4-PBA or a selective PERK/IRE1α inhibitor will normalize dermal thickness and senescent cell burden without requiring direct mitochondrial or lysosomal targeting.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42821663", "pmid": "42821663", "doi": "10.1126/science.aed8207", "title": "Hypertension fuels osteoarthritis through neuroendocrine signaling.", "journal": "Science", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism by which hypertension accelerates an age-related degenerative joint disease.", "background": "Osteoarthritis is a common degenerative disease whose incidence and severity increase with age. Mechanical damage and age-associated changes in joint tissues create susceptibility to progressive cartilage loss. Systemic metabolic disorders, including hypertension, have been associated with greater osteoarthritis risk and severity. However, it was unclear whether elevated blood pressure actively promotes joint degeneration through a defined biological mechanism rather than merely sharing risk factors with osteoarthritis.", "question": "Through what causal mechanism does hypertension accelerate osteoarthritis in joints predisposed by aging or mechanical injury?", "subject": "Hypertension-driven osteoarthritis", "finding": "Hypertension-associated circulating arginine vasopressin activates up-regulated AVPR1A in osteoarthritis-primed chondrocytes, driving NR4A3-dependent catabolic signaling and suppressing anabolic regulation. Genetic deletion or pharmacological inhibition of AVPR1A prevents the hypertension-induced acceleration of osteoarthritis.", "key_points": [ "Hypertension elevates osteoarthritis progression", "OA-primed chondrocytes up-regulate AVPR1A", "Circulating AVP activates AVPR1A", "NR4A3 mediates the downstream catabolic program", "AVPR1A disruption protects cartilage" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "Mechanical injury and aging upregulate Angiotensin II Type 1 Receptors (AT1R) on articular chondrocytes and synovial fibroblasts, sensitizing the joint to elevated circulating Angiotensin II during hypertension. This receptor priming allows systemic RAAS hyperactivity to directly trigger chondrocyte catabolism and oxidative stress without requiring local vascular structural failure. Mechanism: Joint trauma or age-related matrix degradation exposes chondrocytes and induces transcription of AGTR1 (AT1R) via mechanosensitive and pro-inflammatory pathways. In the presence of renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system (RAAS)-driven hypertension, elevated systemic Angiotensin II penetrates the synovial fluid and binds to these newly upregulated AT1R receptors, activating NADPH oxidase (NOX2/NOX4), generating reactive oxygen species, and stimulating NF-kB and MAPK signaling to upregulate MMP-13 and ADAMTS-5 while inducing chondrocyte senescence. Prediction: Chondrocyte-specific conditional deletion of Agtr1 or intra-articular delivery of a non-systemic dose of an AT1R antagonist (e.g., losartan) will abolish hypertension-induced osteoarthritis acceleration in aged or surgically destabilized (DMM) mice despite persistent systemic hypertension, whereas blood pressure reduction via non-RAAS vasodilators (e.g., hydralazine) will fail to fully protect joints during exogenous Angiotensin II infusion.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 3, "text": "Systemic arterial hypertension elevates intraosseous hydrostatic pressure and interstitial fluid shear stress within the subchondral bone lacunar-canalicular network, amplifying aberrant osteocyte mechanotransduction initiated by joint injury or aging. This biomechanical synergy accelerates subchondral bone plate sclerosis, increasing mechanical stiffness and peak shear stresses transmitted to the overlying compromised cartilage. Mechanism: Impaired autoregulation of nutrient arteries in hypertension transmits elevated arterial pressure into the enclosed subchondral marrow space, increasing interstitial fluid pressure and canalicular fluid flow velocity during joint loading. In joints already experiencing altered load distribution from meniscal injury or age-related cartilage thinning, this amplified fluid shear stress hyperactivates osteocyte integrin/Wnt-b-catenin and TGF-b1 signaling, driving osteoblast recruitment and subchondral bone plate densification that mechanically overloads and shears the overlying articular cartilage. Prediction: Direct intraosseous pressure recordings and nanoindentation mapping will show that subchondral hypertension and bone plate stiffening precede cartilage erosion in hypertensive injured joints, and osteocyte-specific inhibition of mechanotransduction or TGF-b1 release will block both subchondral sclerosis and secondary cartilage loss regardless of circulating inflammatory or vasoactive mediator levels.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "Hypertension-associated sympathetic nervous system hyperactivity accelerates osteoarthritis by releasing excessive norepinephrine from sympathetic nerve fibers that sprout into the synovium and subchondral bone marrow following joint injury or aging. This local adrenergic surge polarizes injury-recruited macrophages toward a non-resolving pro-inflammatory state that accelerates cartilage matrix breakdown. Mechanism: Mechanical joint damage and age-related tissue degeneration induce nerve growth factor (NGF)-dependent sprouting of sympathetic nerve fibers into the synovium and subchondral bone marrow lesions, alongside recruitment of CCR2+ monocyte-derived macrophages. In neurogenic oressential hypertension, heightened central sympathetic outflow increases local norepinephrine release from these sprouted fibers, stimulating a1- and b2-adrenergic receptors on primed synovial macrophages and osteoclast precursors to amplify NLRP3 inflammasome activation, TNF-a and IL-1b secretion, and subchondral bone resorption. Prediction: Selective periarticular sympathetic denervation or myeloid-specific deletion of adrenergic receptors will prevent hypertension from exacerbating synovitis, osteophyte formation, and cartilage loss in aged or mechanically injured mice despite persistent systemic hypertension, whereas non-neurogenic blood pressure elevation (e.g., L-NAME with ganglionic blockade) will fail to reproduce the myeloid inflammatory signature.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Elevated intravascular hemodynamic pressure activates mechanosensitive channels and premature senescence in synovial and subchondral endothelial cells, causing them to secrete Endothelin-1 (ET-1) and senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) factors. Age- or injury-induced microcracks in the osteochondral junction allow these endothelium-derived factors to diffuse into articular cartilage and drive chondrocyte catabolism. Mechanism: Pathological hydrostatic pressure and pulsatile shear stress in hypertension hyperactivate endothelial Piezo1 channels, inducing mitochondrial dysfunction, p16INK4a/p21-mediated endothelial senescence, and high-level secretion of ET-1, IL-6, and TGF-b. While an intact calcified cartilage barrier shields healthy cartilage, mechanical injury or aging creates tidemark microcracks and increases hydraulic conductance across the osteochondral plate, permitting endothelial ET-1 to reach deep-zone chondrocytes and activate Endothelin Receptor A (ETA)-dependent matrix metalloproteinase production. Prediction: Endothelial-specific deletion of Edn1 (ET-1) or Piezo1, or selective senolysis of vascular endothelial cells, will prevent hypertension from accelerating osteoarthritis in injured or aged mice without lowering systemic arterial pressure, and fluorescently tagged subchondral vascular tracers will accumulate in cartilage only when osteochondral integrity is compromised by prior injury or aging.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 1, "text": "Hypertension-induced microvascular constriction and arterial stiffening cause chronic subchondral bone ischemia, which synergizes with the heightened metabolic demand of injured or aged joints to trigger hypoxia-driven osteochondral destruction. The resulting hypoxic microenvironment stabilizes HIF-2a and upregulates VEGF, driving catabolic protease expression and aberrant vascular invasion into articular cartilage. Mechanism: Chronic hypertension promotes smooth muscle hypertrophy, endothelial dysfunction, and capillary rarefaction in the subchondral bone microvasculature, reducing local perfusion and oxygen tension. When superimposed on aging- or injury-induced osteochondral remodeling, severe subchondral and deep-zone cartilage hypoxia stabilizes hypoxia-inducible factor-2 alpha (HIF-2a/EPAS1) in osteoblasts and hypertrophic chondrocytes, inducing expression of VEGF, MMP-13, and RANKL, which uncouples subchondral bone turnover and promotes calcified cartilage fibrillation. Prediction: In vivo two-photon oxygen nanoprobe imaging will reveal pronounced subchondral hypoxia preceding cartilage loss specifically in hypertensive injured joints, and osteochondral-specific deletion of Epas1 (HIF-2a) or localized restoration of microvascular perfusion via nitric oxide donors will prevent accelerated cartilage degeneration even if systemic blood pressure and Angiotensin II levels remain elevated.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42822442", "pmid": "42822442", "doi": "10.1016/j.immuni.2026.09.004", "title": "Glucose-deprived tumor microenvironment activates AMP-activated protein kinase to drive adoptively transferred T helper 9 cell senescence.", "journal": "Immunity", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism by which nutrient deprivation induces cellular senescence and impairs antitumor immunity.", "background": "Solid tumors create metabolically stressful microenvironments in which rapidly proliferating malignant and immune cells compete for limited nutrients. Adoptively transferred immune cells often lose function and fail to persist under these conditions, limiting therapeutic efficacy. Cellular senescence can produce durable functional decline in immune cells, but the metabolic signals that initiate this state within tumors have remained incompletely understood. Identifying the causal signaling events could reveal ways to preserve therapeutic immune-cell activity.", "question": "How does nutrient scarcity in the solid-tumor microenvironment cause senescence and loss of persistence in adoptively transferred antitumor immune cells?", "subject": "Nutrient-induced immune-cell senescence", "finding": "Glucose deprivation activates AMPK in transferred Th9 cells, initiating a ZAK–NIK cascade that suppresses noncanonical NF-κB signaling and IL-9 production, thereby driving cellular senescence. Restoring glucose or targeting ZAK reduces senescence, improves Th9-cell persistence, and enhances CAR-Th9 efficacy against solid tumors.", "key_points": [ "Glucose deprivation causes Th9-cell senescence", "AMPK is activated by glucose scarcity", "The ZAK–NIK cascade suppresses noncanonical NF-κB signaling and IL-9", "ZAK targeting rejuvenates Th9 cells and improves antitumor efficacy" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 3, "text": "Starvation of essential and conditionally essential amino acids (such as arginine, tryptophan, and glutamine) in solid tumors induces uncharged tRNA accumulation and ribosome collisions in transferred immune cells, co-activating the GCN2–eIF2α–ATF4 integrated stress response and the ZAKα–p38/JNK ribotoxic stress pathway to enforce senescence. Mechanism: High expression of amino acid–depleting enzymes (such as ARG1 and IDO1) and transporters by tumor and myeloid cells starves infiltrating immune cells of amino acids while antigen stimulation demands high rates of effector protein translation. The resulting ribosome stalling and collisions activate both GCN2—which phosphorylates eIF2α to selectively translate ATF4, CHOP, and the mTORC1 inhibitor DDIT4 (REDD1)—and the ribotoxic stress sensor kinase ZAKα (MAP3K20), which phosphorylates p38 and JNK to transcriptionally induce p21CIP1, suppress mTORC1 anabolism, and establish durable cell cycle arrest. Prediction: Genetic deletion of ZAK (MAP3K20) or EIF2AK4 (GCN2), or pharmacological treatment with the integrated stress response inhibitor ISRIB, in adoptively transferred immune cells will prevent ribosome collision–induced p21CIP1/p16INK4a expression and senescence-associated β-galactosidase activity, restoring persistence in amino acid–depleted solid tumors.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Scarcity of glucose, glutamine, and serine in the tumor microenvironment starves de novo nucleotide biosynthesis during antigen-driven clonal expansion, causing replication fork stalling and chronic ATR/ATM–CHK1/2–p53 signaling that enforces DNA damage–induced senescence. Mechanism: Engagement of chimeric antigen receptors (CARs) or T-cell receptors (TCRs) by tumor antigens delivers strong proliferative signals that require rapid DNA replication, while simultaneous scarcity of glucose (pentose phosphate pathway), glutamine (nitrogen donor), and serine/glycine (one-carbon metabolism) depletes intracellular dNTP pools. Attempting S-phase progression under dNTP scarcity causes replication fork collapse, uracil misincorporation, and persistent double-strand DNA breaks (γH2AX foci), chronically activating the ATR/ATM–CHK1/CHK2–p53–p21CIP1 DNA damage response cascade to lock cells into premature replicative senescence. Prediction: Supplementing nutrient-starved immune cells with exogenous nucleosides or overexpressing nucleotide salvage pathway enzymes (such as deoxycytidine kinase) during antigen stimulation will abolish γH2AX accumulation, block ATR/ATM-dependent p21/p16 induction, and restore in vivo persistence without restoring glycolytic ATP production or amino acid levels.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Depletion of methionine and glutamine in the solid-tumor microenvironment disrupts the intracellular balance of S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) and α-ketoglutarate (α-KG), eroding repressive histone methylation marks at the CDKN2A and CDKN1A loci to transcriptionally initiate senescence. Mechanism: Avid consumption of methionine (via SLC43A2) and glutamine (via SLC1A5) by malignant cells reduces the intracellular SAM/SAH ratio and alters α-KG–dependent histone demethylase activity in infiltrating immune cells. Resulting SAM scarcity impairs the methyltransferases EZH2 (PRC2) and SUV39H1, leading to loss of repressive H3K27me3 and H3K9me3 marks at the CDKN2A (p16INK4a/p14ARF), CDKN1A (p21CIP1), and senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) promoter regions, thereby establishing an epigenetically fixed senescent state. Prediction: Overexpressing the methionine transporter SLC43A2, supplying cell-permeable SAM, or inhibiting the H3K27 demethylase KDM6B (JMJD3) in adoptively transferred immune cells will maintain H3K27me3/H3K9me3 occupancy at the CDKN2A locus under nutrient scarcity, preventing p16INK4a transcription and rescuing long-term intratumoral persistence.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Competition for glucose in the solid-tumor microenvironment triggers premature senescence in adoptively transferred immune cells by activating a Sestrin–AMPK–TAB1 macromolecular complex that drives non-canonical p38 MAPK autophosphorylation and cPLA2α-mediated lipid droplet accumulation. Mechanism: Extracellular glucose depletion lowers the intracellular ATP/AMP ratio and glycolytic intermediates, promoting the assembly of Sestrins (SESN1/2/3) and AMPK with the scaffold protein TAB1. This complex induces p38 MAPK autophosphorylation independently of canonical MAP2K3/6 signaling, which simultaneously inhibits telomerase (TERT) activity, downregulates costimulatory receptors (CD27/CD28), and activates cytosolic phospholipase A2α (cPLA2α) to drive unbalanced intracellular lipid accumulation and p16INK4a/p21CIP1-dependent cell cycle arrest. Prediction: Genetic ablation of TAB1/Sestrins or pharmacological inhibition of p38 MAPK or cPLA2α in adoptively transferred T or NK cells will prevent glucose starvation–induced lipid droplet accumulation and p16INK4a/p21CIP1 upregulation, preserving telomerase activity and intratumoral persistence even when extracellular glucose remains depleted.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 4, "text": "Combined scarcity of bioenergetic substrates and NAD+ precursors in the tumor microenvironment depletes the intracellular NAD+/NADH ratio and impairs mitophagy in adoptively transferred immune cells, triggering SIRT1/SIRT3 inactivation and Mitochondrial Dysfunction-Associated Senescence (MiDAS). Mechanism: Nutrient deprivation coupled with ectonucleotidase (CD38) upregulation in the tumor microenvironment exhausts intracellular NAD+ pools in infiltrating immune cells. Loss of NAD+ inactivates nuclear SIRT1 and mitochondrial SIRT3 deacetylases, resulting in hyperacetylation and stabilization of p53, impaired PINK1/Parkin-mediated mitophagy, accumulation of depolarized mitochondria producing excessive mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS), and sustained AMPK–p53–p21CIP1 activation that drives MiDAS and loss of memory persistence. Prediction: Restoring intracellular NAD+ homeostasis in adoptively transferred immune cells via NAMPT overexpression, CD38 deletion, or nicotinamide riboside supplementation will preserve SIRT1/SIRT3 activity, prevent p53 hyperacetylation and mtROS accumulation, and abrogate senescence induction under tumor nutrient deprivation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42826184", "pmid": "42826184", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aeg1622", "title": "Aging-associated SATB1 deficiency remodels 3D genome architecture and transcriptional programs in naive CD4+ T cells.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-02", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism linking ageing-associated loss of a chromatin organizer to altered genome architecture and immune-cell dysfunction.", "background": "Three-dimensional genome organization helps regulate transcription by partitioning chromosomes into domains and controlling contacts between regulatory elements and gene promoters. Ageing is accompanied by widespread transcriptional dysregulation, including chronic inflammation and impaired immune function. Changes in chromatin structure have been observed during ageing, but whether they actively drive age-related gene-expression programs rather than merely accompany them has remained unclear. The molecular mechanisms connecting altered genome topology to physiological decline are also poorly understood.", "question": "What causal molecular mechanism remodels three-dimensional genome organization during ageing and thereby promotes age-associated inflammatory and activation-related transcription?", "subject": "Age-related genome remodeling", "finding": "Age-associated reduction of SATB1 in naive CD4+ T cells weakens TAD boundaries and expands the range of CTCF-mediated interactions without changing CTCF occupancy, producing enhancer-promoter rewiring and increased expression of proinflammatory and proactivation genes. Conditional SATB1 deletion recapitulates these ageing-associated architectural and transcriptional changes, establishing SATB1 deficiency as a causal contributor.", "key_points": [ "SATB1 expression declines with age", "SATB1 normally constrains CTCF-mediated chromatin interactions", "SATB1 loss weakens TAD boundaries and rewires enhancer-promoter contacts", "Architectural remodeling activates inflammatory and T-cell activation genes", "Conditional SATB1 deletion phenocopies ageing" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Chronic age-associated stress and metabolic signaling induce persistent chromatin engagement of pioneer and inducible transcription factors—principally AP-1 (FOS/JUN) and NF-κB—which actively redistribute SWI/SNF (BAF) chromatin remodelers and cohesin complexes to form de novo enhancer-promoter loops at inflammatory and activation-related loci. This factor-driven recruitment sequesters architectural loop-extrusion machinery away from homeostatic lineage-identity super-enhancers, simultaneously promoting basal activation programs and impairing specialized immune function. Mechanism: Persistent low-grade signaling stabilizes AP-1 complexes at latent distal enhancers, where they recruit BAF remodelers to open chromatin and anchor cohesin-Mediator complexes, establishing de novo long-range chromatin loops with cytokine and activation promoters at the expense of homeostatic cell-identity loops. Prediction: Acute genetic or pharmacological inhibition of AP-1 DNA binding or BAF ATPase activity in aged cells will selectively collapse age-acquired enhancer-promoter loops at inflammatory loci in H3K27ac/cohesin HiChIP assays, redistribute cohesin back to homeostatic identity loci, and reverse the basal activation transcriptional signature.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 0, "text": "Age-related epigenetic drift—specifically altered DNA methylation at CpG-containing CTCF motifs and nuclear depletion of architectural cofactors such as HMGB1/HMGB2—weakens topologically associating domain (TAD) boundaries that normally insulate quiescent pro-inflammatory and immune-activation genes. The resulting breakdown of boundary insulation permits cross-boundary cohesin loop extrusion ('enhancer hijacking'), allowing constitutively active housekeeping enhancers to contact and transcriptionally activate adjacent inflammatory promoters. Mechanism: Progressive loss of CTCF occupancy and architectural HMGB proteins at TAD borders reduces inter-domain insulation, leading to TAD merging and ectopic cohesin-mediated enhancer-promoter contacts across former domain boundaries that drive basal inflammatory and activation-related transcription without canonical immune stimuli. Prediction: Targeted CRISPR-dCas9-mediated restoration of CTCF/insulator tethering or local demethylation at eroded TAD boundaries in aged cells will restore domain insulation in Hi-C/Micro-C maps, abolish cross-boundary enhancer-promoter contacts, and suppress basal inflammatory transcription while preserving acute stimulus-induced activation.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "Age-related erosion of heterochromatic silencing (H3K9me3, TRIM28/KAP1, and SIRT6) across transposable elements (LINE-1, LTR/ERVs, and SINEs) unmasks latent CTCF binding sites and transcription factor motifs embedded within repeat sequences, converting them into de novo chromatin loop anchors and cryptic enhancers. These reactivated retroelements partition existing chromatin domains and establish ectopic long-range loops with promoters of interferon-stimulated, inflammatory, and activation-related genes. Mechanism: Epigenetic de-repression of interspersed repeat elements exposes repeat-encoded CTCF and IRF/STAT/NF-κB binding motifs that recruit cohesin and Mediator complexes, forming novel repeat-to-promoter chromatin loops that directly drive inflammatory and activation transcription independently of cytosolic nucleic acid sensing. Prediction: Epigenetic re-silencing of specific de-repressed repeat families using CRISPRi (dCas9-KRAB) in aged cells—even under pharmacological blockade of reverse transcriptase or cGAS-STING signaling—will eliminate repeat-anchored chromatin loops in CTCF/H3K27ac HiChIP and downregulate linked inflammatory and activation-related target genes.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Age-accumulated DNA double-strand breaks, oxidative lesions, and unresolved RNA-DNA hybrids (R-loops) physically stall cohesin loop extrusion and trigger ATM/PARP1-dependent relocalization of chromatin modifiers, reconfiguring local 3D loop topology around fragile regulatory regions. This damage-induced extrusion arrest and repair-focus clustering brings stress-responsive and inflammatory promoters into sustained spatial proximity with active enhancers while disrupting long-range homeostatic transcription. Mechanism: Persistent γH2AX/53BP1 repair domains and R-loops act as physical barriers to NIPBL-cohesin translocation and nucleate phase-separated repair-transcription hubs, generating ectopic loop anchors that trap enhancers in contact with DNA-damage-responsive and pro-inflammatory activation promoters. Prediction: Resolving nuclear R-loops via RNase H1 overexpression or inhibiting chronic ATM/PARP1 signaling at stalled extrusion sites in aged cells will restore cohesin processivity across damaged domains, dissolve damage-anchored ectopic chromatin loops, and normalize age-associated inflammatory transcription.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 2, "text": "Age-associated degradation of the nuclear lamina (via Lamin B1 depletion) and loss of constitutive H3K9me3/HP1α heterochromatin detach lamina-associated domains (LADs) from the repressive nuclear periphery, driving large-scale B-to-A compartment switching. This spatial untethering repositions previously silenced inflammatory gene clusters and activation regulators into the transcriptionally permissive nuclear interior, where they form de novo contacts with active transcriptional hubs and nuclear speckles. Mechanism: Decline of LMNB1 and H3K9me3 methyltransferases (SUV39H1/SETDB1) disrupts peripheral heterochromatin tethering, causing spatial relocalization of lamina-repressed genomic domains into interior euchromatic A compartments where exposed promoters and enhancers engage RNA polymerase II condensates. Prediction: Restoring peripheral chromatin tethering in aged cells via Lamin B1/SUV39H1 re-expression or synthetic CRISPR-dCas9-Emerin nuclear-periphery tethering of switched domains will reverse B-to-A compartment transitions, prevent interior enhancer-promoter looping at those loci, and attenuate age-associated inflammatory gene expression.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42839094", "pmid": "42839094", "doi": "10.1038/s43587-026-01223-x", "title": "Longer lipids mark aging and constrain lifespan.", "journal": "Nat Aging", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-06", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper identifies a conserved lipid-remodeling process and experimentally demonstrates that manipulating its regulator alters lifespan.", "background": "Ageing is accompanied by widespread changes in metabolism and cellular composition. Lipids support membrane organization, signaling and energy storage, and age-associated lipid disturbances have been observed across many tissues and organisms. Some lipid changes correlate with age-related disease and physiological decline, but their functional importance remains uncertain. A central unresolved question is whether conserved lipid remodeling actively drives ageing or merely reflects it.", "question": "Does a conserved form of lipid remodeling actively constrain lifespan, and what molecular regulator controls it?", "subject": "Lipid remodeling and lifespan", "finding": "Ageing produces a conserved shift toward longer lipid acyl chains, with depletion of shorter lipid species. Plb1 promotes this remodeling, and its knockdown in C. elegans reverses lipid elongation and extends lifespan in a lipid-length-dependent manner, supporting a causal role for lipid chain length in limiting longevity.", "key_points": [ "Ageing shifts lipid composition toward longer acyl chains across species and tissues.", "The remodeling is ratiometric, combining accumulation of longer lipids with depletion of shorter species.", "Plb1 regulates age-associated lipid chain elongation.", "Plb1 knockdown reverses lipid elongation and extends C. elegans lifespan.", "Lifespan extension depends on lipid chain length." ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "A conserved shift in sphingolipid metabolism toward the accumulation of long- and very-long-chain ceramides and dihydroceramides at the expense of sphingomyelin and complex glycosphingolipids actively accelerates ageing across species. This remodeling is controlled by the serine palmitoyltransferase complex (SPTLC1/2 relieved of ORMDL feedback inhibition) and ceramide synthases (CERS2/CERS6) downstream of dysregulated mTORC1 and nuclear hormone receptor (NHR-49/PPARalpha) signaling. Mechanism: Age-associated loss of ORMDL-mediated negative feedback on serine palmitoyltransferase and altered CERS isoform expression expand de novo C16:0 and C24:1 ceramide pools within mitochondrial and autolysosomal membranes. Elevated ceramides activate protein phosphatase 2A (PP2A) to inhibit AKT/FOXO survival signaling, promote Drp1-dependent mitochondrial fragmentation, and increase autolysosomal membrane rigidity, thereby blocking autophagosome-lysosome fusion and mitophagic flux. Prediction: Late-life pharmacological inhibition of serine palmitoyltransferase or genetic stabilization of ORMDL feedback inhibition will normalize tissue ceramide-to-sphingomyelin ratios, restore autolysosomal cargo clearance, and extend lifespan across nematodes, flies, and mice, whereas exogenous C16-ceramide supplementation will abrogate the lifespan extension conferred by dietary restriction.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Conserved age-dependent depletion of vinyl-ether phospholipids (plasmalogens) coupled with a decline in the monounsaturated-to-saturated fatty acid (MUFA:SFA) ratio actively drives systemic ageing by increasing membrane order and depleting endogenous membrane antioxidants. This dual remodeling is controlled by peroxisomal fatty acyl-CoA reductase 1 (FAR1) and the membrane fluidity sensor AdipoR2 (PAQR-2) acting through SREBP-1/SBP-1 and Delta9-desaturases (SCD1/FAT-6/7). Mechanism: Age-related impairment of PEX5-mediated peroxisomal matrix protein import and dysregulated feedback degradation of FAR1 reduce alkyl-glycerone-3-phosphate synthase (AGPS)-dependent plasmalogen biosynthesis, while attenuated AdipoR2/PAQR-2 signaling downregulates Delta9-desaturase expression. The combined loss of sn-1 vinyl-ether bonds (which scavenge singlet oxygen and peroxyl radicals) and sn-2 cis-monounsaturated acyl chains increases lipid packing density in the ER and plasma membrane, triggering chronic unfolded protein response (UPR-ER) activation and blunting transmembrane receptor signaling. Prediction: Restoring peroxisomal ether-lipid synthesis via PEX5/FAR1 stabilization or dietary alkylglycerol supplementation, combined with AdipoR2/SCD1 activation, will normalize membrane fluidity and plasmalogen content, suppress chronic UPR-ER activation, and extend lifespan in C. elegans and aged mice independently of caloric intake.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "Age-dependent acyl-chain remodeling of inner mitochondrial membrane cardiolipin—converting symmetrical tetra-linoleoyl cardiolipin into asymmetrical, highly peroxidizable docosahexaenoyl-enriched species—actively limits organismal longevity. This pathological remodeling is governed by the endoplasmic reticulum–mitochondria contact site acyltransferase ALCAT1 (LCLAT1), which overrides physiological remodeling by tafazzin (TAZ). Mechanism: Age-related oxidative stress and expansion of mitochondria-associated ER membranes (MAMs) upregulate ALCAT1, which catalyzes the incorporation of very-long-chain PUFAs into monolysocardiolipin. Oxidized, remodeled cardiolipin loses its structural affinity for electron transport chain supercomplexes (Complexes I, III, and IV) and fails to externalize properly as a mitophagy receptor for LC3, triggering proton leak, bioenergetic collapse, and cytosolic mtDNA release via VDAC/mPTP pores to activate cGAS-STING inflammation. Prediction: Genetic ablation or small-molecule inhibition of ALCAT1 in aged animals will restore the tetra-linoleoyl cardiolipin ratio, preserve respiratory supercomplex assembly, suppress age-related cGAS-STING interferon signaling, and extend lifespan, whereas overexpressing tafazzin alone without inhibiting ALCAT1 will fail to prevent cardiolipin peroxidation or extend longevity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Conserved age-associated remodeling of membrane glycerophospholipids toward polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA)-enriched species—specifically arachidonoyl- and adrenoyl-phosphatidylethanolamines—actively constrains lifespan by sensitizing post-mitotic membranes to non-enzymatic lipid peroxidation. This acyl-chain remodeling is controlled by the Lands cycle acyltransferase LPCAT3 and the acyl-CoA synthetase ACSL4, whose activities rise with age downstream of chronic innate immune and Hippo/YAP-TAZ signaling. Mechanism: During ageing, progressive decline in GPX4-mediated detoxification and sustained activation of ACSL4 and LPCAT3 accelerate the re-esterification of long-chain n-6 PUFAs into lysophosphatidylethanolamine (LPE) and lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC). The resulting increase in the membrane peroxidizability index generates reactive lipid aldehydes (such as 4-HNE and malondialdehyde) that covalently crosslink mitochondrial respiratory complexes and proteostasis machinery, driving chronic sub-lethal ferroptotic stress and tissue attrition. Prediction: Inducible, adult-onset knockdown or pharmacological inhibition of LPCAT3 or ACSL4 in C. elegans, Drosophila, and mice will prevent the age-dependent rise in the membrane peroxidizability index, reduce tissue 4-HNE protein adducts, and extend median and maximum lifespan even when dietary PUFA intake and baseline mitochondrial superoxide production remain unchanged.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Conserved age-related remodeling of endolysosomal and neutral lipid pools—characterized by progressive accumulation of bis(monoacylglycero)phosphate (BMP) and cholesteryl esters alongside impaired triacylglycerol mobilization—actively constrains lifespan by disrupting lysosomal homeostasis and nuclear lipid signaling. This remodeling is controlled by the balance between the lysosomal BMP hydrolase PLA2G15 and the TFEB/HLH-30–regulated acid lipase axis (LIPA/LIPL-4). Mechanism: With advancing age, declining TFEB/HLH-30 nuclear translocation reduces lysosomal acid lipase (LIPA/LIPL-4) activity while metabolic stress drives compensatory BMP accumulation; concurrently, dysregulated BMP turnover by PLA2G15 destabilizes intraluminal vesicles required for glycosphingolipid and cholesterol egress. The resulting endolysosomal lipid traffic jam causes v-ATPase de-acidification, lysosomal membrane permeabilization, and depletion of lipolysis-derived lipid chaperones (such as oleoylethanolamide) that activate longevity transcription factors (NHR-49/PPARalpha and SKN-1/Nrf2). Prediction: Enhancing TFEB/HLH-30–driven lysosomal acid lipase activity or inhibiting PLA2G15 to preserve functional intraluminal BMP scaffolds will clear lysosomal neutral lipid and cholesterol storage, restore lysosomal pH, and extend lifespan in aged organisms, whereas blocking lysosomal lipid export via NPC1 loss-of-function will abolish these longevity benefits.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 1 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42841227", "pmid": "42841227", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70750", "title": "Age-Associated Gut Microbiota Dysbiosis Impairs Antiviral Defense During Influenza Virus Infection and Identifies Acetate as a Protective Mediator in Senescent Human Lung Cells.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally identifies and mechanistically validates a microbiota-derived mediator that improves antiviral defense in an ageing-associated cellular model.", "background": "Older individuals are more susceptible to severe influenza and often mount less effective antiviral immune responses. Ageing also alters the composition and metabolic activity of the gut microbiota, potentially affecting immune function at distant organs. Microbial metabolites are known to influence host immunity and gene regulation, but their contribution to age-related loss of antiviral protection remains poorly understood. It was therefore unclear whether altered microbial metabolism during ageing directly contributes to defective responses against respiratory viral infection.", "question": "Do age-related changes in gut microbial metabolism causally impair antiviral defense during influenza infection, and through what host mechanism can this deficit be counteracted?", "subject": "Ageing gut–lung antiviral defense", "finding": "Age-associated gut microbiota dysbiosis reduces microbial acetate-production capacity during influenza infection, while acetate supplementation suppresses viral replication and inflammation in senescent human lung fibroblasts. This protection is associated with FFAR2/FFAR3 signaling and increased histone H3 acetylation, supporting acetate as a mechanistic mediator of the ageing gut–lung axis.", "key_points": [ "Ageing-associated dysbiosis reduces acetate-producing microbial functions", "Acetate lowers influenza viral replication in senescent lung fibroblasts", "Acetate attenuates inflammatory responses", "Protection involves FFAR2/FFAR3 signaling", "Protection is associated with enhanced histone H3 acetylation" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Age-related reductions in gut microbial secondary bile acid biosynthesis deplete circulating lithocholic acid (LCA) and deoxycholic acid (DCA) derivatives, impairing activation of the host bile acid receptors TGR5 (GPBAR1) and FXR on pulmonary myeloid cells during influenza infection. The loss of tonic TGR5/FXR signaling simultaneously blunts IRF3-mediated early type I interferon induction and fails to restrain late NLRP3 inflammasome hyperactivation, driving both high viral titers and lethal lung immunopathology. Host-directed pharmacological agonism of TGR5 or FXR counteracts this microbial metabolic deficit by restoring balanced antiviral gene transcription and inflammasome restraint. Mechanism: Gut bacteria expressing bile salt hydrolases and 7alpha-dehydroxylase (such as Clostridium scindens) convert primary bile acids into secondary bile acids (DCA, LCA, and isoalloLCA) that reach the lung and activate TGR5 and nuclear receptor FXR in alveolar macrophages and infiltrating monocytes. TGR5 activation elevates intracellular cAMP to activate PKA, which promotes Src-kinase-dependent phosphorylation of IRF3 to amplify early IFN-I gene expression while simultaneously inducing PKA-mediated ubiquitination and degradation of NLRP3. In aged hosts, loss of bile-acid-converting commensals uncouples this dual regulatory circuit; selective host TGR5 agonism (e.g., INT-777) restores cAMP–PKA signaling to simultaneously rescue early IRF3 transcriptional activity and suppress late IL-1b/IL-18-driven tissue damage. Prediction: Fecal and serum bile acid profiling will demonstrate a markedly increased primary-to-secondary bile acid ratio in aged mice that correlates with elevated lung viral load and IL-1b levels, and treatment with the TGR5-specific agonist INT-777 will restore early IRF3 phosphorylation and survival in aged influenza-infected mice independently of SCFA or indole levels, whereas Tgr5-knockout mice will remain refractory to rescue by young microbiota transfer.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 0, "text": "Age-associated depletion of short-chain fatty acid (SCFA)-producing gut commensals reduces systemic butyrate and propionate levels, which causally impairs pulmonary antiviral defense against influenza by diminishing histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibition and FFAR2/FFAR3 signaling in alveolar macrophages and lung epithelial cells. This metabolic deficit restricts chromatin accessibility at type I/III interferon and interferon-stimulated gene (ISG) loci and impairs virus-specific CD8+ T cell oxidative metabolism. Counteracting this loss via host-directed class I/IIa HDAC inhibition, FFAR2/3 agonism, or SCFA restoration re-establishes permissive histone acetylation at antiviral gene promoters and rescues viral clearance in aged hosts. Mechanism: In young hosts, gut microbiota-derived butyrate and propionate enter the circulation and act in the lung both as endogenous inhibitors of host nuclear HDACs (maintaining H3K9ac and H3K27ac marks at IRF7, STAT1, and ISG promoters) and as ligands for cell-surface G-protein-coupled receptors FFAR2 (GPR43) and FFAR3 (GPR41) on myeloid and lymphoid cells. Ageing-induced dysbiosis depletes SCFA producers (such as Lachnospiraceae and Ruminococcaceae), leading to hypoacetylation and transcriptional silencing of early antiviral response genes in alveolar macrophages alongside defective fatty acid oxidation in effector CD8+ T cells. Pharmacological HDAC inhibition or FFAR2/3 activation in the aged host bypasses the microbial metabolic defect to restore open chromatin states at ISG loci and sustain antiviral immunity. Prediction: ChIP-seq and ATAC-seq of alveolar macrophages from aged mice or young mice colonized with aged microbiota will reveal selective loss of H3K9/H3K27 acetylation and chromatin accessibility at ISG promoters during early influenza infection, and treatment with a selective host HDAC inhibitor or oral butyrate will rescue lung viral clearance in aged mice even when microbial tryptophan, bile acid, and polyamine pathways are pharmacologically blocked.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "Age-related loss of gut microbial flavonoid-catabolizing and nicotinamidase-expressing bacteria depletes circulating phenolic catabolites (such as desaminotyrosine) and nicotinic acid, impairing host NAD+-dependent sirtuin (SIRT1) deacetylase activity and STAT1 transcriptional priming in pulmonary phagocytes. Without microbial metabolic support for host NAD+ salvage and STAT1 chromatin priming, aged lung macrophages fail to deacetylate and activate IRF3/IRF7 and mount a delayed, blunted type I interferon transcriptional response to influenza. Counteracting this deficit through host SIRT1 activation, NAD+ precursor repletion, or desaminotyrosine administration restores rapid IFNAR–STAT1–ISG amplification and viral resistance. Mechanism: Specific gut commensals (such as Flavonifractor plautii and pncA-encoding bacteria) convert dietary flavonoids into desaminotyrosine (DAT) and amidated vitamin B3 into nicotinic acid, feeding the host Preiss-Handler NAD+ salvage pathway and priming IFNAR1–STAT1 signaling in lung myeloid cells. Elevated intracellular NAD+ fuels the nuclear deacetylase SIRT1, which deacetylates key lysine residues on IRF3, IRF7, and STAT1 to enable their DNA binding and rapid transactivation of type I interferon and ISG networks upon viral RNA sensing. In aged hosts, microbial metabolic decline lowers pulmonary NAD+/NADH ratios and basal STAT1 phosphorylation; restoring host SIRT1 catalytic activity or supplying DAT directly re-establishes transcriptional competence of the IRF3/7–STAT1 axis. Prediction: Metabolomic and enzymatic assays of aged lungs during early influenza infection will show depleted NAD+ and desaminotyrosine levels accompanied by hyperacetylated, transcriptionally inactive IRF3/IRF7, and pharmacological activation of host SIRT1 (e.g., SRT1720) or DAT supplementation will restore rapid ISG induction and viral clearance in aged wild-type mice but not in mice lacking myeloid Sirt1 or Stat1.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 3, "text": "Declining gut microbial polyamine biosynthesis during ageing reduces systemic spermidine availability, which causally impairs influenza-specific CD8+ T cell responses and alveolar macrophage homeostasis by limiting hypusination of eukaryotic translation initiation factor 5A (eIF5A) and downstream translation of the autophagy master regulator TFEB. Defective TFEB-driven autophagic and mitophagic gene regulation leads to accumulation of damaged mitochondria, excessive mitochondrial ROS, and immune cell senescence during viral challenge. Counteracting this deficit via host DHPS–eIF5A–TFEB pathway activation or spermidine supplementation restores autophagic flux and rescues adaptive and innate antiviral immunity. Mechanism: Gut commensal production of polyamines (putrescine and spermidine) supplies the systemic pool required by host deoxyhypusine synthase (DHPS) to catalyze the post-translational hypusination of eIF5A. Hypusinated eIF5A is strictly required for efficient translation of triproline-motif-containing proteins, notably the transcription factor TFEB, which drives coordinated transcription of lysosomal biogenesis and autophagy genes essential for viral antigen presentation, mitophagy, and memory/effector CD8+ T cell survival. Age-associated loss of polyamine-producing gut microbes starves pulmonary immune cells of spermidine, halting TFEB translation and causing bioenergetic collapse during influenza infection; direct host TFEB activation or spermidine administration re-engages the lysosomal-autophagic transcriptional network. Prediction: Pulmonary CD8+ T cells and alveolar macrophages from aged or microbiota-depleted mice will exhibit reduced eIF5A hypusination and diminished nuclear TFEB protein despite intact Tfeb mRNA levels during influenza infection, and conditional deletion of Dhps or Tfeb in host hematopoietic cells will abrogate the protective antiviral effect of young fecal microbiota transplantation or spermidine supplementation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 1, "text": "Ageing shifts gut microbial tryptophan catabolism away from commensal indole derivatives (such as indole-3-propionic acid and indole-3-aldehyde) toward host kynurenine production, impairing tonic activation of the aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR)–type I interferon axis in pulmonary mucosal and innate immune cells. This loss of microbial indole signaling blunts early interferon-beta (IFN-b) and IL-22 production while compromising lung epithelial barrier integrity during influenza infection. Restoring host AhR transcriptional activity via microbial indole supplementation or selective AhR modulators counteracts the age-related antiviral deficit and prevents severe pulmonary immunopathology. Mechanism: Commensal Lactobacilli and Peptostreptococcus species metabolize dietary tryptophan into indoles that enter systemic circulation and bind host AhR in lung epithelial cells, endothelial cells, and alveolar macrophages. Ligand-activated AhR translocates to the nucleus, heterodimerizes with ARNT, and cooperates with NF-kB and IRF3/STAT1 to drive transcription of antiviral genes, cytoprotective IL-22, and tight-junction proteins while restraining excessive late-stage pro-inflammatory cytokine release. Age-related gut dysbiosis depletes indole-producing taxa, depriving the lung of tonic AhR transcriptional regulation; exogenous indole administration or direct host AhR agonism restores this transcriptional program unless AhR is genetically ablated in host pulmonary tissues. Prediction: Targeted metabolomics will show a selective drop in serum indole-3-propionic acid and indole-3-aldehyde relative to kynurenine in aged influenza-infected hosts, and administration of indole-3-propionic acid or a selective AhR agonist will restore early lung IFN-I/IL-22 transcription and survival in wild-type aged mice but completely fail to protect aged mice with lung- or myeloid-specific AhR deletion (Ahr-floxed).", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42842666", "pmid": "42842666", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aeh3785", "title": "Human trilayer engineered blood vessel reveals influence of fibroblasts on disease progression in model of Hutchinson-Gilford progeria.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-07", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally identifies causal, cell-specific mechanisms driving vascular pathology in the accelerated-ageing disorder Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome.", "background": "Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome is a premature-ageing disorder caused by an LMNA mutation and is characterized by severe, early-onset vascular disease. Its vascular pathology includes extracellular-matrix abnormalities, fibrosis, collagen accumulation and inflammation. Blood-vessel models have often examined individual vascular compartments in isolation, limiting understanding of how interactions among the vessel wall layers produce disease. The cellular origins of the distinct pathological features and the extent to which they depend directly on the causal mutation remained unresolved.", "question": "How do the different cellular compartments of the vascular wall causally contribute to distinct features of Hutchinson-Gilford progeria vascular pathology?", "subject": "Progeria vascular pathology", "finding": "In trilayer engineered blood vessels, HGPS fibroblasts causally promoted extracellular-matrix dysregulation and fibrotic signaling, while HGPS smooth muscle cells drove collagen accumulation and endothelial cells drove inflammation. Correcting the HGPS-associated mutation by base editing restored many pathological characteristics toward healthy levels.", "key_points": [ "Trilayer vessels separated cell-specific causal effects", "Fibroblasts drove matrix dysregulation and fibrotic signaling", "Smooth muscle cells promoted collagen accumulation", "Endothelial cells promoted inflammation", "Mutation correction reversed multiple disease features" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "Cell-autonomous mechanical failure and attrition of progerin-expressing medial VSMCs is the primary causal event in HGPS vasculopathy, which secondarily triggers compensatory collagen accumulation, adventitial fibrosis, and sterile inflammation in genetically normal endothelial and adventitial compartments. Mechanism: Because the tunica media bears the highest cyclic tensile load, progerin-stiffened VSMC nuclei undergo mechanical rupture, replication stress, and necrotic cell death; the resulting release of damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) and loss of medial structural integrity mechanically and biochemically recruit wild-type adventitial fibroblasts and intimal ECs to mount a chronic wound-healing response characterized by dense fibrillar collagen replacement and inflammatory signaling. Prediction: Selective expression of progerin in VSMCs will recapitulate full-thickness vessel pathology—including adventitial fibrosis and intimal inflammatory gene expression in wild-type neighbouring cells—whereas genetic correction of the LMNA mutation solely within VSMCs will abolish ECM abnormalities, fibrosis, and inflammation across all layers of the vessel wall.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Progerin-expressing endothelial cells in the tunica intima act as the primary non-cell-autonomous instigator of pan-vascular pathology, simultaneously driving intimal inflammation and inducing secondary fibrosis and collagen accumulation in wild-type medial VSMCs and adventitial fibroblasts. Mechanism: Nuclear envelope deformation and persistent DNA damage in LMNA-mutant ECs trigger a senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) enriched in pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-6, IL-1beta, TNF-alpha) and pro-fibrotic growth factors (TGF-beta1, CTGF, PDGF), coupled with loss of vasoprotective nitric oxide; these diffusible signals cross the internal elastic lamina to induce myofibroblastic transdifferentiation and excessive collagen deposition in mural cells regardless of their intrinsic LMNA genotype. Prediction: Endothelial-restricted progerin expression in vivo or in multi-layered engineered vessels containing wild-type VSMCs and fibroblasts will be sufficient to induce both vascular inflammation and mural collagen fibrosis, and neutralizing endothelial TGF-beta/SASP secretion will prevent medial and adventitial matrix abnormalities despite persistent progerin expression in ECs.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Progerin expression in medial vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) and intimal endothelial cells (ECs) drives distinct pathological features in a strictly cell-autonomous, compartment-specific manner: mutant VSMCs directly generate extracellular-matrix (ECM) abnormalities and collagen accumulation, whereas mutant ECs independently drive vascular inflammation. Neither compartment requires the LMNA mutation in the neighbouring layer to manifest its signature pathology. Mechanism: In the tunica media, progerin-induced nuclear lamina stiffening disrupts LINC-complex mechanotransduction under cyclic stretch, shifting VSMCs from a contractile to a synthetic, profibrotic phenotype with elevated collagen and matrix metalloproteinase production. Concurrently, in the tunica intima, progerin impairs endothelial adaptation to laminar shear stress, directly activating NF-kappaB transcriptional programs and surface adhesion molecules (ICAM-1, VCAM-1) without altering mural matrix synthesis. Prediction: In heterotypic three-dimensional blood-vessel models or lineage-specific mosaic mice, vessels composed of HGPS VSMCs and wild-type ECs will exhibit medial ECM disorganization and collagen accumulation without endothelial inflammatory activation, whereas vessels with HGPS ECs and wild-type VSMCs will display robust intimal inflammation and leukocyte adhesion without medial fibrosis.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "While basal cellular stress depends directly on cell-autonomous progerin expression, severe HGPS fibrosis, ECM remodeling, and inflammation emerge from non-linear, synergistic crosstalk among mutant intimal, medial, and adventitial compartments that cannot be explained by the additive effects of individual mutant layers. Mechanism: Mutant VSMCs and adventitial fibroblasts deposit a stiff, fibronectin-rich, disorganized ECM that alters basement membrane mechanics and sensitizes overlying mutant ECs to shear-induced nuclear envelope damage and inflammasome activation; reciprocally, inflammatory cytokines and reactive oxygen species from mutant ECs amplify ER stress, TGF-beta signaling, and progerin transcription in VSMCs and fibroblasts, forming a cross-compartmental positive feedback loop. Prediction: In a full-factorial combinatorial vessel model varying the LMNA genotype of ECs, VSMCs, and fibroblasts independently, vessels in which both intimal and mural compartments carry the HGPS mutation will exhibit super-additive increases in collagen deposition, matrix stiffness, and inflammatory secretome levels compared to the sum of single-compartment mutant constructs.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "LMNA-mutant fibroblasts in the tunica adventitia are the primary cellular origin of pathological collagen accumulation and ECM crosslinking, which initiates an outside-in biomechanical cascade that secondarily induces medial VSMC dysfunction and intimal inflammation. Mechanism: Progerin expression in adventitial fibroblasts drives premature myofibroblast activation, excessive fibrillar collagen I/III secretion, and lysyl oxidase-mediated matrix stiffening; this rigid perivascular cuff increases bulk arterial stiffness and alters transmural mechanical strain and vasa vasorum perfusion, subjecting adjacent VSMCs and ECs to pathological mechanostress that triggers secondary cellular senescence and pro-inflammatory activation even when those inner layers lack the mutation. Prediction: Chimeric three-layer engineered vessels containing HGPS adventitial fibroblasts paired with wild-type VSMCs and ECs will develop severe collagen accumulation and wall stiffening followed by secondary medial depletion and inflammatory cytokine release, whereas substituting wild-type adventitial fibroblasts into otherwise mutant HGPS vessels will markedly attenuate total vessel fibrosis.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42844664", "pmid": "42844664", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70728", "title": "Time-Restricted Feeding Delays Cardiovascular Aging by Increasing Acetic Acid Through Remodeling Gut Microbiota.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal mechanism linking a dietary timing intervention to reduced cardiovascular ageing and cellular senescence.", "background": "Cardiovascular ageing is characterized by hypertension, arterial stiffening, endothelial dysfunction, and maladaptive cardiac remodeling. Chronic inflammation, impaired tissue barriers, and regulated inflammatory cell death can accelerate these changes. Dietary patterns can influence age-related cardiovascular health, but causal chains connecting specific eating schedules to vascular protection remain incompletely understood. Identifying the necessary and sufficient mediators of such protection is important for developing non-pharmacological strategies against cardiovascular decline.", "question": "Through what causal mechanism does time-restricted feeding protect against accelerated cardiovascular ageing?", "subject": "Cardiovascular ageing protection", "finding": "Time-restricted feeding enriches acetate-producing Limosilactobacillus, and microbiota-derived acetate is necessary and sufficient for its protection against angiotensin II-induced cardiovascular ageing. Acetate activates GPR43, inhibits HDAC3, increases H4K8 acetylation, and suppresses NLRP3-mediated pyroptosis and cellular senescence.", "key_points": [ "TRF remodels the gut microbiota and enriches Limosilactobacillus", "Microbiota depletion abolishes TRF-mediated cardiovascular protection", "Acetate supplementation restores the protective phenotype", "Acetate signals through GPR43 and inhibits HDAC3", "Increased H4K8ac suppresses NLRP3 pyroptosis and senescence" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "The daily fasting window of time-restricted feeding slows cardiovascular ageing via periodic surges of hepatic beta-hydroxybutyrate (BHB), which acts as a necessary and sufficient circulating mediator to directly inhibit NLRP3 inflammasome-driven pyroptosis and preserve vascular endothelial barrier integrity. Mechanism: Prolonged daily fasting depletes hepatic glycogen and activates PPARalpha-dependent ketogenesis via HMG-CoA synthase 2 (HMGCS2), elevating circulating BHB levels. In aged vascular endothelial cells, smooth muscle cells, and cardiac macrophages, BHB prevents potassium efflux and ASC oligomerization to block sterile DAMP-induced NLRP3/caspase-1/GSDMD pyroptosis while activating HCAR2 (GPR109A) and histone lysine beta-hydroxybutyrylation to maintain adherens junctions (VE-cadherin) and suppress fibrotic cardiac remodeling. Prediction: Hepatocyte-specific deletion of Hmgcs2 will abrogate TRF-mediated protection against vascular pyroptosis, endothelial hyperpermeability, and hypertension in aged mice despite intact feeding rhythms and gut microbiome remodeling, whereas timed daily administration of exogenous ketone esters to ad libitum-fed aged mice will replicate TRF protection even in germ-free or circadian clock-deficient animals.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 2, "text": "Time-restricted feeding prevents age-related vascular stiffening, endothelial barrier breakdown, and maladaptive cardiac remodeling by entraining peripheral vascular and cardiomyocyte circadian clocks (BMAL1/CLOCK and REV-ERBalpha), which directly transcriptionally repress RIPK1/RIPK3/MLKL-mediated necroptosis. Mechanism: Aligning nutrient intake with the active circadian phase restores high-amplitude oscillation of BMAL1 and its target nuclear receptor REV-ERBalpha (NR1D1) in aged endothelial cells and cardiomyocytes. REV-ERBalpha binds directly to ROR response elements in the promoters of necroptotic effectors (Ripk3, Mlkl, and Zbp1) and pro-inflammatory cytokines, suppressing TNFalpha- and DAMP-triggered MLKL phosphorylation, plasma membrane rupture, microvascular barrier leakage, and sterile perivascular inflammation. Prediction: Inducible endothelial- or cardiomyocyte-specific knockout of Bmal1 or Nr1d1 (REV-ERBalpha) will eliminate the protective effects of TRF against vascular MLKL phosphorylation, endothelial barrier leakage, and hypertension even when daily fasting duration and circulating BHB levels are maintained, whereas pharmacological REV-ERBalpha agonism (e.g., SR9009) will restore vascular integrity in ad libitum-fed aged mice.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 1 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "Time-restricted feeding attenuates cardiovascular ageing by cyclically activating AMPK- and SIRT3-dependent mitophagy during the fasting phase, clearing damaged mitochondria that otherwise trigger cytosolic mtDNA-driven cGAS-STING inflammation and iron-dependent ferroptosis in the vasculature and myocardium. Mechanism: Periodic nutrient deprivation increases the cellular AMP:ATP and NAD+:NADH ratios in aged endothelial cells and cardiomyocytes, activating AMPK-ULK1 and SIRT3-PINK1/Parkin mitophagy while upregulating NRF2-SLC7A11-GPX4 antioxidant defenses. Efficient clearance of senescent mitochondria prevents both the release of oxidized mtDNA into the cytosol—blocking cGAS-STING-TBK1-IRF3 innate immune signaling—and the accumulation of mitochondrial reactive oxygen species and labile iron that drive ACSL4-dependent lipid peroxidation and ferroptotic cell death, thereby preserving microvascular density and cardiac compliance. Prediction: Cardiovascular-specific deletion of Pink1 or Gpx4 haploinsufficiency will abolish TRF-mediated protection against endothelial lipid peroxidation (4-HNE accumulation), STING activation, and diastolic dysfunction regardless of gut barrier status or ketone levels, whereas pharmacological inhibition of ferroptosis (liproxstatin-1) combined with STING inhibition will mimic TRF benefits in aged ad libitum-fed mice.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 1 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Time-restricted feeding (TRF) protects against accelerated cardiovascular ageing by enriching short-chain fatty acid (SCFA)-producing gut microbiota and reinforcing the intestinal epithelial barrier, which prevents systemic lipopolysaccharide (LPS) translocation and subsequent caspase-1/11 and Gasdermin D (GSDMD)-mediated pyroptosis of vascular endothelial cells. Mechanism: Consolidating daily food intake restores rhythmic abundance of butyrate-producing commensals (such as Lachnospiraceae and Ruminococcaceae), increasing luminal butyrate to upregulate colonic mucin secretion and epithelial tight-junction proteins (ZO-1, occludin, claudin-1). This intact gut barrier blocks age-related metabolic endotoxemia, preventing circulating LPS from activating endothelial TLR4/NF-kB priming and canonical/non-canonical inflammasome cleavage of GSDMD, thereby preserving endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) function, preventing IL-1beta/IL-18-driven arterial stiffening, and attenuating hypertension. Prediction: Endothelial-specific deletion of Gsdmd or oral butyrate supplementation will be sufficient to phenocopy TRF-induced reductions in arterial stiffness and blood pressure in aged ad libitum-fed mice, whereas low-dose systemic LPS infusion or intestinal epithelial tight-junction disruption will abolish the cardiovascular benefits of TRF without altering hepatic ketogenesis or core circadian clock gene expression.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 4, "text": "Time-restricted feeding protects against accelerated cardiovascular ageing by restoring diurnal enterohepatic cycling of secondary and conjugated bile acids, which activate vascular endothelial and myeloid TGR5/FXR receptors to stabilize the endothelial glycocalyx and adherens junctions while inhibiting caspase-8/NLRP3-dependent inflammatory cell death. Mechanism: Consolidating feeding schedules re-establishes rhythmic biliary secretion and microbial bile salt biotransformation, producing robust active-phase peaks of cytoprotective bile acids such as tauroursodeoxycholic acid (TUDCA) and lithocholic acid derivatives. Activation of endothelial and macrophage TGR5 (GPBAR1) stimulates cAMP-PKA signaling, which induces inhibitory phosphorylation of NLRP3 at Ser291 to block pyroptotic/PANoptotic cell death and stabilizes cortical actin and VE-cadherin junctions, preventing leukocyte extravasation, endothelial dysfunction, and arterial stiffening. Prediction: Endothelial- and myeloid-specific deletion of Gpbar1 (TGR5) or disruption of luminal bile acid pools via bile acid sequestrants will prevent TRF from rescuing endothelial barrier integrity, vascular inflammation, and hypertension in aged mice, whereas timed daily administration of a selective TGR5 agonist or TUDCA will recapitulate TRF-mediated cardiovascular protection in ad libitum-fed aged controls.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42853938", "pmid": "42853938", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aea2001", "title": "Targeting SUV39H2 exon skipping reverses resistance to CDK4/6 inhibitors via transcriptional activation of p21.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-09", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal mechanism linking alternative splicing and chromatin regulation to therapy-induced cellular senescence and drug resistance.", "background": "Therapy-induced cellular senescence can durably arrest the proliferation of cancer cells and contribute to treatment efficacy. Cancer cells can acquire resistance to treatments that normally induce this state, allowing continued growth and disease progression. Alternative splicing and epigenetic regulation are both frequently altered during cancer evolution, but their causal roles in suppressing treatment-induced senescence remain incompletely understood. Identifying the molecular mechanism responsible could reveal a way to restore therapeutic sensitivity.", "question": "What splicing-dependent mechanism enables resistance to CDK4/6 inhibition, and can disrupting it restore therapy-induced senescence?", "subject": "Senescence-associated drug resistance", "finding": "Increased inclusion of exon 2 drives SUV39H2 overexpression and CDK4/6 inhibitor resistance. Suppressing SUV39H2 expression or methyltransferase activity removes H3K9me3 from enhancer regions, opens associated promoters, activates p21 and other senescence-associated genes, and restores therapy-induced senescence.", "key_points": [ "SUV39H2 exon 2 inclusion increases SUV39H2 expression", "SUV39H2 promotes resistance to CDK4/6 inhibitors", "SUV39H2 targeting reduces enhancer-associated H3K9me3 and opens promoters", "p21 and other senescence-associated genes are transcriptionally activated", "Therapy-induced senescence and drug sensitivity are restored" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 3, "text": "Loss of SWI/SNF chromatin-remodeling activity or altered RNA polymerase II elongation kinetics at the CCND1 locus promotes intron 4 retention and premature polyadenylation to generate the constitutively nuclear Cyclin D1b splice variant, enabling bypass of CDK4/6 inhibition-induced senescence. Blocking the intron 4 cryptic polyadenylation/splice signal with antisense oligonucleotides eliminates Cyclin D1b and restores durable senescence upon CDK4/6 inhibitor treatment. Mechanism: Epigenetic inactivation or subunit loss within the SWI/SNF complex (such as SMARCA2/Brahma) alters nucleosome positioning across the CCND1 exon 4-intron 4 junction, accelerating RNA polymerase II elongation and recruiting the splicing factor SAM68 to inhibit canonical splicing of intron 4. The resulting Cyclin D1b isoform lacks exon 5, which encodes the C-terminal Thr286 phosphorylation motif required for GSK3beta-mediated nuclear export and ubiquitin-dependent proteasomal degradation. Constitutively nuclear Cyclin D1b forms high-affinity complexes with CDK4 and non-canonical CDK2 that resist pharmacological CDK4/6 inhibition and continuously hyperphosphorylate RB and FOXM1, thereby blocking senescence entry; antisense masking of the intron 4 polyadenylation signal forces canonical splicing to exon 5, restoring Cyclin D1 turnover and RB-mediated senescence. Prediction: CDK4/6 inhibitor-resistant cells will exhibit elevated nuclear Cyclin D1b levels, reduced SMARCA2 occupancy at CCND1 intron 4, and persistent RB/FOXM1 phosphorylation under drug treatment, while steric-blocking oligonucleotides targeting the CCND1 intron 4 cleavage site will restore canonical Cyclin D1a splicing, induce nuclear Cyclin D1 clearance, and trigger senescence without affecting cells driven by CCNE1 amplification.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Hyperactivation of the U2 snRNP spliceosomal complex via RBM39 and SF3B1 prevents intron retention and poison exon inclusion in transcripts encoding the chromatin remodeler ATRX and the transcription factor FOXM1, thereby suppressing therapy-induced senescence during CDK4/6 inhibition. Degrading RBM39 with arylsulfonamide molecular glues (e.g., indisulam) or modulating SF3B1 induces unproductive splicing of FOXM1 while altering damage-response chromatin dynamics, restoring senescence in resistant cells. Mechanism: Durable senescence induced by CDK4/6 inhibition depends on simultaneous downregulation of FOXM1 (which otherwise suppresses reactive oxygen species and activates G2/M and epigenetic silencing genes like HELLS) and proper chromatin remodeling of E2F loci. Resistant cells upregulate the splicing factors RBM39 and SF3B1, which suppress inclusion of the inhibitory exon VIIa in FOXM1 (maintaining the transcriptionally active FOXM1b/c isoforms over inactive FOXM1a) and prevent premature intronic termination in DNA repair and cell-cycle progression transcripts. Targeted degradation of RBM39 via DCAF15-recruiting sulfonamides selectively impairs 3' splice site recognition in these cofactor-dependent introns, shifting FOXM1 splicing toward the dominant-negative FOXM1a isoform and triggering p21/ROS-dependent cellular senescence when combined with CDK4/6 blockade. Prediction: Transcriptomic profiling of CDK4/6 inhibitor-resistant cells will show selective exclusion of FOXM1 exon VIIa and high RBM39 dependency, and sub-lethal doses of indisulam combined with palbociclib will shift splicing toward FOXM1a, elevate intracellular ROS, and induce SA-beta-gal-positive senescence that can be rescued by expressing an intronless FOXM1c cDNA construct.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Upregulation of the splicing factor SRSF1 in CDK4/6 inhibitor-resistant cancer cells promotes alternative splicing of the bromodomain epigenetic reader BRD4 toward its short isoform (BRD4-S), which remodels super-enhancers to drive RB-independent G1/S transcription and repress senescence programs. Targeting SRSF1-mediated splicing or selectively degrading BRD4-S re-sensitizes resistant cells to CDK4/6 inhibition and reinstates therapy-induced senescence. Mechanism: SRSF1 binds exonic splicing enhancers in BRD4 pre-mRNA to favor usage of an alternative terminal exon (exon 12), generating BRD4-S lacking the C-terminal P-TEFb-interacting domain while retaining tandem bromodomains. Unlike full-length BRD4-L, chromatin-bound BRD4-S recruits the condensin II complex and corepressor machinery to compact senescence-associated super-enhancers, blunting SASP and CDKN1A activation, while simultaneously co-activating MYC and E2F target promoters to drive S-phase entry despite CDK4/6 inhibition. Inhibiting SRSF1 phosphorylation via SRPK1/CLK inhibitors or using antisense oligonucleotides to block the BRD4-S polyadenylation/splice site restores the BRD4-L:BRD4-S ratio, dismantling condensin II-mediated repression at senescence enhancers. Prediction: Resistant clones will display an elevated BRD4-S:BRD4-L ratio that correlates with SRSF1 nuclear speckle localization and loss of H3K27ac at SASP super-enhancers, and isoform-specific knockdown or splice-redirection of BRD4-S—in contrast to pan-BET bromodomain inhibition, which blocks SASP transcription—will restore both SASP gene expression and permanent senescence arrest under palbociclib treatment.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 0, "text": "Sustained activity of the protein arginine methyltransferase PRMT5 enables resistance to CDK4/6 inhibition by maintaining spliceosomal fidelity required for productive splicing of MDM4 and the histone methyltransferase EZH2. Pharmacological inhibition of PRMT5 or antisense oligonucleotide-mediated skipping of MDM4 exon 6 disrupts this axis, restoring p53 activation, H3K27me3 loss at senescence loci, and durable therapy-induced senescence. Mechanism: In drug-sensitive cells, CDK4/6 inhibition suppresses E2F-dependent expression of PRMT5 cofactors (such as WDR77/MEP50), reducing symmetric dimethylation of spliceosomal Sm proteins (SmD1/SmD3). This hypomethylation impairs recognition of weak 5' splice sites, causing exon 6 skipping in MDM4 (generating unstable MDM4-S subject to nonsense-mediated decay) and intron retention in EZH2, which together unleash p53-p21 signaling and derepress H3K27me3-silenced senescence genes. Resistant cells maintain high PRMT5-WDR77 activity independently of CDK4/6, preserving full-length MDM4 to degrade p53 and full-length EZH2 to epigenetically silence CDKN2A and SASP enhancers; blocking PRMT5 or directly forcing MDM4 exon 6 skipping re-establishes both p53 transcriptional activity and chromatin derepression required for irreversible arrest. Prediction: In CDK4/6 inhibitor-resistant cells with wild-type TP53, RNA-seq and anti-sDMA immunoprecipitation will reveal preserved Sm protein symmetric dimethylation alongside full-length MDM4 (exon 6 inclusion) and EZH2 transcripts, and combining palbociclib with a PRMT5 inhibitor or an MDM4 exon 6 splice-switching oligonucleotide—unlike inhibiting downstream CDK2 alone—will selectively restore SA-beta-gal activity and p21/SASP induction without requiring exogenous DNA damage.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 1, "text": "Chromatin-guided alternative splicing mediated by SETD2-dependent H3K36me3 and the splicing regulator PTBP1 drives resistance to CDK4/6 inhibition by excluding exon 6a of the histone variant gene H2AFY, shifting isoform expression from senescence-promoting macroH2A1.1 to proliferation-permissive macroH2A1.2. Disrupting PTBP1 recruitment or delivering splice-switching oligonucleotides that enforce macroH2A1.1 inclusion restores senescence-associated heterochromatin foci (SAHF) formation and irreversible cell cycle arrest. Mechanism: Conversion of reversible CDK4/6 inhibitor-induced G1 arrest into durable senescence requires incorporation of the macroH2A1.1 splice isoform into chromatin to compact E2F target loci into SAHF and bind ADP-ribose to stabilize p16/p21-driven transcriptional programs. During resistance evolution, altered H3K36me3 deposition along the H2AFY gene body recruits the chromatin adaptor MRG15 and polypyrimidine tract-binding protein PTBP1 to repress exon 6a inclusion in favor of exon 6b, producing macroH2A1.2, which lacks the NAD+/ADP-ribose-binding pocket needed for PARP1 restraint and heterochromatin stabilization. Depleting PTBP1 or using steric-blocking antisense oligonucleotides targeting the exon 6b splice site shifts splicing back to macroH2A1.1, enabling stable heterochromatinization of E2F target promoters upon CDK4/6 blockade. Prediction: Resistant cells treated with CDK4/6 inhibitors will exhibit reversible G1 arrest accompanied by a decreased macroH2A1.1-to-macroH2A1.2 transcript and protein ratio and enriched H3K36me3/PTBP1 occupancy at H2AFY exon 6b, whereas isoform-specific splice switching to macroH2A1.1—even in the presence of intact MDM4 and Cyclin E levels—will suffice to trigger SAHF assembly and prevent clonogenic outgrowth following drug withdrawal.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42858183", "pmid": "42858183", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70755", "title": "Ginsenoside Rg3 Promotes Healthy Aging Through Phosphoinositide-Associated Lysosomal Regulation in Caenorhabditis elegans.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper reports experimentally supported causal and mechanistic effects of a defined compound on lifespan, healthspan, age-related proteostasis decline, and neurodegeneration.", "background": "Aging is accompanied by declining lysosomal activity, impaired autophagic clearance, and loss of protein homeostasis. These changes contribute to progressive functional deterioration and increase vulnerability to protein-aggregation disorders. Restoring cellular clearance systems can sometimes improve lifespan or healthspan in model organisms. However, interventions that preserve lysosomal competence during aging and the mechanisms through which they act remain incompletely understood.", "question": "Can a defined intervention preserve lysosomal function and protein homeostasis during aging, thereby extending lifespan and maintaining organismal function, and through what mechanism?", "subject": "Lysosomal maintenance during aging", "finding": "20(S)-ginsenoside Rg3 extended lifespan and preserved physiological and neuronal function in Caenorhabditis elegans by restoring lysosomal activity and autophagic flux. Rg3 remodeled neuronal lysosomal phosphoinositide signatures toward increased PI(4)P and reduced PI(3)P, suppressed RSKS-1/S6K–TORC1 signaling, and promoted nuclear HLH-30/TFEB activity, thereby improving proteostasis and resistance to polyglutamine- and α-synuclein-associated toxicity.", "key_points": [ "Rg3 extends lifespan and preserves healthspan", "Lysosomal function and autophagic flux are restored during aging", "Neuronal phosphoinositides shift toward higher PI(4)P and lower PI(3)P", "TORC1–RSKS-1/S6K signaling is suppressed and HLH-30/TFEB enters the nucleus", "Protein aggregation and neurodegeneration are reduced" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 3, "text": "Enhancing endolysosomal bis(monoacylglycero)phosphate (BMP) synthesis via phospholipase D3/4 (PLD3/4) activation or promoting NPC1-mediated cholesterol export preserves lysosomal catalytic competence and extends lifespan by reversing age-associated lysosomal lipid accumulation and preventing lysosomal membrane permeabilization (LMP). Mechanism: Aging drives the progressive accumulation of unesterified cholesterol and lipofuscin within lysosomes alongside depletion of the cone-shaped anionic lipid BMP in intralumenal vesicles, which rigidifies the limiting membrane, impairs the interfacial docking of acid hydrolases (such as glucocerebrosidase and acid sphingomyelinase), and triggers galectin-3-positive membrane rupture. Restoring the high BMP-to-cholesterol ratio re-establishes intralumenal membrane curvature for lipid and protein degradation while stabilizing the limiting membrane against cathepsin leakage and inflammasome activation. Prediction: Lipidomic profiling of immunopurified lysosomes (LysoIP) from treated aged tissues will demonstrate restored BMP levels, depleted free cholesterol, and loss of perilysosomal galectin-3 puncta alongside reduced protein aggregation, whereas genetic ablation of PLD3/4 or pharmacological blockade of NPC1 (via U18666A) will abolish the intervention's effects on proteostasis and lifespan even when lumenal pH is artificially maintained.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 2, "text": "Selective pharmacological antagonism of retinoic acid receptor alpha (RARalpha) using atypical retinoids (such as AR7 or CA77.1) maintains proteome integrity and extends organismal healthspan and lifespan by stabilizing the lysosomal membrane receptor LAMP2A to restore chaperone-mediated autophagy (CMA). Mechanism: Age-related alterations in lysosomal membrane lipid composition accelerate the mobilization of LAMP2A into cholesterol-rich microdomains where it undergoes lumenal cleavage by cathepsin A, while tonic RARalpha signaling transcriptionally represses de novo Lamp2a expression. RARalpha antagonists relieve this transcriptional repression and promote the assembly of LAMP2A into functional 700-kDa multimeric translocation complexes at the lysosomal membrane, enabling HSC70-dependent import and degradation of KFERQ-motif-containing oxidized and aggregation-prone cytosolic proteins. Prediction: Treated aged animals will exhibit restored lysosomal internalization of KFERQ-fluorescent biosensors, reduced detergent-insoluble protein aggregates, and preserved neuromuscular function without changes in LC3-II macroautophagic flux, whereas selective genetic deletion of the Lamp2a-specific exon (leaving LAMP2B, LAMP2C, and macroautophagy intact) will completely eliminate the proteostatic and longevity benefits.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Dietary supplementation with the polyamine spermidine preserves lysosomal proteolytic activity and maintains protein homeostasis during aging, thereby extending lifespan and organismal function, by sustaining the eIF5A-dependent translation of the master lysosomal transcription factor TFEB (HLH-30). Mechanism: Spermidine serves as the sole aminobutyl donor for the enzymatic hypusination of eukaryotic translation initiation factor 5A (eIF5A) via deoxyhypusine synthase (DHPS) and deoxyhypusine hydroxylase (DOHH). Hypusinated eIF5A resolves ribosome stalling at polyproline motifs within TFEB/HLH-30 mRNA, preventing age-related translational decline of TFEB and maintaining transcription of the Coordinated Lysosomal Expression and Regulation (CLEAR) network, including V-ATPase subunits and cathepsin hydrolases. Prediction: Spermidine treatment in aged organisms will restore nuclear TFEB/HLH-30 levels, lysosomal cathepsin activity, and clearance of insoluble ubiquitinated protein aggregates to extend lifespan, whereas pharmacological inhibition of DHPS (via GC7) or mutation of the eIF5A hypusination site (K50A) will completely abolish these benefits even when mTORC1 is pharmacologically inhibited to force nuclear translocation of existing TFEB.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Upregulation or pharmacological activation of lysosomal acid lipase (LIPL-4/LIPA) preserves systemic protein homeostasis and extends lifespan by generating lysosome-derived lipid messengers that activate a retrograde lysosome-to-nucleus transcriptional program coordinating proteostasis and mitochondrial bioenergetics. Mechanism: Hydrolysis of autophagically delivered neutral lipids by lysosomal acid lipase releases specific monounsaturated fatty acids and N-acylethanolamines (such as oleoylethanolamide), which are bound by cytosolic lipid chaperones (LBP-8/FABP) and translocated to the nucleus. There, they activate nuclear hormone receptors (NHR-49/PPARalpha and NHR-80) and stress-responsive transcription factors (SKN-1/Nrf2) to upregulate molecular chaperones, V-ATPase subunits, and mitochondrial beta-oxidation enzymes, ensuring both elevated proteolytic capacity and the ATP supply required to power lysosomal proton pumps. Prediction: Exogenous supplementation with the downstream lysosome-derived lipid messenger oleoylethanolamide will bypass the requirement for upstream autophagic lipid delivery and phenocopy the proteostatic and lifespan benefits in aged animals with impaired lipophagy, whereas deletion of the lipid chaperone LBP-8/FABP or nuclear receptor NHR-49/PPARalpha will prevent lifespan extension despite elevated lysosomal lipase activity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 1, "text": "Pharmacological inhibition of mTORC1 or activation of the endolysosomal TRPML1 calcium channel preserves lysosomal proteolytic competence and extends healthspan and lifespan by directly driving the reversible assembly of the vacuolar H+-ATPase (V-ATPase) V1-V0 holoenzyme at the lysosomal membrane. Mechanism: During aging, chronic nutrient signaling and dysregulated endolysosomal phosphoinositide dynamics promote the dissociation of the cytosolic catalytic V1 sector from the membrane-embedded proton-translocating V0 sector. Targeted mTORC1 inhibition or TRPML1-mediated local calcium release recruits the RAVE/DMXL1 assembly complex and the chaperonin TRiC/CCT to promote V1-V0 docking, re-establishing the lumenal proton gradient required for acid hydrolase maturation and autolysosomal cargo degradation independent of de novo lysosomal biogenesis. Prediction: In aged tissues, the intervention will rapidly increase the membrane-to-cytosol ratio of V1 subunits and restore lumenal acidity (pH < 4.8) prior to any change in total lysosomal mass or LAMP1 abundance, and knocking down the V-ATPase assembly factor DMXL1/rabconnectin-3 or applying sub-lethal doses of bafilomycin A1 will selectively abrogate proteostasis and lifespan extension despite intact TFEB transcriptional activity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42806945", "pmid": "42806945", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70732", "title": "Ghrelin Alleviates Aging-Related Cognitive Impairment by Regulating Autophagy-Related Signaling via the SHBG/JNK1/Beclin1 Axis in Microglia.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-29", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally identifies and tests a causal molecular mechanism linking metabolic signaling to cellular senescence and cognitive decline during ageing.", "background": "Ageing is frequently accompanied by cognitive decline and chronic neuroinflammation. Cellular senescence and age-dependent changes in metabolic signaling can disrupt tissue homeostasis and contribute to functional deterioration in the brain. Although several circulating metabolic factors correlate with cognitive impairment, association alone does not establish which factors directly modify the ageing process. The molecular chain connecting a metabolic regulator to cellular dysfunction and cognitive outcomes therefore remained unresolved.", "question": "Which metabolic regulator causally mitigates ageing-related cognitive impairment, and through what molecular mechanism does it suppress cellular senescence and inflammation?", "subject": "Age-related cognitive impairment", "finding": "Ghrelin alleviates ageing-related cognitive impairment by promoting autophagy-related activity and reducing senescence and inflammation in microglia through the SHBG/JNK1/Beclin1 axis. SHBG overexpression and JNK1 inhibition attenuate these effects, while Beclin1 overexpression partially restores them, supporting the proposed causal pathway; excessive ghrelin can also cause GHSR desensitization.", "key_points": [ "Ghrelin improves ageing-related cognitive impairment", "Microglial senescence and inflammation are reduced", "Autophagy-related signaling is enhanced", "The effect is mediated through the SHBG/JNK1/Beclin1 axis", "Beclin1 rescue supports the causal pathway" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Age-dependent depletion of circulating extracellular nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (eNAMPT) drives central NAD+ insufficiency, and restoring systemic eNAMPT causally rescues cognitive function by suppressing mitochondrial-stress-induced cellular senescence and cGAS–STING/NF-κB neuroinflammation. eNAMPT-mediated NAD+ biosynthesis activates SIRT1 and SIRT3 in hippocampal microglia and astrocytes to prevent cytosolic mitochondrial DNA leakage and SASP activation. Mechanism: Extracellular vesicle-contained eNAMPT enters brain parenchymal cells to catalyze the rate-limiting step of NAD+ salvage from nicotinamide. Elevated intracellular NAD+ activates nuclear SIRT1 and mitochondrial SIRT3, which restore mitophagy, prevent mitochondrial permeability transition pore opening and cytosolic mtDNA release, and thereby block cGAS–STING and NF-κB transcriptional activation of p16INK4a/p21CIP1 senescence programs and microglial pro-inflammatory polarization. Prediction: Neutralizing circulating eNAMPT with blocking antibodies in young mice will precipitate hippocampal NAD+ depletion, glial p16INK4a/STING activation, and cognitive deficits, whereas adipose-specific Nampt overexpression or eNAMPT-containing vesicle infusion in aged mice will reverse cognitive decline unless central SIRT1/SIRT3 or STING signaling is genetically perturbed.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 0, "text": "Circulating fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF21) causally mitigates ageing-related cognitive decline by crossing the blood-brain barrier and engaging the FGFR1/β-Klotho coreceptor complex on hippocampal glia and neurons. Through activation of the AMPK–SIRT1 signaling axis, FGF21 suppresses p53/p21/p16INK4a-driven cellular senescence and inhibits NF-κB and NLRP3 inflammasome-mediated neuroinflammation. Mechanism: Binding of systemic FGF21 to central FGFR1c/β-Klotho complexes phosphorylates LKB1/AMPK and elevates NAD+-dependent SIRT1 deacetylase activity. Activated SIRT1 deacetylates p53 and RelA/p65, downregulating senescence effectors (p21CIP1, p16INK4a) and senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) cytokines (IL-1β, IL-6, TNF-α), while promoting PGC-1α-dependent mitochondrial quality control and preserving synaptic plasticity. Prediction: Conditional deletion of Klb (β-Klotho) or Sirt1 specifically in central nervous system glia or neurons will abolish the senomorphic, anti-inflammatory, and pro-cognitive effects of systemic FGF21 administration in aged mice, whereas peripheral metabolic improvements will remain intact.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Circulating adiponectin causally protects the ageing brain from cognitive impairment by activating AdipoR1–AMPK–SIRT1 signaling in microglia and hippocampal neurons to arrest metabolic-stress-induced senescence and neuroinflammation. Declining adiponectin levels during ageing disinhibit STAT3 and NF-κB signaling, driving glial senescence and synaptic dysfunction. Mechanism: Adiponectin binds AdipoR1 on microglia, astrocytes, and neurons, triggering CaMKKβ- and LKB1-dependent phosphorylation of AMPKα and downstream activation of SIRT1 and PPARγ. This cascade inhibits mTORC1 and suppresses STAT3/NF-κB nuclear translocation, reducing p16INK4a and p21CIP1 expression, attenuating SASP and NLRP3 inflammasome activation, and preserving hippocampal neurogenesis and dendritic spine density. Prediction: Brain-specific knockdown of AdipoR1 or pharmacological inhibition of AMPK will prevent systemic adiponectin or AdipoR agonist (AdipoRon) treatment from reducing hippocampal SA-β-gal/p16INK4a burden, microglial activation, and spatial memory deficits in aged mice.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Circulating soluble α-Klotho causally mitigates ageing-associated cognitive decline by dampening insulin/IGF-1/PI3K/Akt/mTORC1 hyperactivation and activating Nrf2/AMPK signaling at the choroid plexus and hippocampus, thereby suppressing cellular senescence and TXNIP–NLRP3 neuroinflammation. Age-related loss of soluble α-Klotho removes a systemic brake on mTORC1-driven geroconversion and inflammasome priming. Mechanism: Soluble α-Klotho binds monosialogangliosides and IGF-1 receptors to restrain PI3K/Akt/mTORC1 signaling while activating AMPK and Nrf2-dependent antioxidant transcription. Restrained mTORC1 activity restores autophagic clearance of damaged organelles, prevents p53/p21/p16INK4a-mediated geroconversion in choroid plexus epithelial cells and hippocampal glia, and downregulates thioredoxin-interacting protein (TXNIP), blocking NLRP3 inflammasome assembly and IL-1β/SASP secretion. Prediction: Systemic delivery of recombinant soluble α-Klotho or AAV-mediated hepatic expression of secreted α-Klotho in aged mice will reduce hippocampal p16INK4a+ senescent glial accumulation, TXNIP–NLRP3 interaction, and cognitive impairment, whereas constitutive genetic activation of mTORC1 (Tsc1 deletion) or Nrf2 knockout in the brain will abrogate these benefits.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "The circulating ketone body β-hydroxybutyrate (BHB) acts as a causal metabolic signaling regulator that ameliorates age-related cognitive decline by concurrently activating the Gi/o-coupled receptor HCAR2 (GPR109A) and inhibiting class I histone deacetylases (HDACs). This dual mechanism suppresses vascular and glial cellular senescence via hnRNP A1/Oct4 and FOXO3a activation while blocking NLRP3 inflammasome-driven neuroinflammation. Mechanism: Elevated circulating BHB crosses the blood-brain barrier via monocarboxylate transporters, binds microglial HCAR2 to inhibit ER-stress- and potassium-efflux-induced NLRP3 inflammasome assembly, and directly inhibits HDAC1/2/3 as well as binds hnRNP A1. This stabilizes Oct4 mRNA and increases histone acetylation/β-hydroxybutyrylation at Foxo3a and Mt2 promoters, repressing p53/p21/p16INK4a senescence pathways and oxidative stress in cerebral endothelial and glial cells. Prediction: In aged mice, exogenous ketone ester or BHB administration will fail to suppress neuroinflammation if Hcar2 is deleted in microglia, and will fail to suppress p16INK4a/p21CIP1 cellular senescence if hnRNP A1/FOXO3a signaling is disrupted, demonstrating a dissociable receptor- and epigenetic-mediated rescue of cognition over simple energetic substrate provision (e.g., acetoacetate infusion).", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42723144", "pmid": "42723144", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70710", "title": "Mitochondrial Haplotype Shapes the Trajectory of Ovarian Aging in Genetically Heterogeneous Rats.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally identifies a heritable determinant of ovarian ageing and links it to a specific defect in organelle genome maintenance and function.", "background": "Ovarian function declines with age, eventually causing reproductive senescence and broader endocrine changes that affect female healthspan. The pace of this decline varies substantially among individuals, even when chronological age is similar. Both nuclear and non-nuclear inherited factors could contribute to this variation, but their causal roles are difficult to separate because genetic backgrounds commonly differ at many loci. The mechanisms connecting inherited variation to follicle depletion, tissue pathology and loss of ovarian function therefore remain poorly understood.", "question": "Can naturally occurring inherited genetic variation alter the rate of ovarian ageing on equivalent heterogeneous nuclear backgrounds, and what cellular mechanism mediates this effect?", "subject": "Genetic control of ovarian ageing", "finding": "The OKC-HETW mitochondrial haplotype accelerated ovarian ageing, causing faster primordial-follicle loss, inflammatory and fibrotic remodelling, mitochondrial dysfunction and impaired ovulation relative to the OKC-HETB haplotype on equivalently distributed nuclear backgrounds. Despite normal TFAM expression and elevated total TFAM protein, OKC-HETW ovaries had reduced mitochondrial TFAM, TFAM–mtDNA binding and TOMM20, supporting defective mitochondrial protein import and compromised mtDNA maintenance as the mechanism linking haplotype to accelerated decline.", "key_points": [ "Mitochondrial haplotype causally modifies the rate of ovarian ageing", "OKC-HETW accelerates follicle depletion and pathological ovarian remodelling", "The susceptible haplotype reduces respiratory activity, ATP production and mtDNA copy number", "Reduced TOMM20 and mitochondrial TFAM indicate defective TFAM import and mtDNA maintenance", "Molecular and tissue defects correspond to impaired ovarian function" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 4, "text": "Naturally occurring inherited hypomorphic alleles in homologous recombination and DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair genes segregated across equivalent heterogeneous nuclear backgrounds accelerate ovarian ageing by reducing genome maintenance capacity in dictyate-arrested oocytes. Accumulated unrepaired endogenous DSBs activate the ATM-CHK2-TAp63alpha DNA damage checkpoint, causing premature apoptotic elimination of the primordial follicle pool. Mechanism: Natural coding or regulatory variants in DNA repair genes (such as Mcm8, Helq, or Brca2) compromise the continuous repair of oxidative and topoisomerase-induced double-strand breaks in long-lived primordial oocytes. When unrepaired breaks exceed a threshold during reproductive ageing, ATM kinase phosphorylates CHK2, which phosphorylates and tetramerizes latent TAp63alpha in the oocyte nucleus, inducing transcription of the pro-apoptotic BH3-only effectors PUMA and NOXA to execute BAX/BAK-mediated oocyte death. Prediction: When segregated across a randomized heterogeneous nuclear background, females carrying the hypomorphic repair allele will exhibit elevated gamma-H2AX and RAD51 foci in primordial oocyte nuclei prior to follicle depletion, increased phosphorylated nuclear TAp63alpha, direct loss of primordial follicles without a transient increase in growing follicles, and preservation of the ovarian reserve upon pharmacological CHK2 inhibition.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 1 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 0, "text": "Naturally occurring maternally inherited mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) haplotypes alter the rate of ovarian reserve depletion on equivalent heterogeneous nuclear backgrounds by modulating basal mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS) generation in dormant oocytes. Specifically, natural Complex I variants that elevate sub-lethal hydrogen peroxide production oxidatively inactivate PTEN, triggering premature PI3K-Akt-FOXO3a-dependent primordial follicle activation and accelerated reserve burnout. Mechanism: Polymorphisms in mtDNA-encoded NADH dehydrogenase (Complex I) subunits alter electron leak at the ubiquinone reduction site, increasing basal H2O2 levels in resting dictyate oocytes. Elevated H2O2 reversibly oxidizes the catalytic cysteine residue of PTEN, relieving its inhibition of PI3K/Akt signaling; activated Akt phosphorylates FOXO3a and causes its nuclear export, driving premature exit of primordial follicles from dormancy into the growing pool. Prediction: In reciprocal F1 hybrid females or conplastic strains sharing an equivalent heterogeneous nuclear background, the faster-ageing mtDNA haplotype will show an elevated ratio of transitional/primary to primordial follicles at young-to-middle age, increased cytoplasmic translocation of FOXO3a in primordial oocytes, and restoration of ovarian reserve longevity upon treatment with mitochondria-targeted antioxidants such as MitoQ, without elevated primordial oocyte apoptosis.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Naturally occurring inherited mtDNA variants interact epistatically with nuclear-encoded mitochondrial proteins across heterogeneous nuclear backgrounds to create stoichiometric mito-nuclear imbalances in ageing oocytes. The resulting chronic mitochondrial proteotoxic stress and loss of perispindle ATP supply disrupt meiotic spindle assembly, accelerating age-related oocyte loss and infertility. Mechanism: Divergent maternally inherited mtDNA rRNA, tRNA, or coding variants pair suboptimally with polymorphic nuclear-encoded mitoribosomal proteins or respiratory complex subunits, reducing mitochondrial translation fidelity and supercomplex assembly. Accumulation of unassembled OXPHOS subunits triggers persistent CLPP/ATF5-dependent mitochondrial unfolded protein response (mtUPR) signaling, dissipates inner membrane potential, and impairs perispindle mitochondrial clustering during oocyte maturation, leading to chromosome misalignment and spindle assembly checkpoint-induced arrest or death. Prediction: Oocytes from females with incompatible mtDNA-nuclear pairings on equivalent heterogeneous nuclear backgrounds will show reduced Complex I/IV supercomplex stoichiometry on blue-native PAGE, elevated HSP60 and ATF5 expression, depolarized perispindle mitochondria, increased MII oocyte aneuploidy, and functional rescue when treated with mitophagy enhancers such as urolithin A.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 3, "text": "Naturally occurring inherited low-level mtDNA heteroplasmy undergoes age-dependent clonal expansion in ovarian stromal fibroblasts and theca cells across equivalent heterogeneous nuclear backgrounds, triggering cytosolic mtDNA release and cGAS-STING-mediated sterile inflammation. This innate immune activation drives premature ovarian stromal fibrosis and biomechanical stiffening that mechanically restricts follicle development and ovulation. Mechanism: Maternally transmitted heteroplasmic mtDNA variants with replicative advantages clonally expand during lifelong turnover of ovarian stromal and theca cells, eventually crossing a bioenergetic threshold that induces mitochondrial permeability transition and BAX/VDAC-mediated extrusion of mtDNA fragments into the cytosol. Cytosolic mtDNA activates the cGAS-STING-TBK1 and NLRP3 inflammasome pathways, promoting secretion of IL-1beta, IL-6, and TGF-beta1, which drives myofibroblast differentiation, collagen I/III cross-linking, and cortical stiffening. Prediction: Single-cell mtDNA sequencing and spatial profiling of ageing ovaries across equivalent nuclear backgrounds will reveal age-progressive expansion of heteroplasmic variants specifically enriched in fibrotic stromal zones, coinciding with cytosolic dsDNA puncta and phosphorylated STING, while pharmacological STING inhibition or antifibrotic treatment (e.g., pirfenidone) will restore ovulation and follicle maturation without altering oocyte mtDNA load.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 1, "text": "Inherited natural variation in mtDNA oxidative phosphorylation capacity accelerates ovarian ageing on equivalent heterogeneous nuclear backgrounds by impairing granulosa cell bioenergetics and lowering the mitochondrial NAD+/NADH ratio. This bioenergetic and redox deficit compromises sirtuin-dependent mitophagy and steroidogenesis in supporting somatic cells, driving premature follicular atresia and endocrine decline. Mechanism: Natural variants in mtDNA respiratory chain subunits or tRNAs reduce Complex I/III/IV catalytic efficiency in metabolically active mural and cumulus granulosa cells, diminishing ATP synthesis and causing NADH accumulation. The resulting drop in NAD+ availability suppresses SIRT1 and SIRT3 deacetylase activity, impairing PINK1/Parkin-mediated mitophagy and StAR-dependent steroidogenesis, which triggers mitochondrial depolarization and caspase-3-mediated granulosa cell apoptosis in growing follicles. Prediction: Females carrying the risk mtDNA variant on an equivalent heterogeneous nuclear background will exhibit a reduced NAD+/NADH ratio and lower maximal oxygen consumption rate in isolated granulosa cells, increased rates of TUNEL-positive atretic secondary and antral follicles despite initially normal primordial counts, early declines in circulating estradiol and AMH, and rescue of follicle survival upon supplementation with NAD+ precursors such as nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN).", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42808804", "pmid": "42808804", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70712", "title": "IGF-1/SLC25A33 Maintains Blood-Labyrinth Barrier Integrity by Suppressing TGF-β/Smad2-Mediated Pericyte Activation in Age-Related Hearing Loss.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-29", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal molecular mechanism linking cochlear ageing to barrier disruption and age-related hearing loss in mice.", "background": "Age-related hearing loss is a common progressive disorder associated with degeneration of cochlear structure and function. Maintenance of cochlear homeostasis depends on a specialized vascular barrier that controls exchange between the circulation and inner-ear tissues. Ageing can compromise this barrier, disturb the local microenvironment, and contribute to auditory dysfunction. However, the causal molecular events connecting cochlear ageing to barrier failure and hearing decline were not fully understood.", "question": "What causal mechanism links cochlear ageing to loss of blood-labyrinth barrier integrity and auditory dysfunction?", "subject": "Age-related cochlear barrier failure", "finding": "Age-dependent loss of IGF-1 lowers SLC25A33 expression in strial pericytes, causing mitochondrial reactive oxygen species accumulation and activation of TGF-β/Smad2 signaling. This drives pericyte phenotypic switching, disrupts blood-labyrinth barrier integrity, and worsens hearing loss, whereas IGF-1 supplementation or SLC25A33 overexpression suppresses the pathway and partially restores auditory function.", "key_points": [ "IGF-1 and SLC25A33 decline in aged strial pericytes", "SLC25A33 loss causes mitochondrial ROS accumulation", "Mitochondrial ROS activates TGF-β/Smad2 signaling and pericyte switching", "The pathway disrupts the blood-labyrinth barrier and aggravates hearing loss", "IGF-1 or SLC25A33 restoration partially rescues barrier and auditory function" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "Age-related accumulation of senescent cells and activation of perivascular resident macrophage-like melanocytes (PVMMs) in the stria vascularis drive local matrix metalloproteinase (MMP-2/MMP-9) secretion and trophic factor loss, which proteolytically degrade endothelial tight junctions to breach the blood-labyrinth barrier (BLB) and collapse the endocochlear potential. Mechanism: Mitochondrial damage-associated molecular patterns and cellular senescence in the ageing stria vascularis activate cGAS-STING and NLRP3 inflammasome signaling in PVMMs, shifting them from a homeostatic phenotype that secretes pigment epithelium-derived factor (PEDF) to a pro-inflammatory state releasing IL-1beta, TNF-alpha, and MMP-2/9; this directly cleaves and internalizes endothelial claudin-5, occludin, ZO-1, and VE-cadherin, causing paracellular vascular leakage and disrupting intrastrial potassium recycling. Prediction: Selective senolytic clearance, PVMM depletion/reprogramming, or MMP-9/NLRP3 inhibition in aged mice will preserve strial claudin-5 and ZO-1 junctional localization, block extravasation of intravascular tracers into the intrastrial space, maintain the endocochlear potential, and attenuate age-related auditory brainstem response (ABR) threshold shifts.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 1, "text": "Ageing impairs platelet-derived growth factor-B (PDGF-B)/PDGFRbeta and Angiopoietin-1 (Ang-1)/Tie2 paracrine signaling between strial capillary endothelial cells and pericytes, inducing pericyte detachment and myofibroblastic transdifferentiation that destabilize the microvascular wall and compromise BLB integrity. Mechanism: Age-dependent decline in endothelial PDGF-B secretion and pericyte PDGFRbeta/Tie2 receptor expression causes pericyte apoptosis, detachment from the strial capillary basement membrane, and abnormal extracellular matrix remodeling (collagen IV/laminin degradation), depriving endothelial cells of essential survival and junction-stabilizing cues required to maintain barrier tightness and capillary perfusion. Prediction: Longitudinal imaging and single-cell transcriptomics of ageing cochleae will demonstrate pericyte detachment and PDGFRbeta/Tie2 downregulation preceding endothelial tight junction loss, and AAV-mediated restoration of Ang-1 or PDGF-B signaling in the stria vascularis will preserve pericyte coverage, prevent BLB leakage, and delay presbycusis without directly targeting sensory hair cells.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 3, "text": "Cochlear ageing downregulates the endothelial lipid transporter Mfsd2a in the stria vascularis, altering membrane docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) composition and disinhibiting caveolin-1 (Cav-1)-mediated vesicular transcytosis, which drives transcellular BLB leakage prior to overt tight junction destruction. Mechanism: Loss of Mfsd2a-mediated lysophosphatidylcholine-DHA incorporation into the luminal plasma membrane of aged strial endothelial cells disrupts the ordered lipid domains that normally suppress caveolae assembly, resulting in Cav-1 upregulation and phosphorylation that accelerate non-selective transendothelial vesicular transport of toxic plasma proteins and inflammatory mediators into the intrastrial fluid space. Prediction: Transmission electron microscopy of early-aged stria vascularis capillaries will reveal increased endothelial caveolar vesicles and transcellular tracer extravasation despite intact inter-endothelial tight junctions, and endothelial-specific Cav-1 deletion or Mfsd2a overexpression will abrogate early BLB leakage and preserve cochlear function.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Age-related decline in mitophagy and the Nrf2/GPX4 antioxidant axis coupled with labile iron accumulation in strial microvascular endothelial cells triggers lipid peroxidation and ferroptotic endothelial damage, leading to structural BLB breakdown and auditory decline. Mechanism: Impaired PINK1/Parkin-mediated mitophagy and dysregulated ferritinophagy in the metabolically demanding stria vascularis lead to intracellular ferrous iron overload and glutathione peroxidase 4 (GPX4) depletion; the resulting peroxidation of polyunsaturated phospholipids in endothelial plasma membranes disrupts membrane integrity, induces endothelial cell loss, and collapses the ionic gradient required for endocochlear potential generation. Prediction: Aged strial capillaries will accumulate labile Fe2+ and 4-HNE/MDA lipid peroxidation adducts alongside reduced GPX4 levels prior to outer hair cell degeneration, and treatment with ferroptosis inhibitors (e.g., ferrostatin-1 or liproxstatin-1) or iron chelators will prevent BLB hyperpermeability and preserve hearing thresholds in aged animals.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 4, "text": "Age-associated NAD+ depletion and loss of SIRT1/SIRT3 deacetylase activity in stria vascularis endothelial cells induce epigenetic and transcriptional repression of tight junction genes while hyperactivating HIF-1alpha/VEGF-A permeability signaling. Mechanism: Chronic DNA damage-induced PARP1 hyperactivation and CD38 upregulation during cochlear ageing deplete cellular NAD+ pools and inactivate SIRT1, resulting in hyperacetylation of FOXO1, NF-kappaB, and HIF-1alpha; this transcriptional shift simultaneously suppresses claudin-5 and ZO-1 expression and upregulates VEGF-A, promoting endothelial fenestration, junctional disassembly, and failure of strial ion transport homeostasis. Prediction: Strial endothelial NAD+ levels and SIRT1 activity will inversely correlate with vascular permeability and VEGF-A expression across the lifespan, and pharmacological NAD+ repletion (via nicotinamide riboside or NMN) or endothelial SIRT1 activation will restore claudin-5 transcription, maintain BLB integrity, and protect the endocochlear potential in aged mice.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42585340", "pmid": "42585340", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aeh0657", "title": "Mitochondrial stress activates ELT-2-dependent lysosomal proteostasis to extend lifespan in C. elegans.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-12", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal pathway linking a mild cellular stress response to proteostasis maintenance and lifespan extension in an ageing model organism.", "background": "Ageing is accompanied by a progressive loss of protein homeostasis and an accumulation of damaged or aggregation-prone proteins. Mild perturbations of cellular physiology can trigger adaptive responses that increase stress resistance and extend lifespan in several species. Effective removal of damaged proteins is thought to contribute to these benefits, but the responsible transcriptional programs and degradation machinery are incompletely understood. It also remains unclear which components are causally required to connect such adaptive stress responses to improved proteostasis and longevity.", "question": "Which molecular mechanism enables mild cellular stress to preserve protein homeostasis during ageing and extend organismal lifespan?", "subject": "Stress-induced longevity mechanism", "finding": "In Caenorhabditis elegans, inhibition of mitochondrial respiration activates an intestinal ELT-2-dependent transcriptional program that increases lysosomal proteolysis during ageing, largely independently of the mitochondrial unfolded protein response. Direct promoter binding by ELT-2, requiring residue R249, and the lysosomal proteases CPR-5 and CPR-8 are necessary for toxic polyglutamine aggregate clearance and mitochondrial stress-induced lifespan extension.", "key_points": [ "Mitochondrial respiration inhibition sustains lysosomal protease transcription", "Intestinal ELT-2 directly activates lysosomal protease genes", "ELT-2 residue R249 is required for transcriptional activity", "The pathway is largely independent of UPRmt", "CPR-5 and CPR-8 are required for aggregate clearance and lifespan extension" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 4, "text": "Mild metabolic, nutritional, or oxidative stress preserves proteostasis and extends lifespan by activating the Integrated Stress Response (ISR) eIF2alpha-ATF4 pathway, which couples global translation attenuation with the selective transcriptional induction of aggrephagy cargo receptors. By simultaneously reducing the influx of nascent folding intermediates and upregulating selective degradation adapters, the ISR prevents age-related proteostatic overload. Mechanism: Stress-activated kinases (GCN2, PERK, or HRI) phosphorylate eIF2alpha at Ser51, reducing ternary complex availability to lower bulk mRNA translation while promotingribosomal bypass of upstream open reading frames (uORFs) in ATF4 (atf-4). Translated ATF4 transcriptionally induces selective autophagy receptors (SQSTM1/p62, NBR1, OPTN) and ubiquitin-binding adapters, freeing existing molecular chaperones from nascent chains and targeting pre-existing protein aggregates for selective autophagic and proteasomal removal. Prediction: Rendering eIF2alpha non-phosphorylatable (eIF2alpha-S51A) or ablating ATF4/atf-4 will prevent mild stress from inducing selective cargo receptors and extending lifespan, whereas pharmacologically attenuating bulk translation alone without ATF4-mediated induction of degradation adapters will fail to clear pre-existing protein aggregates.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 3, "text": "Mild mitochondrial perturbation triggers a mitochondrial-to-nuclear retrograde response via ATFS-1/ATF5 and chromatin remodelers (DVE-1/SATB2) that transcriptionally induces mitochondrial AAA+ proteases alongside a cytosolic proteostasis program. This dual-compartment degradation mechanism prevents intramitochondrial proteotoxicity and alleviates cytosolic folding overload to extend lifespan. Mechanism: Partial impairment of the mitochondrial electron transport chain or mitochondrial translation reduces the mitochondrial import efficiency of ATFS-1/ATF5, redirecting it to the nucleus where it cooperates with DVE-1 and histone demethylases (JMJD-1.2/PHF8). This complex induces mitochondrial matrix proteases (LONP1, CLPP) to degrade damaged respiratory chain subunits and activates a cross-compartmental cytosolic HSF-1 and ubiquitin-proteasome response that prevents mitochondrial precursor overaccumulation stress (mPOS) in the cytosol. Prediction: Depletion of ATFS-1/ATF5 or the mitochondrial protease CLPP/clpp-1 will abolish both the cytosolic proteostasis improvements and lifespan extension triggered by mild electron transport chain inhibition, and cytosolic protein aggregation will specifically track with defective mitochondrial protease activity and precursor import rather than ERAD failure.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "Mild oxidative or proteotoxic stress preserves proteostasis and extends longevity by activating the stress-responsive transcription factors Nrf1/Nrf2 (SKN-1) and FOXO (DAF-16) to transcriptionally upregulate 26S proteasome subunits and specific E3 ubiquitin ligases. This transcriptional program increases 26S proteasome assembly and catalytic capacity, accelerating the ubiquitin-dependent turnover of damaged and misfolded cytosolic proteins during ageing. Mechanism: Low-level reactive oxygen species or transient proteasome insufficiency releases Nrf1/2 (SKN-1) from KEAP1/WDR-23 repression and promotes FOXO/DAF-16 nuclear localization. These transcription factors directly bind the promoters of 20S core particle genes and the 19S regulatory particle lid subunit PSMD11/RPN-6, stabilizing the interaction between the 19S regulatory cap and 20S catalytic core to boost recognition and proteasomal degradation of K48-polyubiquitinated substrates. Prediction: Stress-induced longevity and the suppression of age-associated polyubiquitinated protein accumulation will be selectively blocked by knocking down PSMD11/rpn-6.1 or mutating Nrf/FOXO binding motifs at proteasome subunit promoters, whereas inhibiting lysosomal autophagic flux will not prevent the stress-induced increase in soluble misfolded protein turnover.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Mild endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress promotes healthy ageing and systemic proteostasis by activating the IRE1-XBP1 signaling axis to transcriptionally upregulate ER-associated degradation (ERAD) machinery and lysosomal proteolysis genes. This adaptive unfolded protein response (UPR-ER) clears terminally misfolded secretory and membrane proteins and signals across tissues to extend organismal lifespan. Mechanism: Transient perturbation of ER folding capacity induces IRE1 endoribonuclease oligomerization and unconventional splicing of XBP1 mRNA into the active transcription factor XBP1s. XBP1s transcriptionally induces the ER-resident E3 ubiquitin ligase complex HRD1-SEL1L, the AAA+ ATPase VCP/p97 (CDC-48), and lysosomal degradation genes, accelerating retrotranslocation, ubiquitination, and cytosolic extraction of misfolded ER polypeptides for proteasomal and lysosomal clearance. Prediction: Loss of XBP1 splicing or knockdown of core ERAD components (HRD1/hrd-1 or SEL1L/sel-1) will completely abrogate the lifespan extension and proteostasis benefits conferred by mild ER stress, whereas blocking cytosolic HSF-1 or mitochondrial stress signaling pathways will leave the protective effect intact.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 0, "text": "Mild thermal or proteotoxic stress extends lifespan and prevents age-related protein aggregation by co-activating heat shock factor 1 (HSF-1) and the transcription factor TFEB/HLH-30 to transcriptionally upregulate the macroautophagy-lysosome machinery. Rather than relying solely on molecular chaperones to refold proteins, this hormetic response causally requires autophagic clearance of misfolded and aggregation-prone proteins to maintain organismal proteostasis. Mechanism: Transient sub-lethal stress triggers HSF-1 trimerization and nuclear translocation alongside calcineurin- and mTORC1-regulated nuclear entry of TFEB (HLH-30 in C. elegans). Together, HSF-1 and TFEB/HLH-30 drive coordinated transcription of core autophagy-related genes (such as ATG8/LC3/lgg-1, ULK1/unc-51, and SQSTM1/p62/sqst-1) and lysosomal hydrolases, increasing autophagic flux to encapsulate and degrade ubiquitinated protein oligomers before they form insoluble toxic aggregates. Prediction: Genetic ablation or RNAi knockdown of TFEB/HLH-30 or core autophagy execution genes (such as ATG5, ATG7, or BECN1/bec-1) specifically after mild stress exposure will abolish both the clearance of polyglutamine or amyloid aggregates and the lifespan extension, even when HSF-1-dependent chaperone induction (HSP70/HSP90) and 26S proteasome activity remain intact.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42669067", "pmid": "42669067", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70689", "title": "SIRT1 Silences L1 Retrotransposons by Stabilizing Heterochromatin-Modifying Complexes.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-30", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper reports an experimentally supported causal mechanism linking retrotransposon repression to delayed cellular senescence.", "background": "Cellular senescence is an irreversible growth-arrest state that contributes to ageing and age-related pathology. Senescent cells undergo changes in genome organization and can activate normally repressed repetitive DNA elements. Such activation may compromise genome stability and provoke inflammatory signaling. The regulatory mechanisms that preserve repeat silencing and thereby limit senescence remained incompletely understood.", "question": "How does SIRT1 regulate L1 retrotransposon activity, and does this regulation affect cellular senescence?", "subject": "SIRT1-mediated L1 silencing", "finding": "SIRT1 suppresses L1 transcription and retrotransposition by promoting the association and recruitment of Lamin B1 and KAP1 at the L1 5′-UTR, increasing repressive H3K9me3 chromatin. SIRT1 deficiency derepresses L1, activates cGAS–STING signaling, and induces cellular senescence; reverse-transcriptase inhibition with 3TC rescues this phenotype.", "key_points": [ "SIRT1 represses L1 transcription and retrotransposition", "SIRT1 stabilizes Lamin B1–KAP1 interactions at the L1 5′-UTR", "The mechanism increases repressive H3K9me3 chromatin", "SIRT1 loss activates L1-dependent cGAS–STING signaling and senescence", "3TC rescues senescence caused by SIRT1 deficiency" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Chronic DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) titrate SIRT1 away from L1 retrotransposon repeats to sites of DNA damage, causing passive derepression of L1 elements without requiring an initial drop in total cellular SIRT1 levels. The resulting L1 activation generates ORF2p endonuclease-mediated DNA breaks and cytoplasmic cDNA, creating a self-amplifying feedback loop that locks cells into irreversible senescence. Mechanism: Upon oxidative or replicative genotoxic stress, ATM/ATR-dependent DNA damage signaling recruits SIRT1 from repetitive L1 heterochromatin to dispersed DSB foci to deacetylate repair proteins such as NBS1 and Ku70. This spatial redistribution depletes L1 promoters of SIRT1 activity, allowing unopposed histone acetyltransferases to open L1 chromatin; subsequent expression of L1 ORF2p introduces new genomic DSBs via its endonuclease activity while reverse transcriptase activity triggers cGAS-STING signaling, reinforcing both p53/p21 growth arrest and SASP. Prediction: Inducing defined DSBs via an inducible endonuclease (e.g., AsiSI) will rapidly reduce SIRT1 ChIP occupancy at undamaged L1 5'UTRs while increasing SIRT1 enrichment at cut sites before total SIRT1 protein or NAD+ levels change, and ectopic overexpression of SIRT1 during DNA damage will prevent L1 derepression and block transition to irreversible senescence.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 2, "text": "SIRT1 prevents late-senescence L1 transcriptional activation by deacetylating the pioneer factor FOXA1 to inhibit its binding to L1 5'UTRs while deacetylating RB1 to preserve its repressive complex at L1 promoters. Loss of SIRT1 catalytic activity promotes hyperacetylated FOXA1 recruitment and RB1 eviction at L1 loci, driving L1 transcription and SASP maintenance. Mechanism: SIRT1 directly deacetylates lysine residues within the winged-helix DNA-binding domain of FOXA1, attenuating its pioneer binding affinity for consensus motifs in the L1 5'UTR, and concurrently deacetylates RB1 to prevent its phosphorylation-coupled dissociation from E2F/HDAC corepressor complexes on L1 chromatin. When SIRT1 activity diminishes during senescence progression, hyperacetylated RB1 dissociates and hyperacetylated FOXA1 occupies the L1 5'UTR, recruiting transcriptional coactivators that drive robust L1 expression and downstream innate immune activation. Prediction: SIRT1 inhibition will increase FOXA1 lysine acetylation and FOXA1 ChIP occupancy at L1 5'UTR promoters even when global H3K9me3 and CpG methylation are preserved, and expressing an acetylation-resistant FOXA1 (K-to-R) mutant or depleting FOXA1 will abolish L1 upregulation and SASP induction in SIRT1-deficient cells.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "SIRT1 represses L1 retrotransposon transcription by directly deacetylating H4K16ac and H3K9ac at L1 5'UTR promoters while deacetylating and stabilizing the methyltransferase SUV39H1 to maintain H3K9me3-marked constitutive heterochromatin. Age- or stress-related decline in SIRT1 activity erodes this heterochromatic barrier, driving L1 transcription, cytoplasmic L1 cDNA accumulation, and cGAS-STING-dependent cellular senescence. Mechanism: In proliferating cells, SIRT1 localizes to full-length L1 5'UTR promoters where it removes activating acetyl groups from H4K16 and H3K9 and deacetylates SUV39H1 (at K266), enhancing SUV39H1 catalytic activity and preventing its ubiquitin-mediated proteasomal degradation. When SIRT1 levels or NAD+ availability decline, SUV39H1 is destabilized and local H3K9me3/HP1a occupancy is lost while H4K16ac accumulates, opening L1 chromatin to RNA polymerase II transcription; the resulting L1 RNA is reverse-transcribed by ORF2p into cytoplasmic cDNA, activating cGAS-STING-IRF3 signaling and the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP). Prediction: ChIP-seq in SIRT1-depleted cells will reveal selective loss of SUV39H1 and H3K9me3 accompanied by gained H4K16ac specifically at intact L1 5'UTRs prior to senescence onset, and expressing a non-acetylatable, stabilized SUV39H1-K266R mutant will restore H3K9me3 at L1 loci and prevent L1 cDNA accumulation and SASP despite SIRT1 absence.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 3, "text": "SIRT1 silences L1 retrotransposons across cell divisions by deacetylating and activating DNA methyltransferase 1 (DNMT1) to maintain CpG methylation at L1 5'UTR promoters. Age-associated loss of SIRT1 activity impairs DNMT1 maintenance methylation at L1 repeats, leading to progressive L1 CpG hypomethylation, retrotransposition-associated genomic instability, and replicative senescence. Mechanism: SIRT1 physically interacts with DNMT1 at replication forks and deacetylates key lysines in its GK linker and catalytic domains, stimulating its methyltransferase activity toward hemimethylated CpG dyads within repetitive L1 5'UTR islands. Declining SIRT1 activity during replicative ageing yields hyperacetylated, hypofunctional DNMT1, causing passive dilution of 5-methylcytosine (5mC) at L1 promoters over successive population doublings, which licenses L1 transcription and ORF2p-induced DNA damage signaling that triggers p53/p21-dependent senescence. Prediction: Bisulfite sequencing across serial passages after SIRT1 knockdown will show replication-dependent loss of 5mC at L1 5'UTR CpG islands that precedes histone hyperacetylation and L1 RNA induction, whereas targeted re-methylation of L1 5'UTRs using dCas9-DNMT3A will restore L1 silencing and delay replicative senescence in SIRT1-depleted cells.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 4, "text": "SIRT1 restricts L1 retrotransposition and senescent inflammation post-transcriptionally by deacetylating core autophagy proteins to promote the selective autophagic degradation of cytoplasmic L1 ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complexes. Decline in SIRT1 activity impairs autophagic flux, allowing cytoplasmic L1 RNPs and reverse-transcribed cDNA to accumulate and trigger cGAS-STING-driven cellular senescence. Mechanism: Basally transcribed L1 mRNAs exported to the cytoplasm assemble with ORF1p and ORF2p into L1 RNPs that are normally recognized by selective autophagy receptors (such as p62/SQSTM1 and NDP52) and degraded in autolysosomes. SIRT1 deacetylates nuclear LC3 (enabling its cytoplasmic translocation) as well as ATG5 and ATG7 to sustain autophagosome biogenesis; when SIRT1 activity falls, defective autophagic clearance permits cytoplasmic L1 RNP persistence and ORF2p-catalyzed cDNA synthesis, activating cGAS-STING and paracrine senescence independently of changes in nascent L1 transcription rate. Prediction: In cells expressing an exogenous L1 reporter driven by a constitutive CMV promoter that bypasses endogenous L1 chromatin regulation, SIRT1 inhibition will still cause accumulation of cytoplasmic ORF1p puncta, L1 cDNA, and senescence markers without increasing nascent L1 RNA synthesis (by nuclear run-on/EU labeling), and this effect will be rescued by mTOR-independent autophagy induction.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42811065", "pmid": "42811065", "doi": "10.1038/s41467-026-77654-2", "title": "Pulsed electromagnetic fields activate a peripheral interoceptive pathway to suppress sympathetic Npy for osteogenesis.", "journal": "Nat Commun", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-29", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally establishes a causal mechanism linking chronic stress, cellular senescence in the bone marrow niche, impaired osteogenesis, and osteoporosis.", "background": "Chronic stress can disrupt bone remodeling and promote osteoporosis through sustained sympathetic nervous system activity. Cellular senescence within the bone marrow microenvironment can impair regenerative functions and contribute to reduced bone formation. Neural and endocrine signals are therefore plausible links between psychological stress and deterioration of skeletal health. However, the local mediator responsible for stress-induced senescence and the mechanism by which peripheral stimulation could restore osteogenesis were unresolved.", "question": "Which local mechanism connects stress-induced sympathetic activity to cellular senescence and impaired osteogenesis, and can it be modulated non-invasively?", "subject": "Stress-induced bone loss", "finding": "Sympathetic neuropeptide Y drives stress-induced osteoporosis by activating adipocyte Y1R and inducing senescence in bone marrow adipocytes, which impairs osteogenesis. Pulsed electromagnetic fields activate sensory nerves, causing local semaphorin 3A release that suppresses sympathetic neuropeptide Y secretion through a peripheral circuit independent of central pathways.", "key_points": [ "Sympathetic neuropeptide Y is causally required for stress-induced bone loss", "Neuropeptide Y induces senescence in bone marrow adipocytes through Y1R", "Adipocyte senescence impairs osteogenesis", "Pulsed electromagnetic fields activate sensory nerve-dependent semaphorin 3A release", "Semaphorin 3A locally suppresses sympathetic neuropeptide Y secretion" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Sympathetic hyperactivation during chronic stress suppresses local peptidergic sensory nerve activity in the bone marrow and depletes calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), depriving BMSCs of trophic RAMP1/CLR signaling required to prevent mitochondrial dysfunction and cellular senescence. Non-invasive transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) or somatosensory stimulation of peripheral afferents restores local CGRP release in the bone marrow, reversing BMSC senescence and rescuing bone formation. Mechanism: Excessive NE release from bone marrow sympathetic fibers acts presynaptically and through local vasoconstriction to inhibit dorsal root ganglion (DRG)-derived CGRP+ sensory terminals. Loss of CGRP-RAMP1-cAMP-CREB signaling in BMSCs impairs PINK1/Parkin-mediated mitophagy, leading to mitochondrial ROS accumulation, p53/p21-mediated senescence, and reduced Runx2 activity, which can be reversed by peripheral sensory neuromodulation that drives antidromic/reflex CGRP release into the marrow niche. Prediction: Conditional deletion of Ramp1 in BMSCs will phenocopy stress-induced senescence and block the therapeutic effect of non-invasive peripheral sensory nerve stimulation, even when sympathetic tone is pharmacologically normalized.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Sympathetic overactivity induces alpha1/beta2-adrenergic dysfunction in bone marrow type H capillary endothelial cells, causing local hypoxia, endothelial senescence, and release of senescent extracellular vesicles (EVs) carrying anti-osteogenic microRNAs that arrest coupled osteoprogenitors. Non-invasive peripheral acoustic or magnetic stimulation restores endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) activity and H-type vessel perfusion, halting senescent EV transmission and rejuvenating angiogenic-osteogenic coupling. Mechanism: Chronic adrenergic vasoconstriction and endothelial receptor desensitization reduce marrow blood flow and eNOS-derived nitric oxide, driving endothelial p21-dependent senescence and secretion of exosomal miRNAs (such as miR-31-5p and miR-188) that silence osteogenic transcription factors and induce secondary senescence in perivascular BMSCs. Non-invasive physical stimulation enhances shear-stress-responsive eNOS phosphorylation and Notch signaling in CD31hiEmcnhi endothelial cells, suppressing senescent EV release. Prediction: Endothelial-specific inhibition of exosome biogenesis (e.g., Rab27a deletion) or eNOS overexpression will prevent stress-induced BMSC senescence and bone loss, while eNOS inhibition will block the restorative effects of non-invasive vascular-targeted physical stimulation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Sustained sympathetic beta2-adrenergic signaling directly acts on LepR+ BMSCs and osteocytes to induceNOX4/mitochondrial ROS production and cytoplasmic mtDNA leakage, activating the cGAS-STING pathway to drive cellular senescence and paracrine SASP-mediated suppression of osteogenesis. Non-invasive mechanical stimulation via low-intensity pulsed ultrasound (LIPUS) or high-frequency whole-body vibration activates Piezo1 ion channels to restore mitochondrial integrity and suppress cGAS-STING-driven senescence. Mechanism: Direct binding of NE to BMSC ADRB2 triggers sustained cAMP-PKA signaling that promotes mitochondrial calcium overload, oxidative DNA damage, and mtDNA release into the cytosol, engaging cGAS-STING-IRF3/NF-kB signaling to establish a senescent, anti-osteogenic niche. Non-invasive acoustic or mechanical stimulation opens mechanosensitive Piezo1 channels on BMSCs, activating CaMKK2-AMPK-ULK1 signaling to clear damaged mitochondria and inhibit STING activation. Prediction: BMSC-specific deletion of Adrb2 or Sting1 will directly prevent stress-induced BMSC senescence without altering immune or sensory compartments, and BMSC-specific Piezo1 knockout will abrogate the anti-senescent and pro-osteogenic effects of LIPUS under chronic stress.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 3, "text": "Chronic sympathetic activity stimulates beta2/beta3-adrenergic receptors on bone marrow adipocytes (BMAds), driving excessive lipolysis and local accumulation of peroxidized lipids and pro-senescent adipokines (such as DPP4 and lipocalin-2) that induce senescence in neighboring osteoprogenitors. Non-invasive pulsed electromagnetic field (PEMF) therapy suppresses marrow adipocyte adrenergic lipolysis and activates SIRT1/PGC-1alpha signaling in osteoprogenitors to neutralize lipotoxic senescence and restore bone mass. Mechanism: Sympathetic NE stimulates hormone-sensitive lipase (HSL) and adipose triglyceride lipase (ATGL) in BMAds, flooding the local marrow microenvironment with free fatty acids and reactive aldehydes (e.g., 4-HNE) alongside senogenic adipokines that trigger lipid peroxidation, DNA damage, and p16Ink4a expression in adjacent Osterix+ progenitors. PEMF exposure downregulates BMAd cAMP-dependent lipolysis while upregulating antioxidant and SIRT1 deacetylase pathways in BMSCs. Prediction: Adipocyte-specific ablation of Pnpla2 (ATGL) or Adrb2/3 will protect neighboring BMSCs from stress-induced senescence and preserve bone formation, and lipidomic profiling will show that PEMF normalizes marrow free fatty acid and 4-HNE levels prior to osteogenic recovery.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 0, "text": "Chronic stress-induced sympathetic norepinephrine (NE) release activates beta2-adrenergic receptors (ADRB2) on bone marrow myeloid cells, triggering secretion of pro-senescent factors (such as grancalcin and S100A8/A9) that induce p16Ink4a/p21Cip1-dependent senescence in bone marrow mesenchymal stromal cells (BMSCs) and impair osteogenesis. Non-invasive transcutaneous vagus nerve stimulation (tVNS) or hindlimb electroacupuncture restores osteogenesis by activating the cholinergic anti-inflammatory pathway to suppress adrenergic myeloid activation and senescence propagation. Mechanism: Sustained sympathetic outflow elevates local bone marrow NE, which binds ADRB2 on resident macrophages and neutrophils, driving NF-kB/NLRP3-dependent release of senescence-inducing cytokines and alarmins that arrest adjacent LepR+ BMSCs. Peripheral autonomic neuromodulation (via tVNS or somatosensory electroacupuncture at ST36) engages vagal-splenic/marrow alpha7 nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (alpha7nAChR) signaling in myeloid cells, blunting pro-senescent secretome production and restoring BMSC osteogenic differentiation. Prediction: Myeloid-specific deletion of Adrb2 will prevent stress-induced BMSC senescence and bone loss despite elevated marrow NE, whereas alpha7nAChR antagonism or vagotomy will abolish the osteogenic rescue conferred by non-invasive peripheral electrical stimulation.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42841610", "pmid": "42841610", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70703", "title": "Inhibiting Glutaminase Reverses Senescence-Associated Mitochondrial Dysfunction and Skeletal Muscle Decline.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-10-01", "suitable": true, "reason": "The study experimentally identifies and pharmacologically validates a causal metabolic mechanism linking cellular senescence to mitochondrial dysfunction and age-related skeletal muscle decline.", "background": "Ageing commonly causes a progressive loss of skeletal muscle mass, strength and regenerative capacity known as sarcopenia. Mitochondrial respiratory dysfunction is a prominent feature of ageing muscle and is associated with cellular senescence. Senescent cells undergo extensive metabolic changes that may compromise tissue function. However, the causal metabolic processes connecting senescence to mitochondrial impairment and functional muscle decline remained incompletely understood.", "question": "What causal metabolic mechanism links cellular senescence to mitochondrial dysfunction and functional decline in ageing skeletal muscle, and can this mechanism be therapeutically reversed?", "subject": "Senescent muscle metabolism", "finding": "Senescence-associated p38 MAPK signaling increases GLS1 expression and activity in skeletal muscle myoblasts, causing intracellular urea accumulation that impairs mitochondrial function. Inhibiting GLS1 with CB-839 lowers urea, restores electron transport chain complexes and mitochondrial respiration, and improves skeletal muscle integrity and strength in progeroid mice.", "key_points": [ "Senescence activates a p38 MAPK–GLS1 axis", "Elevated GLS1 causes intracellular urea accumulation", "Urea accumulation impairs mitochondrial function", "GLS1 inhibition restores respiratory-chain function", "CB-839 improves muscle structure and strength in progeroid mice" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Cellular senescence in aged skeletal muscle transcriptionally upregulates pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase 4 (PDK4), which phosphorylates and inactivates the mitochondrial pyruvate dehydrogenase complex (PDC), uncoupling glycolysis from the TCA cycle and causing respiratory dysfunction and lactate-induced myofiber wasting. Pharmacological inhibition of PDK4 restores mitochondrial pyruvate oxidation, dampens metabolic SASP amplification, and rejuvenates muscle contractile force and regenerative capacity. Mechanism: Persistent DNA damage response and p53/FOXO1 activation in senescent muscle cells and satellite cells induce PDK4 expression, driving inhibitory phosphorylation of the E1alpha subunit (PDHA1) of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex at Ser293 and Ser300. This metabolic blockade prevents pyruvate conversion into mitochondrial acetyl-CoA, starving the TCA cycle of reducing equivalents (NADH and FADH2) required for oxidative phosphorylation while diverting carbon flux toward cytosolic lactate accumulation, which acidifies the niche and promotes proteasomal myofibrillar degradation; inhibiting PDK4 (e.g., via dichloroacetate or KPLH1130) re-opens pyruvate entry into the TCA cycle and restores oxidative ATP generation. Prediction: Stable-isotope 13C-glucose flux tracing in aged skeletal muscle will reveal a pronounced block in M+2 citrate enrichment accompanied by elevated PDHA1 phosphorylation and lactate export, and pharmacological PDK4 inhibition or expression of a phospho-resistant PDHA1 mutant will restore TCA cycle flux, maximal mitochondrial respiration, and tetanic force independent of upstream p16/p21 expression.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 4, "text": "Senescent cells in aged skeletal muscle overexpress the oxylipin-catabolizing enzyme 15-hydroxyprostaglandin dehydrogenase (15-PGDH/HPGD), which degrades bioactive prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and deprives myofibers and satellite cells of EP4-cAMP-CREB signaling required for mitochondrial biogenesis and oxidative capacity. Small-molecule inhibition of 15-PGDH restores endogenous PGE2 levels, reactivates mitochondrial respiration, and reverses age-related muscle atrophy and weakness. Mechanism: Senescent macrophages, fibroadipogenic progenitors, and aged myofibers upregulate HPGD (15-PGDH), catalyzing the NAD+-dependent oxidation of bioactive PGE2 into inactive 15-keto-PGE2. Depletion of tissue PGE2 diminishes G-alpha-s-coupled EP4 receptor signaling in myofibers and muscle stem cells, blunting cAMP/PKA-mediated CREB phosphorylation and downregulating master mitochondrial regulators PGC-1alpha and TFAM while derepressing FOXO3a-driven ubiquitin ligases (MuRF1 and Atrogin-1); systemic administration of a small-molecule 15-PGDH inhibitor (e.g., SW033291) re-establishes physiological PGE2 tone, restores mitochondrial biogenesis, and halts proteolysis. Prediction: Eicosanoid lipidomics in aged muscle will reveal a steep decline in the PGE2-to-15-keto-PGE2 ratio that correlates with senescent cell burden and Complex IV deficiency, and pharmacological 15-PGDH inhibition (SW033291) will restore physiological PGE2 levels, increase PGC-1alpha-dependent mitochondrial DNA copy number and respiration, and augment muscle cross-sectional area and strength in an EP4-receptor-dependent manner.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 0, "text": "Senescent cells in ageing skeletal muscle secrete pro-inflammatory SASP factors that induce the NAD+-consuming ecto-enzyme CD38 in neighboring myofibers and infiltrating macrophages, driving local NAD+ depletion that starves mitochondrial sirtuins and Complex I of essential cofactor. Pharmacological inhibition of CD38 or supplementation with NAD+ precursors restores mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation and reverses sarcopenic loss of muscle mass and contractile strength without requiring senescent cell clearance. Mechanism: Accumulation of p16INK4a/p21CIP1-positive senescent fibroadipogenic progenitors and myonuclei releases TNF-alpha, IL-6, and chemokines that transcriptionally upregulate CD38 via NF-kB and STAT3 signaling. Elevated CD38 hydrolyzes NAD+ into nicotinamide and ADP-ribose, collapsing the mitochondrial NAD+/NADH ratio and inactivating the mitochondrial deacetylase SIRT3. Loss of SIRT3 activity leads to inhibitory hyperacetylation of electron transport chain subunits (such as NDUFA9 and SDHA) and superoxide dismutase 2 (SOD2), while impairing PGC-1alpha-driven mitochondrial biogenesis, culminating in bioenergetic failure and myofiber atrophy that can be reversed by small-molecule CD38 inhibitors (e.g., 78c) or nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN). Prediction: In aged mice, muscle-specific genetic ablation of CD38 or treatment with the CD38 inhibitor 78c will normalize mitochondrial NAD+ pools, reverse hyperacetylation of Complex I/II subunits, and restore mitochondrial state 3 respiration and grip strength even when senescent cell burden and SASP transcript levels remain elevated, whereas myofiber-specific SIRT3 deletion will abolish this functional rescue.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 2, "text": "Senescence in skeletal muscle remodels endoplasmic/sarcoplasmic reticulum-mitochondria contact sites (MAMs) and upregulates the IP3 receptor type 2 (ITPR2) and mitochondrial calcium uniporter (MCU) axis, causing chronic mitochondrial matrix Ca2+ overload that triggers permeability transition pore (mPTP) sensitization and respiratory collapse. Attenuating ER-to-mitochondria Ca2+ transfer via ITPR2 suppression or MCU inhibition restores mitochondrial membrane potential and rescues age-related muscle weakness. Mechanism: Senescence-associated chromatin remodeling and p53 activation upregulate ITPR2 and stabilize VDAC1-GRP75-ITPR2 tethering complexes at MAMs in aged myofibers. Sustained Ca2+ transfer from the sarcoplasmic/endoplasmic reticulum into the mitochondrial matrix via MCU initially overstimulates Ca2+-sensitive TCA dehydrogenases to overproduce Complex I/III superoxide, and subsequently induces mPTP opening, osmotic matrix swelling, dissipation of the inner membrane potential, and cytochrome c leakage; partial genetic or pharmacological blockade of MCU (e.g., with Ru265) prevents matrix Ca2+ overload and preserves oxidative phosphorylation. Prediction: High-resolution proximity ligation assays and ratiometric mitochondrial Ca2+ imaging in aged myofibers will demonstrate increased ITPR2-VDAC1 contact density and elevated basal matrix [Ca2+]m prior to respiratory chain failure, and myofiber-specific MCU haploinsufficiency or Ru265 treatment will prevent mPTP opening and restore mitochondrial respiration and specific contractile force without altering NAD+ or lipid profiles.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 0 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Senescent muscle cells upregulate the polyamine catabolic enzymes spermidine/spermine N1-acetyltransferase 1 (SAT1) and spermine oxidase (SMOX), depleting intracellular spermidine required for deoxyhypusine synthase (DHPS)-dependent hypusination of translation factor eIF5A and stalling the synthesis of mitochondrial respiratory complexes. Inhibiting polyamine catabolism or supplementing spermidine restores eIF5A hypusination, rescues OXPHOS complex assembly, and reverses sarcopenic functional decline. Mechanism: Stress-induced p53 and inflammatory signaling in senescent myofibers and muscle stem cells transactivate SAT1 and SMOX, accelerating polyamine acetylation, cellular export, and oxidative degradation while generating cytotoxic hydrogen peroxide and acrolein. The resulting depletion of free spermidine starves the DHPS/DOHH enzymatic cascade that hypusinates eIF5A, a modification essential for translating polyproline tracts and hydrophobic targeting sequences of nuclear-encoded mitochondrial respiratory subunits and mitophagy regulators, leading to defective respiratory supercomplex assembly that is reversible via spermidine repletion or SAT1/SMOX inhibition (e.g., MDL 72527). Prediction: Targeted metabolomics and ribosome profiling of aged skeletal muscle will show a reduced spermidine-to-putrescine ratio, loss of hypusinated eIF5A, and selective ribosome stalling on nuclear-encoded OXPHOS transcripts, and dietary spermidine supplementation or SMOX/SAT1 inhibition will restore respiratory supercomplex abundance and muscle regeneration unless myofiber DHPS is genetically ablated.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42806003", "pmid": "42806003", "doi": "10.1038/s41467-026-77217-5", "title": "CD38-activated macrophages drive age-related placental senescence by depleting NAD+ in decidual stromal cells.", "journal": "Nat Commun", "earliest_public_date": "2026-08-27", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal mechanism linking reproductive ageing to placental senescence and adverse offspring outcomes.", "background": "Advanced maternal age is associated with placental dysfunction, impaired fetal growth, and increased risks to offspring health. Ageing tissues commonly exhibit metabolic disruption, chronic inflammation, and accumulation of senescent cells with a senescence-associated secretory phenotype. The placenta contains interacting maternal and fetal compartments whose metabolic state and inflammatory environment influence pregnancy outcomes. However, the causal processes through which maternal ageing induces placental senescence and developmental complications remained unclear.", "question": "What intercellular mechanism causes placental senescence during maternal ageing, and can disrupting this mechanism restore placental and offspring health?", "subject": "Age-related placental senescence", "finding": "Early inflammation and senescence-associated secretory phenotype activity induce IRF5-dependent CD38 expression in macrophages, which depletes NAD+ in decidual stromal cells and thereby promotes age-related placental senescence. Genetic or pharmacological disruption of this axis, including CD38 inhibition or NAD+ precursor treatment, reduces placental senescence, rescues intrauterine growth restriction, and improves offspring metabolic outcomes.", "key_points": [ "Early inflammation and SASP activate macrophage IRF5", "IRF5 increases macrophage CD38 expression", "Macrophage CD38 depletes stromal-cell NAD+", "NAD+ loss drives placental senescence", "CD38 inhibition or NAD+ replenishment rescues age-related outcomes" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 1, "text": "Pro-inflammatory maternal decidual macrophages in aged dams overexpress the NAD+-consuming ectoenzyme CD38, creating an intercellular NAD+ sink that depletes NAD+ bioavailability in neighbouring fetal trophoblasts and drives metabolic senescence. Inhibiting maternal macrophage CD38 activity or supplementing maternal NAD+ precursors restores placental bioenergetics, prevents trophoblast senescence, and rescues offspring developmental outcomes. Mechanism: Age-associated systemic and uterine low-grade inflammation polarises maternal decidual macrophages toward a pro-inflammatory phenotype characterised by high surface and intracellular expression of the NAD+ glycohydrolase CD38. Enhanced CD38 enzymatic activity rapidly degrades extracellular NAD+ and its precursors (NMN and NR) within the decidual-trophoblast niche, starving highly metabolically active fetal trophoblasts of NAD+. Trophoblast NAD+ depletion inactivates nuclear SIRT1 and mitochondrial SIRT3, leading to hyperacetylation of mitochondrial electron transport chain proteins, reactive oxygen species (ROS) overproduction, AMPK dysregulation, and p53/p21-dependent metabolic senescence. Selective inhibition of CD38 on maternal myeloid cells or gestational supplementation with nicotinamide riboside (NR) or nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) replenishes the shared metabolic pool. Prediction: Conditional deletion of Cd38 specifically in maternal myeloid cells (Lyz2-Cre;Cd38fl/fl aged dams carrying wild-type young embryos) or treatment with a CD38-inhibitory antibody will restore fetal trophoblast NAD+/NADH ratios and SIRT1/3 activity, abolish placental senescence, and normalize offspring birth weight without requiring clearance of pre-existing senescent decidual stromal cells.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 0, "text": "Age-accumulated senescent maternal decidual stromal cells secrete a pro-inflammatory senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) dominated by IL-6, IL-1β, and PAI-1 that acts across the maternal-fetal interface to induce paracrine senescence and metabolic dysfunction in adjacent fetal trophoblasts. Pre-conceptional clearance of maternal decidual senescent cells with senolytics or neutralisation of decidual SASP signalling prevents secondary trophoblast senescence and restores fetal growth and offspring metabolic health. Mechanism: During maternal ageing, replicative and oxidative stress in the uterine endometrium causes decidual stromal cells (DSCs) to undergo p16INK4a/p21CIP1-mediated senescence during decidualisation. These senescent DSCs secrete IL-6, IL-1β, TNF-α, and PAI-1 into the maternal-fetal microenvironment, activating JAK/STAT3 and NF-κB pathways in invading fetal extravillous and syncytial trophoblasts. Persistent paracrine inflammatory signalling impairs trophoblast mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation, triggers DNA damage responses, and locks fetal trophoblasts into secondary senescence with reduced nutrient transport capacity. Targeted senolytic elimination of senescent maternal DSCs prior to pregnancy or uterine-specific blockade of SASP secretion interrupts this paracrine cascade. Prediction: In reciprocal embryo transfer experiments where young blastocysts are transferred into aged dams, pre-conceptional maternal treatment with senolytics (such as dasatinib plus quercetin) or decidual-specific deletion of Il6/Stat3 signalling will prevent senescence markers (SA-β-gal, p16, p21) from appearing in genetically young fetal trophoblasts and normalize fetal weight, whereas fetal trophoblast-intrinsic senolytic resistance or mtDNA/metabolite interventions alone will not rescue placental function if maternal decidual SASP remains active.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 2, "text": "Aged maternal decidual and vascular endothelial cells release small extracellular vesicles (sEVs) enriched in oxidized mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) that are internalized by fetal trophoblasts, activating the cytosolic cGAS-STING pathway to drive placental inflammation and senescence. Blocking maternal sEV secretion or inhibiting fetal trophoblast STING signalling prevents placental senescence and restores fetal growth and long-term offspring health. Mechanism: Mitochondrial dysfunction and defective mitophagy in aged maternal decidual and spiral artery endothelial cells cause the packaging of damaged, oxidized mtDNA fragments into CD63+/TSG101+ small extracellular vesicles. These maternal sEVs cross the maternal-fetal interface and are endocytosed by fetal cytotrophoblasts and syncytiotrophoblasts. Upon endosomal escape into the trophoblast cytosol, oxidized maternal mtDNA binds cyclic GMP-AMP synthase (cGAS), generating 2'3'-cGAMP to activate STING, TBK1, IRF3, and NF-κB. This innate immune activation induces type I interferons, pro-inflammatory cytokines, and p21-mediated cell cycle arrest in trophoblasts while suppressing amino acid and glucose transporter expression. Disrupting Rab27a-dependent maternal sEV release or genetically/pharmacologically inhibiting STING (e.g., with H-151) in the fetal compartment halts this nucleic-acid-driven senescence cascade. Prediction: Transferring embryos with trophoblast-specific deletion of Sting1 (Tmem173) into aged wild-type dams, or maternal uterine knockdown of Rab27a, will selectively block placental IRF3 phosphorylation and trophoblast senescence while restoring fetal growth, even when maternal decidual cytokine levels and NAD+ concentrations remain unaltered.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Physiological developmental senescence in fetal syncytiotrophoblasts escalates into pathological placental senescence during maternal ageing because immunosenescent and metabolically exhausted maternal uterine natural killer (uNK) cells fail to clear senescent trophoblasts. Rejuvenating maternal uNK cell metabolic fitness and cytotoxic surveillance restores homeostatic clearance of senescent placental cells and rescues pregnancy and offspring outcomes. Mechanism: Normal placental morphogenesis requires regulated cell fusion and developmental senescence in syncytiotrophoblasts, which are continuously pruned and remodelled by maternal decidual uNK cells recognizing stress ligands (such as NKG2D ligands MICA/B and ULBPs, or mouse RAE-1/MULT1) via perforin- and granzyme-mediated cytotoxicity. In aged mothers, chronic inflammatory exposure and impaired mTORC1/glycolytic metabolism drive uNK cell exhaustion, characterised by high inhibitory receptor expression (PD-1, TIM-3, TIGIT) and defective degranulation. Uncleared developmentally senescent trophoblasts persist, accumulate DNA damage, and secrete a secondary SASP that spreads senescence laterally across the placental labyrinth and chorionic villi. Adoptive transfer of young uNK cells or targeted blockade of inhibitory immune checkpoints on maternal decidual NK cells restores senescent cell surveillance and placental remodelling. Prediction: Adoptive transfer of young functional uNK cells into aged dams at early gestation, or maternal NK-cell-specific deletion of exhaustion markers (such as Pdcd1 or Havcr2), will restore degranulation against NKG2D-ligand-positive trophoblasts, reduce placental senescent cell burden, and normalize spiral artery remodelling and fetal growth without direct manipulation of maternal decidual stromal cells.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Age-related metabolic reprogramming in maternal decidual cells shifts glucose and lipid metabolism toward excessive export of lactate and pro-senescent ceramides across the maternal-fetal barrier, inducing lipotoxic and acidotic stress that triggers fetal trophoblast senescence. Inhibiting maternal decidual ceramide synthesis or normalising intercellular lactate shuttling prevents trophoblast senescence and rescues placental nutrient transport and offspring health. Mechanism: During maternal ageing, insulin resistance and mitochondrial beta-oxidation defects in maternal decidual cells cause accumulation of long-chain ceramides and a compensatory glycolytic shift with high monocarboxylate transporter 4 (MCT4)-mediated lactate efflux. Excess maternal ceramides and lactate are taken up by fetal trophoblasts via lipid transport proteins and MCT1, inducing intracellular acidosis, mitochondrial membrane permeabilisation, lipid peroxidation, and p38 MAPK/p16INK4a activation. Simultaneously, extracellular lactate and oxidized lipids engage GPR81 and TLR4 on local Hofbauer (fetal macrophage) and trophoblast cells, amplifying NLRP3 inflammasome activation. Pharmacological inhibition of maternal serine palmitoyltransferase/ceramide synthases or modulation of decidual MCT4 restores metabolic homeostasis across the interface. Prediction: Lipidomic and fluxomic profiling of the maternal-fetal interface in aged pregnancies will reveal elevated 13C-labelled maternal-to-fetal ceramide and lactate transfer prior to inflammatory cytokine induction, and decidual-specific knockdown of Sptlc2 or Slc16a3 (MCT4) in aged dams will prevent fetal trophoblast senescence and growth restriction despite persistent maternal immune ageing.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42806572", "pmid": "42806572", "doi": "10.1111/acel.70742", "title": "uPAR-Targeting T Cell Engager Exerts Senolytic Effects in Mice and Non-Human Primates With Serum Aminotransferase Activity as a Safety Monitor.", "journal": "Aging Cell", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-29", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a causal senolytic mechanism and its effects on age-related pathology in animal models.", "background": "Senescent cells accumulate with age and can promote tissue dysfunction through persistent inflammatory and remodeling signals. Experimental removal of these cells can improve several age-related phenotypes, supporting cellular senescence as a causal contributor to declining health. Immune-mediated senolysis offers a way to eliminate selected senescent cells, but differences between therapeutic and toxic exposure can complicate translation. A major open problem is whether an externally controllable treatment can achieve effective senolysis in both rodents and primates while providing a practical marker of emerging toxicity.", "question": "Can a dose-titratable immune engager safely eliminate senescent cells and alleviate age-related pathology across mice and non-human primates, and what measurement can guide its safe dosing?", "subject": "Controllable immune-mediated senolysis", "finding": "A GFD-CD3 bispecific T-cell engager targeting uPAR-positive senescent cells caused dose-dependent senolysis and alleviated age-related pathologies in aged mice and non-human primates at low doses. High doses caused hepatotoxicity through T-cell attack on hepatic endothelial cells, while serum aminotransferase monitoring enabled dosing that retained senolytic efficacy without observed adverse effects.", "key_points": [ "GFD-CD3 targets uPAR-positive senescent cells", "Low-dose treatment produces senolysis in mice and non-human primates", "Senolysis alleviates age-related pathologies", "High-dose toxicity results from T-cell attack on hepatic endothelial cells", "Serum aminotransferase activity provides a safety monitor for dose titration" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "phenomenon_absent", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 2, "text": "A protease-masked bispecific immune engager activated locally by senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) matrix metalloproteinases (MMP-2/9) or uPA safely ablates senescent cells in rodents and primates while sparing healthy tissues that share basal target expression. The plasma ratio of cleaved (unmasked) to intact pro-engager serves as a direct pharmacokinetic marker of systemic spillover to guide safe dosing. Mechanism: Pericellular proteases enriched in senescent, fibrotic microenvironments cleave the peptide mask to locally expose the target- and effector-binding domains, restricting cytolytic engagement to aged lesions. When local senescent target sinks become saturated or the administered dose exceeds local proteolytic retention, active unmasked engager leaks into systemic circulation and engages basal antigen on healthy epithelia and endothelia. Prediction: In aged mice and non-human primates, a SASP-protease-activated engager will achieve equivalent senescent cell clearance and functional tissue rejuvenation to an unmasked engager with a significantly wider therapeutic index, and maintaining plasma unmasked-engager levels below a critical threshold will eliminate systemic cytokine elevation and off-tumor/off-senescence tissue injury.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 0, "text": "A short-half-life bispecific T-cell engager targeting urokinase plasminogen activator receptor (uPAR) and CD3 can dose-dependently eliminate senescent cells and alleviate metabolic and fibrotic pathology in aged mice and non-human primates. Circulating soluble uPAR (suPAR) kinetics paired with early serum IL-6-to-IFN-γ ratios provide a quantitative window to guide dosing and separate therapeutic senolysis from systemic cytokine toxicity. Mechanism: Senescent cells across rodents and primates upregulate membrane uPAR and shed suPAR into circulation; cross-linking uPAR-positive cells to CD3-positive T cells induces perforin/granzyme-mediated apoptosis proportional to receptor occupancy. While productive on-target cytolysis causes a transient shedding spike followed by a sustained drop in baseline plasma suPAR and moderate IFN-γ release, supratherapeutic dosing recruits bystander myeloid activation and triggers a disproportionate IL-6 surge. Prediction: Stepwise dose titration of a uPARxCD3 engager in aged mice and macaques will reduce tissue p16/SA-β-gal burden, lower steady-state plasma suPAR, and improve insulin sensitivity and liver fibrosis, whereas doses that elevate the 6-hour serum IL-6/IFN-γ ratio above a defined threshold will precede weight loss and transaminitis that promptly resolve upon pausing infusion.", "strict": 0, "core": 1, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 3 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 4 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 3 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 4, "text": "A two-component switchable system—comprising a long-lived senescent-antigen binder and a short-half-life soluble effector adapter—enables rapid, reversible titration of immune-mediated senolysis across rodents and primates, with the post-dose velocity of plasma alarmin (HMGB1) and target-ectodomain release guiding real-time dose adjustment. Clamping lysis velocity via adapter titration prevents acute inflammatory toxicity in animals with high baseline senescent burden. Mechanism: Rapid synchronous destruction of large senescent cell reservoirs triggers a senolysis-induced inflammatory syndrome analogous to tumor lysis, driven by sudden release of intracellular damage-associated molecular patterns (such as HMGB1 and cell-free mitochondrial DNA) and SASP factors. Because immune synapse formation in a switchable adapter architecture depends strictly on the concentration of the rapidly cleared adapter, stepping down or pulsing the adapter dose throttles the hourly rate of cell lysis to match reticuloendothelial clearance capacity. Prediction: In aged mice and non-human primates with high baseline senescent cell burden, fixed bolus dosing of a potent immune engager will provoke acute HMGB1 surges and systemic inflammatory toxicity, whereas adapter-titrated dosing clamped to keep the 4-hour rate of rise of plasma HMGB1 and shed target antigen within a safe velocity window will achieve equally complete cumulative senolysis and tissue rejuvenation without toxicity.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 1, "text": "An avidity-tuned immune engager fusing the extracellular domain of NKG2D to a CD3- or CD16-binding domain selectively clears senescent cells expressing conserved stress ligands across mice and non-human primates, reversing age-related tissue dysfunction. Acute peripheral blood lymphocyte redistribution (margination depth) and early serum transaminase/cytokine dynamics serve as a real-time physiological gauge to cap dose escalation before healthy-tissue damage occurs. Mechanism: Because individual NKG2D-ligand interactions have moderate affinity, low-to-intermediate concentrations of a multivalent NKG2D engager selectively trigger immune synapse formation on senescent cells with high-density stress-ligand clustering (Rae-1/Mult-1 in mice; MICA/B and ULBPs in primates). Excessive doses overcome this avidity threshold on transiently stressed non-senescent endothelia and hepatocytes, which manifests immediately as pan-vascular lymphocyte margination (acute peripheral lymphopenia) and early hepatic stress before overt organ injury. Prediction: Intermediate doses of an NKG2D-based engager will deplete senescent cells across adipose, hepatic, and pulmonary tissues and improve physical function in both aged mice and non-human primates without organ toxicity, while titration protocols guided by 24-hour peripheral T/NK-cell drop depth and ALT/AST kinetics will prevent dose-limiting hepatotoxicity far more reliably than fixed body-weight dosing.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "A dose-titratable innate immune engager linking CD16A on NK cells and macrophages to conserved senescent surface antigens (such as GPNMB or DPP4) eliminates senescent cells and ameliorates age-related vascular and metabolic decline across mice and primates without inducing T-cell cytokine release syndrome. Circulating endothelial-derived cell-free DNA (cfDNA) and plasma D-dimer levels provide a sensitive early biomarker of vascular senolysis toxicity to constrain dosing. Mechanism: Engaging CD16A drives antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) and macrophage phagocytosis with substantially lower systemic TNF-α and IL-6 amplification than CD3 pan-T-cell cross-linking. Because a major dose-limiting risk of cross-species senolysis is the acute ablation of senescent endothelial cells that structurally maintain aged capillary beds, nascent vascular barrier disruption releases endothelial-methylation-specific cfDNA and fibrinolytic D-dimer prior to hemorrhage or organ edema. Prediction: CD16A-based senolytic engagers will clear senescent cells and improve arterial stiffness and metabolic homeostasis in aged mice and primates with minimal pyrexia or IL-6 release compared to CD3 bispecifics, and capping dose escalation when post-dose plasma D-dimer or endothelial cfDNA rises above baseline variability will prevent vascular leak and coagulopathy.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] }, { "id": "R42748238", "pmid": "42748238", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.aed1961", "title": "Endothelial C/EBPβ/AEP pathway drives vascular deterioration and systemic aging.", "journal": "Sci Adv", "earliest_public_date": "2026-09-16", "suitable": true, "reason": "The paper experimentally establishes a specific causal pathway that links age-related vascular degeneration to systemic senescence and reduced lifespan.", "background": "Microvascular function declines with age, impairing tissue perfusion, nutrient delivery, and waste clearance. Vascular deterioration is associated with dysfunction across multiple organs and with increased frailty and mortality. Cellular senescence and altered metabolic homeostasis are recognized contributors to age-related tissue decline. However, the molecular mechanism by which vascular aging can drive organism-wide aging and shorten lifespan remained unclear.", "question": "What molecular mechanism causes age-related vascular deterioration to promote systemic senescence and shorten lifespan?", "subject": "Vascular control of systemic aging", "finding": "Progressive activation of endothelial C/EBPβ induces AEP, which cleaves NAMPT and thereby causes systemic NAD+ depletion, vascular dysfunction, senescence, and reduced lifespan. Genetic disruption of AEP or expression of cleavage-resistant NAMPT N136A ameliorates these effects, while AEP inhibition or NMN supplementation alleviates age-related vascular decline.", "key_points": [ "Endothelial C/EBPβ activates AEP during aging", "AEP cleaves the NAD+ biosynthetic enzyme NAMPT", "NAMPT cleavage causes systemic NAD+ depletion and senescence", "The pathway drives vascular dysfunction and lifespan reduction", "Blocking AEP or preventing NAMPT cleavage rescues the phenotype" ], "roles": [ "heretical", "cross_domain", "scout" ], "candidates": [ { "id": "H1", "index": 0, "text": "Age-related microvascular rarefaction and impaired vasodilation cause chronic low-grade tissue hypoperfusion and micro-hypoxia, which disrupt cellular NAD+/NADH balance and mitochondrial bioenergetics in parenchymal cells. This metabolic stress triggers mitochondrial dysfunction-associated senescence (MiDAS) across multiple organs and shortens organismal lifespan. Mechanism: Loss of capillary density and reduced endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS)-derived nitric oxide impair oxygen and nutrient delivery while slowing the clearance of lactate and metabolic byproducts. Chronic parenchymal micro-hypoxia stabilizes HIF-1alpha, suppresses PGC-1alpha-dependent oxidative phosphorylation, increases mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mtROS), and lowers the cytosolic NAD+/NADH ratio; this metabolic shift activates AMPK-p53-p21 and p16INK4a pathways, driving widespread parenchymal senescence and systemic insulin resistance. Prediction: Restoring tissue oxygenation or normalizing the parenchymal cytosolic NAD+/NADH ratio (for example, via parenchymal expression of the NADH oxidase LbNOX or NAD+ precursor supplementation) in mice with induced microvascular rarefaction will prevent multi-organ senescence accumulation and lifespan shortening even without rescuing capillary density.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H2", "index": 2, "text": "Age-related insufficiency of endothelial VEGF-VEGFR2 and SIRT1-eNOS signaling—driven by elevated soluble VEGFR1 (sFlt1) decoy trapping—deprives tissues of essential angiocrine trophic factors and nitric oxide. This loss of endothelial-parenchymal paracrine coupling precipitates systemic metabolic decompensation, multi-organ cellular senescence, and shortened lifespan. Mechanism: During aging, alternative mRNA processing increases circulating soluble VEGFR1 (sFlt1) that sequesters VEGF-A, while endothelial NAD+ decline blunts SIRT1 and eNOS-NO-sGC-cGMP signaling. The resulting attrition of capillaries and loss of endothelial angiocrine signals (including nitric oxide, Apelin, Jagged1, and trans-endothelial fatty acid transport proteins) starves adjacent parenchymal cells of trophic cues required for mitochondrial maintenance and stem cell renewal, causing ectopic lipid accumulation, mitochondrial stress, and entry into senescence. Prediction: Neutralizing circulating sFlt1 decoy activity or selectively restoring endothelial VEGF-A/VEGFR2 signaling in aged mice will preserve microvascular density, restore systemic metabolic flexibility, suppress multi-organ senescence markers, and extend median and maximum lifespan relative to controls.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H3", "index": 1, "text": "Senescent and deteriorating microvascular endothelial cells release pro-senescent senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) factors and extracellular vesicles (EVs) directly into the circulation and perivascular niche. This vascular secretome acts as an endocrine amplification system that induces secondary bystander senescence and metabolic dysfunction in distant organs, accelerating mortality. Mechanism: Age-related telomere uncapping, oxidative DNA damage, or mitochondrial DNA leakage in endothelial cells activates NF-kappaB and cGAS-STING signaling, driving the secretion of soluble mediators (such as PAI-1, IL-6, GDF15, and IGFBP7) and exosomes enriched in pro-senescent microRNAs into the bloodstream. Because the microvasculature interfaces directly with all perfused tissues, these circulating signals engage cytokine receptors and innate immune sensors in parenchymal and progenitor cells, triggering p53/p21- and p16INK4a-dependent bystander senescence and impairing systemic glucose and lipid homeostasis. Prediction: Endothelial-specific genetic ablation of SASP or EV release (such as Cdh5-CreERT2-driven deletion of Rela, Sting1, or Rab27a) in aged or endothelial-progeroid mice will block secondary senescence in liver, adipose, muscle, and brain tissues and extend lifespan without requiring a change in basal blood flow.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H4", "index": 4, "text": "Age-related vascular stiffening and disturbed microvascular hemodynamics impair endothelial mechanotransduction, triggering endothelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EndoMT) and perivascular extracellular matrix stiffening. This biomechanical and matricellular remodeling disrupts parenchymal mechanosensing and metabolic transport, propagating cellular senescence organism-wide and shortening lifespan. Mechanism: Loss of physiological laminar shear-stress sensing through endothelial Piezo1 and PECAM1-VEGFR2 complexes downregulates the vasoprotective transcription factors KLF2 and KLF4 while activating TGF-beta/SMAD and YAP/TAZ-mediated EndoMT. Transitioning endothelial cells lose specialized nutrient-transport functions and deposit cross-linked fibrotic matrix proteins (collagens, fibronectin) and pro-senescent matricellular factors (such as CCN1) into the perivascular niche, engaging integrin-FAK-p38 signaling in neighboring parenchymal cells to induce p16INK4a/p21-mediated senescence and metabolic dysfunction. Prediction: Endothelial-specific maintenance of laminar shear-stress transcriptional programs (via inducible endothelial Klf2/Klf4 expression or inhibition of endothelial TGF-betaR1 signaling) in aged mice will block EndoMT and perivascular fibrosis, preserve tissue mechanical compliance, prevent parenchymal senescence induction, and prolong lifespan.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] }, { "id": "H5", "index": 3, "text": "Age-associated breakdown of the microvascular barrier and impaired perivascular waste clearance permit the extravasation of plasma proteins and accumulation of damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) in the interstitium. These retained factors trigger chronic innate immune activation in tissue-resident macrophages and stromal cells, driving paracrine senescence across organs and reducing longevity. Mechanism: Degradation of the endothelial glycocalyx, downregulation of tight and adherens junctions (claudin-5 and VE-cadherin), and loss of Tie2-mediated pericyte coverage increase microvascular permeability while impairing interstitial and glymphatic fluid drainage. Extravasated pro-inflammatory plasma proteins (such as fibrinogen and immunoglobulins) and un-cleared metabolic waste products activate TLR4, RAGE, and the NLRP3 inflammasome in perivascular macrophages, generating sterile inflammation and reactive oxygen species that induce DNA damage and paracrine senescence in surrounding parenchymal cells. Prediction: Stabilizing endothelial barrier integrity and pericyte coverage (for example, via Tie2 agonism, Angiopoietin-2 blockade, or depletion of extravasated fibrinogen) will prevent interstitial plasma protein deposition, abrogate tissue inflammasome activation, reduce systemic senescence burden, and extend lifespan despite persistent intrinsic endothelial aging.", "strict": 0, "core": 0, "judgeScores": [ { "judge": "gpt-5.6-sol", "score": 2 }, { "judge": "claude-opus-5-5", "score": 1 }, { "judge": "grok-4.7", "score": 2 } ] } ] } ] }, "sourceHashes": { "protocol.json": "f68582029dd625762c5a2852eb00a711068a7ec5a9b6d8a3aa92a82ef180264c", "cohort.json": "864112330b7b49bbc4919e1d7a8eee78054581ec16d87a2b8dfcbbdbb2d448f9", "coin.json": "40c4ec19067fc6f8c512b5b31775efe8a64f1782ecc28df25d46af4859dce74d", "preprint-recheck/42581103.json": "5c1941ae2fa9fe444d25717a6043a1adc53684b153863d14dc93c2b70494e4ef", "preprint-recheck/42601407.json": "4e2ce010756ef968110e0470a823c56a35bbf1bc1c2be05cc22ee1ff4484e8d4", "preprint-recheck/42605193.json": "d2a6dc7deb692653cf5b257ad54ab3e0601daee8e9bdbd4eb0c8b3a86827f810", "preprint-recheck/42608398.json": "2affc7ebfb766320eb6e1e333d57932249d82f651c766bec4420a4add277e2f5", "preprint-recheck/42627902.json": "4eef147ac314b026898553f24abc4b9d77411a701c90952630a834cf7a21a3a9", "preprint-recheck/42630044.json": "2802601671cc252ae8d238ff7510b7543b3cb6ed83502a373300fdac3caf3818", "preprint-recheck/42639736.json": "113e459f6757f74a8bfd48dd293ad6864e4766b953ec484da64db7d4019173d2", "preprint-recheck/42642518.json": "74beaa73d2bc399a8bf6174ac8af57d37a132113c3acc68e61a8cef05c81a207", "preprint-recheck/42642521.json": "2fbe5ceb76034a368c52157301a2d18aff0f7eaabf227ffadce6a8795e6b9f9a", "preprint-recheck/42647119.json": "9a5f475c801f07a93364ec5218fcd1b93f25d61525ecd7e911a6bdca5d7bcd74", "preprint-recheck/42647635.json": "ff359c36fac074a2a6a6ea150b5fd756c27519c6951a73cfbba40bf8905445de", "preprint-recheck/42663085.json": "e833a970ab954dc73ad2c59c3762319f93f08b4358729baf05ed22353a2e3b51", "preprint-recheck/42664348.json": "020547c9c8ed1f12e2e2a325b4b7a864c6f6457b337c1187d784bf40da847464", "preprint-recheck/42665751.json": "1454efa58125ff0fe9961560518a56d7b719a3d008256220c035d74df4bb8e10", "preprint-recheck/42689491.json": "ee5ba161a2c3f81cd9063221a58eb04c5f6a2301ae4dd34edaccfeb772c7afb1", "preprint-recheck/42696595.json": "5a65b7d7d64161ca5e8f56993d67e7b3ed5fe72f1978587bca35ef4a8b2137bc", "preprint-recheck/42698274.json": "8fc555d4d0b13711f43d4ee79b499d643ab12262c248aaaf4598f1b311cb0f2a", "preprint-recheck/42717261.json": "22b31ffdc3b5f0153e076f4ae82c350df1804b64f5785f36427796332f649ae2", "preprint-recheck/42723546.json": "ede3def9d1235fdab9b58109d3d912ced36e4bd4f3cbee9b66a728d9d9d86648", "preprint-recheck/42725837.json": "f882512cfc78cf5aadd082ffa7de355562009cef2c7249aeaefec9577e23ed77", "preprint-recheck/42736449.json": "24ca01968ef074a621248e48ac4495d4c6af08c981f10d300ec756ae177f9114", "preprint-recheck/42744804.json": "6f91cb12f10c40f65f9a9296f3787ef64b1a38dd967019ce86eb9f65f7dd25ca", "preprint-recheck/42749700.json": "41a8c4349c3d4822633ebd7df038e8fe0538e12c791e9250a6b1f1fb54389a6b", "preprint-recheck/42758848.json": "a5b6ffd09182c55303af260ede2be8f75daa8b2afa91224de1566506a725acf3", "preprint-recheck/42759510.json": "03ed3241592a911eb7afb17f3420769cdc7cb842c5dacb762c03ad658bfcbe41", "preprint-recheck/42775695.json": "7154e3d9594f685a0597d197a1bd248e9b2c74877b93432c77bbd7d12e0fb40f", "preprint-recheck/42775698.json": "4e62373433b432017d88e093edf9e3c89b6ce919e1061333f365ceed9a8a7746", "preprint-recheck/42786310.json": "a442312ce7d33e857a4fcb17fac731988aacb02d551100a93487817ed98266d8", "preprint-recheck/42805954.json": "63ce449723c29c4a63d6ecefcce6d11e7c108c9a5de7d8ea7c9fbb416e11e5fd", "preprint-recheck/42810392.json": "f1108d01df89c43887402bc2d08fe08f32243bf9a140ad3eb1ca6f199b97a314", "preprint-recheck/42811497.json": "097b90b1703ac5ae612729004a77dd19449c322f8845b046eb035f9e9fe0072e", "preprint-recheck/42821663.json": "8a1778e859adc325aa08b5525ca65ac3dcb3a636c9a8a284bd008b36cff94cd1", "preprint-recheck/42822442.json": "92fffd9dd32d8ad347a092b994733904cf5fae7fde0b399bef5b4d9c1d85961f", "preprint-recheck/42826184.json": "dc24d46df16c4b3ab0da58ee2eac854f2cd03711f682c9d27c3e0810dd9f2d31", "preprint-recheck/42839094.json": "207c04f165fca3b57e4d1cadacf86bebd57a899fee996d735c8e677196d62908", "preprint-recheck/42841227.json": "778ce001b65a73ac02f1542baea8dfd3a02b815e4034e74615f3015a4da35c5e", "preprint-recheck/42842666.json": "4b55f4f514e7761a1b7faf11cdf8788a8aa7688d93db4eaf0e4b0a90657dc49d", "preprint-recheck/42844664.json": "f4ddd99e5df65233f9d7861b78580a4c7f77401cb698914145c9319b496953f4", "preprint-recheck/42853938.json": "813a879cd9f49c09a3f2ddad4c35adbd14336982fe6e5dc944d955b52472fa1f", "preprint-recheck/42858183.json": "862570ebf41aa383d24f443fa691690a2a60d10040fc14ba3df8563e74a7ecc6", "preprint-recheck/42806945.json": "1fdac0ec43a27c04bc2daced28859367146490e040f9eef443748df92876306a", "preprint-recheck/42723144.json": "225d8029290c9677182ec2440505ed8c7e9751cf0ad61f1242888da77225b4eb", "preprint-recheck/42808804.json": "be67b12477022ac349ee6f036a700d9ea52f4c7000dbcf9967b8d6b2c591ab86", "preprint-recheck/42585340.json": "24c0d67efecb5d4a38f54c979f38298e37c3f630b42d0f9f0c348947d1f926cf", "preprint-recheck/42669067.json": "619a4dda793b2d8f7cc1d8073291d6138253f52bea88a9480018ab156cc7170d", "preprint-recheck/42811065.json": "e9d5ea290a527f68e6ac8a57ea8aeae895b5bfb02ff27f91aec40092bfe80cb9", "preprint-recheck/42841610.json": "4c4dd91ebaf7c4b3a2a09c363a2ba223458eeec1245921554369f921fe79f9f7", "preprint-recheck/42806003.json": "27c2712abf56b5bec2678ec32c6b54f65595b87ae6d5e3db5a3f099cf2c0a62c", "preprint-recheck/42806572.json": "c83c0e0310d9b91da2a38b9a74bbf87cf3d0be564244a411803061b3e26349b7", "preprint-recheck/42748238.json": "5c804e68b13403709f4054269ab8bacd884dc483643992ddcd33e61b040f47e2", "infrastructure-recovery.json": "2588b71f2944614d03e1d947b96a30f77ff99129630d4953d2d4122c55213dd2", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42581103.attempt-1.json": "f43a0015febbba58368fc907efd0e723c183fc0e4ca06e197e5603edd93e5192", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42581103.attempt-2.json": "ea6ee955347a8ae34a286ba8cc2a0b71eca609d5d41a08e619a2cce44a82de32", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42601407.attempt-1.json": "a495cb3043512c280e6e6ed46089f55273e5271b607cc56f2fc1347ab9dbd306", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42601407.attempt-2.json": "2c2b3a95c5537213fbd894a42e766e1834f90db17885ccca41764e850bb24944", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42605193.attempt-1.json": "5095d7aa70104849b982d2381a76efe08cf342bb3a1baf6b88560a6095989c4e", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42605193.attempt-2.json": "9354325f5dbbefa551762470155bd88339224a97c4dab1c705936fa66e5b2ace", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42581103.attempt-1.json": "e48a6c78068ace961d1773c790ee890ab21eda62e46bacffe61031120760e77b", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42581103.attempt-2.json": "e6dbeab5bb5346e8af5a8fb9c3d843158c23fe2ea9b47bc12349986724bd88f6", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42601407.attempt-1.json": "944cbf20d72a6c2131ee88ef40f2928130a162873ee7cbf62012fb49f460caa1", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42601407.attempt-2.json": "106b80eb9314bad85ae5ffd8d61a7d19bd3310c8cb42a75fa978c56dc8733a5e", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42605193.attempt-1.json": "46f63986893ad13da02c1a20043799263d505e0ab887af4cb2a81f09744a8239", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42605193.attempt-2.json": "1912ca595208e05eb859c4fd83b962f284d9608f03dbb49725d8888b4e1588da", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gpt-6-astra/R42581103.attempt-1.json": "85b2b7d13dbb725c3f42652230e240e59e3476524ee4e4533434891bee3af7ba", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gpt-6-astra/R42581103.attempt-2.json": "da6d70324ec6b9c7f37f16db5afc347374f066053b6181c37b57171868499730", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gpt-6-astra/R42601407.attempt-1.json": "6807f57ed36bb9e3349167513d51d0e81f07454d1efa68ec0cdb678dd4331cb5", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gpt-6-astra/R42601407.attempt-2.json": "818c3e18699cc33cf50c239c73a4b797863deb9c750e2a51a30dfdc88b10b679", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gpt-6-astra/R42605193.attempt-1.json": "c0f1aaac60a2c02a79dac8b7f4dab62e1df4eda60322132c812107091b92a2cd", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/gpt-6-astra/R42605193.attempt-2.json": "98808893f75d59e3904a150042cd4a59c04d56361c9e8f9db3a4f069c99a3f51", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/grok-4.5/R42581103.attempt-1.json": "27c8e5f641414a29c7b02b6a5ac42308e7a8a71cbb4b64492a5ac3b484e2b0fd", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/grok-4.5/R42581103.attempt-2.json": "c17faace38ce08135b1c587ecf6a79248d4ca5c7c4c9ceb512ded205dd963ab3", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/grok-4.5/R42601407.attempt-1.json": "3c35df7497dc36e27b20c3c184e48947ad3f75221086a830638c88ebf5590c19", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/grok-4.5/R42601407.attempt-2.json": "8f509fee49a8dda181b7a2d97c82e3c5ec371735c8cd27acd1760d0455f7e2d1", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/grok-4.5/R42605193.attempt-1.json": "8372df5993fa10a66eb03f247a33cbdf5972c12f1b45f7080ec734ff4b1561c5", "infrastructure-failure-20261023T2205/runs/grok-4.5/R42605193.attempt-2.json": "63f543b940d7e1bbb6b291fc0db6dad07bae5f5624ed72d575c8437250aaef07", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/config.json": "854e1744010a649a011df9ba89988133719075131d08b26f5ef4cb48ef7ee282", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/requests.json": "9a905175f54f365366681de8ad0d3ce095a9ef9e91c29a15b268e985bd7ec7cb", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/isolation-audit.json": "2487925a5f8a8554fa3df88a3b3fbb11f0c892cc074d9ea5463cde378194a9d9", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/transport-attempts.json": "90e874b72434c501c2545b48e44c1f096b6c470609c385dd75c2ae6d2f139a03", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/eligibility.json": "9d79993092fec634aa7241667c81a05b6bf0929a239e989e31ba27be69bb693a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42581103.attempt-1.json": "82ddfec4ab65eeefafc63b76932e12b3213f6a521297864051f6972d9790a43d", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42581103.json": "548b7a56b8392535494e1d0f3e93cdbb4f41d952d1ec9b16e49d263b92e6c6a7", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42601407.attempt-1.json": "d54d4da239506cc7719acb59690de02c34fc041cd094c01d3da12a2fef8f6b3c", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42601407.json": "57e5407d667d857abbb9283c84573e8191ac4406ad87b206281839b3d046990f", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42605193.attempt-1.json": "ab86a41ee3aab2bd4b218b4835aa960f59f7fa30096b82eb9eb8f3f59047e404", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42605193.json": "6f951ca4cb38c3b5d929e6c42ffcd26a045c46216818a579211cb64f99fdf3df", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42608398.attempt-1.json": "eedb0a71a79ac3d6587b138692395a4dc8288bdb4a327c2f3d15503616e03d98", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42608398.json": "0bf342cedf9df2cade37a1e17ea19f470be2e79a8b5b2d76478f717572df0908", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42627902.attempt-1.json": "6a7e0759c7392b58d7b6bf21a2ac977cae9ea229fb42a307d175c1a70deb4fea", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42627902.json": "532ebc5313f6a1f6d391a858806337c66fb28f91a5f4b458595018bb8bd45b3b", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42630044.attempt-1.json": "e4568f5882c85bcba0452b357f75b5d819a320c7df61d6faf608e129d20bf31a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42630044.json": "ae291d93212fd7fa2c693ec00364d071b9758f748a0c5218c39ad1b3e21d2373", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42639736.attempt-1.json": "891a6690640f9ec1f2a8888f31700153fe21819510afea9c1e91e7be69e769b6", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42639736.json": "e2ab68539f9bdf9991d50112b611ab6a6cc1aeea3a4de1e80bf57d0340df724b", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42642518.attempt-1.json": "3ad2297e27b1a7d8b27b3a1f1686a98428d4403156ca0ff853feca99a6374b1c", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42642518.json": "a843c0dffb0021064dfc3b0593243e081d05964b3b4530b4a67b4690d79f089e", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42642521.attempt-1.json": "6cbf5ec261e7a6ea01c9c3dadda3361a9196ae45e818df764f85e909f2f64913", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42642521.json": "760154d094bce2f5058b9526cf495fa4277edbdc662694c07ff6c5c96bffc319", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42647119.attempt-1.json": "c60ae6aa94ef077590b1dc78b6130aab3bf2dbd0f963c771b1cb290a95d5b5db", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42647119.json": "d82baac037a153637879488e3337b393c744fbbf004d886ca06d00c45495cea2", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42647635.attempt-1.json": "f3f2106953bba4dbad1b46449f449e40444901e7f58bf06aaf3a80832e7f7f7a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42647635.json": "0c7a6560631c9277adadeac9283b720a941701fa241e7994c3c2fe658f7d9721", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42663085.attempt-1.json": "0df2f12c4000a63bc7dfa5c716ba122ba3287e645a7a1982f586a43142c4197a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42663085.json": "7a48f82a371a7910c6a0696d58834b2c67c9880ef1d7ed93512e6ade10807a14", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42664348.attempt-1.json": "684a248b5f50c97917905ffeb4185e7b1f16c793f0398b10320b8f5fdb75b087", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42664348.json": "4d8371cd9b9917d44beec54afe6cfcd872accdc061547b30dad03eb6e079a7a6", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42665751.attempt-1.json": "f47a071d7fc624b951f244d50e8f20868b52313e2adc1f6b3bd9733d94867078", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42665751.attempt-2.json": "1009587fbf29cd3161d82e710426268bb2942404a1ecc2d3eac38d1440449371", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42665751.json": "9f1450ae3c06203ca73429afb2e220d436ead18501a7de54b8c488f00ab2beef", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42689491.attempt-1.json": "44f99bd0edb1bc1c4cfeba1e25ba201bcbd5c1bcf74e7aab8c55e33b3dce74a2", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42689491.attempt-2.json": "8fcc4665799cc7e8a8c60b436ad2814837b845fa54d854f943a089822f498885", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42689491.json": "eacae5346b6c052ebbc0ce46605821d3f0b0672f75809d0cfe8ad55bef5bb62d", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42696595.attempt-1.json": "92b133b8a3fd4446111f22f509d9afefa23e89b63daebba2427a0577a87ef519", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42696595.json": "60babe52afca264bf5743a21394477b9098a21c22e53c8d4d140fe09c1ba1e02", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42698274.attempt-1.json": "5b2e433d4b9b0713b5b852c4651b3c1648a5afd23e702cafccc94afc7dae61cd", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42698274.attempt-2.json": "d02d41842580f24e3654c519da00b28ac74b51f8d1a3707ee0c5dee8c5768245", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42698274.invalid.json": "07c3f16958434f0ad5a7095a2f5a63f0fb750174977ea6948d2a07a13c2f2924", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42717261.attempt-1.json": "41c7b39db0208b66437a1d41c73132438b20caac245d61882c4fc261c6752d71", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42717261.json": "8d786a7d82d0283f7b4a485ae463b6c0d19453eae91a1d239b97fe79d74a5498", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42723546.attempt-1.json": "d6eecbcb5a4211b1d7bc4ec6dd11a0f6d4c1f7095bcff7dc340a6863581ce97a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42723546.json": "97e5051140ac77cbada95921da0342af5f6b4287b6ed6274ae5570803c1ce999", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42725837.attempt-1.json": "2300211224d89f8a24c7ded9221ddb88f7cb6f1556f57c51f8524c876bbf82dd", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42725837.attempt-2.json": "2429b7e30b0e44e4451e51553cf48c5fc91c341691dfb59f7701bd12d8f3a9cf", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42725837.json": "8053852ecd90bfa1bfcda85050f7cea63e4cdfa319a0a79d9d2377c0c8f7385f", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42736449.attempt-1.json": "12a3dace9ca08783c031af6aaf8cdba605f07f84df6b23271aa8696cd9a2788c", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42736449.attempt-2.json": "7689e45b6eada4365e19126a0ec668e3fcc0627ae4a7fe028430a402225076de", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42736449.invalid.json": "75c6fefc96465c19b182f2e29baa1fcf6d021360c5e78000c13efa5e817f1345", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42744804.attempt-1.json": "b30caa21babac396f408058c06aeffccf9cbd8e587cb467eba8ca61e463778ed", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42744804.json": "2158318e4668ebb428dd73f3ce435d7dc0bac4d9d169558307be84b3ba0ca188", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42749700.attempt-1.json": "1aa810ede2461781417c14bdc29896e9ac4359b6c1fb7c60c24537f2532518b1", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42749700.json": "85cbfaaf8251ba81ff2d787240e3f1232575c58691b6045aa3ef94256ef442fb", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42758848.attempt-1.json": "2f41e4be67d60d45ebfea76d5c35630a746321a8d85048bafbce950830d2303d", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42758848.json": "316a678305ff6b643280d7dc84655a6d3ecb427614826b3e26180545e25ad1bc", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42759510.attempt-1.json": "dcfcfb9e46b78004d162d4d80cb7c64198ba77f5e3f63537d01ea3c20b010bf1", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42759510.json": "18578f2de58bb117f4ba58af210b2fdc5d17cb596c8769f3403e133e1262d01e", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42775695.attempt-1.json": "708f4795cd35010d0024a52d36478f32d7a6e2d5f96f44645893a22a7110f379", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42775695.json": "2377031a582023df69e01ddccdf40f798d16c73bb50443e38717cb5b05f21b19", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42775698.attempt-1.json": "9065bc77164377f952c629a3d1f656b5a4cb263e8568c5804c288b92e50d8324", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42775698.json": "c21d4ce173652f6dbd5959a41b1b3a0a5317b6a7c905f3b1da02c35ce071a922", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42786310.attempt-1.json": "7fd2fd578d448a415644c9f8a91ddb4dbfa2bf1c7827abc47199eea5e5752d36", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42786310.json": "2a3fec6c812cfd4ccb43d97b51095a600d0f1330828c04fd24f5cb67559d893d", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42805954.attempt-1.json": "78f09fcff2a928c075c492624847ff2fb4cb3db17ce952baae746999d87a1b7a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42805954.json": "5619766c2bafae83d31997c8cb51b595414728e36cd0ab16b49d4a9ba473121c", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42810392.attempt-1.json": "a83b866cbf0b2471eaca062958f33e9590a2e313dd167ea8dcc70cd507949ebf", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42810392.json": "93c946d5b5bcbabf96ae4e1b978e17196ffdc4ba0d39c6377ca3eccdc8f7f028", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42811497.attempt-1.json": "87ef51b07863a5c2ada93a8d6de5cb181ca8c430033905a06f86f6dc251d6955", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42811497.json": "aeeb2ebdf880762c757843c177c7bfb5b63a17e94a0aa14f30dede23ff438f3f", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42821663.attempt-1.json": "2a40a55672958a978eb9503d608735fe16c889aed3b0055e810afd0deaa13a48", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42821663.json": "7e7ed2e25c014bfd2f7e03b2989f3f17f6e918f804da11810b6c7d1b9d2f207a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42822442.attempt-1.json": "969d0f533a6ae6baba318eb2e2ce0522e30bcdd6b9a4c73f919eb84c0d427f91", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42822442.json": "67793aad469ccf80291bb3f1033b518bc470ee59f5a0f9db311a496e83b10faa", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42826184.attempt-1.json": "9c396e52f8ca3dee666bafe14e82500d716b62cbaf2ce8d2c99ec7869e100a38", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42826184.json": "bd24328a284c9d8d14ef6b01a584b82e7a62673187c3351fd1ba4683686e40e7", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42839094.attempt-1.json": "63f62ebaf4b4fd2c3a344084aeb65380d77fa303b13e593b3a52eb2ba9de890f", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42839094.json": "fbaabebf1bed93bf7a4002bddeb61693c8be7cfc070b29e440e8a099825f97d5", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42841227.attempt-1.json": "5eb61f546ffb250e6411c8c49ddd53f15e271e32c14b0f65034b5c3fc95d38c3", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42841227.json": "96897e85fa75be83a3e923ca3aed7eff6565b08eb93ca1dc17bccda4d329f8bc", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42842666.attempt-1.json": "798f50aaffaf45998a201e82330fc7ba504babfaf2d0525ae4d02e52ad2224f3", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42842666.json": "7cc14bfa248e5ed5abb067fa7ff87f716e1e8b674b2a5d706a50ae1862208996", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42844664.attempt-1.json": "d04d5e07eba6a99c8360a2cdd1231b3f5d796553399213d08fa4ecf21d3386b4", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42844664.json": "0204ce018f2b9a08555d567a2cdb25e5211258d41d2ab3dbd2ede57e7a9e10c4", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42853938.attempt-1.json": "98af3c68a1ace4eb9233558f52ba75e89b500d3b17d77392f48c9fe41a5d1c8e", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42853938.json": "028c32d5bc707b23abeaadea2f68747b85df0aa83c231a7a9b50ff33f5b60a6f", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42858183.attempt-1.json": "5a1252b495c26a00d81bf4fa946f99f9c65334cd546fb6814b8d5c2745609122", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42858183.json": "a458e413e45a4f3545f96e03d211f37c6c331b17622fead8a37a1d6234485330", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42806945.attempt-1.json": "62b41fa5b6b6ed27e88d04b03209be9c7d1d97ced0ea00aa383804b92d5b6ce3", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42806945.json": "6bb4c2ef587023d4337fd7ed0148b5cddec27b86cdcd20ec45f74bb58435556e", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42723144.attempt-1.json": "fa176fd587081c84e5bd45b0fabaa2de0513ddb6633a023b8a92f8902a55a023", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42723144.attempt-2.json": "a6f234f693ae354b84c256bc3f04f5d24f64fce44b6a27f8e2a63799fcd63195", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42723144.json": "c6e4e7002dcdc1082724d0aad7a4b5e461b2398b3a1322126c3f2f4610d0633e", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42808804.attempt-1.json": "d9811abea9f352bafca119976f85da1904990fbbe7a3e08aa79e2c286ff4ccdf", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42808804.json": "c75ce1c93e56d1850aefde7fe46751381534e257d1d78ef0b42b7ba0ca5e77cd", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42585340.attempt-1.json": "63f235f257fe030200f925f0d81283cf1bb0293a9e4fe13bad47a6e4294b7b10", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42585340.json": "f7bfde4e30d441b1b595b5186468a05b15f6a6e33954507848a49d44c1644495", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42669067.attempt-1.json": "73776dbe060d2127844c3b0732aeee90c4829b10c552d2584e167110a67e3936", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42669067.json": "91d03fb4c4d80c5e0c5ab97477be084d36860bc3e4a4a3daf74e33a549911534", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42811065.attempt-1.json": "28653e8ded6c6591712e7227ca8140caae81eeb4849c81aca8b9d389e41b45e8", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42811065.json": "079da7b83ec86d71bc70663e2b051e87b38861f8b4d06ce88d6e1d14c0358442", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42841610.attempt-1.json": "339946309f293d9146265f985ea6b2c0544b5c1b6bbc8daaaef69c4889fc6dd9", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42841610.json": "81c5c92be95cee19c81c425d405fd969e03f36c189bbabca0f81e7bc92769fa7", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42806003.attempt-1.json": "674fe5d55f76697b914aa68144e66f137212b2e59d1f1fac774e270263df951a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42806003.json": "1148b5b5682109f476159ce8aafe97e8a8ff31cdcff54378de7a22526b8b2dac", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42806572.attempt-1.json": "c438f35dd0ef4e1a72026e5db99ce6371bfa3f7f48824bf5b5ff85c01ca2245a", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42806572.json": "30d2bf683d7a9b48bca0ed730a026c58ad325d522407d5ccbf04fcaa0c1d94d4", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42748238.attempt-1.json": "94ff6d21897ba5209062a548c62853303f6c98185dfc8c2a19f7f88d16bd46a1", "runs/claude-sonnet-5-5/R42748238.json": "71f6bde83d3286889f2d8c19d67cb6c7de08abd4959aa775fac3a6ddaf695905", "runs/gpt-6-astra/config.json": "700822656fb51025af7058318973767db9cf8aac5e6c6a5484aee88e23873390", "runs/gpt-6-astra/requests.json": "9cd31503bfdf7e08060b55dce6d980045add89ef2518853be5e4d926f60f38e9", "runs/gpt-6-astra/isolation-audit.json": "40633f358136af526c43658a9461df505f9f4a84b7440f4c4d92c772c0e6eaa2", "runs/gpt-6-astra/transport-attempts.json": "27fef4d1630245c17bab817327ed87f1996a7fda5f5157492e448c60e9ba937e", "runs/gpt-6-astra/eligibility.json": "aef1ab9e8a9310a89b7c5a882ecf100b6f30972611b49e21d3f7dd86af0f07e2", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42581103.attempt-1.json": "00a7bcfed2aa3589a6e5fcb5a8a4aa40b38a79a32052a70a27e27a6041864677", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42581103.json": "ee0d84a907558273ba3ccd35e5acefea4b5ab3b5befd4a777ce16d0860bba55d", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42601407.attempt-1.json": "43f18136f3ef3318688ea4a1c5e84aaa3b3b9b51648b9031c8f80256fc1c80db", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42601407.json": "0bffc9a74fbafef3bf40bfe6b8cf30905496d895e930a3fcd3eedb74e8585441", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42605193.attempt-1.json": "f6442eacda575ece15165554141c8db9616211614c07ad5414761f1f28673fd4", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42605193.json": "7afdea756af11eaa70a52f43cf99719a5065030777e56a0691a59bf026e22110", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42608398.attempt-1.json": "bd418e9180dbc581cd1a05336ca46c537eb56172cc45d733309c3d2881db34c6", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42608398.json": "19d59d5ecb464c195c911fd5bf09c8f30f111f3c6c8893fba9ca5b95b4356145", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42627902.attempt-1.json": "67df4d072ea34d923fc584eb5247b9bcf3ef90ee389fb1f10ebe9b4d8dcc7e6c", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42627902.json": "4f09c77cdf1d81dc051168e96bbe6a4ce1a12993abed89d832c46674b4b49ee4", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42630044.attempt-1.json": "c93a142fab969709d39285316bc81a453eae68a518d4e1a7f95916f20e2f06bf", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42630044.json": "31223dfcca8b31344cd304c81b9f6a996f7a9c477a62477dd7c36f7ad0626d34", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42639736.attempt-1.json": "f02d5a67c39d39eb77291825930bf21ca050173b3b5f4112295dbf764d5387fb", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42639736.json": "b7c287e6a5b0dfde4c61e6a75f7f4e2850edf5a16d718bb3e3ee0de96a124d63", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42642518.attempt-1.json": "04b3891ad6559dc9cd62935ad056c322a9ca7c5ceed193ab7d127028a44176c4", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42642518.json": "42c1720be32cdb04ab790a85029e234854ab88e795bea7fd80b2bbe5cd484a36", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42642521.attempt-1.json": "3cee3f7233917d52da385899a45fd01c7f5bce891353233ecd31d61bc8b38a11", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42642521.json": "e53249189816dc3d5e79100d35b3ee504bc7bdb3ded4ce366924d74f2c82b707", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42647119.attempt-1.json": "6bb3a00a2818c0adf8455c34fe6edb5c1715f786aa51e95c71756f6a69ff695f", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42647119.json": "885173532fde2ca49e9d15248e385526714e1de0ba8eaf1ea9a7ef3c9bd3df9d", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42647635.attempt-1.json": "0f55dc13f5c4270cca72d8f9e58b17c65b96098ed29fadb8a197572425c48dd4", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42647635.json": "24bc35b3cd40fc307ca1609337a42d971fa831aaf96babe45e900861d17c2fc1", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42663085.attempt-1.json": "200051ca761fb425c23b9ee4bc342b91e4e0652813b01156ac0a65b8c53cad71", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42663085.json": "14ced1cf0003717135c0bb87e1299926b30c7c2b0c7620755c54ec2b9a330ac7", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42664348.attempt-1.json": "e3659d27212cbac06105a83cddacf5916da318d6cc56b0b3a03f89eaf3df884a", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42664348.json": "2b5308cfb95846bc4a6dd84740af4d3ea55ad84aa2be4bb10bda4a3aa895e469", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42665751.attempt-1.json": "7a2b05a47dac1fe4c2c883e9d75f79cb50787206b12a1ba7fab832453e162233", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42665751.json": "5a8274c21d5f433152dd324808fb3e7d31c2385e43b93ea240368eb0616838df", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42689491.attempt-1.json": "6e7a5406d6d21c9cc81206b9db44addab891ca53d8c426bc95b1f0560cbb452d", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42689491.json": "a98218055f893016f2031a63a807595acabf87521e20a0efe600b4defd2b65d4", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42696595.attempt-1.json": "22a5411e066cb4845a7ad9e8c1c0520ce75273a6dae3c53114192869b19a1c5d", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42696595.json": "e6a1a561447c04f2a4c765302a91ee136551cfbc5ef2a6af33a58e48d7e253d9", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42698274.attempt-1.json": "5968f6a6906c8799254113e304087e677c7fd151b684683cb0fa93cc4b7341fd", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42698274.json": "79394022ddadee6c286eb90a81487709417ea77acf8b27d1b4cc46bff4758080", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42717261.attempt-1.json": "a7b5ddbd64067c7161ea0ca2c6918a15b43cbac2dfc825d4fb632abe4b29c879", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42717261.json": "63703f2b50ed763b4d9c2559dbe1b5cc1cf9c959b93ec8f12566c3e33f6140ef", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42723546.attempt-1.json": "f6b8321a9a60271c55d3f28498874a0c1ede5596c2185eed21afb53c9a816381", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42723546.json": "2e29dedba42942e766e7b67e5c14455f828e80d70f4ca5a475fbe57c603870ca", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42725837.attempt-1.json": "212acd5f034968ccb1f60a8a2b3b19ff264dcae8910cc46b58814b5b75a58981", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42725837.json": "76901b0c62565df2c98684c889a27d6b280cb9c9eeaa4417b5299373316e5e13", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42736449.attempt-1.json": "ab35002adf416ce6392d5ad48a48f94588710fe3502c01fcc50195cc7cc2aee7", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42736449.json": "0cac14f0ddcba680b06902856ca974f5d6abac0e754f58da00e24d291c1f547d", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42744804.attempt-1.json": "5be3032d0369f2afa5681607d7c6259d096f110e4619a705e049d072bdac7256", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42744804.json": "0abb520b1b34307943b8cf1b031b0023a6b879db13513e463f8eda71cc955546", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42749700.attempt-1.json": "1aa669768957970456a8ba7f7c3ec09a5620cb72d5e8b2c9c8eed42eb544439c", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42749700.json": "c6e24b51b58f38a2ab2deb3ca92aa6c03c662a7cab4ae5765737085bca7a8f8e", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42758848.attempt-1.json": "96b5fc516c5163d2397edc784da6809034c46bdf519782fc56ae7f516b189522", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42758848.json": "b3402eae546c3c517a2aaca3c868a1d168bf703d20db997b6d41a1a172e73dab", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42759510.attempt-1.json": "8d250b37c6f25476963b164924cd3915a91bdf461b6876742f280f08fc350694", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42759510.json": "0c3bc70d66a94e767a874b2ec7dbe7df0c3a708f34f8cd0370447d3c44d6e099", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42775695.attempt-1.json": "ddafbca62c62286bbc2f8abf1ed2e00dcb7d8d90cac858c1832f1b956b086024", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42775695.json": "143580bc7aae38693f23ef23761c71ef3b9be70cdf90cdf1cee2396bcafc2d8f", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42775698.attempt-1.json": "2bf2912a68d23480b7c97e85c3bd51e86833b124c21b0bd6d4d8ac7c56103ce8", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42775698.json": "17d7de074b1742df083bc8ef3d932f4811201c520be8b38a5e43b591bd25fe87", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42786310.attempt-1.json": "5175abea399a38b67aec932c6044d0ef23eb7546e03b0ad08d2c3c2fff3ce50e", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42786310.json": "c92c5ccd08e7c469ee4ad6b8cd2cf1a4d9907db8c7fd3aa3143496b6a965729a", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42805954.attempt-1.json": "75279dd3d656e5e13c145fede894b750f116c29d1441938f0609d41448972732", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42805954.json": "677df466c03cda8660bd4863857a25397744fc1bef309b858d636a953028c53d", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42810392.attempt-1.json": "c90717357dac0b075c17bbfe174ec727c5a1f9ffe728bad7b81eea8e2f8b805a", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42810392.json": "efaaa02816aa6bbadade07d9f62f385e282c126e700a613fb60614ae7ad087ce", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42811497.attempt-1.json": "51a8126a7c7dae0e01dabbca7850b6fab43a5bbd4e8070e15db0832d6ca9f96b", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42811497.json": "da18562d1ba97cdc39070ccee0cf6cc0d8a4a964013ee44f201714070dd92444", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42821663.attempt-1.json": "52d32122ec0c082e3558593cbb19e6845bcc24afada30b8bb84d1802f26f100d", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42821663.json": "37591bdb60b0b16e66f813f6f11501ebe9eef79c362f1937d9d652d96ffae0e1", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42822442.attempt-1.json": "0e6209ba97b5adbb4680803b578a23eae2d309b644d094652dc36c444bb206ad", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42822442.json": "20ccad934a6530ad054e5ec5371f16df616382e9308405c9e730e376712bf5cb", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42826184.attempt-1.json": "5443edb24a576ea2588d9b5386b39a7718eb2cb4d4d31ac4ebbf1be64648ab4e", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42826184.json": "35349f4fc3db77ae647d74b95cec928869d8af303ae4a5bfd1300139e78d69aa", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42839094.attempt-1.json": "c3c312dbb231f8b799cd64ae055760592b8261f04c83f89ccbbe0897e5fa658e", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42839094.json": "8680a26f6151fcc33f2553b1ec93e1593b3ee75c214eddbbe4d2235ce7d1655c", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42841227.attempt-1.json": "5b179443dd003f68704d626cec64f049932f95594e7b0bd077ff2d252c6f8a95", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42841227.json": "1afa9802f247b04a7ab9416f715892d490fefb2bdbd6fe6b4a929cff8d926b48", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42842666.attempt-1.json": "63622a91333af30779ccf40ee2eb83b37eb702142b937fa0556e6d63e5ab09eb", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42842666.json": "fc1aa137f5ea2226963192440ba1a103ecb8f6c8d40c110f62097dfed3960822", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42844664.attempt-1.json": "30c9e9cda698172def5a5de2b891b287a82dfda5cbad68a4dba2935e1498b8a8", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42844664.json": "2e74c94d47b084364ab16e83ed70f585d473dc4350247ae65a062ca3875eb5e6", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42853938.attempt-1.json": "8aa699fad2cafd77337f764010fd8f46a15ff79a05f42e971d60d0e496bd10ba", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42853938.json": "3aaebad43f86b63553ed66997bd77774f72a033c61935467cd93d3c9c8db413e", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42858183.attempt-1.json": "5782888991cf7c517e276cc3d5e294917ee17991e9dde84615057bb0e555f5fa", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42858183.json": "d67a43ed897f7f03462ab7fb758daa5d62fa1aafabfb3aefff959ac518e2bf77", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42806945.attempt-1.json": "578c18d96349ed19ebe93cc36d9b9db2c4e4f6782e89b8797a77940950fafdd1", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42806945.json": "c121da6cc5730764239201149d8b765bc4b037281f9d0548f92fcaa90d52eeea", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42723144.attempt-1.json": "0912e4f9bc72fe0a01f82cd62ae29092d8683d4961538a6833e4de5b67d1eb5f", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42723144.json": "2fa8010f2f66289d167ddb46311c1f169b235cc1f70763393144dd0d566c9243", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42808804.attempt-1.json": "6d68688695e92ffe47a208c8bc1b6652947553e7eb31aab5001b4df3d5d6322e", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42808804.json": "308ebcd8d39797aa72eba8dc3c49cda013d1c785c1f71b09a35b22fd4b1c3e7c", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42585340.attempt-1.json": "7a7b53d51ae16a079df37c14514a785fe53000e72867c78a25db5a4af262ca81", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42585340.json": "d46ebddf23ebc36e4db81c7864fcb7e7df8d852c4506395fcce527b4f6767a11", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42669067.attempt-1.json": "7da5cfa2c39335e6d6ea9ea635029f8e72fd97fc5eb0fb34a88cc7c80acec07f", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42669067.json": "a9fc8b577f26c4153628dba37000dda1027d99ecc428ddd9a5b5d04cab7d944c", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42811065.attempt-1.json": "68848695e3eb734bab359800247fb322014b4d29dd664818e4224bf7d5ce73f8", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42811065.json": "e123fcc047097d7c51039b4e2e0dffb3aa2cdf15a364ed8c735c3a0dd5cbd185", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42841610.attempt-1.json": "7694fe273a864b66094e9951e5b0236049dcde121883ba0940352d5ea08edd30", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42841610.json": "de3ca2d18e9cad4e58eedf6733a3e6cf5a274fc17bcecf540fe82569481eb201", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42806003.attempt-1.json": "e16e3999896928bed33a60fabc3e2e28136a31df82a5b9b26fee08cd456c1f6e", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42806003.json": "3ca553b4f2d30f4291eae56a3428181fe323bfea6a8924f34934f02dac176287", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42806572.attempt-1.json": "8f97bb06cfff16b0bc6d92f5db904f960ab217915dc8362216b6cafeeca1f06d", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42806572.json": "293d4657f47ed9fea36eaa3b481fd1bce9f17f9584f8f8ab399afc94e816faed", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42748238.attempt-1.json": "cd39bb48a023445612eb1c47922a9b7b6dcf7bbd09ab6985eec2ed1d13673bb9", "runs/gpt-6-astra/R42748238.json": "702d4c5e52e74ebb666195d3c752b85807b76bc308462ebc277c459fd0dd7108", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/config.json": "7eb92530c2b922d0bb30d059dcd1b2a6df05af1089545e22ef23a71febec6031", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/requests.json": "bf6bf111bf01e50ac4af9c2ebfb62e2eb85b198ef11a0c329218647e95f2c091", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/isolation-audit.json": "228165b226ee0816ca01adf22e633aa115f97a0fd763cc1502ae90fea19cad09", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/transport-attempts.json": "5e58eacea9bea4c305f00864cd9821dfdd42fccb7bd8627d852244a16255f4c9", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/eligibility.json": "29789f4f325068f533b7a8502d7e0c3c0f7cf81b03a8ef5ca697f9167ed2a9b7", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42581103.attempt-1.json": "d06a09d1147c281aa6db2eec685ce536f7a5d50f6bb64fa52496558842fbbab7", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42581103.json": "dca4d8a0b8c72d4c3a2c5d3f995a57dc6b66ce207e42971eee8fe0e957fb8238", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42601407.attempt-1.json": "0d501d9a5cf47f3b8953c516c7028a27523d8688e131fd826fa25a534fec65a0", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42601407.json": "739755f2d7026bf6c9915159a6c68b2284fac09e27d02200c8b77646f8e35786", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42605193.attempt-1.json": "bc81efd55c1458cdda3223f7c8498ad3e4d929e93c8dfe59b9b076ac9cfa55c4", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42605193.json": "6ae25baf10ae1cad115dfc559ae0b05f5bd251ea38e04f44981ee188f762ffb6", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42608398.attempt-1.json": "41a12fe3917b9cb8cc06b40885b7e8b2932b88a68d8ae86983de9b5e9e171363", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42608398.json": "0d387cb4df2180fb68460cfbc1672f21a927b0f8574d8a42c999a75ef5c6ed09", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42627902.attempt-1.json": "ab23959411304e737bf530cd9fb97d8fc00a6d016da8d95d00d0074b8f8664e0", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42627902.json": "79b51fd06e30b66a3ca8a8094058083bc71e69cd8983544739c0161ae2715ea9", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42630044.attempt-1.json": "52e001e70c893463749121560980fdc58d44dc7c506b99b6dbec84276d240cc7", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42630044.json": "62e35cbfc95dbc98a7222a51953288dca39b88a1a82798d33c84ad6d6fc3ca08", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42639736.attempt-1.json": "de9eabd42db222b6a74da587cce869ccb1f26fbd960d6c8b390f5698e0dea97e", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42639736.json": "3f28c06381958645c2d90f2908179a63f99773ab6d88d5ab7425c48a4ae75b1f", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42642518.attempt-1.json": "a4c70c1363c124bdeb54bbc4a21f8516052b81a10e3b1daaf5813c28f78ffd31", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42642518.json": "072f6ca5a8dead082db2ff72b63c2e378ea284fce22c4500b3e3dcaa4224ee9b", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42642521.attempt-1.json": "96c355637c99eb6e3e1a8e7c4a99ff5202bee0821925e93fd9fbad27c902cf61", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42642521.json": "6328c13b43589e0841fc78c25a98a58964addcd28f95d28d31fe425fa1b0dee5", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42647119.attempt-1.json": "45e0d0a28decabc99cb845e4cf666cb1180fda6985685eed4df5157ade6b2586", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42647119.json": "90cd5f552614e2326bb8e1c052c7879e9d157ee4377e6a6e25546a746217bac8", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42647635.attempt-1.json": "983ea28f7d755063ab0152ead37d80cc68718ca55a8236f486b1fb5ec47867a8", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42647635.json": "35d25327aa971ef4ea139aeccb758b1135dad311fa07a17036c1bc2190d5d93b", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42663085.attempt-1.json": "855693fc2e1037503cabb64f2d22ecf1f48bbd318aaf806e574481b54284af9d", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42663085.json": "8eff48a6328d5f5763f487b7a69cbccaa12426bf5d4dda9510abbd080d568511", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42664348.attempt-1.json": "0fc663ad709fb41f54a1d9a9ef266b66ac3d072d78bb007b295707db81f26943", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42664348.json": "f1100afeb6f5ba3d5acbc4ad2ff83437f237758e741944159128745924b8bcec", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42665751.attempt-1.json": "8926d5193993497c1d89f4f3fe40fe85d2423c97c84ed324edcf48a054d2b020", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42665751.json": "b00243bc6809e97c165081cfb50b317dcd26e2bd65fecdce4e0df6bdaa292b9f", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42689491.attempt-1.json": "13dc000ae2ad836881343d07827a1ac0278716e75d21c11586746d5b6d38b10e", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42689491.json": "3c08d0925cf02265a3564aca30803ed196212fc70bd19379a98a13ac544ea703", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42696595.attempt-1.json": "aa2a0c8dfe9443e1caa36f0c4bb17a258c606ba0c386b69a4147c5358af76de6", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42696595.json": "60005ed99591f4c77b54de109b136b936df61be7fec18f980abb624146ca638c", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42698274.attempt-1.json": "e2fb86b4b2eff4c76e12fd2db8d5e94ba31a32e834ec9f8156e6e22d117aced1", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42698274.json": "d389c55e2bd55fabbd7c07883b0bf53898c2ea77b489bf57461d4f779ba45501", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42717261.attempt-1.json": "0a965ac45e7ea2b7b2254a0b00236b2dcebb8c0e5681ff072f0875fb9b0fc01f", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42717261.json": "8e3d67dee1996121e25be0c17a995e4ae62ec9116292e98ebcaf13885baef060", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42723546.attempt-1.json": "d8a49bdc16fbe639332aef59a46ed45647590cbb9d1b18c184be31120bc12daa", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42723546.json": "71ed9dce42f2b4bf61e84b057c3510cd172912627128fab2cc03867c86e00ed8", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42725837.attempt-1.json": "21af813e970e003714f806dbfc29d8ccb350c413cf71d9b561e01fdfdf8ab739", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42725837.json": "e530ba28d7eebe6bc559cdf81f8d15c1428c13e08b69201928dee4d290ab809d", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42736449.attempt-1.json": "5a886de62970d4797fda1fc29d2b80791ccf642990574813377c9a78bacde7e7", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42736449.json": "a2dcb741e91314631ee6dbc071fe35b1777015eba793c3141dca0ff3125899e3", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42744804.attempt-1.json": "cea8c0356d19857ad7d05aa22ef158cffc366f18a94c14359b838808a6755d4f", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42744804.json": "da7f70b1763ab6b92f158ce3050081d21ba3bb14f26adacb1bed031c61031fb8", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42749700.attempt-1.json": "580dc4941c2a6976257d72f62fe134baaabe7246dd48509a52eb64f3940d4b18", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42749700.json": "c191f15103a1b82cbe4f625640075b395c6926a803516879e49c7c61f57f1038", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42758848.attempt-1.json": "1302abaceaf20a636756ed3f39e485e5ff2ddd2d5184964e811c27572aedbd50", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42758848.json": "88d20cb6dc3194ab8164447cecbae6051bbb3b1ed6585f5d735c1eec1c7d2b52", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42759510.attempt-1.json": "4b1e65359900d51c53844cb4792b6b8d2a632f734c4c2467d18a17a2b4d9a276", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42759510.json": "fbea6a40d35cebe9044c72fbb63f99ad9c091574098713c3c71c0bf062c9a98f", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42775695.attempt-1.json": "499f828679a694873e57a3e5a945f2012f6658a50627f0111595782266879ea3", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42775695.json": "859688d224531f310a5b51a4bc2c54e3d8aade6afd2f9840dfc3e875b6aa85b6", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42775698.attempt-1.json": "2ed29f03a43cff313e07e8c116bc3ae71e77dce5354b5524420a3cca209b9cbb", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42775698.json": "a115d8a5c362c8561e14276e136ecc4b421b2375468dfb75b2c634fb15fc60bb", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42786310.attempt-1.json": "d7ddc8e941cdd50c6cd68056e748a16971196c7e5a0617483afc7b97708bc816", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42786310.json": "7b0900cea78e3cfbccba8fd22004fc9919790277f1a4415abf9dda3c22f9d932", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42805954.attempt-1.json": "2d378fe7288e70e6d8ab9bbf908ad84059768b105fc7db284648be15f3f8718e", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42805954.json": "72282b6f0707b84973fdfa859169b9f0f5c7675a5d82ddb97f13953eaa0b5e7b", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42810392.attempt-1.json": "8e0b76c4287c77ec175942f35f04d4d33816592ac2a5c8ff91aa4bfd32a5953c", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42810392.json": "fd3351dc2588b7efd905ad9e8763b7e5b10ac5e6e47633b33b741ec2ab122cb3", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42811497.attempt-1.json": "e7535c858b3418912fcc84cdb832a4529a4a60afeeff4cc2c8eb7337a2e6e9f0", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42811497.json": "9af08f57dd312c3e2263d0ae4a10ea6117736864278ea280021e9d114449f5d6", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42821663.attempt-1.json": "4a91b7be0a20ab61553af2c795e8ba0dc070cdfb59845ed3b4f12dc7f1b9a983", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42821663.json": "74ad9868d51ab2b0dcf8f2ffd96e4d20a460478cc1302c4db128cb2a1388c372", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42822442.attempt-1.json": "1ee41bcb1780622737d96fd78b93fb8a4b6367273f51efd59258f49fe17e4423", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42822442.json": "87ed880dc1732ec26ea9dea4e77372f3521d88e6972320aa36b9cb9862cd161d", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42826184.attempt-1.json": "33ae7c02ac054d8a7bf074f85435046e4bfa3aabb291319e0f9940646830f3ed", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42826184.json": "4421a9a4cb623cb5e17df153d3f3a2193945dff3cde5bd30c3f60efcd4bf2204", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42839094.attempt-1.json": "4954f6ac5f21625b0a949c6886d2736dc84c9817d93b33100566a8a63ea60205", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42839094.json": "effbfc704a4d5689fdd23e0b66b35bb4551290daa5455115db7ab52817e9c4da", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42841227.attempt-1.json": "1afd30395fd23d51b9984d3e163090856439d0bb5fc60fc72fb42d0ba19f2f7f", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42841227.json": "f16f936cd2340fb5e24d279fb1912e18c526610b8f8e76dbdfccba7983ffb44f", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42842666.attempt-1.json": "202155e8b0532dd730bcd5124005eb56814b6ca09b6bcb41ea40a59b076872e0", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42842666.json": "62834eb015b1606949687fc120e1ed23747c33db6af003bbc39d20cceceb2242", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42844664.attempt-1.json": "6a0c26509a10b4b29457a0bd9e5a2688b273070aefcf60a88bb23fc1f91bd2fb", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42844664.json": "ba19971db316b6ce09e159884a289ee13be928ab12bbe15ad1ffcbe7edbc23da", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42853938.attempt-1.json": "ce9fe50fb462d53ab94c19b41e42e0b9e15b1cdbd76bdd073772b92e79336e80", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42853938.json": "3928c879aaa8a62861a132067c4683e967ab462d18bf7e14373270326edb1b78", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42858183.attempt-1.json": "9b0d2e6eaf67b7e1115b36b83c7be85d98c3a9ce679d779dd878b05ccd959374", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42858183.json": "9e7b31bfb731e13e3f6e363cdc58b3dae9434a4e4f537575a4d655e52554fca8", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42806945.attempt-1.json": "1215402da23ee4692c731780cb6fbfd55f7c779f1db7573895c11be5e8499532", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42806945.json": "a3d0e2278eddb1cb61b203c99f0d01548a2f8a3af36ebd36f37a8af2d5055c5e", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42723144.attempt-1.json": "d1b3822ac9f9824a2f91d2c821c204e9fdff69a8b9f3a7c54158f19d8eab0e4f", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42723144.json": "27749370adfe5b14927d5ada84a1791e7f62c030f3d6ac278a4a05fced889d36", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42808804.attempt-1.json": "6aaafb1ae5c556a8bfa0f7670dd936640c2ccb7ac5bcb93d5cb6031bf13244d0", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42808804.json": "e066e5be779c4834b25106ddd2de83885455081c9caab7c7b60ae3dbdd9bd476", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42585340.attempt-1.json": "781c1e9b61f47ecfca2ee9efbd27bf3e626b43d557427562af63312b334e73c0", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42585340.json": "879657ce0e4482a4e0171c3b0041822e79310318c026759fff39e4893034480d", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42669067.attempt-1.json": "9e66650fa111c860ffd25dc159148dc98923a08aea34fc0771812affef679a9a", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42669067.json": "ecbc36889c6378d23e84aca9e8be617b0d9dcc1fc6619c8150ff009fcb5e64fb", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42811065.attempt-1.json": "69390aba1ea97c4064c5313f37b61a30b9f820b961254b955cf6f8fc2349ec7e", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42811065.json": "3677370348f7f642545b833b4a3a68755cf2f6275e47470868f9a5b671722fa4", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42841610.attempt-1.json": "6cda8800ce4c5c838ea5410bdca3a91bd55131916c26777ab656453a157acc9a", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42841610.json": "54d91315c7eb87ac253de00643977435638ff04b080df48c04fcd0fcd78fbbce", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42806003.attempt-1.json": "53a19bc8de262743f8f63c2d052eda6709924697169eb737cfc64ab04ab8f3ca", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42806003.json": "8ca35a0c8b41c12ebb6992c7ef2b784c436646885f16e92c4085dedef1d73788", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42806572.attempt-1.json": "f726ab4bbb0282ae8ecee153c5e6a3045a394b4e63cb6d9d0f8b09c2532e05eb", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42806572.json": "f2781c5633e4c96180a086deb689b5f8197ef85c2d044d11f01d9ec5bddf0f6e", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42748238.attempt-1.json": "2bc025c74441ec94adcd7208329cb41265a79d9c2d074b68d9119921913fbf3d", "runs/gemini-4-argon-high/R42748238.json": "d576ae14546a0a4669c30cbf6fc57a219c6c0bccd129554ca86cd9a2d59f19a3", "runs/grok-4.5/config.json": "c30effafa40b308a0f92c8fd44f548e80bffc7184caa557718ee761d6f601c4c", "runs/grok-4.5/requests.json": "1284cafaa1dcaf63968730e6042019fce538e6adc36737cb0f57903ee41109a9", "runs/grok-4.5/isolation-audit.json": "5a28fbd77266c100770da9b3811cee90c3a9026748b5699ab871ee1db53980d4", "runs/grok-4.5/transport-attempts.json": "177200cf873f8b58aa97d52cd22e417419c7353e887d037b8fcc7bfbee67c1b6", "runs/grok-4.5/eligibility.json": "1e16e974673344403307e9ca719f0b1f1ade5bff8f33bf63fed7ddca40ff1cf2", "runs/grok-4.5/R42581103.attempt-1.json": "3373a7901bb00b3b8d74431a84fbb07a52ed8860984530af3edd419fca6f62f6", "runs/grok-4.5/R42581103.json": "44607d19fc0ee871dd2e405520f8a966461b0da2d0329c5980d9f196df6600b6", "runs/grok-4.5/R42601407.attempt-1.json": "0f0ad7c808aec4b901e62113d029ef62980328777076109b43eb1553a0f9e31e", "runs/grok-4.5/R42601407.json": "b485bde8f3bca02e8aeea4501258b9c54d996daaf4273315e9581510d11429b2", "runs/grok-4.5/R42605193.attempt-1.json": "fb3e70dc519e63cdf029f916eaff6abed2d082d227150f9232f21eeb1cb075ff", "runs/grok-4.5/R42605193.json": "0d9509bbe310398037f1c6b177e9860437818a8ab0f604e427d13253ccbb3dbb", "runs/grok-4.5/R42608398.attempt-1.json": "af43b447986961feb43312d52d6f222aad0ee2d5f06a2c1df78000c94dca4734", "runs/grok-4.5/R42608398.json": "2f37ccf14504911635a8a6d228e70df19623817f9421d7244b46c52407566523", "runs/grok-4.5/R42627902.attempt-1.json": "caaaab4fb08828313d077df88b6b3eb9ffae2c968ffefb8d63a053a39ba22d02", "runs/grok-4.5/R42627902.attempt-2.json": "7e86d0624d4be04071a3807dd6ca3272b7bdca528fec88aac45b797e5cb0ef11", "runs/grok-4.5/R42627902.json": "25961e1821996696062e3ee02014da9a9a9424d8eb6264722e2c9900d92e2fe6", "runs/grok-4.5/R42630044.attempt-1.json": "35029357175ee58a9a81361d75a7c87ad108c21bbf7838e6383c0e28536d85bf", "runs/grok-4.5/R42630044.json": "008f4d6e0105bdabda95ff8911097c8d9417e42b3e2be9f83ee6cd72c54e68b2", "runs/grok-4.5/R42639736.attempt-1.json": "2156e7c2d9c2511bf8ba0404203cc1e378b9fec5528d2a8e50edbfeaacbc544a", "runs/grok-4.5/R42639736.json": "2dd86dfca0db13035d6f746a5c9f5113433741eed31c804ab84891741ae242f1", "runs/grok-4.5/R42642518.attempt-1.json": "47add06dca6143a673578b2aa8a970734c1091b2ecd22a13c04b697f91d781c2", "runs/grok-4.5/R42642518.json": "f78160c3dd09973d3c69843c0376ff9dbc0a9bdefe4f6be0e348b5fe1afb61db", "runs/grok-4.5/R42642521.attempt-1.json": "491cc749bfe7e2d57caf0b5d2c841ce425dfdd8a81dd4f7c062fb12bfa7ead2c", "runs/grok-4.5/R42642521.json": "5c80c102d838165e61e3292b7450791c3ce0d08e496026e99417d040d6fdea9e", "runs/grok-4.5/R42647119.attempt-1.json": "2cde7c8d58384bbf203b7edf6a8e4a43c6075ff42ed0632a50cafc42774084a4", "runs/grok-4.5/R42647119.json": "e4099a1a6109d84c5a845e72c367426cbae9daaf25af1f134a7f3d78a28c3c08", "runs/grok-4.5/R42647635.attempt-1.json": "0371fcf686f7193b79674d1a2e30b72c4ab512e486e3bcfe4b9d5ba2442f7731", "runs/grok-4.5/R42647635.json": "3d474817a72584262cb2ac809ef78fe09dbb1dbc807a93abcc08201cf34bbb63", "runs/grok-4.5/R42663085.attempt-1.json": "8ff74dce4e78a3c9ff6575829901f75827297d1faba6ee8b53293c9c68b47c59", "runs/grok-4.5/R42663085.json": "4421ae6767d293a0296636eea96a8ce67e3a92a829af14dbe39f13c5af819080", "runs/grok-4.5/R42664348.attempt-1.json": "94464bca67b250abab2444889262de8fc7ebb779147a268a1596d455c9ff221a", "runs/grok-4.5/R42664348.json": "36a6975693120a8b85958db3bb113ee2ddaf75b9a0a180ff3590467f77a33352", "runs/grok-4.5/R42665751.attempt-1.json": "9952ea33f10d0a60a8953b629db5a58d976060c8dbf27936c3692debed5cb8f9", "runs/grok-4.5/R42665751.json": "9a432825fc098a007feef6fe5cde81c10268eac5f8fde225cce344e3acee4137", "runs/grok-4.5/R42689491.attempt-1.json": "7d8105fc1439323464020107bde1da8746c13642594966ca5e3363691436a484", "runs/grok-4.5/R42689491.json": "98163861f7eb71b2871cc5a9b37e7b1e6b6a38b5b2af707a2de0fdc4e3df6a7e", "runs/grok-4.5/R42696595.attempt-1.json": "279e2e7849f7f5abf0e52b71d6e328d17a01c3fe4289be3181c5fc49ff3e6c86", "runs/grok-4.5/R42696595.attempt-2.json": "0abbb329467f5d4c36b56e9fcb7f8afcda9c7f95f9081e3baea733cd903055c4", "runs/grok-4.5/R42696595.json": "db56941c6e71804bdc8c734a8001f3259b6bf02cceca569cad6fb10419b8f7d4", "runs/grok-4.5/R42698274.attempt-1.json": "56722b51505f4be115b72349fce96f359369357d9b6c4080e61a93bf0f3c5097", "runs/grok-4.5/R42698274.attempt-2.json": "011dd834c6c648fdb652465eedcb1bfe09285e373d63c58f83203b6b42dcffd1", "runs/grok-4.5/R42698274.json": "44af5ecdb4a4d994dfea304cb51af222f6851dcdc4530f464f0fc50fc139e865", "runs/grok-4.5/R42717261.attempt-1.json": "d6115cb980886e448245c6324e22fbafde90c655fd8ab6990ee704cedae18b39", "runs/grok-4.5/R42717261.json": "f9ee6ed9fce6fad869753e995dc6d235236dd5924d96b54f6d31f9e4ce4e26fa", "runs/grok-4.5/R42723546.attempt-1.json": "02d95c5fcfbaac4b11d81fee74306631ad256e24082e4c054bdcbec32f88b7a2", "runs/grok-4.5/R42723546.json": "6803b562539d7bad8e8c7dd66985ada550f4acde99ff0629c00a6d160b89f16e", "runs/grok-4.5/R42725837.attempt-1.json": "7a8463c73817215d48e9521d0fd5cd6fefa61d9f798ae18ac09eb0b0b943ba2a", "runs/grok-4.5/R42725837.json": "858decc7143ff9491e96e198a439f70a16657d21e04d17dd26a096f1d8ca7bcf", "runs/grok-4.5/R42736449.attempt-1.json": "c1f4f20eb4d8cd1d406869d8157c3fea0f53a3854d53d7edd8ebfc53af8b26cd", "runs/grok-4.5/R42736449.attempt-2.json": "c59bfe89172f7828a1340f90f03897f1bd8c88a3c4d6f66098f9fe30a2c7600f", "runs/grok-4.5/R42736449.json": "4ffce7e6aae8c29c0e8ddebd087aeb487edbefdecd94d5f61e0750545835ebf6", "runs/grok-4.5/R42744804.attempt-1.json": "7e988cf2f4cca9adc7ea463724dd3c33fe11a664b08a32889de10798a1dcbbd8", "runs/grok-4.5/R42744804.json": "8858c1f6993d78550b6ec28c4c44d23761f9f1b40c3f594e26121efa75aecce1", "runs/grok-4.5/R42749700.attempt-1.json": "7d80bdf6c9bbbe994117ed5186f1d2090f91a165d8cab1dc4caef4d2eb162f1e", "runs/grok-4.5/R42749700.json": "dd398a5e22bb3de3491a115fd914754a28c7f38457d031c3add152849eaeecf5", "runs/grok-4.5/R42758848.attempt-1.json": "7cadaea29fd9a80f29ccf0c527b039feff59f97371a8c40881d9c325cd250c61", "runs/grok-4.5/R42758848.json": "e8883daecb1b9798ae440d8e3a896dbfce6e0525a33bec75b002c0d5478c8a32", "runs/grok-4.5/R42759510.attempt-1.json": "f7656e25e3d4aa6e52f363f05ee4a71d1d45b628906a2b8d965d5b28cf6278b7", "runs/grok-4.5/R42759510.json": "552ff3f4e4b31485d8657db5dfba1a19616a082c6dff2b1d9f456dbc7daa2b93", "runs/grok-4.5/R42775695.attempt-1.json": "f8be5c6c9e1bfdc9b7893872d232b75e45c90f2277179dd26b123e30309567d0", "runs/grok-4.5/R42775695.json": "21f3065ef0e1e55e6414f122b8a8a7808a649a0c32b5a5a4e5515a8ca5242e26", "runs/grok-4.5/R42775698.attempt-1.json": "d7b360e59d3f62e387f2ac2a29b2b76e91638319cb8d97eb8459067b2a100608", "runs/grok-4.5/R42775698.json": "bdb3ba36868e64b68d2496bc9c0aaffbe1c72666a70e8a3ac4c06550b60a440c", "runs/grok-4.5/R42786310.attempt-1.json": "d317de35822fe12f767a80bc7b40f2610f3ccca4024f68316488c6e9d5ff556b", "runs/grok-4.5/R42786310.json": "e850b80637729c8bd2aa23485023357c63a534dd054cd10954a24db0e1bc4144", "runs/grok-4.5/R42805954.attempt-1.json": "396726e1748ba63361cd19a2823527040071e85db40a13aa6c724d60814c754c", "runs/grok-4.5/R42805954.json": "c83d089b9118b799c864af4780cca1e61501f0083198e6f7e062cc302ba11837", "runs/grok-4.5/R42810392.attempt-1.json": "6de148f44e7563b7edf936aa7554c22cf344f00e89853f63f3afd174c8180c1b", "runs/grok-4.5/R42810392.json": "09abf4488916a2f9ba9d82a06bde8c971ff160b40416e5279c19925f47e66da9", "runs/grok-4.5/R42811497.attempt-1.json": "737a34a9a8ce760dd1af87fadacd6b4a2f785b5a5501ae166d6f0eebebb3dfc3", "runs/grok-4.5/R42811497.json": "37f2e509ebdf6a77eb3bc170a72733d212979eb83b5459c5a1e6e182c4f8289f", "runs/grok-4.5/R42821663.attempt-1.json": "a82c3a406c897fdc211f16d0da7afc3a13f0cf40a316d38b700d2e1ee5d04a53", "runs/grok-4.5/R42821663.attempt-2.json": "efa596d80a1a617e40518386f6c4e1571b61c2e129aa39e04b8d78bd1d5c1f29", "runs/grok-4.5/R42821663.json": "f219b8ad6158b411e9bcbf8513df0143604b1519019354320ca279c1a2d4c979", "runs/grok-4.5/R42822442.attempt-1.json": "db5525ecec437318caf40cb0183733d3b23f3e037901e0de1fa740632c17ad94", "runs/grok-4.5/R42822442.json": "ebac36cdcc0db60e5729ef9ebfbaa37533cc99c3d438415a187f1de918351911", "runs/grok-4.5/R42826184.attempt-1.json": "32f8398615a14e389c84cb7f8ec838ac57a1c808a81861ffb04ac66561ed9882", "runs/grok-4.5/R42826184.json": "48abdbcaddcbd90ace5498927c2bfc609568b01315b6b2373b4fd5798f75f52e", "runs/grok-4.5/R42839094.attempt-1.json": "39bc66422f37c270576cbe2e1ca87515b07ab8eca9e38a6288c413dc1c470155", "runs/grok-4.5/R42839094.json": "51c3b997b74e7e492d12c1f37c03defe2d191eb5f7bca3ef3c699b88e9da3cec", "runs/grok-4.5/R42841227.attempt-1.json": "e89340fb7ff6209fda621abaff2f24eb30622fa8d69849af55724368fd683635", "runs/grok-4.5/R42841227.json": "a3a603d7b49e2772f09c7eaf17aa5722fe56f33f315bca8878dead9bc13a7144", "runs/grok-4.5/R42842666.attempt-1.json": "ed7fb3305290421e7d431caa97150d9d9cd7eef84ac4b3397f0c0323f4914457", "runs/grok-4.5/R42842666.json": "4ba3d92a14d9d1430b8afd65bf908653441dfcac48ff2ba703d77e6f47158c3b", "runs/grok-4.5/R42844664.attempt-1.json": "317241660abbbeaba3d1ff111a8c2e78b3e2bc369b3bf0c3a5ac1e62ff586d9a", "runs/grok-4.5/R42844664.json": "f24d0afba21315e87fe2d9fa887487577e294563f22dd78e2eacdfd5424fafc7", "runs/grok-4.5/R42853938.attempt-1.json": "c9e8cd2ef386c84b95730f394252bb7456273a9ef61aae00ad09d41cb6221120", "runs/grok-4.5/R42853938.json": "93c8047c0f15f55a738468cdda00f21a5b66698f244198c1b99c23386f30363a", "runs/grok-4.5/R42858183.attempt-1.json": "da6f0181efcc179e03cede41c0661d07cbb5ca590f17792e124032266e5a0e1b", "runs/grok-4.5/R42858183.json": "ca0a57392cd5df5410bbcf30721b64b61a11b0618cf97a65be7628a145d3c00c", "runs/grok-4.5/R42806945.attempt-1.json": "3a7fec99e6da951659f47b5ed59caf6df414859b1846de47ae03a8ac88e38949", "runs/grok-4.5/R42806945.json": "4a4890b598bb1bd395b045144de3e2aad2bbfd70a92c1ced941d41b7eea3829c", "runs/grok-4.5/R42723144.attempt-1.json": "a4f2653ce27fe698ad22132da7d08bb8953fd0eaa3720dfd694869803ec8d2d0", "runs/grok-4.5/R42723144.json": "19f0f7d7d8bfa268c350758d7337164976be8d6192e6f1308707b17c2f401fbf", "runs/grok-4.5/R42808804.attempt-1.json": "a82d03024dc433668ba132039eca71cceeb8fe4d26667ce203d88aa7bcf8ad5d", "runs/grok-4.5/R42808804.attempt-2.json": "082a8354f2dce8f16a70cb52917e7c74b6aaed965a7da5ad3e04222cd8ba53d9", "runs/grok-4.5/R42808804.json": "2d895e9de1176a06c6c5ec2a2f0fc92157e867dfbbec6aec7be8dca77d57df93", "runs/grok-4.5/R42585340.attempt-1.json": "de4ad7cd2b80180dbdbd849cfb3b0ba9a0a097461389a331b57189ce8c48ead1", "runs/grok-4.5/R42585340.json": "7b7da46b2cc0133a4c16e971fe0bac47e3c43d622bfd3c89a0d85dc95e0b63de", "runs/grok-4.5/R42669067.attempt-1.json": "404f2a8c033dba50b2d8926a2334a1463c99ae80e50ac21b081ccc79108b27c4", "runs/grok-4.5/R42669067.json": "7252a7f0927afc79ead7eb06359631e296b0c0be61f138ab83e05ab33d0c6c1d", "runs/grok-4.5/R42811065.attempt-1.json": "20223e75da4e3dce91cf67d8efb27512a1645f998309872779ea918a4b87880f", "runs/grok-4.5/R42811065.json": "5a01b0fdf4596b24f0bf111ca49662828a7d866902d723c83fedce915aaf8551", "runs/grok-4.5/R42841610.attempt-1.json": "d7261db1116cde46c527c5f7a846dd9b4a3995b6d8abc244ebd1813023e28557", "runs/grok-4.5/R42841610.json": "5c0239dc6122d4900bda5164a253cf1e6e5e626bfaf9d5f0f855e64b356959b7", "runs/grok-4.5/R42806003.attempt-1.json": "c6b4cb93d26bbeb7b3a9e96e133a22870a706840617dbddbb9d3e7ac895a89ed", "runs/grok-4.5/R42806003.json": "11ae7fe17a41d5cb73b9b349bf9cc0428b21280520400d762155959f0512f72e", "runs/grok-4.5/R42806572.attempt-1.json": "1f9fe741be8e445d08ec5d90e82c7a6482b5aa5ccaf2a3865ceada9b602c3fc6", "runs/grok-4.5/R42806572.json": "73e2c62710a6d3529b1ba4a5b9b86dc18a2ff1262f673ec1a8ed5f8a960046b4", "runs/grok-4.5/R42748238.attempt-1.json": "860ff47949ebd2912620a56bfd7491d000339e602d68d9da6b1e22406c829b44", "runs/grok-4.5/R42748238.json": "59cb93ea755569d337315b6aad10fdcdbbf6592fa16fc8243dda1996aec9bc59" }, "panels": { "core": { "models": [ { "model": "claude-sonnet-5-5", "label": "Sonnet 5.5", "valid": 240, "invalid": [ "R42698274|H1", "R42698274|H2", "R42698274|H3", "R42698274|H4", "R42698274|H5", "R42736449|H1", "R42736449|H2", "R42736449|H3", "R42736449|H4", "R42736449|H5" ], "calls": 56, "transportAttemptCount": 56, "strictForecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": true, "R42581103|H3": false, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": true, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": false, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": true, "R42630044|H4": false, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": true, "R42639736|H2": false, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": false, "R42642518|H5": false, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": true, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": false, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": false, "R42663085|H3": false, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": false, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": true, "R42696595|H4": false, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": true, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": false, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": true, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": false, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": false, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": true, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": false, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": true, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": false, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": true, "R42759510|H3": false, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": true, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": false, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": false, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": false, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": true, "R42821663|H1": false, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": true, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": true, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": false, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": false, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": true, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": false, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": false, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": false, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": true, "R42806945|H2": false, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": false, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": false, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": false, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": true, "R42841610|H2": false, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": true, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": false, "R42748238|H3": true, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "strictInvalid": [ "R42698274|H1", "R42698274|H2", "R42698274|H3", "R42698274|H4", "R42698274|H5", "R42736449|H1", "R42736449|H2", "R42736449|H3", "R42736449|H4", "R42736449|H5" ], "formatRecovered": [], "selections": [ { "id": "R42581103|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" } ], "forecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": true, "R42581103|H3": false, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": true, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": false, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": true, "R42630044|H4": false, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": true, "R42639736|H2": false, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": false, "R42642518|H5": false, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": true, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": false, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": false, "R42663085|H3": false, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": false, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": true, "R42696595|H4": false, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": true, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": false, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": true, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": false, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": false, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": true, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": false, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": true, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": false, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": true, "R42759510|H3": false, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": true, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": false, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": false, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": false, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": true, "R42821663|H1": false, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": true, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": true, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": false, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": false, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": true, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": false, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": false, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": false, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": true, "R42806945|H2": false, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": false, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": false, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": false, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": true, "R42841610|H2": false, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": true, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": false, "R42748238|H3": true, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "parentResultReused": false, "sourceGenerator": false, "originalReferenceJudge": false, "judgeRelationships": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "claude-opus-5-5" ] }, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 43, "matches": 11, "known": 32, "missed": 21, "counts": { "yes_true": 11, "yes_false": 32, "no_true": 21, "no_false": 176 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2558139534883721, "npv": 0.8934010152284264, "sens": 0.34375, "spec": 0.8461538461538461, "youden": 0.18990384615384626, "accuracy": 0.7791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5949519230769231 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.1404293381037567, "npv": 0.04794646977388095, "sens": -0.125, "spec": 0.3990384615384615, "youden": 0.2740384615384617, "accuracy": 0.32916666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.13701923076923084 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.13333333333333333, "hi": 0.3953488372093023, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.01785714285714285, "hi": 0.2760339693728731, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.85, "hi": 0.9336734693877551, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.008093084012292988, "hi": 0.10669191919191923, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.1935483870967742, "hi": 0.5172413793103449, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.37037037037037035, "hi": 0.12903225806451613, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8186046511627907, "hi": 0.8761904761904762, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.32075471698113206, "hi": 0.4757281553398058, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.018755159569113052, "hi": 0.3798858146684232, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.003327845835598233, "hi": 0.5502589958609374, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7333333333333333, "hi": 0.825, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.24583333333333335, "hi": 0.4125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5093775797845566, "hi": 0.6899429073342116, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.0016639229177991164, "hi": 0.2751294979304687, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "gpt-6-astra", "label": "GPT-6 Astra", "valid": 250, "invalid": [], "calls": 50, "transportAttemptCount": 56, "strictForecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": false, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": true, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": false, "R42630044|H4": true, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": false, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": false, "R42642518|H5": true, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": false, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": false, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": true, "R42663085|H3": true, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": true, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": false, "R42696595|H4": true, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": false, "R42698274|H2": false, "R42698274|H3": false, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": false, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": true, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": false, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": true, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": true, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": false, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": false, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": false, "R42759510|H3": true, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": false, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": true, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": true, "R42821663|H1": false, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": true, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": false, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": false, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": true, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": false, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": false, "R42806945|H2": true, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": true, "R42808804|H1": false, "R42808804|H2": false, "R42808804|H3": true, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": false, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": true, "R42841610|H1": false, "R42841610|H2": true, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": false, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": true, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": false, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": true, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "strictInvalid": [], "formatRecovered": [], "selections": [ { "id": "R42581103|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" } ], "forecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": false, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": true, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": false, "R42630044|H4": true, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": false, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": false, "R42642518|H5": true, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": false, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": false, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": true, "R42663085|H3": true, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": true, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": false, "R42696595|H4": true, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": false, "R42698274|H2": false, "R42698274|H3": false, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": false, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": true, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": false, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": true, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": true, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": false, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": false, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": false, "R42759510|H3": true, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": false, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": true, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": true, "R42821663|H1": false, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": true, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": false, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": false, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": true, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": false, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": false, "R42806945|H2": true, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": true, "R42808804|H1": false, "R42808804|H2": false, "R42808804|H3": true, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": false, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": true, "R42841610|H1": false, "R42841610|H2": true, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": false, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": true, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": false, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": true, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "parentResultReused": false, "sourceGenerator": false, "originalReferenceJudge": false, "judgeRelationships": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "gpt-5.6-sol" ] }, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "left": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 51, "matches": 14, "known": 33, "missed": 19, "counts": { "yes_true": 14, "yes_false": 37, "no_true": 19, "no_false": 180 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.27450980392156865, "npv": 0.9045226130653267, "sens": 0.42424242424242425, "spec": 0.8294930875576036, "youden": 0.25373551180002796, "accuracy": 0.776, "balancedAccuracy": 0.626867755900014 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 16, "known": 33, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 16, "yes_false": 116, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 101 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.12121212121212122, "npv": 0.8559322033898306, "sens": 0.48484848484848486, "spec": 0.46543778801843316, "youden": -0.049713727133081975, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.475143136433459 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.15329768270944744, "npv": 0.048590409675496105, "sens": -0.06060606060606061, "spec": 0.3640552995391705, "youden": 0.30344923893310993, "accuracy": 0.308, "balancedAccuracy": 0.15172461946655497 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.15384615384615385, "hi": 0.41818181818181815, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.07030293924825176, "hi": 0.17558320610687006, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.03831763285024154, "hi": 0.2884492547436244, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.864321608040201, "hi": 0.9430051813471503, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7881291730868002, "hi": 0.9186991869918699, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.007071358748778147, "hi": 0.10608713147340275, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.2727272727272727, "hi": 0.5909090909090909, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.3055555555555556, "hi": 0.6666666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.3142857142857143, "hi": 0.19444444444444442, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7818142119888846, "hi": 0.8733152484294687, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.39622641509433965, "hi": 0.5405405405405406, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.287037037037037, "hi": 0.4407582938388626, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.07684319833852538, "hi": 0.44211702276218423, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.24375336873535364, "hi": 0.15201060539107392, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.02604527397343094, "hi": 0.578132005233024, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.724, "hi": 0.824, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.404, "hi": 0.536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.22799999999999998, "hi": 0.38400000000000006, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5384215991692627, "hi": 0.7210585113810921, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3781233156323232, "hi": 0.576005302695537, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.01302263698671547, "hi": 0.289066002616512, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "gemini-4-argon-high", "label": "Gemini 4 Argon High", "valid": 250, "invalid": [], "calls": 50, "transportAttemptCount": 51, "strictForecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": true, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": false, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": false, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": false, "R42630044|H4": true, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": false, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": false, "R42642518|H4": true, "R42642518|H5": false, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": false, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": true, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": false, "R42663085|H3": false, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": false, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": false, "R42696595|H4": true, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": false, "R42698274|H2": false, "R42698274|H3": false, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": false, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": true, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": false, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": true, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": false, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": true, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": false, "R42759510|H3": true, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": true, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": false, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": true, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": false, "R42821663|H1": true, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": false, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": false, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": true, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": true, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": true, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": true, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": false, "R42806945|H2": true, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": true, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": false, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": true, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": true, "R42841610|H2": false, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": false, "R42806003|H2": true, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "strictInvalid": [], "formatRecovered": [], "selections": [ { "id": "R42581103|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" } ], "forecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": true, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": false, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": false, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": false, "R42630044|H4": true, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": false, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": false, "R42642518|H4": true, "R42642518|H5": false, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": false, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": true, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": false, "R42663085|H3": false, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": false, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": false, "R42696595|H4": true, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": false, "R42698274|H2": false, "R42698274|H3": false, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": false, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": true, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": false, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": true, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": false, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": true, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": false, "R42759510|H3": true, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": true, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": false, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": true, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": false, "R42821663|H1": true, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": false, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": false, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": true, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": true, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": true, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": true, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": false, "R42806945|H2": true, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": true, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": false, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": true, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": true, "R42841610|H2": false, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": false, "R42806003|H2": true, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "parentResultReused": false, "sourceGenerator": true, "originalReferenceJudge": false, "judgeRelationships": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [] }, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "left": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 53, "matches": 18, "known": 33, "missed": 15, "counts": { "yes_true": 18, "yes_false": 35, "no_true": 15, "no_false": 182 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.33962264150943394, "npv": 0.9238578680203046, "sens": 0.5454545454545454, "spec": 0.8387096774193549, "youden": 0.3841642228739004, "accuracy": 0.8, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6920821114369502 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 16, "known": 33, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 16, "yes_false": 116, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 101 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.12121212121212122, "npv": 0.8559322033898306, "sens": 0.48484848484848486, "spec": 0.46543778801843316, "youden": -0.049713727133081975, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.475143136433459 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.21841052029731273, "npv": 0.067925664630474, "sens": 0.06060606060606055, "spec": 0.3732718894009217, "youden": 0.43387795000698237, "accuracy": 0.332, "balancedAccuracy": 0.21693897500349119 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.21153846153846154, "hi": 0.48, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.07030293924825176, "hi": 0.17558320610687006, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.0995187397875817, "hi": 0.34945946658233173, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8871794871794871, "hi": 0.958974358974359, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7881291730868002, "hi": 0.9186991869918699, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.009705220117147676, "hi": 0.12932082748948112, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3939393939393939, "hi": 0.7058823529411765, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.3055555555555556, "hi": 0.6666666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.19444444444444448, "hi": 0.31999999999999995, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8035714285714286, "hi": 0.8732531108983999, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.39622641509433965, "hi": 0.5405405405405406, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2977777777777778, "hi": 0.4465116279069767, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.21008573052548163, "hi": 0.5636243509865002, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.24375336873535364, "hi": 0.15201060539107392, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.15337194240997984, "hi": 0.716774834145786, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.756, "hi": 0.844, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.404, "hi": 0.536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.252, "hi": 0.4119999999999999, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6050428652627409, "hi": 0.7818121754932501, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3781233156323232, "hi": 0.576005302695537, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.07668597120498992, "hi": 0.358387417072893, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "grok-4.5", "label": "Grok 4.5", "valid": 250, "invalid": [], "calls": 56, "transportAttemptCount": 56, "strictForecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": true, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": true, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": true, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": true, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": true, "R42630044|H3": true, "R42630044|H4": false, "R42630044|H5": true, "R42639736|H1": true, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": true, "R42642518|H1": true, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": true, "R42642518|H5": true, "R42642521|H1": true, "R42642521|H2": true, "R42642521|H3": true, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": true, "R42647119|H1": true, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": true, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": true, "R42663085|H3": true, "R42663085|H4": true, "R42663085|H5": true, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": true, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": true, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": true, "R42696595|H4": false, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": true, "R42698274|H2": true, "R42698274|H3": true, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": true, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": false, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": true, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": true, "R42749700|H3": true, "R42749700|H4": false, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": true, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": true, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": true, "R42759510|H3": false, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": true, "R42775695|H2": true, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": true, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": true, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": true, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": true, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": true, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": true, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": true, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": false, "R42821663|H1": true, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": false, "R42821663|H5": true, "R42822442|H1": true, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": true, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": true, "R42839094|H2": true, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": true, "R42841227|H1": true, "R42841227|H2": true, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": true, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": true, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": false, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": true, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": true, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": true, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": true, "R42806945|H2": false, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": true, "R42806945|H5": true, "R42723144|H1": true, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": true, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": true, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": true, "R42585340|H2": true, "R42585340|H3": true, "R42585340|H4": true, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": true, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": false, "R42841610|H2": true, "R42841610|H3": true, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": true, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "strictInvalid": [], "formatRecovered": [], "selections": [ { "id": "R42581103|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" } ], "forecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": true, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": true, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": true, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": true, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": true, "R42630044|H3": true, "R42630044|H4": false, "R42630044|H5": true, "R42639736|H1": true, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": true, "R42642518|H1": true, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": true, "R42642518|H5": true, "R42642521|H1": true, "R42642521|H2": true, "R42642521|H3": true, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": true, "R42647119|H1": true, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": true, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": true, "R42663085|H3": true, "R42663085|H4": true, "R42663085|H5": true, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": true, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": true, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": true, "R42696595|H4": false, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": true, "R42698274|H2": true, "R42698274|H3": true, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": true, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": false, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": true, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": true, "R42749700|H3": true, "R42749700|H4": false, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": true, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": true, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": true, "R42759510|H3": false, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": true, "R42775695|H2": true, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": true, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": true, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": true, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": true, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": true, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": true, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": true, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": false, "R42821663|H1": true, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": false, "R42821663|H5": true, "R42822442|H1": true, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": true, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": true, "R42839094|H2": true, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": true, "R42841227|H1": true, "R42841227|H2": true, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": true, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": true, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": false, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": true, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": true, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": true, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": true, "R42806945|H2": false, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": true, "R42806945|H5": true, "R42723144|H1": true, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": true, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": true, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": true, "R42585340|H2": true, "R42585340|H3": true, "R42585340|H4": true, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": true, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": false, "R42841610|H2": true, "R42841610|H3": true, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": true, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "parentResultReused": false, "sourceGenerator": false, "originalReferenceJudge": false, "judgeRelationships": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "grok-4.7" ] }, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "left": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 105, "matches": 20, "known": 33, "missed": 13, "counts": { "yes_true": 20, "yes_false": 85, "no_true": 13, "no_false": 132 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.19047619047619047, "npv": 0.9103448275862069, "sens": 0.6060606060606061, "spec": 0.6082949308755761, "youden": 0.21435553693618203, "accuracy": 0.608, "balancedAccuracy": 0.607177768468091 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 16, "known": 33, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 16, "yes_false": 116, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 101 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.12121212121212122, "npv": 0.8559322033898306, "sens": 0.48484848484848486, "spec": 0.46543778801843316, "youden": -0.049713727133081975, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.475143136433459 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.06926406926406925, "npv": 0.05441262419637638, "sens": 0.12121212121212122, "spec": 0.1428571428571429, "youden": 0.264069264069264, "accuracy": 0.13999999999999996, "balancedAccuracy": 0.132034632034632 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.12148824695553669, "hi": 0.27184466019417475, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.07030293924825176, "hi": 0.17558320610687006, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.006841058792668657, "hi": 0.14296058646812954, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8639455782312925, "hi": 0.9530201342281879, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7881291730868002, "hi": 0.9186991869918699, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0015142424939327648, "hi": 0.11345215287404668, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.4594594594594595, "hi": 0.76, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.3055555555555556, "hi": 0.6666666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.09999999999999998, "hi": 0.3448275862068966, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.5370285423037717, "hi": 0.6780487804878049, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.39622641509433965, "hi": 0.5405405405405406, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.045871559633027525, "hi": 0.23981900452488686, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.04205607476635498, "hi": 0.39462168851114726, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.24375336873535364, "hi": 0.15201060539107392, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.013615510306686658, "hi": 0.5234938871704228, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.54, "hi": 0.676, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.404, "hi": 0.536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.04799999999999993, "hi": 0.23199999999999998, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5210280373831775, "hi": 0.6973108442555737, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3781233156323232, "hi": 0.576005302695537, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.006807755153343329, "hi": 0.2617469435852114, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } } ], "coin": { "method": "Original saved gemini-4-argon-high/N per-hypothesis coin decisions reused unchanged by task and generation index; never redrawn", "sourceSha256": "052b7f8e5cc1f50cdd708eb5d3cee2ad0ebe393f3a1e1bff88ed00d8840d458c", "tosses": [ { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" } ], "comparison": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "left": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 16, "known": 33, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 16, "yes_false": 116, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 101 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.12121212121212122, "npv": 0.8559322033898306, "sens": 0.48484848484848486, "spec": 0.46543778801843316, "youden": -0.049713727133081975, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.475143136433459 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 16, "known": 33, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 16, "yes_false": 116, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 101 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.12121212121212122, "npv": 0.8559322033898306, "sens": 0.48484848484848486, "spec": 0.46543778801843316, "youden": -0.049713727133081975, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.475143136433459 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0, "npv": 0, "sens": 0, "spec": 0, "youden": 0, "accuracy": 0, "balancedAccuracy": 0 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.07030293924825176, "hi": 0.17558320610687006, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.07030293924825176, "hi": 0.17558320610687006, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.7881291730868002, "hi": 0.9186991869918699, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7881291730868002, "hi": 0.9186991869918699, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3055555555555556, "hi": 0.6666666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.3055555555555556, "hi": 0.6666666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.39622641509433965, "hi": 0.5405405405405406, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.39622641509433965, "hi": 0.5405405405405406, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.24375336873535364, "hi": 0.15201060539107392, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.24375336873535364, "hi": 0.15201060539107392, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.404, "hi": 0.536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.404, "hi": 0.536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3781233156323232, "hi": 0.576005302695537, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3781233156323232, "hi": 0.576005302695537, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true } } } } }, "common": { "hypotheses": 240, "sources": 48, "ids": [ "R42581103|H1", "R42581103|H2", "R42581103|H3", "R42581103|H4", "R42581103|H5", "R42601407|H1", "R42601407|H2", "R42601407|H3", "R42601407|H4", "R42601407|H5", "R42605193|H1", "R42605193|H2", "R42605193|H3", "R42605193|H4", "R42605193|H5", "R42608398|H1", "R42608398|H2", "R42608398|H3", "R42608398|H4", "R42608398|H5", "R42627902|H1", "R42627902|H2", "R42627902|H3", "R42627902|H4", "R42627902|H5", "R42630044|H1", "R42630044|H2", "R42630044|H3", "R42630044|H4", "R42630044|H5", "R42639736|H1", "R42639736|H2", "R42639736|H3", "R42639736|H4", "R42639736|H5", "R42642518|H1", "R42642518|H2", "R42642518|H3", "R42642518|H4", "R42642518|H5", "R42642521|H1", "R42642521|H2", "R42642521|H3", "R42642521|H4", "R42642521|H5", "R42647119|H1", "R42647119|H2", "R42647119|H3", "R42647119|H4", "R42647119|H5", "R42647635|H1", "R42647635|H2", "R42647635|H3", "R42647635|H4", "R42647635|H5", "R42663085|H1", "R42663085|H2", "R42663085|H3", "R42663085|H4", "R42663085|H5", "R42664348|H1", "R42664348|H2", "R42664348|H3", "R42664348|H4", "R42664348|H5", "R42665751|H1", "R42665751|H2", "R42665751|H3", "R42665751|H4", "R42665751|H5", "R42689491|H1", "R42689491|H2", "R42689491|H3", "R42689491|H4", "R42689491|H5", "R42696595|H1", "R42696595|H2", "R42696595|H3", "R42696595|H4", "R42696595|H5", "R42717261|H1", "R42717261|H2", "R42717261|H3", "R42717261|H4", "R42717261|H5", "R42723546|H1", "R42723546|H2", "R42723546|H3", "R42723546|H4", "R42723546|H5", "R42725837|H1", "R42725837|H2", "R42725837|H3", "R42725837|H4", "R42725837|H5", "R42744804|H1", "R42744804|H2", "R42744804|H3", "R42744804|H4", "R42744804|H5", "R42749700|H1", "R42749700|H2", "R42749700|H3", "R42749700|H4", "R42749700|H5", "R42758848|H1", "R42758848|H2", "R42758848|H3", "R42758848|H4", "R42758848|H5", "R42759510|H1", "R42759510|H2", "R42759510|H3", "R42759510|H4", "R42759510|H5", "R42775695|H1", "R42775695|H2", "R42775695|H3", "R42775695|H4", "R42775695|H5", "R42775698|H1", "R42775698|H2", "R42775698|H3", "R42775698|H4", "R42775698|H5", "R42786310|H1", "R42786310|H2", "R42786310|H3", "R42786310|H4", "R42786310|H5", "R42805954|H1", "R42805954|H2", "R42805954|H3", "R42805954|H4", "R42805954|H5", "R42810392|H1", "R42810392|H2", "R42810392|H3", "R42810392|H4", "R42810392|H5", "R42811497|H1", "R42811497|H2", "R42811497|H3", "R42811497|H4", "R42811497|H5", "R42821663|H1", "R42821663|H2", "R42821663|H3", "R42821663|H4", "R42821663|H5", "R42822442|H1", "R42822442|H2", "R42822442|H3", "R42822442|H4", "R42822442|H5", "R42826184|H1", "R42826184|H2", "R42826184|H3", "R42826184|H4", "R42826184|H5", "R42839094|H1", "R42839094|H2", "R42839094|H3", "R42839094|H4", "R42839094|H5", "R42841227|H1", "R42841227|H2", "R42841227|H3", "R42841227|H4", "R42841227|H5", "R42842666|H1", "R42842666|H2", "R42842666|H3", "R42842666|H4", "R42842666|H5", "R42844664|H1", "R42844664|H2", "R42844664|H3", "R42844664|H4", "R42844664|H5", "R42853938|H1", "R42853938|H2", "R42853938|H3", "R42853938|H4", "R42853938|H5", "R42858183|H1", "R42858183|H2", "R42858183|H3", "R42858183|H4", "R42858183|H5", "R42806945|H1", "R42806945|H2", "R42806945|H3", "R42806945|H4", "R42806945|H5", "R42723144|H1", "R42723144|H2", "R42723144|H3", "R42723144|H4", "R42723144|H5", "R42808804|H1", "R42808804|H2", "R42808804|H3", "R42808804|H4", "R42808804|H5", "R42585340|H1", "R42585340|H2", "R42585340|H3", "R42585340|H4", "R42585340|H5", "R42669067|H1", "R42669067|H2", "R42669067|H3", "R42669067|H4", "R42669067|H5", "R42811065|H1", "R42811065|H2", "R42811065|H3", "R42811065|H4", "R42811065|H5", "R42841610|H1", "R42841610|H2", "R42841610|H3", "R42841610|H4", "R42841610|H5", "R42806003|H1", "R42806003|H2", "R42806003|H3", "R42806003|H4", "R42806003|H5", "R42806572|H1", "R42806572|H2", "R42806572|H3", "R42806572|H4", "R42806572|H5", "R42748238|H1", "R42748238|H2", "R42748238|H3", "R42748238|H4", "R42748238|H5" ], "excluded": [ "R42698274|H1", "R42698274|H2", "R42698274|H3", "R42698274|H4", "R42698274|H5", "R42736449|H1", "R42736449|H2", "R42736449|H3", "R42736449|H4", "R42736449|H5" ] }, "rules": [ { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 43, "matches": 11, "known": 32, "missed": 21, "counts": { "yes_true": 11, "yes_false": 32, "no_true": 21, "no_false": 176 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2558139534883721, "npv": 0.8934010152284264, "sens": 0.34375, "spec": 0.8461538461538461, "youden": 0.18990384615384626, "accuracy": 0.7791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5949519230769231 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.1404293381037567, "npv": 0.04794646977388095, "sens": -0.125, "spec": 0.3990384615384615, "youden": 0.2740384615384617, "accuracy": 0.32916666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.13701923076923084 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.13333333333333333, "hi": 0.3953488372093023, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.01785714285714285, "hi": 0.2760339693728731, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.85, "hi": 0.9336734693877551, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.008093084012292988, "hi": 0.10669191919191923, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.1935483870967742, "hi": 0.5172413793103449, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.37037037037037035, "hi": 0.12903225806451613, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8186046511627907, "hi": 0.8761904761904762, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.32075471698113206, "hi": 0.4757281553398058, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.018755159569113052, "hi": 0.3798858146684232, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.003327845835598233, "hi": 0.5502589958609374, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7333333333333333, "hi": 0.825, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.24583333333333335, "hi": 0.4125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5093775797845566, "hi": 0.6899429073342116, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.0016639229177991164, "hi": 0.2751294979304687, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 49, "matches": 13, "known": 32, "missed": 19, "counts": { "yes_true": 13, "yes_false": 36, "no_true": 19, "no_false": 172 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2653061224489796, "npv": 0.900523560209424, "sens": 0.40625, "spec": 0.8269230769230769, "youden": 0.23317307692307687, "accuracy": 0.7708333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6165865384615384 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.14992150706436422, "npv": 0.055069014754878576, "sens": -0.0625, "spec": 0.37980769230769224, "youden": 0.3173076923076923, "accuracy": 0.32083333333333336, "balancedAccuracy": 0.15865384615384615 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.14285714285714285, "hi": 0.40476190476190477, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.031224762238381693, "hi": 0.28617961145360155, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.859375, "hi": 0.9390862944162437, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0034953838127212145, "hi": 0.11458633091253487, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.25, "hi": 0.5714285714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.20012820512820328, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7777777777777778, "hi": 0.8719211822660099, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.30243902439024395, "hi": 0.4558823529411764, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.052085843940148244, "hi": 0.42020905923344953, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.037036704209601354, "hi": 0.6014973683092084, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7166666666666667, "hi": 0.8208333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2416666666666667, "hi": 0.39583333333333337, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5260429219700741, "hi": 0.7101045296167248, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.018518352104800677, "hi": 0.3007486841546042, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 71, "matches": 16, "known": 32, "missed": 16, "counts": { "yes_true": 16, "yes_false": 55, "no_true": 16, "no_false": 153 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.22535211267605634, "npv": 0.9053254437869822, "sens": 0.5, "spec": 0.7355769230769231, "youden": 0.23557692307692313, "accuracy": 0.7041666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6177884615384616 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.10996749729144095, "npv": 0.05987089833243675, "sens": 0.03125, "spec": 0.2884615384615385, "youden": 0.31971153846153855, "accuracy": 0.2541666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.15985576923076927 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.13333333333333333, "hi": 0.328125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.020218394409444986, "hi": 0.20930232558139533, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8597560975609756, "hi": 0.9467455621301775, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0010387377091598535, "hi": 0.12107631134696467, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.6774193548387096, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.22862637362637364, "hi": 0.29166666666666663, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.6854460093896714, "hi": 0.784037558685446, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2037914691943128, "hi": 0.37073571510362985, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.050650731990909616, "hi": 0.4288372093023256, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.03594771241830074, "hi": 0.6047619047619046, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.6541666666666667, "hi": 0.7541666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.17083333333333328, "hi": 0.33749999999999997, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5253253659954548, "hi": 0.7144186046511628, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.01797385620915037, "hi": 0.3023809523809523, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 21, "matches": 8, "known": 32, "missed": 24, "counts": { "yes_true": 8, "yes_false": 13, "no_true": 24, "no_false": 195 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.38095238095238093, "npv": 0.8904109589041096, "sens": 0.25, "spec": 0.9375, "youden": 0.1875, "accuracy": 0.8458333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.59375 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.2655677655677655, "npv": 0.04495641344956414, "sens": -0.21875, "spec": 0.49038461538461536, "youden": 0.2716346153846154, "accuracy": 0.3958333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1358173076923077 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.17647058823529413, "hi": 0.6, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.06538538953960457, "hi": 0.47732115497323346, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8520137850855339, "hi": 0.9276018099547512, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.009018037656961303, "hi": 0.10102328848508932, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.11428571428571428, "hi": 0.40540540540540543, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.4666666666666666, "hi": 0.033333333333333326, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9082125603864735, "hi": 0.9656862745098039, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4193548387096774, "hi": 0.5603864734299517, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.043266107615623536, "hi": 0.3483123724714714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.018602569302612677, "hi": 0.5322907683985202, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8041666666666667, "hi": 0.8875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3208333333333333, "hi": 0.47083333333333327, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5216330538078118, "hi": 0.6741561862357357, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.009301284651306339, "hi": 0.2661453841992601, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 51, "matches": 17, "known": 32, "missed": 15, "counts": { "yes_true": 17, "yes_false": 34, "no_true": 15, "no_false": 174 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3333333333333333, "npv": 0.9206349206349206, "sens": 0.53125, "spec": 0.8365384615384616, "youden": 0.3677884615384617, "accuracy": 0.7958333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6838942307692308 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.21794871794871792, "npv": 0.07518037518037513, "sens": 0.0625, "spec": 0.3894230769230769, "youden": 0.4519230769230771, "accuracy": 0.34583333333333327, "balancedAccuracy": 0.22596153846153855 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.20408163265306123, "hi": 0.46938775510204084, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.09403916907228167, "hi": 0.3496147348213841, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8829787234042553, "hi": 0.9565217391304348, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.013144708597853964, "hi": 0.13703006799005354, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3793103448275862, "hi": 0.6896551724137931, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.2068965517241379, "hi": 0.3235294117647059, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8, "hi": 0.8712871287128713, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.31578947368421056, "hi": 0.4622641509433962, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.19303255282695586, "hi": 0.5474750776270634, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.1570149835232692, "hi": 0.7401991026023091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.75, "hi": 0.8376041666666652, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2666666666666667, "hi": 0.42083333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5965162764134779, "hi": 0.7737375388135317, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.0785074917616346, "hi": 0.3700995513011546, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 71, "matches": 19, "known": 32, "missed": 13, "counts": { "yes_true": 19, "yes_false": 52, "no_true": 13, "no_false": 156 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2676056338028169, "npv": 0.9230769230769231, "sens": 0.59375, "spec": 0.75, "youden": 0.34375, "accuracy": 0.7291666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.671875 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.1522210184182015, "npv": 0.07762237762237767, "sens": 0.125, "spec": 0.30288461538461536, "youden": 0.4278846153846154, "accuracy": 0.2791666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2139423076923077 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.17333333333333334, "hi": 0.3783783783783784, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.05445023045962037, "hi": 0.2585633402606515, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8809523809523809, "hi": 0.9590643274853801, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.012637260536826204, "hi": 0.14223199761617397, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.4444444444444444, "hi": 0.75, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.1470588235294118, "hi": 0.3823529411764706, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7047619047619048, "hi": 0.7969561994270492, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2142857142857143, "hi": 0.3894230769230769, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.16346153846153832, "hi": 0.5242566510172144, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.12497473045822105, "hi": 0.71875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.6791666666666667, "hi": 0.7791666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.1875, "hi": 0.3666666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5817307692307692, "hi": 0.7621283255086072, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.062487365229110525, "hi": 0.359375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 23, "matches": 9, "known": 32, "missed": 23, "counts": { "yes_true": 9, "yes_false": 14, "no_true": 23, "no_false": 194 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.391304347826087, "npv": 0.8940092165898618, "sens": 0.28125, "spec": 0.9326923076923077, "youden": 0.2139423076923077, "accuracy": 0.8458333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6069711538461539 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.2759197324414716, "npv": 0.04855467113531631, "sens": -0.1875, "spec": 0.4855769230769231, "youden": 0.29807692307692313, "accuracy": 0.3958333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.14903846153846156 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.19230769230769232, "hi": 0.5925925925925926, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.08630385716057695, "hi": 0.4736192175177405, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8552036199095022, "hi": 0.9308755760368663, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.005038823943200729, "hi": 0.10445913832822844, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.13793103448275862, "hi": 0.4411764705882353, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.42857142857142855, "hi": 0.06060606060606061, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9033816425120773, "hi": 0.9609756097560975, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4187192118226601, "hi": 0.5518867924528301, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.06266846361185974, "hi": 0.37953488372093025, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.04329612826531822, "hi": 0.5523854447439352, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8083333333333333, "hi": 0.8833333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.32499999999999996, "hi": 0.4666666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5313342318059299, "hi": 0.6897674418604651, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.02164806413265911, "hi": 0.2761927223719676, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 67, "matches": 17, "known": 32, "missed": 15, "counts": { "yes_true": 17, "yes_false": 50, "no_true": 15, "no_false": 158 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2537313432835821, "npv": 0.9132947976878613, "sens": 0.53125, "spec": 0.7596153846153846, "youden": 0.2908653846153846, "accuracy": 0.7291666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6454326923076923 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.1383467278989667, "npv": 0.0678402522333158, "sens": 0.0625, "spec": 0.31249999999999994, "youden": 0.375, "accuracy": 0.2791666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1875 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.15151515151515152, "hi": 0.3728813559322034, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.0373506440400736, "hi": 0.2528631806065012, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.872093023255814, "hi": 0.9508221864628381, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.004657302077275614, "hi": 0.13031923625355266, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3793103448275862, "hi": 0.6896551724137931, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.2068965517241379, "hi": 0.3235294117647059, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7023255813953488, "hi": 0.8133971291866029, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2358490566037736, "hi": 0.38725490196078427, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.1064746732026143, "hi": 0.47370559343152047, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.07686205533816139, "hi": 0.6666666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.6708333333333333, "hi": 0.7875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.19583333333333341, "hi": 0.3583333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5532373366013071, "hi": 0.7368527967157602, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.03843102766908069, "hi": 0.33333333333333337, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 33, "matches": 13, "known": 32, "missed": 19, "counts": { "yes_true": 13, "yes_false": 20, "no_true": 19, "no_false": 188 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3939393939393939, "npv": 0.9082125603864735, "sens": 0.40625, "spec": 0.9038461538461539, "youden": 0.31009615384615374, "accuracy": 0.8375, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6550480769230769 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.2785547785547785, "npv": 0.06275801493192801, "sens": -0.0625, "spec": 0.4567307692307692, "youden": 0.39423076923076916, "accuracy": 0.3875, "balancedAccuracy": 0.19711538461538458 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.22857142857142856, "hi": 0.5666666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.11914741209815641, "hi": 0.4456771919292945, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8708133971291866, "hi": 0.9436673613107214, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.004761278195488706, "hi": 0.12195624439521069, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.25, "hi": 0.5714285714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.20012820512820328, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8701923076923077, "hi": 0.9362745098039216, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990292, "hi": 0.5343137254901961, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.1428571428571428, "hi": 0.48557692307692313, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.1173445321524836, "hi": 0.6738675958188154, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7958333333333333, "hi": 0.875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.31249999999999994, "hi": 0.4625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5714285714285714, "hi": 0.7427884615384616, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.0586722660762418, "hi": 0.3369337979094077, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 84, "matches": 19, "known": 32, "missed": 13, "counts": { "yes_true": 19, "yes_false": 65, "no_true": 13, "no_false": 143 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2261904761904762, "npv": 0.9166666666666666, "sens": 0.59375, "spec": 0.6875, "youden": 0.28125, "accuracy": 0.675, "balancedAccuracy": 0.640625 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.1108058608058608, "npv": 0.07121212121212117, "sens": 0.125, "spec": 0.24038461538461536, "youden": 0.3653846153846154, "accuracy": 0.22500000000000003, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1826923076923077 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.14432989690721648, "hi": 0.3246753246753247, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.02539091472748925, "hi": 0.20448490081602755, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8717948717948718, "hi": 0.9557031685375367, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.005053998065553043, "hi": 0.13614071767895009, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.4444444444444444, "hi": 0.75, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.1470588235294118, "hi": 0.3823529411764706, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.6338028169014085, "hi": 0.7424279927992798, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.15419662113587343, "hi": 0.3233867427568042, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.09622913835200196, "hi": 0.4642173746651359, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.06324113019494775, "hi": 0.6562741163759839, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.6166666666666667, "hi": 0.7333333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.13749999999999996, "hi": 0.30833333333333335, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.548114569176001, "hi": 0.732108687332568, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.03162056509747387, "hi": 0.32813705818799194, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 41, "matches": 14, "known": 32, "missed": 18, "counts": { "yes_true": 14, "yes_false": 27, "no_true": 18, "no_false": 181 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.34146341463414637, "npv": 0.9095477386934674, "sens": 0.4375, "spec": 0.8701923076923077, "youden": 0.3076923076923077, "accuracy": 0.8125, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6538461538461539 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.22607879924953098, "npv": 0.06409319323892193, "sens": -0.03125, "spec": 0.4230769230769231, "youden": 0.39182692307692313, "accuracy": 0.3625, "balancedAccuracy": 0.19591346153846156 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.2, "hi": 0.4883720930232558, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.0902974124394638, "hi": 0.36989018541264546, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.87, "hi": 0.945, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.006649696415599157, "hi": 0.12257024897167584, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.28125, "hi": 0.6071428571428571, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.29032258064516125, "hi": 0.22862637362637278, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8388625592417062, "hi": 0.9025728155339805, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3465298237140787, "hi": 0.4976744186046511, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.1333333333333333, "hi": 0.49011857707509887, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.11631292383933235, "hi": 0.6666755425376114, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7708333333333334, "hi": 0.8541666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2875, "hi": 0.4375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5666666666666667, "hi": 0.7450592885375494, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.058156461919666176, "hi": 0.3333377712688057, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 18, "matches": 8, "known": 32, "missed": 24, "counts": { "yes_true": 8, "yes_false": 10, "no_true": 24, "no_false": 198 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.4444444444444444, "npv": 0.8918918918918919, "sens": 0.25, "spec": 0.9519230769230769, "youden": 0.20192307692307687, "accuracy": 0.8583333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6009615384615384 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.329059829059829, "npv": 0.04643734643734643, "sens": -0.21875, "spec": 0.5048076923076923, "youden": 0.2860576923076923, "accuracy": 0.40833333333333327, "balancedAccuracy": 0.14302884615384615 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.21428571428571427, "hi": 0.6842105263157895, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.10407407695579554, "hi": 0.5592306925049871, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8539797753263022, "hi": 0.9282511210762332, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.007513523620987641, "hi": 0.10245366731464052, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.11428571428571428, "hi": 0.40540540540540543, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.4666666666666666, "hi": 0.033333333333333326, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9252336448598131, "hi": 0.9759644138755981, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4347826086956522, "hi": 0.5734597156398105, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.06062717770034842, "hi": 0.3591095932369515, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.03270647685285824, "hi": 0.5442690437558003, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8208333333333333, "hi": 0.8958333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.33333333333333337, "hi": 0.4791666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5303135888501742, "hi": 0.6795547966184757, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.01635323842642912, "hi": 0.27213452187790016, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 100, "matches": 19, "known": 32, "missed": 13, "counts": { "yes_true": 19, "yes_false": 81, "no_true": 13, "no_false": 127 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.19, "npv": 0.9071428571428571, "sens": 0.59375, "spec": 0.6105769230769231, "youden": 0.20432692307692313, "accuracy": 0.6083333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6021634615384616 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.07461538461538461, "npv": 0.06168831168831168, "sens": 0.125, "spec": 0.1634615384615385, "youden": 0.28846153846153855, "accuracy": 0.15833333333333327, "balancedAccuracy": 0.14423076923076927 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.11926605504587157, "hi": 0.27083820093457933, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.008558449482308557, "hi": 0.1484375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8592592592592593, "hi": 0.950354609929078, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.0012279773770340178, "hi": 0.12156634348697502, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.4411764705882353, "hi": 0.75, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.11111111111111116, "hi": 0.3548387096774193, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.5377358490566038, "hi": 0.6824760143336029, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.06730769230769229, "hi": 0.25961538461538464, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.02701034110202194, "hi": 0.3811895598133346, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.02586965268760169, "hi": 0.5449917232597621, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.5416666666666666, "hi": 0.675, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.06666666666666665, "hi": 0.25, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.513505170551011, "hi": 0.6905947799066673, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.012934826343800845, "hi": 0.27249586162988104, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 109, "matches": 19, "known": 32, "missed": 13, "counts": { "yes_true": 19, "yes_false": 90, "no_true": 13, "no_false": 118 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.1743119266055046, "npv": 0.9007633587786259, "sens": 0.59375, "spec": 0.5673076923076923, "youden": 0.1610576923076923, "accuracy": 0.5708333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5805288461538461 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.058927311220889206, "npv": 0.05530881332408044, "sens": 0.125, "spec": 0.12019230769230765, "youden": 0.2451923076923077, "accuracy": 0.12083333333333329, "balancedAccuracy": 0.12259615384615385 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.11016754781526979, "hi": 0.24752475247524752, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.002624158372821479, "hi": 0.12781986746527335, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.85, "hi": 0.9465648854961832, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.006140674179031062, "hi": 0.11643063311420557, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.4411764705882353, "hi": 0.75, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.11111111111111116, "hi": 0.3548387096774193, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.49514563106796117, "hi": 0.6407766990291263, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.02380952380952378, "hi": 0.22000000000000003, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.016175505893242084, "hi": 0.33831134181495043, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.019541778975741057, "hi": 0.5064575203432761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.5, "hi": 0.6416666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.02916666666666662, "hi": 0.21666666666666662, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.49191224705337894, "hi": 0.6691556709074752, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.009770889487870528, "hi": 0.25322876017163803, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 34, "matches": 11, "known": 32, "missed": 21, "counts": { "yes_true": 11, "yes_false": 23, "no_true": 21, "no_false": 185 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3235294117647059, "npv": 0.8980582524271845, "sens": 0.34375, "spec": 0.8894230769230769, "youden": 0.23317307692307687, "accuracy": 0.8166666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6165865384615384 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.2081447963800905, "npv": 0.05260370697263905, "sens": -0.125, "spec": 0.44230769230769224, "youden": 0.3173076923076923, "accuracy": 0.36666666666666664, "balancedAccuracy": 0.15865384615384615 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.17142857142857143, "hi": 0.4857142857142857, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.05877521934016364, "hi": 0.366798628215654, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8571428571428571, "hi": 0.9365853658536586, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0028472742554597184, "hi": 0.11039867746211027, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.1935483870967742, "hi": 0.5172413793103449, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.37037037037037035, "hi": 0.12903225806451613, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8584905660377359, "hi": 0.9207920792079208, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.36274509803921573, "hi": 0.5170731707317073, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.06587615283267456, "hi": 0.4190476190476189, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.04848284328058455, "hi": 0.5885477531019028, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.775, "hi": 0.8625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2833333333333333, "hi": 0.44583333333333336, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5329380764163373, "hi": 0.7095238095238094, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.024241421640292277, "hi": 0.2942738765509514, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 113, "matches": 19, "known": 32, "missed": 13, "counts": { "yes_true": 19, "yes_false": 94, "no_true": 13, "no_false": 114 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.168141592920354, "npv": 0.8976377952755905, "sens": 0.59375, "spec": 0.5480769230769231, "youden": 0.14182692307692313, "accuracy": 0.5541666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5709134615384616 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.0527569775357386, "npv": 0.05218324982104505, "sens": 0.125, "spec": 0.10096153846153849, "youden": 0.22596153846153855, "accuracy": 0.10416666666666669, "balancedAccuracy": 0.11298076923076927 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.10526315789473684, "hi": 0.24, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.006423452488497745, "hi": 0.11772649405846125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8472128378378379, "hi": 0.9448818897637795, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.00973798268815127, "hi": 0.11316662073960583, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.4411764705882353, "hi": 0.75, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.11111111111111116, "hi": 0.3548387096774193, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.4790697674418605, "hi": 0.616504854368932, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.004854368932038833, "hi": 0.1970443349753695, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.035144850996021076, "hi": 0.31777124370941834, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.03487339677727558, "hi": 0.4836261243011102, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4875, "hi": 0.6208333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.012500000000000011, "hi": 0.1958333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.4824275745019895, "hi": 0.6588856218547092, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.01743669838863779, "hi": 0.2418130621505551, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 36, "matches": 13, "known": 32, "missed": 19, "counts": { "yes_true": 13, "yes_false": 23, "no_true": 19, "no_false": 185 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3611111111111111, "npv": 0.9068627450980392, "sens": 0.40625, "spec": 0.8894230769230769, "youden": 0.29567307692307687, "accuracy": 0.825, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6478365384615384 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.24572649572649571, "npv": 0.061408199643493755, "sens": -0.0625, "spec": 0.44230769230769224, "youden": 0.3798076923076923, "accuracy": 0.37499999999999994, "balancedAccuracy": 0.18990384615384615 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.2, "hi": 0.56, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.08752922661870503, "hi": 0.4383705789728682, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8685446009389671, "hi": 0.943127962085308, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.003454595978611955, "hi": 0.12034640571828947, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.25, "hi": 0.5714285714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.20012820512820328, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8349503114123465, "hi": 0.9375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3658443729107342, "hi": 0.5169082125603865, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.12288953830783798, "hi": 0.4762003345027331, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.09895085337000052, "hi": 0.659473576076143, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7708333333333334, "hi": 0.875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2958333333333334, "hi": 0.45000000000000007, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5614447691539189, "hi": 0.7381001672513665, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.04947542668500026, "hi": 0.3297367880380715, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 120, "matches": 19, "known": 32, "missed": 13, "counts": { "yes_true": 19, "yes_false": 101, "no_true": 13, "no_false": 107 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.15833333333333333, "npv": 0.8916666666666667, "sens": 0.59375, "spec": 0.5144230769230769, "youden": 0.10817307692307687, "accuracy": 0.525, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5540865384615384 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.042948717948717935, "npv": 0.04621212121212126, "sens": 0.125, "spec": 0.06730769230769224, "youden": 0.1923076923076923, "accuracy": 0.07500000000000001, "balancedAccuracy": 0.09615384615384615 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.1, "hi": 0.22500563063063056, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.013922099033270107, "hi": 0.10559912434137657, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8384615384615385, "hi": 0.9411764705882353, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.01681406971033673, "hi": 0.10909296452901104, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.4411764705882353, "hi": 0.75, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.11111111111111116, "hi": 0.3548387096774193, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.44776119402985076, "hi": 0.5829250418760468, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": -0.02870813397129185, "hi": 0.16433626760563358, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.06748541955674998, "hi": 0.28095238095238084, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.06938086854460097, "hi": 0.45238095238095233, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4583333333333333, "hi": 0.5916666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": -0.016666666666666663, "hi": 0.16666666666666669, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.466257290221625, "hi": 0.6404761904761904, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.03469043427230049, "hi": 0.22619047619047616, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 53, "matches": 16, "known": 32, "missed": 16, "counts": { "yes_true": 16, "yes_false": 37, "no_true": 16, "no_false": 171 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3018867924528302, "npv": 0.9144385026737968, "sens": 0.5, "spec": 0.8221153846153846, "youden": 0.3221153846153846, "accuracy": 0.7791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6610576923076923 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.1865021770682148, "npv": 0.06898395721925132, "sens": 0.03125, "spec": 0.37499999999999994, "youden": 0.40625, "accuracy": 0.32916666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.203125 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.17857142857142858, "hi": 0.44, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.06730567226890757, "hi": 0.31866262341363055, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8723404255319149, "hi": 0.9518716577540107, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.009381148032829793, "hi": 0.1289642933979318, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.6774193548387096, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.22862637362637364, "hi": 0.29166666666666663, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7718342579750347, "hi": 0.87, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.29523809523809524, "hi": 0.45098039215686275, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.1342580033631576, "hi": 0.5168269230769231, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.12090141612200439, "hi": 0.6859839902600363, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.725, "hi": 0.8333333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.24989583333333337, "hi": 0.4083333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5671290016815788, "hi": 0.7584134615384616, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.060450708061002195, "hi": 0.34299199513001816, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 19, "matches": 8, "known": 32, "missed": 24, "counts": { "yes_true": 8, "yes_false": 11, "no_true": 24, "no_false": 197 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.42105263157894735, "npv": 0.8914027149321267, "sens": 0.25, "spec": 0.9471153846153846, "youden": 0.19711538461538458, "accuracy": 0.8541666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5985576923076923 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.3056680161943319, "npv": 0.04594816947758129, "sens": -0.21875, "spec": 0.49999999999999994, "youden": 0.28125, "accuracy": 0.4041666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.140625 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.2, "hi": 0.6470588235294118, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.08805820895522389, "hi": 0.5322382352941176, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8533302752293579, "hi": 0.9279360077566354, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.008061072581384334, "hi": 0.10207486012439572, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.11428571428571428, "hi": 0.40540540540540543, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.4666666666666666, "hi": 0.033333333333333326, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9195979899497487, "hi": 0.9716981132075472, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.427906976744186, "hi": 0.570754716981132, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.05477308294209693, "hi": 0.35679759109826986, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.0257747240501695, "hi": 0.5416666666666665, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8166666666666667, "hi": 0.8958333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.32916666666666666, "hi": 0.47916666666666663, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5273865414710485, "hi": 0.678398795549135, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.01288736202508475, "hi": 0.27083333333333326, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 113, "matches": 21, "known": 32, "missed": 11, "counts": { "yes_true": 21, "yes_false": 92, "no_true": 11, "no_false": 116 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.18584070796460178, "npv": 0.9133858267716536, "sens": 0.65625, "spec": 0.5576923076923077, "youden": 0.2139423076923077, "accuracy": 0.5708333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6069711538461539 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.07045609257998639, "npv": 0.06793128131710813, "sens": 0.1875, "spec": 0.11057692307692307, "youden": 0.29807692307692313, "accuracy": 0.12083333333333329, "balancedAccuracy": 0.14903846153846156 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.12195121951219512, "hi": 0.2596249999999999, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.00724378881987577, "hi": 0.14017216989382725, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.864, "hi": 0.9586776859504132, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.001913361470039415, "hi": 0.1315443632169199, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.5135135135135135, "hi": 0.8108108108108109, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.0625, "hi": 0.42857142857142855, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.48528676470588233, "hi": 0.6313197767145134, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.013697073474470734, "hi": 0.21078431372549017, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.04166666666666652, "hi": 0.3846192251364664, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.023809523809523725, "hi": 0.5660501653118549, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.5, "hi": 0.6375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.025000000000000022, "hi": 0.21666666666666662, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5208333333333333, "hi": 0.6923096125682332, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.011904761904761862, "hi": 0.28302508265592746, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 38, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 23, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 185 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.39473684210526316, "npv": 0.9158415841584159, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.8894230769230769, "youden": 0.35817307692307687, "accuracy": 0.8333333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6790865384615384 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.27935222672064774, "npv": 0.07038703870387042, "sens": 0, "spec": 0.44230769230769224, "youden": 0.4423076923076923, "accuracy": 0.38333333333333336, "balancedAccuracy": 0.22115384615384615 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.23529411764705882, "hi": 0.5641025641025641, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.1304787749563869, "hi": 0.4397851222420989, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.88, "hi": 0.949748743718593, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.012983626281057498, "hi": 0.1287825059376891, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3181818181818182, "hi": 0.625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.25806451612903225, "hi": 0.24999999999999994, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.84688995215311, "hi": 0.9278846153846154, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.37142503536067895, "hi": 0.5141509433962264, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.18976744186046512, "hi": 0.5257029196371962, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.16826923076923084, "hi": 0.7083362273247261, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7916666666666666, "hi": 0.875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.30833333333333335, "hi": 0.45416666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5948837209302326, "hi": 0.762851459818598, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.08413461538461542, "hi": 0.35416811366236306, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 121, "matches": 21, "known": 32, "missed": 11, "counts": { "yes_true": 21, "yes_false": 100, "no_true": 11, "no_false": 108 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.17355371900826447, "npv": 0.907563025210084, "sens": 0.65625, "spec": 0.5192307692307693, "youden": 0.17548076923076916, "accuracy": 0.5375, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5877403846153846 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.05816910362364908, "npv": 0.06210847975553857, "sens": 0.1875, "spec": 0.07211538461538464, "youden": 0.2596153846153846, "accuracy": 0.08749999999999997, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1298076923076923 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.11475409836065574, "hi": 0.24324324324324326, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.0024167450009167277, "hi": 0.12444681792364137, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8548387096774194, "hi": 0.9553571428571429, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.005431937783689844, "hi": 0.12687848893060633, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.5135135135135135, "hi": 0.8108108108108109, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.0625, "hi": 0.42857142857142855, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.4460093896713615, "hi": 0.5933053481196618, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": -0.028571428571428525, "hi": 0.17391304347826086, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.005393038078117307, "hi": 0.34703504043126676, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.01559137422224369, "hi": 0.528270368414814, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4666666666666667, "hi": 0.6083333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": -0.00833333333333336, "hi": 0.18333333333333335, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5026965190390587, "hi": 0.6735175202156334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.007795687111121845, "hi": 0.264135184207407, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 51, "matches": 17, "known": 32, "missed": 15, "counts": { "yes_true": 17, "yes_false": 34, "no_true": 15, "no_false": 174 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3333333333333333, "npv": 0.9206349206349206, "sens": 0.53125, "spec": 0.8365384615384616, "youden": 0.3677884615384617, "accuracy": 0.7958333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6838942307692308 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.21794871794871792, "npv": 0.07518037518037513, "sens": 0.0625, "spec": 0.3894230769230769, "youden": 0.4519230769230771, "accuracy": 0.34583333333333327, "balancedAccuracy": 0.22596153846153855 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.20754716981132076, "hi": 0.4716981132075472, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.09502054467681828, "hi": 0.3496306454836131, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8823529411764706, "hi": 0.9543147208121827, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.015431641525591162, "hi": 0.13536978168789293, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3783783783783784, "hi": 0.6896551724137931, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.1935483870967742, "hi": 0.30769230769230765, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7922705314009661, "hi": 0.8792270531400966, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.30733889013202054, "hi": 0.46969696969696967, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.19143849844432656, "hi": 0.5474485591836673, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.16847486842328072, "hi": 0.7233424311010517, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7458333333333333, "hi": 0.8416666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.26249999999999996, "hi": 0.42500000000000004, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5957192492221632, "hi": 0.7737242795918337, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.08423743421164036, "hi": 0.36167121555052584, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 22, "matches": 9, "known": 32, "missed": 23, "counts": { "yes_true": 9, "yes_false": 13, "no_true": 23, "no_false": 195 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.4090909090909091, "npv": 0.8944954128440367, "sens": 0.28125, "spec": 0.9375, "youden": 0.21875, "accuracy": 0.85, "balancedAccuracy": 0.609375 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.29370629370629375, "npv": 0.049040867389491205, "sens": -0.1875, "spec": 0.49038461538461536, "youden": 0.3028846153846154, "accuracy": 0.39999999999999997, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1514423076923077 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.20833333333333334, "hi": 0.6190476190476191, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.09788755453147995, "hi": 0.4959153956122774, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8558558558558559, "hi": 0.9311926605504587, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.004578964613368269, "hi": 0.10489450521066197, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.13793103448275862, "hi": 0.4411764705882353, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.42857142857142855, "hi": 0.06060606060606061, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9086538461538461, "hi": 0.9653465346534653, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4228855721393035, "hi": 0.5571428571428572, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.06938954765041716, "hi": 0.3841860465116278, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.047675952351770544, "hi": 0.5571462264150943, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8125, "hi": 0.8916666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.32500000000000007, "hi": 0.4708333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5346947738252086, "hi": 0.6920930232558139, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.023837976175885272, "hi": 0.27857311320754713, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 119, "matches": 21, "known": 32, "missed": 11, "counts": { "yes_true": 21, "yes_false": 98, "no_true": 11, "no_false": 110 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.17647058823529413, "npv": 0.9090909090909091, "sens": 0.65625, "spec": 0.5288461538461539, "youden": 0.18509615384615374, "accuracy": 0.5458333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5925480769230769 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.06108597285067874, "npv": 0.0636363636363636, "sens": 0.1875, "spec": 0.08173076923076922, "youden": 0.26923076923076916, "accuracy": 0.09583333333333327, "balancedAccuracy": 0.13461538461538458 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.11627906976744186, "hi": 0.24561403508771928, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.0015270746202949617, "hi": 0.12530868362764913, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8583316929133857, "hi": 0.956140350877193, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.002136752136752129, "hi": 0.12724240601633602, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.5135135135135135, "hi": 0.8108108108108109, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.0625, "hi": 0.42857142857142855, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.46045583578993343, "hi": 0.6, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": -0.009661835748792258, "hi": 0.17452830188679247, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.017671732491752686, "hi": 0.3495829894128411, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.5310508578431373, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4791666666666667, "hi": 0.6125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.004166666666666763, "hi": 0.1833333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5088358662458763, "hi": 0.6747914947064205, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.26552542892156866, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 55, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 40, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 168 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2727272727272727, "npv": 0.9081081081081082, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.8076923076923077, "youden": 0.2764423076923077, "accuracy": 0.7625, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6382211538461539 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.15734265734265732, "npv": 0.0626535626535627, "sens": 0, "spec": 0.3605769230769231, "youden": 0.36057692307692313, "accuracy": 0.31249999999999994, "balancedAccuracy": 0.18028846153846156 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.15384615384615385, "hi": 0.41509433962264153, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.044033619663823895, "hi": 0.2890893096368982, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8688524590163934, "hi": 0.945054945054945, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.0031138745679085335, "hi": 0.12260898946055407, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3181818181818182, "hi": 0.625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.25806451612903225, "hi": 0.24999999999999994, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7511737089201878, "hi": 0.8605769230769231, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2764948011949147, "hi": 0.4427860696517413, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.09523809523809512, "hi": 0.4571673329525985, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.07516339869281041, "hi": 0.6376471268118897, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7041666666666667, "hi": 0.8166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.22500000000000003, "hi": 0.3958333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5476190476190476, "hi": 0.7285836664762992, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.037581699346405206, "hi": 0.31882356340594487, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 26, "matches": 13, "known": 32, "missed": 19, "counts": { "yes_true": 13, "yes_false": 13, "no_true": 19, "no_false": 195 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.5, "npv": 0.9112149532710281, "sens": 0.40625, "spec": 0.9375, "youden": 0.34375, "accuracy": 0.8666666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.671875 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.3846153846153846, "npv": 0.06576040781648262, "sens": -0.0625, "spec": 0.49038461538461536, "youden": 0.4278846153846154, "accuracy": 0.4166666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2139423076923077 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.30434782608695654, "hi": 0.7, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.19456925243215567, "hi": 0.5786274832826991, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8744186046511628, "hi": 0.9454567956795679, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.00814733955597741, "hi": 0.12405714604078781, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.25, "hi": 0.5714285714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.20012820512820328, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9052132701421801, "hi": 0.9663461538461539, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.42180094786729855, "hi": 0.5586854460093896, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.1794470526864893, "hi": 0.5138247867612856, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.1545851027974385, "hi": 0.7024631999477281, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.825, "hi": 0.9041666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3458333333333333, "hi": 0.4875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5897235263432447, "hi": 0.7569123933806428, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.07729255139871925, "hi": 0.35123159997386405, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 125, "matches": 21, "known": 32, "missed": 11, "counts": { "yes_true": 21, "yes_false": 104, "no_true": 11, "no_false": 104 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.168, "npv": 0.9043478260869565, "sens": 0.65625, "spec": 0.5, "youden": 0.15625, "accuracy": 0.5208333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.578125 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.05261538461538462, "npv": 0.05889328063241106, "sens": 0.1875, "spec": 0.05288461538461536, "youden": 0.24038461538461542, "accuracy": 0.07083333333333336, "balancedAccuracy": 0.12019230769230771 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.11191956882255392, "hi": 0.23333333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.006265664160401002, "hi": 0.11546454883855431, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8512396694214877, "hi": 0.9537037037037037, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.008548850574712615, "hi": 0.12386163808410947, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.5135135135135135, "hi": 0.8108108108108109, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.0625, "hi": 0.42857142857142855, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.431924882629108, "hi": 0.57, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": -0.04285714285714287, "hi": 0.14815257841573629, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.009347729201470987, "hi": 0.3231991702930938, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.032679738562091616, "hi": 0.5059252352416216, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.45416666666666666, "hi": 0.5833333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": -0.020833333333333315, "hi": 0.16249999999999998, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.4953261353992645, "hi": 0.6615995851465469, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.016339869281045808, "hi": 0.2529626176208108, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 69, "matches": 17, "known": 32, "missed": 15, "counts": { "yes_true": 17, "yes_false": 52, "no_true": 15, "no_false": 156 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2463768115942029, "npv": 0.9122807017543859, "sens": 0.53125, "spec": 0.75, "youden": 0.28125, "accuracy": 0.7208333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.640625 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.13099219620958752, "npv": 0.06682615629984046, "sens": 0.0625, "spec": 0.30288461538461536, "youden": 0.3653846153846154, "accuracy": 0.2708333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1826923076923077 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.14666666666666667, "hi": 0.36507936507936506, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.034076730213555555, "hi": 0.2419404725253423, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8698160535117057, "hi": 0.95, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.005639733055547518, "hi": 0.12817346013718073, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3783783783783784, "hi": 0.6896551724137931, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.1935483870967742, "hi": 0.30769230769230765, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.6922985781990522, "hi": 0.8066077613708869, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2119775941522326, "hi": 0.39108910891089105, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.0915032679738561, "hi": 0.46884134645521197, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.07565741420841551, "hi": 0.6447211343707122, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.6623958333333334, "hi": 0.7791666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.1791666666666667, "hi": 0.35833333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.545751633986928, "hi": 0.734420673227606, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.03782870710420776, "hi": 0.3223605671853561, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 31, "matches": 14, "known": 32, "missed": 18, "counts": { "yes_true": 14, "yes_false": 17, "no_true": 18, "no_false": 191 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.45161290322580644, "npv": 0.9138755980861244, "sens": 0.4375, "spec": 0.9182692307692307, "youden": 0.35576923076923084, "accuracy": 0.8541666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6778846153846154 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.3362282878411911, "npv": 0.06842105263157894, "sens": -0.03125, "spec": 0.4711538461538461, "youden": 0.43990384615384626, "accuracy": 0.4041666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.21995192307692313 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.2758405172413793, "hi": 0.6296783625730987, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.1661757943953066, "hi": 0.5104370754963424, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8761467889908257, "hi": 0.9478672985781991, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.011137580061632889, "hi": 0.12638795275997902, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.28125, "hi": 0.6071428571428571, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.29032258064516125, "hi": 0.22862637362637278, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8846153846153846, "hi": 0.9507389162561576, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4019607843137255, "hi": 0.5388349514563107, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.18707750924219352, "hi": 0.5336087718742953, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.1658626722473705, "hi": 0.7140581232492997, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8125, "hi": 0.8958333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.475, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5935387546210967, "hi": 0.7668043859371477, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.08293133612368525, "hi": 0.35702906162464987, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 4, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 18, "matches": 8, "known": 32, "missed": 24, "counts": { "yes_true": 8, "yes_false": 10, "no_true": 24, "no_false": 198 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.4444444444444444, "npv": 0.8918918918918919, "sens": 0.25, "spec": 0.9519230769230769, "youden": 0.20192307692307687, "accuracy": 0.8583333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6009615384615384 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.329059829059829, "npv": 0.04643734643734643, "sens": -0.21875, "spec": 0.5048076923076923, "youden": 0.2860576923076923, "accuracy": 0.40833333333333327, "balancedAccuracy": 0.14302884615384615 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.21428571428571427, "hi": 0.6842105263157895, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.10407407695579554, "hi": 0.5592306925049871, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8539797753263022, "hi": 0.9282511210762332, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.007513523620987641, "hi": 0.10245366731464052, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.11428571428571428, "hi": 0.40540540540540543, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.4666666666666666, "hi": 0.033333333333333326, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9252336448598131, "hi": 0.9759644138755981, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4347826086956522, "hi": 0.5734597156398105, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.06062717770034842, "hi": 0.3591095932369515, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.03270647685285824, "hi": 0.5442690437558003, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8208333333333333, "hi": 0.8958333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.33333333333333337, "hi": 0.4791666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5303135888501742, "hi": 0.6795547966184757, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.01635323842642912, "hi": 0.27213452187790016, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } } ], "baselines": [ { "model": "claude-sonnet-5-5", "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 43, "matches": 11, "known": 32, "missed": 21, "counts": { "yes_true": 11, "yes_false": 32, "no_true": 21, "no_false": 176 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2558139534883721, "npv": 0.8934010152284264, "sens": 0.34375, "spec": 0.8461538461538461, "youden": 0.18990384615384626, "accuracy": 0.7791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5949519230769231 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.1404293381037567, "npv": 0.04794646977388095, "sens": -0.125, "spec": 0.3990384615384615, "youden": 0.2740384615384617, "accuracy": 0.32916666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.13701923076923084 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.13333333333333333, "hi": 0.3953488372093023, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.01785714285714285, "hi": 0.2760339693728731, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.85, "hi": 0.9336734693877551, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.008093084012292988, "hi": 0.10669191919191923, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.1935483870967742, "hi": 0.5172413793103449, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.37037037037037035, "hi": 0.12903225806451613, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8186046511627907, "hi": 0.8761904761904762, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.32075471698113206, "hi": 0.4757281553398058, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.018755159569113052, "hi": 0.3798858146684232, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.003327845835598233, "hi": 0.5502589958609374, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7333333333333333, "hi": 0.825, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.24583333333333335, "hi": 0.4125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5093775797845566, "hi": 0.6899429073342116, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.0016639229177991164, "hi": 0.2751294979304687, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "gpt-6-astra", "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 49, "matches": 13, "known": 32, "missed": 19, "counts": { "yes_true": 13, "yes_false": 36, "no_true": 19, "no_false": 172 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2653061224489796, "npv": 0.900523560209424, "sens": 0.40625, "spec": 0.8269230769230769, "youden": 0.23317307692307687, "accuracy": 0.7708333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6165865384615384 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.14992150706436422, "npv": 0.055069014754878576, "sens": -0.0625, "spec": 0.37980769230769224, "youden": 0.3173076923076923, "accuracy": 0.32083333333333336, "balancedAccuracy": 0.15865384615384615 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.14285714285714285, "hi": 0.40476190476190477, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.031224762238381693, "hi": 0.28617961145360155, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.859375, "hi": 0.9390862944162437, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0034953838127212145, "hi": 0.11458633091253487, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.25, "hi": 0.5714285714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.3333333333333333, "hi": 0.20012820512820328, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7777777777777778, "hi": 0.8719211822660099, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.30243902439024395, "hi": 0.4558823529411764, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.052085843940148244, "hi": 0.42020905923344953, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.037036704209601354, "hi": 0.6014973683092084, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7166666666666667, "hi": 0.8208333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2416666666666667, "hi": 0.39583333333333337, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5260429219700741, "hi": 0.7101045296167248, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.018518352104800677, "hi": 0.3007486841546042, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "gemini-4-argon-high", "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 51, "matches": 17, "known": 32, "missed": 15, "counts": { "yes_true": 17, "yes_false": 34, "no_true": 15, "no_false": 174 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3333333333333333, "npv": 0.9206349206349206, "sens": 0.53125, "spec": 0.8365384615384616, "youden": 0.3677884615384617, "accuracy": 0.7958333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6838942307692308 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.21794871794871792, "npv": 0.07518037518037513, "sens": 0.0625, "spec": 0.3894230769230769, "youden": 0.4519230769230771, "accuracy": 0.34583333333333327, "balancedAccuracy": 0.22596153846153855 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.20408163265306123, "hi": 0.46938775510204084, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.09403916907228167, "hi": 0.3496147348213841, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8829787234042553, "hi": 0.9565217391304348, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.013144708597853964, "hi": 0.13703006799005354, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.3793103448275862, "hi": 0.6896551724137931, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.2068965517241379, "hi": 0.3235294117647059, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8, "hi": 0.8712871287128713, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.31578947368421056, "hi": 0.4622641509433962, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.19303255282695586, "hi": 0.5474750776270634, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.1570149835232692, "hi": 0.7401991026023091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.75, "hi": 0.8376041666666652, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2666666666666667, "hi": 0.42083333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5965162764134779, "hi": 0.7737375388135317, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.0785074917616346, "hi": 0.3700995513011546, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "grok-4.5", "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 100, "matches": 19, "known": 32, "missed": 13, "counts": { "yes_true": 19, "yes_false": 81, "no_true": 13, "no_false": 127 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.19, "npv": 0.9071428571428571, "sens": 0.59375, "spec": 0.6105769230769231, "youden": 0.20432692307692313, "accuracy": 0.6083333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6021634615384616 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 15, "known": 32, "missed": 17, "counts": { "yes_true": 15, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 17, "no_false": 93 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11538461538461539, "npv": 0.8454545454545455, "sens": 0.46875, "spec": 0.44711538461538464, "youden": -0.08413461538461542, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4579326923076923 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.07461538461538461, "npv": 0.06168831168831168, "sens": 0.125, "spec": 0.1634615384615385, "youden": 0.28846153846153855, "accuracy": 0.15833333333333327, "balancedAccuracy": 0.14423076923076927 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.11926605504587157, "hi": 0.27083820093457933, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0.06611570247933884, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.008558449482308557, "hi": 0.1484375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.8592592592592593, "hi": 0.950354609929078, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.7758620689655172, "hi": 0.9090909090909091, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0.0012279773770340178, "hi": 0.12156634348697502, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.4411764705882353, "hi": 0.75, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0.2903225806451613, "hi": 0.65625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.11111111111111116, "hi": 0.3548387096774193, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.5377358490566038, "hi": 0.6824760143336029, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3786407766990291, "hi": 0.5167464114832536, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.06730769230769229, "hi": 0.25961538461538464, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.02701034110202194, "hi": 0.3811895598133346, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.27359137096861097, "hi": 0.11112124370331761, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.02586965268760169, "hi": 0.5449917232597621, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.5416666666666666, "hi": 0.675, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3875, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.06666666666666665, "hi": 0.25, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.513505170551011, "hi": 0.6905947799066673, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.3632043145156945, "hi": 0.5555606218516588, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.012934826343800845, "hi": 0.27249586162988104, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false } } } } } ], "voteCounts": [ { "votes": 0, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 115, "matches": 11, "known": 32, "missed": 21, "counts": { "yes_true": 11, "yes_false": 104, "no_true": 21, "no_false": 104 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.09565217391304348, "npv": 0.832, "sens": 0.34375, "spec": 0.5, "youden": -0.15625, "accuracy": 0.4791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.421875 } }, { "votes": 1, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 56, "matches": 4, "known": 32, "missed": 28, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 52, "no_true": 28, "no_false": 156 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.07142857142857142, "npv": 0.8478260869565217, "sens": 0.125, "spec": 0.75, "youden": -0.125, "accuracy": 0.6666666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4375 } }, { "votes": 2, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 38, "matches": 3, "known": 32, "missed": 29, "counts": { "yes_true": 3, "yes_false": 35, "no_true": 29, "no_false": 173 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.07894736842105263, "npv": 0.8564356435643564, "sens": 0.09375, "spec": 0.8317307692307693, "youden": -0.07451923076923073, "accuracy": 0.7333333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.46274038461538464 } }, { "votes": 3, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 13, "matches": 6, "known": 32, "missed": 26, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 7, "no_true": 26, "no_false": 201 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.46153846153846156, "npv": 0.8854625550660793, "sens": 0.1875, "spec": 0.9663461538461539, "youden": 0.15384615384615374, "accuracy": 0.8625, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5769230769230769 } }, { "votes": 4, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 18, "matches": 8, "known": 32, "missed": 24, "counts": { "yes_true": 8, "yes_false": 10, "no_true": 24, "no_false": 198 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.4444444444444444, "npv": 0.8918918918918919, "sens": 0.25, "spec": 0.9519230769230769, "youden": 0.20192307692307687, "accuracy": 0.8583333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6009615384615384 } } ], "pareto": [ { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1 }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1 }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 3 }, { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1 }, { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2 }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2 }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3 }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3 }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 4 } ] }, "strict": { "models": [ { "model": "claude-sonnet-5-5", "label": "Sonnet 5.5", "valid": 240, "invalid": [ "R42698274|H1", "R42698274|H2", "R42698274|H3", "R42698274|H4", "R42698274|H5", "R42736449|H1", "R42736449|H2", "R42736449|H3", "R42736449|H4", "R42736449|H5" ], "calls": 56, "transportAttemptCount": 56, "strictForecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": true, "R42581103|H3": false, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": true, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": false, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": true, "R42630044|H4": false, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": true, "R42639736|H2": false, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": false, "R42642518|H5": false, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": true, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": false, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": false, "R42663085|H3": false, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": false, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": true, "R42696595|H4": false, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": true, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": false, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": true, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": false, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": false, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": true, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": false, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": true, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": false, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": true, "R42759510|H3": false, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": true, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": false, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": false, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": false, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": true, "R42821663|H1": false, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": true, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": true, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": false, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": false, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": true, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": false, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": false, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": false, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": true, "R42806945|H2": false, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": false, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": false, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": false, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": true, "R42841610|H2": false, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": true, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": false, "R42748238|H3": true, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "strictInvalid": [ "R42698274|H1", "R42698274|H2", "R42698274|H3", "R42698274|H4", "R42698274|H5", "R42736449|H1", "R42736449|H2", "R42736449|H3", "R42736449|H4", "R42736449|H5" ], "formatRecovered": [], "selections": [ { "id": "R42581103|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" } ], "forecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": true, "R42581103|H3": false, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": true, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": false, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": true, "R42630044|H4": false, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": true, "R42639736|H2": false, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": false, "R42642518|H5": false, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": true, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": false, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": false, "R42663085|H3": false, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": false, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": true, "R42696595|H4": false, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": true, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": false, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": true, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": false, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": false, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": true, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": false, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": true, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": false, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": true, "R42759510|H3": false, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": true, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": false, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": false, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": false, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": true, "R42821663|H1": false, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": true, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": true, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": false, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": false, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": true, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": false, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": false, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": false, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": true, "R42806945|H2": false, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": false, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": false, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": false, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": true, "R42841610|H2": false, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": true, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": false, "R42748238|H3": true, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "parentResultReused": false, "sourceGenerator": false, "originalReferenceJudge": false, "judgeRelationships": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "claude-opus-5-5" ] }, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 43, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 37, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 194 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.13953488372093023, "npv": 0.9847715736040609, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8398268398268398, "youden": 0.5064935064935066, "accuracy": 0.8333333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7532467532467533 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.10876565295169946, "npv": 0.030226119058606282, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3852813852813853, "youden": 0.6075036075036075, "accuracy": 0.3791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3037518037518038 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.045454545454545456, "hi": 0.25, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.024285452395917513, "hi": 0.20704054119119839, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9646464646464646, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.004843002108323584, "hi": 0.0678211121001282, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8181818181818182, "hi": 0.8634361233480177, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3187772925764192, "hi": 0.45132743362831856, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.18896387455339436, "hi": 0.8396624472573839, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.08332624690107435, "hi": 1.234101256245352, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8083333333333333, "hi": 0.8583333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3125, "hi": 0.44166666666666665, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5944819372766972, "hi": 0.919831223628692, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.04166312345053717, "hi": 0.617050628122676, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "gpt-6-astra", "label": "GPT-6 Astra", "valid": 250, "invalid": [], "calls": 50, "transportAttemptCount": 56, "strictForecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": false, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": true, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": false, "R42630044|H4": true, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": false, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": false, "R42642518|H5": true, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": false, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": false, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": true, "R42663085|H3": true, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": true, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": false, "R42696595|H4": true, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": false, "R42698274|H2": false, "R42698274|H3": false, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": false, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": true, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": false, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": true, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": true, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": false, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": false, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": false, "R42759510|H3": true, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": false, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": true, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": true, "R42821663|H1": false, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": true, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": false, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": false, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": true, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": false, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": false, "R42806945|H2": true, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": true, "R42808804|H1": false, "R42808804|H2": false, "R42808804|H3": true, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": false, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": true, "R42841610|H1": false, "R42841610|H2": true, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": false, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": true, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": false, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": true, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "strictInvalid": [], "formatRecovered": [], "selections": [ { "id": "R42581103|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" } ], "forecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": false, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": true, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": false, "R42630044|H4": true, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": false, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": false, "R42642518|H5": true, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": false, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": false, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": true, "R42663085|H3": true, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": true, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": false, "R42696595|H4": true, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": false, "R42698274|H2": false, "R42698274|H3": false, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": false, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": true, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": false, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": true, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": true, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": false, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": false, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": false, "R42759510|H3": true, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": false, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": true, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": true, "R42821663|H1": false, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": true, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": false, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": false, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": true, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": false, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": false, "R42806945|H2": true, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": true, "R42808804|H1": false, "R42808804|H2": false, "R42808804|H3": true, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": false, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": true, "R42841610|H1": false, "R42841610|H2": true, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": false, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": true, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": false, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": true, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "parentResultReused": false, "sourceGenerator": false, "originalReferenceJudge": false, "judgeRelationships": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "gpt-5.6-sol" ] }, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "left": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 51, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 45, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 196 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11764705882352941, "npv": 0.9849246231155779, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8132780082987552, "youden": 0.4799446749654219, "accuracy": 0.808, "balancedAccuracy": 0.739972337482711 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 128, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 113 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.030303030303030304, "npv": 0.9576271186440678, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.46887966804979253, "youden": -0.08667588750576305, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4566620562471185 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.0873440285204991, "npv": 0.027297504471510137, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.34439834024896265, "youden": 0.566620562471185, "accuracy": 0.34, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2833102812355925 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.03771837875611462, "hi": 0.21818181818181817, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.06818181818181818, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.017535933890065466, "hi": 0.1770036259064766, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9655172413793104, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9212598425196851, "hi": 0.9908256880733946, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0051216204047635884, "hi": 0.062466472416828664, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.37357954545454547, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.31510416666666663, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.773109243697479, "hi": 0.8497907725321887, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.4057377049180328, "hi": 0.5355648535564853, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2734603841536614, "hi": 0.41452991452991456, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.15900397050243392, "hi": 0.8122448979591836, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5161290322580645, "hi": 0.26610644257703076, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.03961748633879769, "hi": 1.19277382224737, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.768, "hi": 0.848, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.408, "hi": 0.532, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.272, "hi": 0.408, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.579501985251217, "hi": 0.9061224489795918, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.24193548387096775, "hi": 0.6330532212885154, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.019808743169398846, "hi": 0.596386911123685, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "gemini-4-argon-high", "label": "Gemini 4 Argon High", "valid": 250, "invalid": [], "calls": 50, "transportAttemptCount": 51, "strictForecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": true, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": false, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": false, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": false, "R42630044|H4": true, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": false, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": false, "R42642518|H4": true, "R42642518|H5": false, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": false, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": true, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": false, "R42663085|H3": false, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": false, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": false, "R42696595|H4": true, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": false, "R42698274|H2": false, "R42698274|H3": false, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": false, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": true, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": false, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": true, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": false, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": true, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": false, "R42759510|H3": true, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": true, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": false, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": true, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": false, "R42821663|H1": true, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": false, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": false, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": true, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": true, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": true, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": true, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": false, "R42806945|H2": true, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": true, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": false, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": true, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": true, "R42841610|H2": false, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": false, "R42806003|H2": true, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "strictInvalid": [], "formatRecovered": [], "selections": [ { "id": "R42581103|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" } ], "forecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": true, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": false, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": false, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": false, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": false, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": false, "R42630044|H3": false, "R42630044|H4": true, "R42630044|H5": false, "R42639736|H1": false, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": false, "R42642518|H1": false, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": false, "R42642518|H4": true, "R42642518|H5": false, "R42642521|H1": false, "R42642521|H2": false, "R42642521|H3": false, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": true, "R42647119|H1": false, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": false, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": false, "R42663085|H3": false, "R42663085|H4": false, "R42663085|H5": false, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": false, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": false, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": false, "R42696595|H4": true, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": false, "R42698274|H2": false, "R42698274|H3": false, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": false, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": true, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": false, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": false, "R42749700|H3": false, "R42749700|H4": true, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": false, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": true, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": false, "R42759510|H3": true, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": false, "R42775695|H2": false, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": false, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": false, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": true, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": false, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": false, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": false, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": false, "R42811497|H2": true, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": false, "R42821663|H1": true, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": false, "R42821663|H5": false, "R42822442|H1": false, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": false, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": false, "R42839094|H2": false, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": true, "R42841227|H1": false, "R42841227|H2": false, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": false, "R42841227|H5": true, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": false, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": true, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": false, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": false, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": true, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": false, "R42806945|H2": true, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": false, "R42806945|H5": false, "R42723144|H1": false, "R42723144|H2": true, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": false, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": true, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": false, "R42585340|H2": false, "R42585340|H3": false, "R42585340|H4": false, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": false, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": true, "R42841610|H2": false, "R42841610|H3": false, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": false, "R42806003|H2": true, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "parentResultReused": false, "sourceGenerator": true, "originalReferenceJudge": false, "judgeRelationships": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [] }, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "left": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 53, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 47, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 194 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11320754716981132, "npv": 0.9847715736040609, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8049792531120332, "youden": 0.47164591977869996, "accuracy": 0.8, "balancedAccuracy": 0.73582295988935 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 128, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 113 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.030303030303030304, "npv": 0.9576271186440678, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.46887966804979253, "youden": -0.08667588750576305, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4566620562471185 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.08290451686678102, "npv": 0.02714445495999307, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3360995850622407, "youden": 0.558321807284463, "accuracy": 0.332, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2791609036422315 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.037037037037037035, "hi": 0.20754716981132076, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.06818181818181818, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.015453915307623887, "hi": 0.16496401670544875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.964824120603015, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9212598425196851, "hi": 0.9908256880733946, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.005230291493616399, "hi": 0.062291371920488885, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.37357954545454547, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.31510416666666663, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7800829875518672, "hi": 0.8277310924369747, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.4057377049180328, "hi": 0.5355648535564853, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.26970954356846466, "hi": 0.39999999999999997, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.15861544313427167, "hi": 0.8032786885245902, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5161290322580645, "hi": 0.26610644257703076, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.03221288515406173, "hi": 1.1776624887963687, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.772, "hi": 0.828, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.408, "hi": 0.532, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.268, "hi": 0.39200000000000007, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5793077215671358, "hi": 0.9016393442622951, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.24193548387096775, "hi": 0.6330532212885154, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.016106442577030866, "hi": 0.5888312443981844, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "grok-4.5", "label": "Grok 4.5", "valid": 250, "invalid": [], "calls": 56, "transportAttemptCount": 56, "strictForecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": true, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": true, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": true, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": true, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": true, "R42630044|H3": true, "R42630044|H4": false, "R42630044|H5": true, "R42639736|H1": true, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": true, "R42642518|H1": true, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": true, "R42642518|H5": true, "R42642521|H1": true, "R42642521|H2": true, "R42642521|H3": true, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": true, "R42647119|H1": true, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": true, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": true, "R42663085|H3": true, "R42663085|H4": true, "R42663085|H5": true, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": true, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": true, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": true, "R42696595|H4": false, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": true, "R42698274|H2": true, "R42698274|H3": true, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": true, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": false, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": true, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": true, "R42749700|H3": true, "R42749700|H4": false, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": true, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": true, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": true, "R42759510|H3": false, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": true, "R42775695|H2": true, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": true, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": true, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": true, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": true, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": true, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": true, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": true, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": false, "R42821663|H1": true, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": false, "R42821663|H5": true, "R42822442|H1": true, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": true, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": true, "R42839094|H2": true, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": true, "R42841227|H1": true, "R42841227|H2": true, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": true, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": true, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": false, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": true, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": true, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": true, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": true, "R42806945|H2": false, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": true, "R42806945|H5": true, "R42723144|H1": true, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": true, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": true, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": true, "R42585340|H2": true, "R42585340|H3": true, "R42585340|H4": true, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": true, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": false, "R42841610|H2": true, "R42841610|H3": true, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": true, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "strictInvalid": [], "formatRecovered": [], "selections": [ { "id": "R42581103|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42581103|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42601407|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42605193|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42608398|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42627902|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42630044|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42639736|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642518|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42642521|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647119|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42647635|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42663085|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42664348|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42665751|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42689491|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42696595|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42698274|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42717261|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723546|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42725837|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42736449|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42744804|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42749700|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42758848|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42759510|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775695|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42775698|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42786310|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42805954|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42810392|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811497|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42821663|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42822442|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42826184|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42839094|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841227|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42842666|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42844664|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42853938|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42858183|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806945|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42723144|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H1", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H2", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H3", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H4", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42808804|H5", "attempt": 2, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42585340|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42669067|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42811065|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42841610|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806003|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42806572|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H1", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H2", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H3", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H4", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" }, { "id": "R42748238|H5", "attempt": 1, "format": "strict_json" } ], "forecasts": { "R42581103|H1": false, "R42581103|H2": false, "R42581103|H3": true, "R42581103|H4": false, "R42581103|H5": false, "R42601407|H1": false, "R42601407|H2": false, "R42601407|H3": true, "R42601407|H4": false, "R42601407|H5": true, "R42605193|H1": false, "R42605193|H2": false, "R42605193|H3": true, "R42605193|H4": true, "R42605193|H5": false, "R42608398|H1": false, "R42608398|H2": false, "R42608398|H3": true, "R42608398|H4": false, "R42608398|H5": false, "R42627902|H1": false, "R42627902|H2": false, "R42627902|H3": false, "R42627902|H4": true, "R42627902|H5": true, "R42630044|H1": false, "R42630044|H2": true, "R42630044|H3": true, "R42630044|H4": false, "R42630044|H5": true, "R42639736|H1": true, "R42639736|H2": true, "R42639736|H3": false, "R42639736|H4": false, "R42639736|H5": true, "R42642518|H1": true, "R42642518|H2": false, "R42642518|H3": true, "R42642518|H4": true, "R42642518|H5": true, "R42642521|H1": true, "R42642521|H2": true, "R42642521|H3": true, "R42642521|H4": false, "R42642521|H5": true, "R42647119|H1": true, "R42647119|H2": false, "R42647119|H3": false, "R42647119|H4": true, "R42647119|H5": true, "R42647635|H1": false, "R42647635|H2": false, "R42647635|H3": false, "R42647635|H4": true, "R42647635|H5": false, "R42663085|H1": true, "R42663085|H2": true, "R42663085|H3": true, "R42663085|H4": true, "R42663085|H5": true, "R42664348|H1": false, "R42664348|H2": false, "R42664348|H3": false, "R42664348|H4": false, "R42664348|H5": true, "R42665751|H1": true, "R42665751|H2": false, "R42665751|H3": false, "R42665751|H4": true, "R42665751|H5": true, "R42689491|H1": false, "R42689491|H2": false, "R42689491|H3": false, "R42689491|H4": false, "R42689491|H5": true, "R42696595|H1": false, "R42696595|H2": false, "R42696595|H3": true, "R42696595|H4": false, "R42696595|H5": false, "R42698274|H1": true, "R42698274|H2": true, "R42698274|H3": true, "R42698274|H4": true, "R42698274|H5": false, "R42717261|H1": false, "R42717261|H2": false, "R42717261|H3": false, "R42717261|H4": false, "R42717261|H5": true, "R42723546|H1": false, "R42723546|H2": false, "R42723546|H3": false, "R42723546|H4": true, "R42723546|H5": false, "R42725837|H1": true, "R42725837|H2": false, "R42725837|H3": false, "R42725837|H4": false, "R42725837|H5": false, "R42736449|H1": false, "R42736449|H2": false, "R42736449|H3": false, "R42736449|H4": true, "R42736449|H5": false, "R42744804|H1": true, "R42744804|H2": false, "R42744804|H3": true, "R42744804|H4": false, "R42744804|H5": false, "R42749700|H1": false, "R42749700|H2": true, "R42749700|H3": true, "R42749700|H4": false, "R42749700|H5": false, "R42758848|H1": true, "R42758848|H2": false, "R42758848|H3": true, "R42758848|H4": false, "R42758848|H5": false, "R42759510|H1": false, "R42759510|H2": true, "R42759510|H3": false, "R42759510|H4": false, "R42759510|H5": false, "R42775695|H1": true, "R42775695|H2": true, "R42775695|H3": false, "R42775695|H4": true, "R42775695|H5": false, "R42775698|H1": true, "R42775698|H2": false, "R42775698|H3": true, "R42775698|H4": true, "R42775698|H5": false, "R42786310|H1": true, "R42786310|H2": false, "R42786310|H3": false, "R42786310|H4": false, "R42786310|H5": true, "R42805954|H1": false, "R42805954|H2": true, "R42805954|H3": false, "R42805954|H4": false, "R42805954|H5": true, "R42810392|H1": false, "R42810392|H2": false, "R42810392|H3": true, "R42810392|H4": true, "R42810392|H5": false, "R42811497|H1": true, "R42811497|H2": false, "R42811497|H3": false, "R42811497|H4": false, "R42811497|H5": false, "R42821663|H1": true, "R42821663|H2": false, "R42821663|H3": false, "R42821663|H4": false, "R42821663|H5": true, "R42822442|H1": true, "R42822442|H2": false, "R42822442|H3": false, "R42822442|H4": true, "R42822442|H5": true, "R42826184|H1": true, "R42826184|H2": false, "R42826184|H3": false, "R42826184|H4": false, "R42826184|H5": false, "R42839094|H1": true, "R42839094|H2": true, "R42839094|H3": false, "R42839094|H4": false, "R42839094|H5": true, "R42841227|H1": true, "R42841227|H2": true, "R42841227|H3": false, "R42841227|H4": true, "R42841227|H5": false, "R42842666|H1": false, "R42842666|H2": false, "R42842666|H3": true, "R42842666|H4": false, "R42842666|H5": false, "R42844664|H1": true, "R42844664|H2": false, "R42844664|H3": false, "R42844664|H4": false, "R42844664|H5": false, "R42853938|H1": false, "R42853938|H2": true, "R42853938|H3": false, "R42853938|H4": true, "R42853938|H5": true, "R42858183|H1": false, "R42858183|H2": true, "R42858183|H3": true, "R42858183|H4": true, "R42858183|H5": false, "R42806945|H1": true, "R42806945|H2": false, "R42806945|H3": false, "R42806945|H4": true, "R42806945|H5": true, "R42723144|H1": true, "R42723144|H2": false, "R42723144|H3": false, "R42723144|H4": false, "R42723144|H5": true, "R42808804|H1": true, "R42808804|H2": true, "R42808804|H3": false, "R42808804|H4": false, "R42808804|H5": false, "R42585340|H1": true, "R42585340|H2": true, "R42585340|H3": true, "R42585340|H4": true, "R42585340|H5": true, "R42669067|H1": true, "R42669067|H2": false, "R42669067|H3": true, "R42669067|H4": false, "R42669067|H5": false, "R42811065|H1": true, "R42811065|H2": false, "R42811065|H3": false, "R42811065|H4": false, "R42811065|H5": false, "R42841610|H1": false, "R42841610|H2": true, "R42841610|H3": true, "R42841610|H4": false, "R42841610|H5": false, "R42806003|H1": true, "R42806003|H2": false, "R42806003|H3": false, "R42806003|H4": false, "R42806003|H5": false, "R42806572|H1": false, "R42806572|H2": true, "R42806572|H3": false, "R42806572|H4": false, "R42806572|H5": false, "R42748238|H1": false, "R42748238|H2": true, "R42748238|H3": false, "R42748238|H4": false, "R42748238|H5": false }, "parentResultReused": false, "sourceGenerator": false, "originalReferenceJudge": false, "judgeRelationships": { "sameModelJudges": [], "sameCompanyJudges": [ "grok-4.7" ] }, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "left": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 105, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 99, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 142 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.05714285714285714, "npv": 0.9793103448275862, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5892116182572614, "youden": 0.25587828492392806, "accuracy": 0.592, "balancedAccuracy": 0.627939142461964 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 128, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 113 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.030303030303030304, "npv": 0.9576271186440678, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.46887966804979253, "youden": -0.08667588750576305, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4566620562471185 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.026839826839826837, "npv": 0.021683226183518367, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.1203319502074689, "youden": 0.3425541724296911, "accuracy": 0.12399999999999994, "balancedAccuracy": 0.17127708621484555 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.01818181818181818, "hi": 0.10752688172043011, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.06818181818181818, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.009885234638241312, "hi": 0.071876858769663, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.954248366013072, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9212598425196851, "hi": 0.9908256880733946, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.013034470855837397, "hi": 0.05818473406276078, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.37357954545454547, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.31510416666666663, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.5247933884297521, "hi": 0.6510638297872341, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.4057377049180328, "hi": 0.5355648535564853, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.03658536585365857, "hi": 0.20502092050209209, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.06608146963791059, "hi": 0.5789473684210527, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5161290322580645, "hi": 0.26610644257703076, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.18579234972677594, "hi": 0.9600235155790711, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.528, "hi": 0.652, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.408, "hi": 0.532, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.040000000000000036, "hi": 0.20400000000000001, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.4669592651810447, "hi": 0.7894736842105263, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.24193548387096775, "hi": 0.6330532212885154, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.09289617486338797, "hi": 0.48001175778953553, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false } } } } } ], "coin": { "method": "Original saved gemini-4-argon-high/N per-hypothesis coin decisions reused unchanged by task and generation index; never redrawn", "sourceSha256": "052b7f8e5cc1f50cdd708eb5d3cee2ad0ebe393f3a1e1bff88ed00d8840d458c", "tosses": [ { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42581103", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42581103|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42601407", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42601407|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42605193", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42605193|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42608398", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42608398|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42627902", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42627902|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42630044", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42630044|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42639736", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42639736|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642518", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642518|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42642521", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42642521|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647119", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647119|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42647635", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42647635|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42663085", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42663085|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42664348", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42664348|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42665751", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42665751|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42689491", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42689491|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42696595", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42696595|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42698274", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42698274|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42717261", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42717261|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42723546", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723546|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42725837", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42725837|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42736449", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42736449|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42744804", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42744804|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42749700", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42749700|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42758848", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42758848|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42759510", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42759510|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775695", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775695|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42775698", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42775698|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42786310", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42786310|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42805954", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42805954|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42810392", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42810392|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42811497", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811497|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42821663", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42821663|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42822442", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42822442|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42826184", "id": "H5", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42826184|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42839094", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42839094|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42841227", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841227|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42842666", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42842666|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42844664", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42844664|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H4", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42853938", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42853938|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H1", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42858183", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42858183|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-16T23:20:31.519Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42806945", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806945|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42723144", "id": "H5", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42723144|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H2", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H3", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42808804", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42808804|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T21:05:20.877Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H1", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H2", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42585340", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42585340|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42669067", "id": "H5", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42669067|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H4", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42811065", "id": "H5", "index": 0, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42811065|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T22:15:29.810Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H2", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H3", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H4", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42841610", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42841610|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H1", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H3", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806003", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806003|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H1", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H2", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H3", "index": 4, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H4", "index": 1, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42806572", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42806572|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-18T23:17:19.659Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H1", "index": 0, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|0", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H2", "index": 2, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|2", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H3", "index": 1, "yes": false, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|1", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H4", "index": 4, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|4", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" }, { "task": "R42748238", "id": "H5", "index": 3, "yes": true, "originalKey": "gemini-4-argon-high|N|R42748238|3", "tossedAt": "2026-10-19T00:19:18.834Z" } ], "comparison": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "left": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 128, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 113 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.030303030303030304, "npv": 0.9576271186440678, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.46887966804979253, "youden": -0.08667588750576305, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4566620562471185 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 250, "questions": 50, "selected": 132, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 128, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 113 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.030303030303030304, "npv": 0.9576271186440678, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.46887966804979253, "youden": -0.08667588750576305, "accuracy": 0.468, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4566620562471185 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0, "npv": 0, "sens": 0, "spec": 0, "youden": 0, "accuracy": 0, "balancedAccuracy": 0 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.06818181818181818, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.06818181818181818, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9212598425196851, "hi": 0.9908256880733946, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9212598425196851, "hi": 0.9908256880733946, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": true }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.4057377049180328, "hi": 0.5355648535564853, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.4057377049180328, "hi": 0.5355648535564853, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.5161290322580645, "hi": 0.26610644257703076, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5161290322580645, "hi": 0.26610644257703076, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": true }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.408, "hi": 0.532, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.408, "hi": 0.532, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": true }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.24193548387096775, "hi": 0.6330532212885154, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.24193548387096775, "hi": 0.6330532212885154, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0, "validReplicates": 9996, "degenerate": true } } } } }, "common": { "hypotheses": 240, "sources": 48, "ids": [ "R42581103|H1", "R42581103|H2", "R42581103|H3", "R42581103|H4", "R42581103|H5", "R42601407|H1", "R42601407|H2", "R42601407|H3", "R42601407|H4", "R42601407|H5", "R42605193|H1", "R42605193|H2", "R42605193|H3", "R42605193|H4", "R42605193|H5", "R42608398|H1", "R42608398|H2", "R42608398|H3", "R42608398|H4", "R42608398|H5", "R42627902|H1", "R42627902|H2", "R42627902|H3", "R42627902|H4", "R42627902|H5", "R42630044|H1", "R42630044|H2", "R42630044|H3", "R42630044|H4", "R42630044|H5", "R42639736|H1", "R42639736|H2", "R42639736|H3", "R42639736|H4", "R42639736|H5", "R42642518|H1", "R42642518|H2", "R42642518|H3", "R42642518|H4", "R42642518|H5", "R42642521|H1", "R42642521|H2", "R42642521|H3", "R42642521|H4", "R42642521|H5", "R42647119|H1", "R42647119|H2", "R42647119|H3", "R42647119|H4", "R42647119|H5", "R42647635|H1", "R42647635|H2", "R42647635|H3", "R42647635|H4", "R42647635|H5", "R42663085|H1", "R42663085|H2", "R42663085|H3", "R42663085|H4", "R42663085|H5", "R42664348|H1", "R42664348|H2", "R42664348|H3", "R42664348|H4", "R42664348|H5", "R42665751|H1", "R42665751|H2", "R42665751|H3", "R42665751|H4", "R42665751|H5", "R42689491|H1", "R42689491|H2", "R42689491|H3", "R42689491|H4", "R42689491|H5", "R42696595|H1", "R42696595|H2", "R42696595|H3", "R42696595|H4", "R42696595|H5", "R42717261|H1", "R42717261|H2", "R42717261|H3", "R42717261|H4", "R42717261|H5", "R42723546|H1", "R42723546|H2", "R42723546|H3", "R42723546|H4", "R42723546|H5", "R42725837|H1", "R42725837|H2", "R42725837|H3", "R42725837|H4", "R42725837|H5", "R42744804|H1", "R42744804|H2", "R42744804|H3", "R42744804|H4", "R42744804|H5", "R42749700|H1", "R42749700|H2", "R42749700|H3", "R42749700|H4", "R42749700|H5", "R42758848|H1", "R42758848|H2", "R42758848|H3", "R42758848|H4", "R42758848|H5", "R42759510|H1", "R42759510|H2", "R42759510|H3", "R42759510|H4", "R42759510|H5", "R42775695|H1", "R42775695|H2", "R42775695|H3", "R42775695|H4", "R42775695|H5", "R42775698|H1", "R42775698|H2", "R42775698|H3", "R42775698|H4", "R42775698|H5", "R42786310|H1", "R42786310|H2", "R42786310|H3", "R42786310|H4", "R42786310|H5", "R42805954|H1", "R42805954|H2", "R42805954|H3", "R42805954|H4", "R42805954|H5", "R42810392|H1", "R42810392|H2", "R42810392|H3", "R42810392|H4", "R42810392|H5", "R42811497|H1", "R42811497|H2", "R42811497|H3", "R42811497|H4", "R42811497|H5", "R42821663|H1", "R42821663|H2", "R42821663|H3", "R42821663|H4", "R42821663|H5", "R42822442|H1", "R42822442|H2", "R42822442|H3", "R42822442|H4", "R42822442|H5", "R42826184|H1", "R42826184|H2", "R42826184|H3", "R42826184|H4", "R42826184|H5", "R42839094|H1", "R42839094|H2", "R42839094|H3", "R42839094|H4", "R42839094|H5", "R42841227|H1", "R42841227|H2", "R42841227|H3", "R42841227|H4", "R42841227|H5", "R42842666|H1", "R42842666|H2", "R42842666|H3", "R42842666|H4", "R42842666|H5", "R42844664|H1", "R42844664|H2", "R42844664|H3", "R42844664|H4", "R42844664|H5", "R42853938|H1", "R42853938|H2", "R42853938|H3", "R42853938|H4", "R42853938|H5", "R42858183|H1", "R42858183|H2", "R42858183|H3", "R42858183|H4", "R42858183|H5", "R42806945|H1", "R42806945|H2", "R42806945|H3", "R42806945|H4", "R42806945|H5", "R42723144|H1", "R42723144|H2", "R42723144|H3", "R42723144|H4", "R42723144|H5", "R42808804|H1", "R42808804|H2", "R42808804|H3", "R42808804|H4", "R42808804|H5", "R42585340|H1", "R42585340|H2", "R42585340|H3", "R42585340|H4", "R42585340|H5", "R42669067|H1", "R42669067|H2", "R42669067|H3", "R42669067|H4", "R42669067|H5", "R42811065|H1", "R42811065|H2", "R42811065|H3", "R42811065|H4", "R42811065|H5", "R42841610|H1", "R42841610|H2", "R42841610|H3", "R42841610|H4", "R42841610|H5", "R42806003|H1", "R42806003|H2", "R42806003|H3", "R42806003|H4", "R42806003|H5", "R42806572|H1", "R42806572|H2", "R42806572|H3", "R42806572|H4", "R42806572|H5", "R42748238|H1", "R42748238|H2", "R42748238|H3", "R42748238|H4", "R42748238|H5" ], "excluded": [ "R42698274|H1", "R42698274|H2", "R42698274|H3", "R42698274|H4", "R42698274|H5", "R42736449|H1", "R42736449|H2", "R42736449|H3", "R42736449|H4", "R42736449|H5" ] }, "rules": [ { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 43, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 37, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 194 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.13953488372093023, "npv": 0.9847715736040609, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8398268398268398, "youden": 0.5064935064935066, "accuracy": 0.8333333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7532467532467533 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.10876565295169946, "npv": 0.030226119058606282, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3852813852813853, "youden": 0.6075036075036075, "accuracy": 0.3791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3037518037518038 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.045454545454545456, "hi": 0.25, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.024285452395917513, "hi": 0.20704054119119839, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9646464646464646, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.004843002108323584, "hi": 0.0678211121001282, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8181818181818182, "hi": 0.8634361233480177, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3187772925764192, "hi": 0.45132743362831856, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.18896387455339436, "hi": 0.8396624472573839, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.08332624690107435, "hi": 1.234101256245352, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8083333333333333, "hi": 0.8583333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3125, "hi": 0.44166666666666665, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5944819372766972, "hi": 0.919831223628692, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.04166312345053717, "hi": 0.617050628122676, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 49, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 43, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 188 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.12244897959183673, "npv": 0.9842931937172775, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8138528138528138, "youden": 0.48051948051948035, "accuracy": 0.8083333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7402597402597402 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.09167974882260596, "npv": 0.02974773917182294, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3593073593073593, "youden": 0.5815295815295813, "accuracy": 0.3541666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.29076479076479067 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.0392156862745098, "hi": 0.22727272727272727, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.018415825609930724, "hi": 0.18604651162790697, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9639175257731959, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.005348519127930911, "hi": 0.06746245766323482, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7725321888412017, "hi": 0.8526785714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2887931034482759, "hi": 0.42920353982300885, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.15609759438873372, "hi": 0.8109419518880511, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.053341508277130675, "hi": 1.20907418761496, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7666666666666667, "hi": 0.85, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2875, "hi": 0.42083333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5780487971943669, "hi": 0.9054709759440256, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.026670754138565338, "hi": 0.60453709380748, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 71, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 65, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 166 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.08450704225352113, "npv": 0.9822485207100592, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.7186147186147186, "youden": 0.3852813852813852, "accuracy": 0.7166666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6926406926406926 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.053737811484290354, "npv": 0.027703066164604606, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.26406926406926406, "youden": 0.4862914862914862, "accuracy": 0.2625, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2431457431457431 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.02631578947368421, "hi": 0.15942028985507245, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.002335712478683731, "hi": 0.12246352459016391, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9590643274853801, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0083018891498826, "hi": 0.06632557829041748, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.6736401673640168, "hi": 0.7644509803921568, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.18803418803418803, "hi": 0.33913043478260874, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.05063291139240511, "hi": 0.7186147186147185, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.04968956348672223, "hi": 1.1208807268652587, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.6666666666666666, "hi": 0.7666666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.1875, "hi": 0.33749999999999997, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5253164556962026, "hi": 0.8593073593073592, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.024844781743361116, "hi": 0.5604403634326294, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 21, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 15, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 216 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2857142857142857, "npv": 0.9863013698630136, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.935064935064935, "youden": 0.6017316017316017, "accuracy": 0.925, "balancedAccuracy": 0.8008658008658008 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.2549450549450549, "npv": 0.03175591531755906, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.4805194805194805, "youden": 0.7027417027417027, "accuracy": 0.4708333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.35137085137085133 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.1, "hi": 0.5, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.08367998133217992, "hi": 0.4449371603260868, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9684684684684685, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.002108857107016107, "hi": 0.06904506411394279, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9078947368421053, "hi": 0.961038961038961, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4137931034482759, "hi": 0.5462643731800193, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.2894736842105263, "hi": 0.9307359307359309, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.18643678101196098, "hi": 1.3202007422402153, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8958333333333334, "hi": 0.95, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4083333333333333, "hi": 0.5291666666666668, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6447368421052632, "hi": 0.9653679653679654, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.09321839050598049, "hi": 0.6601003711201077, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 51, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 45, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 186 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11764705882352941, "npv": 0.9841269841269841, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8051948051948052, "youden": 0.47186147186147176, "accuracy": 0.8, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7359307359307359 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.08687782805429864, "npv": 0.029581529581529487, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3506493506493507, "youden": 0.5728715728715728, "accuracy": 0.3458333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2864357864357864 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.038461538461538464, "hi": 0.21153846153846154, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.0173178760555317, "hi": 0.1738521364317841, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9633507853403142, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.005543326765707201, "hi": 0.06731975317966721, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7792207792207793, "hi": 0.8289473684210527, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.28755364806866957, "hi": 0.415929203539823, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.1540293767368004, "hi": 0.8025210084033614, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.04898935912743213, "hi": 1.1984051724137912, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7708333333333334, "hi": 0.8291666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2833333333333333, "hi": 0.40833333333333327, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5770146883684002, "hi": 0.9012605042016807, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.024494679563716065, "hi": 0.5992025862068956, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 71, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 65, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 166 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.08450704225352113, "npv": 0.9822485207100592, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.7186147186147186, "youden": 0.3852813852813852, "accuracy": 0.7166666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6926406926406926 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.053737811484290354, "npv": 0.027703066164604606, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.26406926406926406, "youden": 0.4862914862914862, "accuracy": 0.2625, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2431457431457431 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.02666666666666667, "hi": 0.15714285714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.003228530297171898, "hi": 0.12061868065497489, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9593023255813954, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.007863385617899532, "hi": 0.0662256851810129, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.6810344827586207, "hi": 0.7567740080506036, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.18964068385975075, "hi": 0.34061135371179047, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.06030614500442083, "hi": 0.7148936170212767, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.04338286211011737, "hi": 1.1153846153846154, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.675, "hi": 0.7583333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.1875, "hi": 0.33749999999999997, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5301530725022104, "hi": 0.8574468085106384, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.021691431055058684, "hi": 0.5576923076923077, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 23, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 17, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 214 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2608695652173913, "npv": 0.9861751152073732, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.9264069264069265, "youden": 0.5930735930735931, "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7965367965367965 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.23010033444816053, "npv": 0.031629660661918635, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.4718614718614719, "youden": 0.6940836940836941, "accuracy": 0.46249999999999997, "balancedAccuracy": 0.34704184704184704 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.08695652173913043, "hi": 0.45, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.06990517592027659, "hi": 0.40538628472222216, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9678899082568807, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.002569112260288721, "hi": 0.06900161030595808, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8978723404255319, "hi": 0.9525912942134083, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.408695652173913, "hi": 0.5347826086956522, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.277756707402725, "hi": 0.9243697478991597, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.17329093759224778, "hi": 1.3176733679340278, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8875, "hi": 0.9458333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4041666666666666, "hi": 0.5208333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6388783537013625, "hi": 0.9621848739495799, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.08664546879612389, "hi": 0.6588366839670139, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 67, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 61, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 170 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.08955223880597014, "npv": 0.9826589595375722, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.7359307359307359, "youden": 0.4025974025974026, "accuracy": 0.7333333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7012987012987013 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.05878300803673937, "npv": 0.02811350499211762, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.28138528138528135, "youden": 0.5036075036075036, "accuracy": 0.2791666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2518037518037518 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.028169014084507043, "hi": 0.16923076923076924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.005207524585921328, "hi": 0.13088592119970194, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.96045197740113, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.007790768163240402, "hi": 0.066633805190428, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.688034188034188, "hi": 0.7807017543859649, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.21585903083700442, "hi": 0.3478260869565218, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.07359307359307365, "hi": 0.7307692307692308, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.030199954520323036, "hi": 1.1318702935119238, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.6833333333333333, "hi": 0.7791666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.21666666666666662, "hi": 0.34166666666666673, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5367965367965368, "hi": 0.8653846153846154, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.015099977260161518, "hi": 0.5659351467559619, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 33, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 27, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 204 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.18181818181818182, "npv": 0.9855072463768116, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8831168831168831, "youden": 0.5497835497835497, "accuracy": 0.875, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7748917748917749 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.15104895104895105, "npv": 0.030961791831357055, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.42857142857142855, "youden": 0.6507936507936507, "accuracy": 0.42083333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.32539682539682535 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.06060606060606061, "hi": 0.3225806451612903, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.040402342755283926, "hi": 0.2806377143272304, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9665071770334929, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0035173389225680012, "hi": 0.06839484934793415, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8528138528138528, "hi": 0.9134199134199135, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3537052025297394, "hi": 0.5022920308580977, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.23275862068965525, "hi": 0.8808889289578069, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.13043478260869576, "hi": 1.2734518700183934, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8416666666666667, "hi": 0.9083333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.35, "hi": 0.49166666666666664, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6163793103448276, "hi": 0.9404444644789035, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.06521739130434788, "hi": 0.6367259350091967, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 84, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 78, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 153 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.07142857142857142, "npv": 0.9807692307692307, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.6623376623376623, "youden": 0.32900432900432897, "accuracy": 0.6625, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6645021645021645 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.040659340659340654, "npv": 0.02622377622377614, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.2077922077922078, "youden": 0.43001443001442996, "accuracy": 0.20833333333333331, "balancedAccuracy": 0.21500721500721498 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.022222222222222223, "hi": 0.13580246913580246, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.003730447525076213, "hi": 0.09966155053023269, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.95625, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.01034589855510162, "hi": 0.06558984077535476, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.6163793103448276, "hi": 0.70995670995671, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.13559322033898308, "hi": 0.2819383259911894, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.004333276372750033, "hi": 0.658119658119658, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.10679209800388864, "hi": 1.0641025641025639, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.6125, "hi": 0.7125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.13749999999999996, "hi": 0.2791666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.497833361813625, "hi": 0.829059829059829, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.05339604900194432, "hi": 0.5320512820512819, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 41, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 35, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 196 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.14634146341463414, "npv": 0.9849246231155779, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8484848484848485, "youden": 0.5151515151515151, "accuracy": 0.8416666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7575757575757576 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.11557223264540337, "npv": 0.03037916857012335, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.393939393939394, "youden": 0.6161616161616161, "accuracy": 0.3875, "balancedAccuracy": 0.30808080808080807 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.047619047619047616, "hi": 0.2608695652173913, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.027195022714504063, "hi": 0.22048846675712347, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.965, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.00462575446588693, "hi": 0.06794915783023116, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8220338983050848, "hi": 0.8771929824561403, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3245324748040313, "hi": 0.463527075152954, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.1932539621950103, "hi": 0.8478467253714912, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.09276258773189287, "hi": 1.2434089515634579, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8125, "hi": 0.875, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3208333333333333, "hi": 0.45416666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5966269810975051, "hi": 0.9239233626857456, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.04638129386594644, "hi": 0.6217044757817289, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 18, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 12, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 219 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3333333333333333, "npv": 0.9864864864864865, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.948051948051948, "youden": 0.6147186147186146, "accuracy": 0.9375, "balancedAccuracy": 0.8073593073593073 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.30256410256410254, "npv": 0.03194103194103193, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.4935064935064935, "youden": 0.7157287157287155, "accuracy": 0.48333333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3578643578643578 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.11764705882352941, "hi": 0.5625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.10304847058515738, "hi": 0.5210105964961017, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9688888888888889, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0017182608513388686, "hi": 0.06921297137737505, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9224137931034483, "hi": 0.9734542512962456, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4273504273504274, "hi": 0.559322033898305, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.30580916927899676, "hi": 0.9444444444444444, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.19994481912936846, "hi": 1.3336310745608178, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.9125, "hi": 0.9625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4208333333333334, "hi": 0.5416666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6529045846394984, "hi": 0.9722222222222222, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.09997240956468423, "hi": 0.6668155372804089, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 100, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 94, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 137 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.06, "npv": 0.9785714285714285, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5930735930735931, "youden": 0.2597402597402598, "accuracy": 0.5958333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6298701298701299 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.029230769230769227, "npv": 0.02402597402597395, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.13852813852813856, "youden": 0.3607503607503608, "accuracy": 0.14166666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1803751803751804 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.019230769230769232, "hi": 0.11224489795918367, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.008718512245980529, "hi": 0.07715866400935012, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9523809523809523, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.013777427209886903, "hi": 0.06423479049272898, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.5276595744680851, "hi": 0.6575373318524003, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.05603448275862066, "hi": 0.2217391304347826, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.06382978723404253, "hi": 0.5787234042553191, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.16682666746514918, "hi": 0.9827586206896552, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.5291666666666667, "hi": 0.6583333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.0625, "hi": 0.22083333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.46808510638297873, "hi": 0.7893617021276595, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.08341333373257459, "hi": 0.4913793103448276, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 109, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 103, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 128 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.05504587155963303, "npv": 0.9770992366412213, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5541125541125541, "youden": 0.22077922077922074, "accuracy": 0.5583333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6103896103896104 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.02427664079040226, "npv": 0.02255378209576675, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.09956709956709958, "youden": 0.32178932178932174, "accuracy": 0.10416666666666669, "balancedAccuracy": 0.16089466089466087 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.017543859649122806, "hi": 0.102803738317757, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.011904989442260084, "hi": 0.06929328663019121, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9495798319327731, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.015627176857585138, "hi": 0.06340285246510835, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.48717948717948717, "hi": 0.6200873362445415, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.017167381974248885, "hi": 0.18454935622317598, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.09925172003624687, "hi": 0.5364806866952789, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.20847866073094648, "hi": 0.9439655172413792, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.49166666666666664, "hi": 0.625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.024999999999999967, "hi": 0.1833333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.4503741399818766, "hi": 0.7682403433476395, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.10423933036547324, "hi": 0.4719827586206896, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 34, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 28, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 203 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.17647058823529413, "npv": 0.9854368932038835, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8787878787878788, "youden": 0.5454545454545454, "accuracy": 0.8708333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7727272727272727 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.14570135746606336, "npv": 0.030891438658428916, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.42424242424242425, "youden": 0.6464646464646464, "accuracy": 0.4166666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3232323232323232 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.058823529411764705, "hi": 0.3125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.038131769124082567, "hi": 0.26869700039665945, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.966183574879227, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0038231093337142445, "hi": 0.06837666398642006, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.851063829787234, "hi": 0.9070796460176991, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.35497835497835495, "hi": 0.491304347826087, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.2236286919831223, "hi": 0.8808510638297873, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.12107979356887655, "hi": 1.2720439779706763, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8416666666666667, "hi": 0.9, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.35, "hi": 0.4791666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6118143459915611, "hi": 0.9404255319148936, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.060539896784438274, "hi": 0.6360219889853381, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 113, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 107, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 124 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.05309734513274336, "npv": 0.9763779527559056, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5367965367965368, "youden": 0.20346320346320335, "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6017316017316017 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.02232811436351259, "npv": 0.021832498210450968, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.0822510822510823, "youden": 0.30447330447330434, "accuracy": 0.08749999999999997, "balancedAccuracy": 0.15223665223665217 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.01694915254237288, "hi": 0.09900990099009901, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.01283713420475263, "hi": 0.06631440189974848, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9477513747054203, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.016539050770597714, "hi": 0.06299496469769317, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.47619047619047616, "hi": 0.5982905982905983, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.16666666666666663, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.12344380796508451, "hi": 0.5252653655196025, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.22457627118644063, "hi": 0.9316457537734131, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4791666666666667, "hi": 0.6041666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.008333333333333304, "hi": 0.16666666666666669, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.43827809601745776, "hi": 0.7626326827598012, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.11228813559322032, "hi": 0.46582287688670654, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 36, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 30, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 201 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.16666666666666666, "npv": 0.9852941176470589, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8701298701298701, "youden": 0.5367965367965368, "accuracy": 0.8625, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7683982683982684 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.1358974358974359, "npv": 0.03074866310160429, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.41558441558441556, "youden": 0.6378066378066378, "accuracy": 0.4083333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3189033189033189 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.05405405405405406, "hi": 0.3142857142857143, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.033520622457102564, "hi": 0.2738152472527472, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9663420893719807, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0041178240270462125, "hi": 0.06807957072638472, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8217391304347826, "hi": 0.9151785714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.34347826086956523, "hi": 0.48695933283358317, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.21951406155324785, "hi": 0.8652611518915861, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.10822510822510822, "hi": 1.263614149485189, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8166666666666667, "hi": 0.9083333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3375, "hi": 0.47500000000000003, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6097570307766239, "hi": 0.932630575945793, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.05411255411255411, "hi": 0.6318070747425945, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 120, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 114, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 117 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.05, "npv": 0.975, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5064935064935064, "youden": 0.17316017316017307, "accuracy": 0.5125, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5865800865800865 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.019230769230769232, "npv": 0.020454545454545392, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.05194805194805191, "youden": 0.27417027417027406, "accuracy": 0.05833333333333329, "balancedAccuracy": 0.13708513708513703 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.015873015873015872, "hi": 0.09322627910660533, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.014846491509948602, "hi": 0.061469917906386035, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9448818897637795, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.019036631050430977, "hi": 0.06224945162998263, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.4444444444444444, "hi": 0.5695081887307467, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": -0.033758850032181965, "hi": 0.13733905579399142, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.1517909140487207, "hi": 0.4915966386554622, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.25567136725935, "hi": 0.900004598405886, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.45, "hi": 0.575, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": -0.02083333333333337, "hi": 0.14166666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.42410454297563965, "hi": 0.7457983193277311, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.127835683629675, "hi": 0.450002299202943, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 53, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 47, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 184 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11320754716981132, "npv": 0.983957219251337, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.7965367965367965, "youden": 0.4632034632034632, "accuracy": 0.7916666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7316017316017316 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.08243831640058055, "npv": 0.02941176470588236, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.341991341991342, "youden": 0.5642135642135642, "accuracy": 0.33749999999999997, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2821067821067821 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.03571428571428571, "hi": 0.20933292533659686, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.014108424470266574, "hi": 0.17151078605200942, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9629629629629629, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.005967116491952919, "hi": 0.06726346305338902, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7531914893617021, "hi": 0.8377192982456141, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.27111111111111114, "hi": 0.41048034934497823, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.13247863247863245, "hi": 0.7983193277310925, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.029317189360857403, "hi": 1.1961986511342735, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7458333333333333, "hi": 0.8375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2666666666666667, "hi": 0.4041666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5662393162393162, "hi": 0.8991596638655462, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.014658594680428702, "hi": 0.5980993255671367, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 19, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 13, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 218 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3157894736842105, "npv": 0.9864253393665159, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.9437229437229437, "youden": 0.6103896103896105, "accuracy": 0.9333333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.8051948051948052 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.28502024291497974, "npv": 0.0318798848210613, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.4891774891774892, "youden": 0.7113997113997115, "accuracy": 0.4791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.35569985569985574 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.1111111111111111, "hi": 0.5333333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.09637088343670282, "hi": 0.4942719572368421, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.96875, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0018839011642803126, "hi": 0.06920103762915723, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9177489177489178, "hi": 0.9693015973339462, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4217391304347826, "hi": 0.5560344827586207, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.29958507569127046, "hi": 0.9399141630901289, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.19480519480519476, "hi": 1.3292458614347027, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.9083333333333333, "hi": 0.9583333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.41666666666666663, "hi": 0.5416666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6497925378456353, "hi": 0.9699570815450644, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.09740259740259738, "hi": 0.6646229307173513, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 113, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 107, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 124 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.05309734513274336, "npv": 0.9763779527559056, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5367965367965368, "youden": 0.20346320346320335, "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6017316017316017 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.02232811436351259, "npv": 0.021832498210450968, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.0822510822510823, "youden": 0.30447330447330434, "accuracy": 0.08749999999999997, "balancedAccuracy": 0.15223665223665217 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.01680672268907563, "hi": 0.0990990990990991, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.013196495922255283, "hi": 0.06665356446952898, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9473684210526315, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.01672253517401882, "hi": 0.06306306306306309, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.47185532807803554, "hi": 0.6017316017316018, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.16956521739130437, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.12186401480111003, "hi": 0.523419322436307, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.2276129356210123, "hi": 0.9276738509717232, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.475, "hi": 0.6083333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.004166666666666652, "hi": 0.17083333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.439067992599445, "hi": 0.7617096612181534, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.11380646781050616, "hi": 0.4638369254858616, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 38, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 32, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 199 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.15789473684210525, "npv": 0.9851485148514851, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8614718614718615, "youden": 0.5281385281385282, "accuracy": 0.8541666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7640692640692641 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.12712550607287448, "npv": 0.03060306030603055, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.40692640692640697, "youden": 0.6291486291486292, "accuracy": 0.39999999999999997, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3145743145743146 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.05128205128205128, "hi": 0.2857142857142857, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.03193096639947034, "hi": 0.2454462313553223, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9658536585365853, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.004390402904938695, "hi": 0.0681132141851956, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8247863247863247, "hi": 0.8961038961038961, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.34051724137931033, "hi": 0.4739130434782609, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.20845675600994748, "hi": 0.8565400843881856, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.10361254466057956, "hi": 1.2478632478632479, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8166666666666667, "hi": 0.8916666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3375, "hi": 0.4625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6042283780049738, "hi": 0.9282700421940928, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.05180627233028978, "hi": 0.6239316239316239, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 121, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 115, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 116 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.049586776859504134, "npv": 0.9747899159663865, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5021645021645021, "youden": 0.16883116883116878, "accuracy": 0.5083333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5844155844155844 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.018817546090273363, "npv": 0.020244461420931947, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.047619047619047616, "youden": 0.26984126984126977, "accuracy": 0.05416666666666664, "balancedAccuracy": 0.13492063492063489 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.015748031496062992, "hi": 0.09322033898305085, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.01509872241579558, "hi": 0.06131401181657162, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9444444444444444, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.019118552036199138, "hi": 0.06220792373470514, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.4358836206896552, "hi": 0.5702127659574469, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": -0.038793103448275856, "hi": 0.13596491228070173, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.1574972722313148, "hi": 0.48752864782276356, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.2627118644067796, "hi": 0.8937696577243271, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.44166666666666665, "hi": 0.5791666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": -0.029166666666666674, "hi": 0.14166666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.4212513638843426, "hi": 0.7437643239113818, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.1313559322033898, "hi": 0.4468848288621636, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 51, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 45, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 186 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11764705882352941, "npv": 0.9841269841269841, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8051948051948052, "youden": 0.47186147186147176, "accuracy": 0.8, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7359307359307359 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.08687782805429864, "npv": 0.029581529581529487, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3506493506493507, "youden": 0.5728715728715728, "accuracy": 0.3458333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2864357864357864 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.03773584905660377, "hi": 0.21568627450980393, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.016658040126970128, "hi": 0.17618595825426933, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9635416666666666, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0054614498873716, "hi": 0.06739242842503705, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7679324894514767, "hi": 0.8414096916299559, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.27896995708154504, "hi": 0.4229074889867841, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.14767932489451474, "hi": 0.8016877637130801, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.04329004329004338, "hi": 1.1967082964927773, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7625, "hi": 0.8375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.275, "hi": 0.41250000000000003, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5738396624472574, "hi": 0.9008438818565401, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.02164502164502169, "hi": 0.5983541482463887, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 22, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 16, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 215 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.2727272727272727, "npv": 0.9862385321100917, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.9307359307359307, "youden": 0.5974025974025974, "accuracy": 0.9208333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7987012987012987 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.24195804195804194, "npv": 0.03169307756463713, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.4761904761904762, "youden": 0.6984126984126984, "accuracy": 0.4666666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3492063492063492 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.09523809523809523, "hi": 0.46671874999999924, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.07575468424705066, "hi": 0.42444382025678673, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9680365296803652, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.002441883826629169, "hi": 0.06902812371663983, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.902542372881356, "hi": 0.9568965517241379, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4130434782608696, "hi": 0.5394736842105263, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.2801724137931034, "hi": 0.9285714285714286, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.17780502759043526, "hi": 1.3235079105291856, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8916666666666667, "hi": 0.95, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4083333333333333, "hi": 0.525, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6400862068965517, "hi": 0.9642857142857143, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.08890251379521763, "hi": 0.6617539552645928, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 119, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 113, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 118 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.05042016806722689, "npv": 0.9752066115702479, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5108225108225108, "youden": 0.17748917748917759, "accuracy": 0.5166666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5887445887445888 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.01965093729799612, "npv": 0.02066115702479332, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.056277056277056314, "youden": 0.2784992784992786, "accuracy": 0.06250000000000006, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1392496392496393 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.016, "hi": 0.0943433367998811, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.014760809615386424, "hi": 0.062171385940664986, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.944954128440367, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.01875270769622838, "hi": 0.06239320568019704, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.4473684210526316, "hi": 0.575107296137339, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": -0.025531914893617003, "hi": 0.13973799126637548, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.14893617021276595, "hi": 0.4978902953586499, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.2514363140436102, "hi": 0.9043531575720416, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.45416666666666666, "hi": 0.5833333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": -0.016666666666666663, "hi": 0.14166666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.425531914893617, "hi": 0.748945147679325, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.1257181570218051, "hi": 0.4521765787860208, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 55, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 49, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 182 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.10909090909090909, "npv": 0.9837837837837838, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.7878787878787878, "youden": 0.4545454545454546, "accuracy": 0.7833333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7272727272727273 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.07832167832167831, "npv": 0.029238329238329253, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3333333333333333, "youden": 0.5555555555555556, "accuracy": 0.32916666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2777777777777778 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.034482758620689655, "hi": 0.20689655172413793, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.01235713362142099, "hi": 0.16628020889206746, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9625668449197861, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.006048296338853412, "hi": 0.06723379508526646, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7404255319148936, "hi": 0.8311688311688312, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.26086956521739124, "hi": 0.4061135371179039, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.12650419201052115, "hi": 0.7881355932203391, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.023298589822194904, "hi": 1.1854865187087287, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7333333333333333, "hi": 0.8291666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2583333333333333, "hi": 0.39999999999999997, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5632520960052606, "hi": 0.8940677966101696, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.011649294911097452, "hi": 0.5927432593543643, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 26, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 20, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 211 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.23076923076923078, "npv": 0.985981308411215, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.9134199134199135, "youden": 0.5800865800865802, "accuracy": 0.9041666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7900432900432901 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.2, "npv": 0.03143585386576042, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.45887445887445893, "youden": 0.6810966810966812, "accuracy": 0.45, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3405483405483406 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.07692307692307693, "hi": 0.4074074074074074, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.06024957838139843, "hi": 0.36562210679058493, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9678899082568807, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0028359866708215662, "hi": 0.06874379811344397, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8820900816243804, "hi": 0.9434782608695652, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3905579399141631, "hi": 0.5265486725663717, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.26724137931034475, "hi": 0.9075630252100839, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.16218592030924767, "hi": 1.299145299145299, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8708333333333333, "hi": 0.9333333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3833333333333334, "hi": 0.5125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6336206896551724, "hi": 0.953781512605042, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.08109296015462383, "hi": 0.6495726495726495, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 1, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 125, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 119, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 112 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.048, "npv": 0.9739130434782609, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.48484848484848486, "youden": 0.15151515151515138, "accuracy": 0.49166666666666664, "balancedAccuracy": 0.5757575757575757 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.01723076923076923, "npv": 0.019367588932806323, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.03030303030303033, "youden": 0.2525252525252524, "accuracy": 0.03749999999999998, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1262626262626262 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.015151515151515152, "hi": 0.09016393442622951, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.01618605483511178, "hi": 0.058365117949476575, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9426229508196722, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.020833482015415395, "hi": 0.061700979544324235, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.42105263157894735, "hi": 0.5502183406113537, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": -0.051724137931034475, "hi": 0.11538888888888886, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.17449717730015782, "hi": 0.47058823529411775, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.2777777777777778, "hi": 0.8743619711833225, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.425, "hi": 0.5583333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": -0.041666666666666685, "hi": 0.12083333333333329, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.4127514113499211, "hi": 0.7352941176470589, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.1388888888888889, "hi": 0.43718098559166124, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 2, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 69, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 63, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 168 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.08695652173913043, "npv": 0.9824561403508771, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.7272727272727273, "youden": 0.39393939393939403, "accuracy": 0.725, "balancedAccuracy": 0.696969696969697 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.05618729096989966, "npv": 0.027910685805422553, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.27272727272727276, "youden": 0.49494949494949503, "accuracy": 0.2708333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.24747474747474751 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.0273972602739726, "hi": 0.1639405431857107, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.003499957489319188, "hi": 0.12698412698412698, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9595375722543352, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.007897297091283144, "hi": 0.06643515812127117, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.679324894514768, "hi": 0.7733333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.19408964426014838, "hi": 0.3491379310344828, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.0578333238813589, "hi": 0.728448275862069, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.04219409282700416, "hi": 1.1277004909983628, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.675, "hi": 0.775, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.1958333333333333, "hi": 0.3458333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5289166619406794, "hi": 0.8642241379310345, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.02109704641350208, "hi": 0.5638502454991814, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 3, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 31, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 25, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 206 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.1935483870967742, "npv": 0.9856459330143541, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8917748917748918, "youden": 0.5584415584415585, "accuracy": 0.8833333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7792207792207793 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.16277915632754342, "npv": 0.031100478468899517, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.43722943722943725, "youden": 0.6594516594516595, "accuracy": 0.42916666666666664, "balancedAccuracy": 0.32972582972582976 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.0625, "hi": 0.34375, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.04533800304053031, "hi": 0.30220099667774086, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.966824644549763, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.003579219992478368, "hi": 0.06848893508957973, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8613445378151261, "hi": 0.9227467811158798, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.37067773294203954, "hi": 0.5042372881355932, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.23806363253265914, "hi": 0.8870605336086502, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.1366652180211502, "hi": 1.2820355610055183, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.85, "hi": 0.9166666666666666, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3666666666666666, "hi": 0.49166666666666664, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6190318162663295, "hi": 0.9435302668043251, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.0683326090105751, "hi": 0.6410177805027591, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 4, "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 18, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 12, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 219 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3333333333333333, "npv": 0.9864864864864865, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.948051948051948, "youden": 0.6147186147186146, "accuracy": 0.9375, "balancedAccuracy": 0.8073593073593073 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.30256410256410254, "npv": 0.03194103194103193, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.4935064935064935, "youden": 0.7157287157287155, "accuracy": 0.48333333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3578643578643578 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.11764705882352941, "hi": 0.5625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.10304847058515738, "hi": 0.5210105964961017, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9688888888888889, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.0017182608513388686, "hi": 0.06921297137737505, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.9224137931034483, "hi": 0.9734542512962456, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.4273504273504274, "hi": 0.559322033898305, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.30580916927899676, "hi": 0.9444444444444444, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.19994481912936846, "hi": 1.3336310745608178, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.9125, "hi": 0.9625, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.4208333333333334, "hi": 0.5416666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.6529045846394984, "hi": 0.9722222222222222, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.09997240956468423, "hi": 0.6668155372804089, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } } ], "baselines": [ { "model": "claude-sonnet-5-5", "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 43, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 37, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 194 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.13953488372093023, "npv": 0.9847715736040609, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8398268398268398, "youden": 0.5064935064935066, "accuracy": 0.8333333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7532467532467533 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.10876565295169946, "npv": 0.030226119058606282, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3852813852813853, "youden": 0.6075036075036075, "accuracy": 0.3791666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3037518037518038 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.045454545454545456, "hi": 0.25, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.024285452395917513, "hi": 0.20704054119119839, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9646464646464646, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.004843002108323584, "hi": 0.0678211121001282, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.8181818181818182, "hi": 0.8634361233480177, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.3187772925764192, "hi": 0.45132743362831856, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.18896387455339436, "hi": 0.8396624472573839, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.08332624690107435, "hi": 1.234101256245352, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.8083333333333333, "hi": 0.8583333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3125, "hi": 0.44166666666666665, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5944819372766972, "hi": 0.919831223628692, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.04166312345053717, "hi": 0.617050628122676, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "gpt-6-astra", "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 49, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 43, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 188 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.12244897959183673, "npv": 0.9842931937172775, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8138528138528138, "youden": 0.48051948051948035, "accuracy": 0.8083333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7402597402597402 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.09167974882260596, "npv": 0.02974773917182294, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3593073593073593, "youden": 0.5815295815295813, "accuracy": 0.3541666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.29076479076479067 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.0392156862745098, "hi": 0.22727272727272727, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.018415825609930724, "hi": 0.18604651162790697, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9639175257731959, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.005348519127930911, "hi": 0.06746245766323482, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7725321888412017, "hi": 0.8526785714285714, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.2887931034482759, "hi": 0.42920353982300885, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.15609759438873372, "hi": 0.8109419518880511, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.053341508277130675, "hi": 1.20907418761496, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7666666666666667, "hi": 0.85, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2875, "hi": 0.42083333333333334, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5780487971943669, "hi": 0.9054709759440256, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.026670754138565338, "hi": 0.60453709380748, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "gemini-4-argon-high", "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 51, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 45, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 186 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.11764705882352941, "npv": 0.9841269841269841, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.8051948051948052, "youden": 0.47186147186147176, "accuracy": 0.8, "balancedAccuracy": 0.7359307359307359 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.08687782805429864, "npv": 0.029581529581529487, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.3506493506493507, "youden": 0.5728715728715728, "accuracy": 0.3458333333333334, "balancedAccuracy": 0.2864357864357864 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.038461538461538464, "hi": 0.21153846153846154, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": 0.0173178760555317, "hi": 0.1738521364317841, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9633507853403142, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.005543326765707201, "hi": 0.06731975317966721, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.7792207792207793, "hi": 0.8289473684210527, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.28755364806866957, "hi": 0.415929203539823, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": 0.1540293767368004, "hi": 0.8025210084033614, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": 0.04898935912743213, "hi": 1.1984051724137912, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.7708333333333334, "hi": 0.8291666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.2833333333333333, "hi": 0.40833333333333327, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.5770146883684002, "hi": 0.9012605042016807, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.024494679563716065, "hi": 0.5992025862068956, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } }, { "model": "grok-4.5", "comparison": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "left": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 100, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 94, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 137 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.06, "npv": 0.9785714285714285, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.5930735930735931, "youden": 0.2597402597402598, "accuracy": 0.5958333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.6298701298701299 } }, "right": { "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 130, "matches": 4, "known": 9, "missed": 5, "counts": { "yes_true": 4, "yes_false": 126, "no_true": 5, "no_false": 105 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.03076923076923077, "npv": 0.9545454545454546, "sens": 0.4444444444444444, "spec": 0.45454545454545453, "youden": -0.101010101010101, "accuracy": 0.45416666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4494949494949495 } }, "differences": { "ppv": 0.029230769230769227, "npv": 0.02402597402597395, "sens": 0.2222222222222222, "spec": 0.13852813852813856, "youden": 0.3607503607503608, "accuracy": 0.14166666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.1803751803751804 }, "uncertainty": { "method": "paired original-question cluster percentile bootstrap", "replicates": 10000, "intervals": { "left_ppv": { "lo": 0.019230769230769232, "hi": 0.11224489795918367, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_ppv": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.0703125, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_ppv": { "lo": -0.008718512245980529, "hi": 0.07715866400935012, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_npv": { "lo": 0.9523809523809523, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_npv": { "lo": 0.9166666666666666, "hi": 0.98989898989899, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_npv": { "lo": -0.013777427209886903, "hi": 0.06423479049272898, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_sens": { "lo": 0.36363636363636365, "hi": 1, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_sens": { "lo": 0, "hi": 0.8, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_sens": { "lo": -0.30000000000000004, "hi": 0.8571428571428571, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_spec": { "lo": 0.5276595744680851, "hi": 0.6575373318524003, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_spec": { "lo": 0.3901345291479821, "hi": 0.51931330472103, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_spec": { "lo": 0.05603448275862066, "hi": 0.2217391304347826, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_youden": { "lo": -0.06382978723404253, "hi": 0.5787234042553191, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_youden": { "lo": -0.5364806866952789, "hi": 0.24531024531024537, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_youden": { "lo": -0.16682666746514918, "hi": 0.9827586206896552, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "left_accuracy": { "lo": 0.5291666666666667, "hi": 0.6583333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "right_accuracy": { "lo": 0.3958333333333333, "hi": 0.5166666666666667, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "difference_accuracy": { "lo": 0.0625, "hi": 0.22083333333333333, "validReplicates": 10000, "degenerate": false }, "left_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.46808510638297873, "hi": 0.7893617021276595, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "right_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": 0.2317596566523605, "hi": 0.6226551226551227, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false }, "difference_balancedAccuracy": { "lo": -0.08341333373257459, "hi": 0.4913793103448276, "validReplicates": 9998, "degenerate": false } } } } } ], "voteCounts": [ { "votes": 0, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 115, "matches": 3, "known": 9, "missed": 6, "counts": { "yes_true": 3, "yes_false": 112, "no_true": 6, "no_false": 119 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.02608695652173913, "npv": 0.952, "sens": 0.3333333333333333, "spec": 0.5151515151515151, "youden": -0.1515151515151516, "accuracy": 0.5083333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.4242424242424242 } }, { "votes": 1, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 56, "matches": 0, "known": 9, "missed": 9, "counts": { "yes_true": 0, "yes_false": 56, "no_true": 9, "no_false": 175 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0, "npv": 0.9510869565217391, "sens": 0, "spec": 0.7575757575757576, "youden": -0.24242424242424243, "accuracy": 0.7291666666666666, "balancedAccuracy": 0.3787878787878788 } }, { "votes": 2, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 38, "matches": 0, "known": 9, "missed": 9, "counts": { "yes_true": 0, "yes_false": 38, "no_true": 9, "no_false": 193 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0, "npv": 0.9554455445544554, "sens": 0, "spec": 0.8354978354978355, "youden": -0.16450216450216448, "accuracy": 0.8041666666666667, "balancedAccuracy": 0.41774891774891776 } }, { "votes": 3, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 13, "matches": 0, "known": 9, "missed": 9, "counts": { "yes_true": 0, "yes_false": 13, "no_true": 9, "no_false": 218 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0, "npv": 0.960352422907489, "sens": 0, "spec": 0.9437229437229437, "youden": -0.05627705627705626, "accuracy": 0.9083333333333333, "balancedAccuracy": 0.47186147186147187 } }, { "votes": 4, "hypotheses": 240, "questions": 48, "selected": 18, "matches": 6, "known": 9, "missed": 3, "counts": { "yes_true": 6, "yes_false": 12, "no_true": 3, "no_false": 219 }, "rates": { "ppv": 0.3333333333333333, "npv": 0.9864864864864865, "sens": 0.6666666666666666, "spec": 0.948051948051948, "youden": 0.6147186147186146, "accuracy": 0.9375, "balancedAccuracy": 0.8073593073593073 } } ], "pareto": [ { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high" ], "minVotes": 3 }, { "members": [ "claude-sonnet-5-5", "gpt-6-astra", "gemini-4-argon-high", "grok-4.5" ], "minVotes": 4 } ] } }, "interpretation": "Saved gemini-4-argon-high/N hypotheses, evaluated against historical article-correspondence judgments by three judges from other companies. Unmatched generated hypotheses are not experimentally refuted. A predictor forecasts its own hypotheses only when it is also this cohort's generator; judge/company relationships of every predictor are disclosed per model. Five-claim request units differ from the one-claim balanced condition; PPVs cannot be directly compared across prevalences.", "generationBudgetMeaning": "32000 is a requested output parameter, not matched actual compute; provider services retain provider-specific internal reasoning. Full token usage and logical versus underlying transport counts are saved.", "omissionMeaning": "False-negative rate = FN/(TP+FN) among usable matched forecasts. Technical omissions are counted separately. It is not the error fraction among forecasts of yes." }